Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr. P. Kumari, P.C.M.S Class Ii (Petitioner) v. The State Of Punjab And Another (S).

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 7, 1981

I.S Tiwana, J.:— The petitioner who is employed as a Medical Officer in P.C.M.S Class II, impugns the enquiry which is sought to be held against her on the basis of the charges contained in Annexure ‘C’ on the sole ground that earlier also on the basis of the same or similar charges, an enquiry was held against her by the Chief Medical Officer, Hoshiarpur, and as a result thereof a warning had been administered to her by the Director of Health Services, Punjab vide order dated April 7, 1967 (Annexure ‘B’). Her case further, is that once a punishment had been inflicted on her, may be a minor one, no second enquiry on the time charges can be held with a view to punish her again for the same lapse.

2. In the return the case set up by the respondent authorities is not that the Director, Health Services was not competent to inflict the punishment of warning as per his order Annexure ‘B’, but on the other hand, is that in fact there was no formal enquiry against the petitioner as the one held earlier was only a fact finding enquiry It is also sought to be maintained that the warning by itself is no punishment.

3. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, I do not find any merit in the stand taken by the respondent authorities. As per Rule 4(1) of the Punjab Civil Service Punishment and Appeal rules, 1952, which undisputably were in operation at the time the order Annexure ‘B’ was passed on April 7, 1967, ‘warning’ was one of the punishments prescribed therein, though a minor one.

4. So far as the question of not holding a formal enquiry prior to the awarding of this punishment is concerned, it may be that the enquiry held against the petitioner was not a regular one; but it is not disputed that the charges or the statement of allegations which resulted in infliction of punishment of warning vide order Anne-xure ‘B’ was on the basis of the same facts which are now contained in Annexure ‘C’. If that is so as already indicated, it is not disputed-then obviously the petitioner cannot be punished for the second time for the same lapse or on the same charges. In this view of the matter the charge-sheet Annexure ‘C’ and any proceedings taken on the basis of the same are hereby quashed.

5. Thus this petition is allowed as indicated above with no order as to costs.

6. Petition allowed.