Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kanshi Ram v. The State .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
May 30, 1962
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — Kanshi Ram (Revision)

Factual and Procedural Background

Kanshi Ram, the petitioner, was tried under section 9 of the Opium Act by the First Class Magistrate, Ludhiana, who convicted him and sentenced him to 18 months' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,000/-, with six months' further rigorous imprisonment in default of the fine. He appealed to the Court of Sessions where the sentence of imprisonment was reduced to six months but the fine and default sentence were maintained (order dated 20 January 1962). The petitioner then filed the present revision petition in this Court.

The prosecution case: on the night of 30 April 1961, a nakabandi (checkpoint) was held at the railway level crossing of Laudowal on G.T. Road. At about 2 a.m. a truck (No. PNP-1066) was stopped; one person jumped down and fled, while the petitioner was found driving the truck. Thirty gunny bags containing crushed poppy-heads were recovered from the truck; samples were taken and sealed at the spot. The petitioner was sent up for trial.

The petitioner, when examined under section 342 Cr.P.C., admitted ownership of the truck and the recovery but stated that the truck was being driven by Duni Chand at the time and that he (the petitioner) was unaware of the contents of the gunny-bags. He explained he had brought fuel-wood from Rupar to Ludhiana, unloaded, and left the truck with Duni Chand at a relative's house, instructing the driver to arrange for hiring out the truck and to inform him later. The petitioner called two witnesses in support of his claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, from the circumstances of recovery and the admitted facts, an inference can be drawn that the petitioner was aware of the nature of the load (crushed poppy-heads) in the truck.
  2. Whether the petitioner, having been released on bail by this Court, should be permitted to avoid serving the unexpired portion of the sentence of imprisonment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner admitted ownership of the truck and recovery of the goods but denied knowledge of the contents, asserting that the other driver, Duni Chand, was in control and knew of the contents.
  • The petitioner contended he had left the truck with the driver and was not present when the goods were loaded; therefore he was oblivious of the poppy-heads being carried.
  • The petitioner's counsel argued that since this Court had released the petitioner on bail, he should not be sent back to jail to serve the unexpired sentence.
  • The petitioner relied on the case Maharaj Prithvisinghji Bhimsinghji v. State of Bombay. A.I.R 1960 S.C 483. to support his claim of non-knowledge.

Prosecution's Case / Respondent's Position

  • The prosecution presented the facts of the nakabandi, recovery of thirty gunny-bags containing crushed poppy-heads from the truck driven by the petitioner, and the flight of the other occupant/driver on seeing the police.
  • It relied on the circumstances: petitioner found driving the vehicle at night, owner of the truck, three entries in the log-book showing petitioner as a driver, absence of any log-book entry describing the goods transported, and the nighttime transportation — to infer petitioner had knowledge of the nature of the load.
  • The prosecution distinguished the petitioner's reliance on prior authorities as inapplicable on the facts of this case and argued that the sentence imposed was not excessive given the quantity recovered (thirty bags ≈ thirty maunds).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Maharaj Prithvisinghji Bhimsinghji v. State of Bombay. A.I.R 1960 S.C 483. Facts in that case (as stated in the opinion): some bottles of liquor were recovered from the suit-cases of the master; it was proved that the servant always packed and unpacked the master's things; the keys of the suit-cases remained with the servant; and the servant admitted that he bought the bottles to be delivered to someone else. The Court found the facts of Maharaj Prithvisinghji Bhimsinghji to be entirely different and held that the ruling had no application to the present case.
Fauja Singh v. The State. 1962 64 P.L.R 92. Reported outcome (as stated): 23 seers of crushed poppy-heads were recovered from the offender; revision dismissed with sentence reduced from four months to two months' rigorous imprisonment and fine maintained. The Court held that Fauja Singh was not relevant because the quantity recovered in the present case (thirty bags, about thirty maunds) was far greater, and therefore the sentence in Fauja Singh had no relevancy to the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court identified the sole determinative point as whether the circumstances permitted drawing an inference that the petitioner was aware of the nature of the load in the truck.

The Court set out the admitted facts: the petitioner was found driving the truck at the time of the raid; thirty gunny-bags containing poppy-heads were recovered from the truck; the other driver jumped down and fled; no entry relating to the goods was made in the log-book; the petitioner owned the truck and had a valid driving licence; entries in the log-book showed the petitioner regularly travelled in the truck and, on the day in question, three entries showed him as one of the drivers.

The Court reasoned that, while in some situations an owner who does not travel in a truck may be unaware of its contents, the facts here were different because the petitioner regularly travelled in the truck and was recorded as a driver. The omission of any log-book entry relating to the transport of these goods was viewed as strongly adverse to the petitioner's claim of ignorance. The fact that the incriminating articles were transported at night and the other occupant fled on seeing the police were additional circumstances from which the Court concluded that the petitioner was fully aware of the nature of the goods being carried.

The Court considered and distinguished the petitioner's reliance on Maharaj Prithvisinghji Bhimsinghji v. State of Bombay, finding that the factual matrix of that case (involving servant control over suitcases and an admission by the servant) did not apply here. The petitioner's counsel's reliance on Fauja Singh v. The State was also rejected on the basis that the quantity of contraband in the present case was far greater.

On the contention that, because the petitioner had been released on bail by this Court he should not be required to serve the unexpired sentence, the Court treated the precedent cited but concluded that the larger quantity involved and the facts did not make the sentence excessive; thus the plea was not accepted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court dismissed the revision petition. Petition dismissed.

Implications: The Court's dismissal means the conviction and the sentence as determined by the Court of Sessions (reduction of imprisonment to six months, maintenance of the fine and the default sentence) remain in force. The Court expressly distinguished earlier authorities relied on by the petitioner and did not treat this decision as establishing a broader precedent beyond the facts of this case.

Show all summary ...

Bedi, J.:— Kanshi Ram, the petitioner in this case, was sent up for trial under section 9 of the Opium Act by Shri Randhir Singh, Magistrate 1st Class, Ludhiana, who convicted him and sentenced him to 18 months' rigorous imprisonment besides a fine of Rs. 1,000/-. In default of payment of fine he was to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months. Kanshi Ram felt aggrieved against that order and went up in appeal in the Court of Sessions which came up before Shri Gurnam Singh, Additional Sessions Judge, Ludhiana, who dismissed the same but reduced the sentence of imprisonment to six months and maintained the fine as also the sentence in default of payment of fine vide his order dated the 20th of January 1962. The petitioner still did not feel satisfied and has approached this court in revision.

2. The story for the prosecution briefly runs as under: On receipt, of information Charan Das, A.S.I and T.R Khanna, Excise Sub-Inspector, organised a raiding party consisting of Bir Bhan, Ajit Singh, Bishambar Singh and some police and excise officials and held nakabandi on the railway level crossing of Laudowal on the G.T Road beyond Ludhiana on the 30th of April 1961 at about 9-30 p.m The nakabandi party waited there till about 2 a.m when truck No. PNP-1066 turned up there. The nakabandi party stopped the truck. One of the persons sitting in it, however, jumped down and ran away, but the petitioner was found driving the truck which was searched and thirty gunny bags containing crushed poppy heads were found therein. Samples were taken and duly sealed at the spot. As a result of the above the petitioner was sent up for trial.

3. When examined under section 342, Criminal Procedure Code, he admitted the ownership of the truck and the recovery of the incriminating bags containing poppy-heads. He, however, added that the truck at that time was being driven by Duni Chand and as he was aware of the contents of the gunny-bags, he felt guilty and ran away therefrom. The petitioner stated further that he brought load of fuel-wood from Rupar to Ludhiana and after unloading the same went to the house of Guranditta Mal, one of his relatives, leaving Duni Chand there giving him directions that he should arrange for the load to be carried in the truck on hire. He also told Duni Chand at that time that after arrangements for the load were made, he should inform him at Guranditta Mal's house. His plea, therefore, was that he was quite oblivious of the fact that poppy-heads were being carried in the truck. In support of his plea he examined Guranditta Mal and lshar Das.

4. The only point, therefore, which requires determination is whether from the circumstances mentioned above the inference against the appellant could be drawn that he was aware of the nature of the load in the truck. The admitted facts in this case are that the appellant was found driving the truck in question at the time of the raid; thirty gunny-bags containing poppy-heads were recovered from the truck; Duni Chand, the other driver of the truck jumped down from the truck on seeing the police party; no entry relating to the goods in question was made in the log-book; the appellant had a valid licence to drive the vehicle, and, lastly, he was the owner of the truck. The appellant's counsel wants me to believe that the appellant who was the owner of the truck, had no knowledge whatsoever about the contents of the goods in his vehicle, although Duni Chand had. In some cases when the owner does not travel in the truck himself and the matter of loading or unloading entirely rests with the driver, the owner may or may not know what goods were being carried in his vehicle, but in this case we find that the petitioner regularly travels in this truck and even on the day in question there are three entries in the log-book showing that the petitioner was one of the drivers of this vehicle. The omission of the entry from the log-book relating to the transport of these goods, in my opinion, goes a long way against the petitioner. It is also to be taken into consideration that the incriminating articles were being transported at dead of night. All these circumstances, in my opinion, conclusively prove that the petitioner was fully aware of the nature of the goods, being carried in the truck at that time. The learned counsel for the petitioner cited Maharaj Prithvisinghji Bhimsinghji v. State of Bombay . A.I.R 1960 S.C 483., but the facts in that case were entirely different. In that case some-bottles of liquor were recovered from the suit-cases of the master, but it was proved as a fact that the servant always packed and unpacked the things of his master and that the keys of the suit cases also remained with the servant. Moreover, the servant himself admitted that it was he who bought the bottles of liquor to be delivered to someone else. That ruling, therefore, had no application to the facts of this case. I am, therefore, of the view that the case against the petitioner is proved beyond any shadow of doubt. The learned counsel for the petitioner lastly contended that the petitioner had been released on bail by this Court and he should, therefore, not be sent back to jail to serve the unexpired sentence of imprisonment. The learned counsel for the petitioner cited Fauja Singh v. The State . 1962 64 P.L.R 92., in that case 23 seers of crushed poppy-heads were recovered from the offender, and Gurdev Singh J. dismissed his revision petition, reduced the sentence from four months to two months' rigorous imprisonment and maintained the sentence of fine of Rs. 200/- imposed upon him. The quantity of poppy-heads recovered in this case, however, is thirty bags containing about thirty maunds. Under the circumstances, the sentence awarded by Gurdev Singh J. in that case has no relevancy to the present one. The counsel also submitted that the possession of poppy heads is no offence in U.P and this was only made an offence in Punjab probably in 1959. Whether that is or is not an offence in U.P, we are not concerned. The possession of poppy-heads was made an offence in the Punjab quite a few years back and it, therefore, cannot be said to be a recent happening. In my opinion, therefore the sentence imposed on the petitioner is by no means excessive. The revision, therefore stands dismissed.

Petition dismissed.