Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Palwinder Singh And Others (Petitioners) v. Director Of Public Instruction, Punjab And Others (S).

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Sep 24, 1982

I.S Tiwana, J.:— The petitioners, who were candidates for the posts of Masters, and applied for the same in response to advertisement, Annexure P. 1, assail the selection of respondents Nos. 3 to 6, primarily on the ground that the Selection Committee appointed by the Govern-m???t was totally illegal and the recommendations made by that Committee were nonest and of no avail. In a nut shell, the case of the petitioners is that under Rule 3 of the Punjab Educational Service Class III (School Cadre Rules), 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules), it is the Director of Public Instruction, Punjab, who is the appointing authority and this rule does not envisage the appointment of any committee by ???he Director. As a matter of fact, as already indicated, the Committee in question was constituted by the Government and not by the Director. The stand on behalf of the respondent authorities is that “the recruitment committees are duly constituted by the Government. The appointing authority can seek the recommendations of such bodies as Departmental Recruitment Committee, Public Service Commission or Subordinate Services Selection Boards constituted by the Government.”

2. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties at some length, I find that the controversy raised does not call for any deep exami???ation in view of the Division Bench judgment of this Court in the Excise and Taxation Commissioner, Punjab v. Jagan Nath Sharma, 1980 (2) S.L.R 744, wherein it has been held in almost similar circumstances that where statutory power of appointment vests in a particular authority, the Government cannot appoint a Selection Committee for such appointments as that would amount to altering or adding to the ruless.

3. In view of this authoritative pronouncement, the selection of respondents Nos. 3 to 6 cannot obviously be sustained Mr. Majithia, learned counsel appearing for these respondents, however, contends that the petition deserves to be dismissed on the short ground that the petitioners having once chosen to appear before this committee, cannot now turn round and assail the very constitution of this Committee. In support of this proposition of his he relies on Civil Writ No. 2508 of 1973 (Jasbir Singh Bains v. The Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala) decided on March 15, 1982; State of Tamil Nadu v. M.N Sundrajan, 1980 (3) S.L.R 451; Dr. G. Sarana v. University of Lucknow, (1976) 3 SCC 585 : A.I.R 1976 S.C 2428 and K.R Bapna v. University of Udaipur, 1978 (2) S.L.R 200. Mr. Majithia might have been right in raising this contention had this been the case pleaded by the respondents. In fact the private respondents have not even filed any return to contest the petition. The respondent authorities, as already oointed out, have raised no such plea. Mr. Majithia further submits that he can well base this submission of his on the contents of the advertisements Annexures P. 1 and P. 2. As against this, the forceful stand of Mr. Gupta is that prior to the passing of the impugned order by the Director of Public Instruction, Punjab, appointing the private respondents as Masters, he could not possibly come forward and assail the selection because till that time it was open to the Director of Public Instruction not to agree or go by the recommendations made by the Selection Committee and he might well have appointed the petitione???s instead of respondents Nos. 3 to 6. For this stand of his, Mr. Gu???ta squarely relies on the very judgment;, that is, Dr. G. Sarana's case (supra) on which the learned counsel for the private respondents has placed reliance. This is what has been observed in this judgment in this regard:—

“It is also difficult to understand how the writ petition or for that matter the present appeal before us is maintainable when the recommendation of the Selection Committee has still to be scrutinized by the Executive Council of the University and either accepted or rejected by it and other remedies by way of representation to the Executive Council and an application for reference of the matter under section 68 of the Uttar Pradesh Universities (Re-enactment and Amendment) Act, 1974 to the Chancel???or are still open to the appellant and have not been exhausted.”

4. In the light of all what has been said above and particularly in view of the Divi???ion Bench Judgment of this ???Court in Jagan Nath Shama's case (supra) t???is petition is allowed and the selection as well as appointment of respondents Nos. 3 to 6 is set aside. In the facts and circumstances of this case I, how???ver, I leave the parties to bear their own costs.

5. Petition allowed.