- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Punjab And Others v. Mohinder Singh .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, a Constable in the Punjab Armed Police at Jalandhar, was dismissed from service after a departmental enquiry found him absent from duty for five-and-a-half months without sanctioned leave or prior intimation. His departmental appeal and revision were rejected by higher police authorities.
The respondent then filed a civil suit before the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Amritsar, seeking to quash the dismissal order. The trial court dismissed the suit. On appeal (No. 204 of 1999) the Additional District Judge, Amritsar, reversed the trial court, declared all disciplinary orders “null and void,” and ordered reinstatement with full consequential benefits, while giving the department liberty to pass a fresh order considering the respondent’s length of service. The Punjab Police authorities filed a second appeal, which the High Court dismissed. The present appeal challenges that High Court decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a single act of prolonged absence without leave by a police constable can constitute a “gravest act of misconduct” warranting dismissal under Rule 16.2 of the Punjab Police Rules.
- Whether the appellate and High Court judgments setting aside the dismissal order were sustainable in view of the respondent’s service record and Rule 16.2.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent's Arguments
- At the final hearing, counsel requested that, if dismissal were upheld, it be converted into compulsory retirement because the respondent had already completed more than 23 years of service.
Appellants' Arguments
- While defending the dismissal, counsel stated—after obtaining instructions—that the authorities would “consider sympathetically” any application by the respondent to convert dismissal into compulsory retirement.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court analyzed Rule 16.2 of the Punjab Police Rules, which permits dismissal only for the gravest acts of misconduct or cumulative misconduct proving unfitness for police service. Contrary to the High Court’s view that a single act of absence cannot amount to such misconduct, the Court held that the determination depends on the facts of each case.
Key reasons:
- The respondent’s absence was extensive—five-and-a-half months.
- His explanation was rejected by the enquiry officer, the disciplinary authority, and all departmental appellate authorities; these findings of fact were never disturbed.
- The record showed the respondent had been absent without leave on 15 separate occasions, demonstrating a pattern of indiscipline, even though only one censure had been imposed earlier.
- A police constable is part of a disciplined force; such prolonged, unexplained absence undermines discipline and operational readiness.
The Court concluded that the conduct constituted a gravest act of misconduct, justifying dismissal. Accordingly, it set aside the judgments of the first appellate court and the High Court and ordered dismissal of the respondent’s suit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed; the impugned orders of the first appellate court and the High Court are set aside, and the respondent’s civil suit is dismissed. The respondent’s dismissal from service stands.
Implications: The respondent remains dismissed but may apply to have the dismissal converted to compulsory retirement, which the authorities have indicated they will consider sympathetically. The decision turns on a factual assessment under Rule 16.2 and does not articulate new precedent beyond reaffirming that prolonged absence without leave can, in appropriate circumstances, constitute a gravest act of misconduct warranting dismissal.
Order
1. Leave granted.
2. The respondent, who is working as a Constable in the Punjab Armed Police at Jalandhar, was dismissed from service after holding a departmental enquiry on the charge of remaining absent from duty for five-and-a-half months without any sanctioned leave or prior intimation. Appeals/revision filed by the respondent before the higher authorities were dismissed. Thereafter the respondent filed a civil suit in the Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division), Amritsar, for quashing the impugned orders with consequential relief.
3. The trial court dismissed the suit. Aggrieved against which the respondent filed an appeal bearing No. 204 of 1999 before the Additional District Judge, Amritsar. The appellate court set aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial court and decreed the suit. The order passed by the Senior Superintendent of Police dated 13-7-1995, the order passed by the Deputy Inspector General of Police in appeal dated 21-9-1996 and the order passed by the Inspector General of Police, Border Range, Amritsar in revision dated 14-5-1997 were held to be null and void. As a consequence thereof the respondent was ordered to be reinstated in service with all consequential benefits like reinstatement in service and the arrears of salary, etc. It was held that the order of dismissal could not be passed against the respondent for a single act of remaining absent from duty without sanctioned leave. Liberty was reserved with the authorities to pass a fresh order keeping in view the length of service of the respondent. Relevant portion of the order reads thus:
“In view of what has been discussed above, this appeal is accepted. The suit of the appellant is decreed for a declaration that the order passed by the Senior Superintendent of Police dated 13-7-1995, Order dated 21-9-1996 passed by the Deputy Inspector General, Border Range, Amritsar and Order dated 14-5-1997 passed by the Inspector General, Border Range, Amritsar are null and void. The appellant is deemed to be in service of the respondents continuously and is held entitled to all the service benefits. The respondents are however at liberty to pass a fresh order keeping in view the length of service of the appellant. There is no order as to costs….”
4. Aggrieved against the order passed by the first appellate court, the appellants filed second appeal before the High Court which has been dismissed by the impugned order. Aggrieved against which the present appeal has been filed.
5. The conduct of the respondent who is a member of a disciplined force in remaining absent from duty for five-and-a-half months without sanctioned leave or prior intimation is reprehensible.
6. Rule 16.2 of the Punjab Police Rules reads as follows:
“16.2 Dismissal.—Dismissal shall be provided only for the gravest acts of misconduct or as the cumulative effect of continued misconduct proving incorrigibility and complete unfitness for police service. In making such an award regard shall be had to the length of service of the offender and his claim to pension.
(2)***”
7. Rule 16.2 provides that an order of dismissal can be passed only for the commission of gravest acts of misconduct or as the cumulative effect of continued misconduct proving incorrigibility and complete unfitness for police service.
8. We do not agree with the High Court that a single act of remaining absent without leave would not amount to gravest act of misconduct. This would depend upon the fact situation of each case. In the present case we find that the respondent remained absent without leave for quite a long period. The explanation rendered by him did not find favour either with the enquiry officer or the punishing authority. The finding of facts were not disturbed in the departmental appeal/revision. This finding was also not disturbed in the suit. The only ground for setting aside the orders impugned in the suit is that a single act of remaining absent from duty without sanctioned leave did not merit an order of dismissal from service. We find from the record that the respondent had remained absent from duty without sanctioned leave on 15 different occasions. Although no major punishment was awarded to him but he was ordered to be censured once. In our view, the respondent being member of a disciplined force could not be permitted to remain absent without taking leave and that too for such a long period. He cannot be retained in service. The order impugned before us is set aside and the suit is ordered to be dismissed.
9. Counsel appearing for the respondent submitted that the order of dismissal may be converted into an order of compulsory retirement from service as the respondent has already put in more than 23 years of service. Counsel appearing for the appellants after taking instructions states that the case of the respondent would be considered sympathetically by the authorities if he moves an application for converting his order of dismissal into an order of compulsory retirement. Impugned orders are set aside. The authorities however shall be at liberty to pass an appropriate order on the representation, if any, filed by the respondent for converting the order of dismissal into an order of compulsory retirement.
10. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
Alert