Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bachpan Bachao Andolan v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 13, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present opinion consolidates a series of interlocutory orders passed by the Supreme Court of India in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 75 of 2012 and connected matters. Earlier directions dated 17-1-2013 and 10-5-2013 (2014 16 SCC 612 and 2014 16 SCC 616) required every State and Union Territory to adopt concrete measures for tracing and rehabilitating missing children, including:

  • Registration of all First Information Reports (FIRs) relating to missing children.
  • Designation of Juvenile Welfare Officers in police stations.
  • Appointment of para-legal volunteers and networking with NGOs.
  • Creation of Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) and regular status reports by Anti-Human Trafficking Units.
  • Establishment and funding of adequate shelter or after-care homes.

Despite repeated extensions, many States/UTs failed to file compliance affidavits. Consequently, by orders dated 16-10-2014 and 13-11-2014 the Court:

  • Granted fresh deadlines ranging from two to four weeks for defaulting States/UTs to file status reports.
  • Directed personal appearance of Chief Secretaries and Directors-General of Police for certain recalcitrant States.
  • Took on record additional affidavits from Bihar, Chhattisgarh and Assam, and issued quantitative targets for tracing the remaining untraced children in those jurisdictions.
  • Requested the Union Ministry of Women and Child Development to examine and, if satisfied, direct nationwide adoption of the draft SOP.
  • Allowed withdrawal of W.P. (C) No. 301 of 2012 with liberty to intervene in the lead petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the States and Union Territories have complied with the Supreme Court’s directions of 17-1-2013 and 10-5-2013 regarding investigation, rescue and rehabilitation of missing children.
  2. What coercive or supervisory measures are necessary to secure such compliance, including personal appearances of high-ranking officials and imposition of fresh timelines.
  3. Whether the Standard Operating Procedure devised in W.P. (C) No. 75 of 2012 should be uniformly adopted across all States/UTs.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Submissions

  • Through senior counsel Shri H.S. Phoolka, the petitioner highlighted that numerous States/UTs had not filed the mandated status/compliance reports even by 13-10-2014, contrary to earlier extensions granted by the Court.
  • Specific defaulters were named: Jammu & Kashmir, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Manipur, Mizoram, Tripura, West Bengal, Chandigarh, Dadra & Nagar Haveli and the NCT of Delhi.

States’ and Union Territories’ Responses

  • Manipur and Delhi informed the Court that they had already filed their compliance affidavits.
  • Maharashtra sought additional time owing to the conduct of Legislative Assembly elections.
  • Counsel for several States/UTs requested further extensions ranging from two to four weeks to file reports.
  • Additions affidavits from Bihar, Chhattisgarh and Assam disclosed the number of traced and untraced children; those States accepted responsibility for tracing the remaining children within the fresh timelines set by the Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2014 16 SCC 612 (Order dated 17-1-2013) Initial comprehensive directions to all States/UTs on registration, investigation and rehabilitation mechanisms for missing children. Treated as the operative mandate; present orders measure and enforce State compliance with these directions.
2014 16 SCC 616 (Order dated 10-5-2013) Supplementary directions, timelines and reporting obligations concerning missing children. Referenced to remind States of continuing obligations and to justify fresh coercive measures for non-compliance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court’s analysis centres on administrative efficacy rather than substantive legal doctrine. It noted a persistent pattern of non-compliance despite multiple opportunities and therefore escalated its supervisory role:

  • Graduated Enforcement: Defaulting States were given last-chance extensions coupled with orders for personal appearance of their Chief Secretaries and Directors-General of Police (e.g., Karnataka and Tripura on 25-11-2014; Bihar and Chhattisgarh on 30-10-2014).
  • Quantifiable Targets: Upon examining fresh affidavits, the Court fixed state-specific targets—e.g., Bihar was ordered to trace 464 children within three weeks; Chhattisgarh to locate 1,327 missing children in four weeks; Assam to trace over 2,000 children in four weeks.
  • Standard Operating Procedure: Observing that no State objected to the draft SOP circulated earlier, the Bench tasked the Union Ministry of Women & Child Development to vet and, if satisfied, direct its uniform adoption, thereby seeking to institutionalise best practices nationwide.
  • Case Management: Matters were re-listed on staggered dates (20-11-2014, 11-12-2014, etc.) to maintain continual judicial oversight, while individual petitions were consolidated or de-tagged to streamline proceedings.

Holding and Implications

FURTHER DIRECTIONS ISSUED FOR STATE COMPLIANCE.

The Court did not finally dispose of the writ petitions but issued robust supervisory orders: (1) fixed fresh, short deadlines for filing compliance affidavits; (2) mandated personal appearances of high-level State officials for persistent default; (3) set concrete numerical targets for tracing missing children; and (4) sought central government endorsement of a uniform SOP.

Implications are immediate and pragmatic rather than precedential. The decision tightens judicial oversight of State machinery concerning missing children, signalling potential coercive action for future defaults. No new point of law was created, but the Court reinforced the enforceability of its earlier directives and underscored inter-governmental accountability.

Show all summary ...

(Before H.L Dattu, S.A Bobde and Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.)

1. It is submitted by Shri H.S Phoolka, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner that most of the States have not complied with the directions of this Court, dated 17-1-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 612 and 10-5-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 616. We grant time till 16-10-2014 to all the States to file appropriate affidavits inter alia indicating whether they have complied with the directions, as stated hereinbelow:

Sl. No. Directions issued by the Hon'ble Court. 1. Registration of all first information reports (FIRs). 2. Number of police stations with police officer designated as a Juvenile Welfare Officer. 3. Appointment of para-legal volunteers. 4. Presence of network of NGOs for tracing and reintegrating missing children. 5. Provision for photograph of every found/recovered child to be taken by the police. 6. Formulation of standard operating procedure to handle the cases of missing children. 7. Cases handed over to the Anti-Human Trafficking Unit in each State. 8. Status reports filed by Anti-Human Trafficking Unit. 9. Registration of all first information reports within a month from the date of communication of this order. 10. Shelter homes or aftercare homes set up by the State Government. Funds provided by the State Government. Infrastructure provided by the State Government.

2. List the matter on 16-10-2014.

WP (C) No. 301 of 2012

3. Submissions made on behalf of the petitioner are placed on record.

4. Appropriate orders will be passed in the due course.

Order dated 16-10-2014

(Before H.L Dattu, C.J and Madan B. Lokur and Dr A.K Sikri, JJ.)

5. Shri H.S Phoolka, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner has brought to our notice that certain States in spite of our orders and directions, dated 17-1-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 612 and 10-5-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 616, have not filed their status/compliance reports as on 13-10-2014. In the memo filed, he has stated that the States of Jammu and Kashmir, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Manipur, Mizoram, Tripura and West Bengal; the Union Territories of Chandigarh and Dadra and Nagar Haveli and the NCT of Delhi have not filed their respective status/compliance reports. Therefore, in continuation of our earlier orders, we would now examine the case of each State/Union Territory serially and pass necessary directions to ensure compliance with the aforesaid.

5.1 Insofar as the State of Jammu and Kashmir is concerned, we grant another four weeks' time from today for compliance with our orders and directions, dated 17-1-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 612 and 10-5-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 616.

5.2 As regards the State of Karnataka, it has also not filed its affidavit of compliance in accordance with the aforesaid orders. Therefore, we now direct the Chief Secretary of the State to be present before this Court on 25-11-2014 at 10.30 a.m

5.3 Insofar as the State of Maharashtra is concerned, since the State administration is engaged in conducting the elections to the Legislative Assembly, we grant them another four weeks' time from today to ensure compliance with our earlier orders.

5.4 We are informed by the learned counsel appearing for the State of Manipur that they have already filed their compliance report. Therefore, we request Shri Phoolka to examine the report so filed and render further assistance on the next date of hearing.

5.5 Insofar as the State of Mizoram is concerned, we grant another two weeks' time from today to file their compliance report.

5.6 In spite of granting sufficient time, the State of Tripura has not filed its compliance report. Therefore, we direct the Chief Secretary of the State to be present before this Court on 25-11-2014 at 10.30 a.m

5.7 We grant another two weeks' time to the learned counsel appearing for the State of West Bengal to file their compliance report in accordance with our earlier orders.

5.8 Insofar as the Union Territory of Chandigarh and the Union Territory of Dadra and Nagar Haveli are concerned, we grant another three weeks' time from today to file their compliance reports.

5.9 We are informed by the learned counsel appearing for the NCT of Delhi that they have filed their compliance report.

5.10 The State of Madhya Pradesh is also granted another two weeks' time from today for filing its compliance report.

In re: States of Bihar and Chhattisgarh

6. In order to determine whether the officers of the States of Bihar and Chhattisgarh have complied with the orders and directions issued by us on 17-1-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 612 and 10-5-2013 (2014) 16 SCC 616 in Writ Petition (C) No. 75 of 2012, we intend to not only require the learned counsel for the respective States to be present before us, but also the responsible officers of the State Governments so as to facilitate us to pass appropriate orders. Therefore, we direct the Chief Secretaries and the Director General of Police of the States of Bihar and Chhattisgarh to be present before this Court on 30-10-2014 at 10.30 a.m

WP (C) No. 906 of 2014

7. Issue notice returnable on 30-10-2014. Reply, if any, to be filed by the States of Bihar and Chhattisgarh on or before 30-10-2014.

8. List Writ Petition (C) No. 301 of 2012 along with these matters.

Order dated 13-11-2014

(Before H.L Dattu, C.J and Madan B. Lokur and Dr A.K Sikri, JJ.)

WP (C) No. 75 of 2012

9. By our order dated 14-7-2014 WP (C) No. 75 of 2012, we had taken notice of the Standing Operating Procedure (for short “SOP”). We had directed the learned counsel representing different States/Union Territories to file their objections, if any, to the aforesaid procedure. It appears that none of the States/Union Territories have filed any response/reply or objection.

10. Now we request Shri Maninder Singh, learned ASG, who appears for the Ministry of Women and Child Development (Government of India), to look into the said procedure and if they are satisfied, can direct all the State Governments/Union Territories to adopt the said procedure.

11. Call the matter on 20-11-2014.

In re: State of Bihar

12. Pursuant to the directions issued by this Court on the last date of hearing, an additional affidavit on behalf of the State of Bihar is filed. The same is taken on record. In Para 3 of the said affidavit, they have stated that between 1-1-2013 to 30-9-2014, the missing children were 2874 and out of them they had traced 2241 children so far. They had also indicated that nearly 633 children remained untraced.

13. Between the last date of hearing and today, they have stated that they could trace out 169 children out of the 633 missing children. That would mean that they could trace out 169 children within a span of 7 days. Taking into consideration the progress so made by the State agencies and also appreciating their efforts, we now direct the State to trace out 464 children still missing within three weeks' time from today and file an appropriate additional affidavit before this Court in this regard.

14. Call the matter on 4-12-2014.

In re: State of Chhattisgarh

15. The additional affidavit filed by the State of Chhattisgarh is taken on record.

16. While arguing the matter, Shri Ravindra Shrivastava, learned Senior Counsel has brought to our notice the statement of missing children (both traced and untraced) from the year 2011 till 31-5-2014. According to the said chart, even today there are 1327 children missing/untraced. The figures are very high. Therefore, we now direct the Chief Secretary of the State to trace out the 1327 untraced children within four weeks' time from today.

17. Pursuant to the directions issued by this Court, the Chief Secretary and the DGP are present before us. In our opinion, their presence may not be required in future. Therefore, their presence is dispensed with.

18. Call the matter on 11-12-2014.

In re: State of Assam

19. The additional affidavit filed by the State of Assam is taken on record. A perusal of the same would demonstrate that more than 2000 children are still missing in the State. Therefore, we now direct the Chief Secretary and the DGP to trace out the untraced children within four weeks' time from today.

20. Call the matter on 11-12-2014.

In re: State of Madhya Pradesh

21. List the matter on 20-11-2014. The Chief Secretary of the State shall be present on that date.

22. An appropriate affidavit indicating the number of missing children from the year 2011 till 31-5-2014 and the number of children traced and untraced shall be filed before this Court before the next date of hearing.

WP (Crl.) No. 102 of 2007

23. De-tag and list on 27-11-2014.

WP (C) No. 301 of 2012

24. We permit Mr Mahajan, learned Senior Counsel to withdraw the writ petition with liberty to intervene in Writ Petition (C) No. 75 of 2012.

Court Masters