- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri I.M Lall (Petit... v. The Union Of India T...
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Shri I.M. Lall, a former member of the Indian Civil Service (ICS), resigned with effect from 2 October 1957. The respondents are (1) the Union of India through the Ministry of Home Affairs and (2) the State of Punjab through its Chief Secretary.
Under the Civil Service Regulations (CSR) as amended in 1921 Articles 561 and 983 guaranteed an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 subject to a minimum of £1,000 and permitted options as to place/currency of payment. In 1957 the Government of India (by Notification dated 29 June 1957) substituted Articles 561 and 983. The substituted provisions classified annuitants into Indian and non-Indian officers and, in effect, restricted Indian officers to payment in rupees in India (fixed at a rupee amount), reserving the sterling option to non-Indian officers or to specified channels.
The Punjab Government initially issued an order in January 1964 granting the petitioner an annuity of Rs.13,333.33 under the amended Articles (i.e., payable in rupees). The petitioner later sought payment of the minimum £1,000 in sterling in the United Kingdom. In October 1964 the Punjab Government (Annexure E) issued an order (in supersession of January order) granting the petitioner an annuity of Rs.10,666.66 subject to a minimum of £1,000 under the unamended Articles and indicating the petitioner’s option to receive payment in the U.K. Subsequently, in December 1965 the Punjab Government revoked the October 1964 order and again authorised payment in rupees under the amended Article 561 (Annexure G), without giving reasons and without affording the petitioner an opportunity to be heard.
The petitioner filed this writ petition (in July 1966) seeking quashing of the December 1965 order (Annexure G) and a writ of mandamus directing respondents to pay his annuity at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000 in the United Kingdom (as per the October 1964 order). Affidavits were filed by both respondents; rejoinders and supplementary material were filed by the petitioner. The High Court heard arguments, examined constitutional and historical materials concerning pension guarantees, and delivered the judgment summarized here.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner (an ICS officer who resigned effective 2 October 1957) is entitled to receive his annuity at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000 in sterling in the United Kingdom under Articles 561 and 983 as they stood before the 1957 amendment.
- Whether the 1957 amendment (substitution) of Articles 561 and 983, retrospectively effective from 12 June 1956, is valid as against the constitutional guarantee in Article 314 of the Constitution.
- Whether the President (or Central Government) had the power to make the 1957 amendment by notification — in particular, whether that power derived from the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution or from section 3(1) of the All India Services Act, 1951 — as applied to an ICS officer who had not become a member of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS).
- Whether procedural defects (failure to give the petitioner an opportunity to show cause before rescinding the October 1964 order) rendered the December 1965 order invalid for breach of principles of natural justice.
- Whether the petitioner’s claimed right (if established) would be infructuous because payment from the Home Treasury (U.K.) is not practicable.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments (Shri I.M. Lall)
- He is governed by the unamended Articles 561 and 983 (as amended in 1921) which fixed an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 subject to a minimum of £1,000 and gave the annuitant the option to take payment at the Home Treasury (i.e., in sterling) or in India.
- The constitutional guarantee protecting conditions of service (including pension) — culminating in Article 314 of the Constitution — preserves his right to the sterling minimum and the option, and the 1957 amendment cannot take that away.
- The proviso to section 247(1)(b) of the Government of India Act, 1935 (and analogous guarantees in the Independence Act and the Constitution) prevent making rules less favourable to him than those in force when he was appointed (he joined ICS on 2 October 1922 and the 1921 Articles were then operative).
- Even if “changed circumstances” could permit change, such change must be expressly provided by the Constitution; a Presidential notification under Article 309 or rule under the All India Services Act cannot abrogate Article 314 protections.
- The petitioner also argued that the Punjab Government’s revocation (Annexure G) of the October 1964 order was made without giving him an opportunity to show cause, violating principles of natural justice.
Respondents’ Arguments (Union of India and State of Punjab)
- The petitioner is entitled only to the annuity as fixed by the amended Articles 561 and 983 (i.e., rupee annuity of Rs.13,333.33 for Indians payable in India).
- Article 314 permits modification in view of changed circumstances; the Government of India validly amended the CSR in exercise of power under the proviso to Article 309 and section 3(1) of the All India Services Act, 1951.
- The October 1964 order (Annexure E) was issued under a bona fide mistake by the Accountant General who had not taken the amended provisions into account; once the State was so advised by the Government of India, the State corrected (superseded) the mistaken order by Annexure G.
- Even if some procedural lapse occurred, the State had authority to correct an incorrect grant; further, the Government of India or the High Commissioner mechanism can be used to pay pensions in sterling, so the petitioner's relief would be impracticable.
- Failure to place the rule/amendment before Parliament (section 3(2) All India Services Act) was not material because the requirement is directory and not mandatory (relying on Jan Mohammad v. State of Gujarat reasoning).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| R.P. Kapur v. Union of India, A.I.R. 1964 S.C. 787 | Interpretation that the phrase "as changed circumstances may permit" qualifies the rights respecting disciplinary matters (second part) and not the guaranteed "conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension" (first part). | The Court relied on R.P. Kapur to hold that Article 314's words permitting change by "changed circumstances" qualify only the disciplinary-rights part, not the pension/remuneration guarantee; thus the 1957 amendment could not be justified on the broad ground of changed circumstances as to pension conditions. |
| Grewal v. State of Punjab, A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 512 | Validity of parliamentary delegation to make rules under Article 312 / All India Services Act. | Cited to show that Parliament validly delegated power to make rules for All India Services; used to frame limits on what rule-making can alter given Article 314 protections. |
| Jan Mohammad v. State of Gujarat, A.I.R. 1966 S.C. 385 | Failure to lay rules before the legislature does not necessarily vitiate their validity — the laying requirement may be directory. | The Court adopted the reasoning from Jan Mohammad (Shah, J.'s observations) to conclude that section 3(2) of the All India Services Act (requirement to lay rules before Parliament) is not mandatory in the sense that failure to lay immediately invalidates rules; thus delay in placing the 1957 amendment before Parliament did not itself invalidate it. |
| Govindarju v. State of Mysore, A.I.R. 1963 Mysore 265 | Authority cited on the point of retrospective effect of amendments (authority treated as supporting non-retrospective approach). | Cited by the petitioner to contend retrospective amendment was impermissible; the petitioner did not press this authority after it was noted that it had been overruled by a later Supreme Court decision. |
| B.S. Vadera v. Union of India, A.I.R. 1969 S.C. 118 | Supreme Court decision which overruled Govindarju on the relevant point. | The existence of this later decision caused the petitioner to abandon the contention based on Govindarju; the Court recorded that Govindarju had been overruled by B.S. Vadera. |
| State of Orissa v. Dr. (Miss) Binapani Dei, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 1269 | Principle that administrative orders affecting civil rights must conform with principles of natural justice. | Used (along with several other authorities) to support the proposition that the State could not validly revise the October 1964 order without first affording the petitioner an opportunity to show cause; the Court struck down Annexure G for lack of such opportunity. |
| A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 262 | Natural justice requirements for administrative decisions affecting rights. | Cited as one of the authorities establishing that administrative decisions with civil consequences must comply with natural justice; applied to invalidate the December 1965 supersession without hearing. |
| Lapointe v. L. Association, 1906 A.C. 535 | English authority on natural justice principles applicable to administrative decisions. | Grouped with other English authorities to support the natural justice requirement; Court relied on these when holding the petitioner should have been given an opportunity before the State rescinded the October 1964 order. |
| Ridge v. Baldwin, 1962 (2) All E.R. 66 | Landmark English precedent on natural justice (procedural fairness) in administrative action. | Invoked as part of the jurisprudence requiring hearing before administrative orders that affect civil rights; contributed to the conclusion invalidating Annexure G for failure to afford a hearing. |
| Duryappa v. Fernando, 1967 (2) All E.R. 152 | Another English authority cited for natural justice principles. | Used collectively with other precedents to support the requirement of an opportunity to be heard before varying orders affecting financial rights. |
| R. v. Senate of University of Aston, 1969 (2) All E.R. 964 | English authority on procedural fairness in administrative decisions. | Again cited among authorities supporting natural justice; Court treated these authorities as establishing the requirement to hear the affected person before varying financial entitlements. |
| Full Bench of High Court of Allahabad (Civil Misc. Writs Nos. 3006 of 1967 & 1646 of 1968) — (dated 10 Sep 1969) | Decision concerning pension rights of judges and effect of subsequent statutory changes; discussed for comparison. | The Court distinguished this Full Bench decision (which dealt with different provisions and facts concerning High Court Judges) and held it not to assist respondents on the particular Article 314 / Articles 561 & 983 point raised by the petitioner. |
| Division Bench of High Court of Patna (Civil Writ No. 720 of 1968 — C.K. Raman) — (dated 1 Jul 1969) | Challenge to amendments of Articles 561 and 983 on grounds similar to petitioner’s; court considered but reached different conclusions. | The Court examined this decision and distinguished it because the issues and the precise contention (omission of option to receive sterling payment) in the present case were different; the Patna decision did not assist the respondents in the present matter. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a structured manner, relying exclusively on the materials and arguments in the record:
- Historical and statutory background: The Court reviewed the legislative and regulatory history of the annuity provision — from East India Company annuity funds, through the English statutes (1874, 1861, 1915, 1919, 1935), the India Independence Act 1947 and the Governor-General's provisional order, to the Constitution (Article 314). This established the long-standing origin of the annuity and the continuity of guarantees for ICS officers.
- Nature of the unamended Articles: The Court analysed Articles 561 and 983 as they stood before the 1957 substitution. It concluded that read together they fixed an annuity (Rs. 10,666-10-8) subject to a sterling minimum of £1,000 and implicitly gave the annuitant an option to take payment at the Home Treasury (sterling) or in India (rupees), with conversion-rate mechanisms established by prior Secretary of State resolutions.
- Effect of the 1957 amendment: The substituted Articles classified annuitants into Indian and non-Indian officers and, for Indian officers, removed the option to take payment in sterling; instead a rupee amount was fixed (Rs. 13,333.33). The Court concentrated on whether this change could lawfully affect the constitutional guarantee in Article 314.
- Interpretation of Article 314: Relying on the reasoning in R.P. Kapur, the Court held that Article 314 protects “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension” unqualified by the phrase “as changed circumstances may permit”, because those qualifying words relate to the subsequent part (rights as respects disciplinary matters). Consequently, the guaranteed pension/remuneration conditions could not be altered by ordinary administrative rule-making merely on the ground of "changed circumstances."
-
Competence to amend by Presidential notification or under All India Services Act: The Court examined the claim that the President amended Articles 561 and 983 under the proviso to Article 309 and/or under section 3(1) of the All India Services Act. It held:
- The proviso to Article 309 is subordinate to Article 314; the proviso cannot be treated as the "express provision" contemplated by Article 314's opening words allowing alteration of guaranteed conditions. Thus the President could not, by notification under Article 309's proviso, abrogate the Article 314 guarantee as to pension conditions for ICS officers who had not become IAS members.
- Section 3(1) of the All India Services Act empowers rule-making for All India Services (IAS), but officers of the erstwhile ICS who had not become IAS members (the petitioner averred he had not been declared an IAS member) remained outside the pale of that Act; therefore section 3(1) could not be relied upon to affect Article 314 rights of such persons.
- Character of the CSR provisions and concept of "rules": The Court rejected the petitioner's argument that Articles are "regulations" distinct from "rules" and therefore not amendable under rule-making powers. It observed that the CSR themselves refer to "rules" throughout and that provisions effectively operate as rules; accordingly the semantic distinction did not assist the respondents.
- Laying requirement under section 3(2) All India Services Act: The Court accepted the respondents' submission (following Jan Mohammad reasoning) that the duty to lay rules before Parliament is not of the nature that invalidates rules from their date of making when there is failure/delay in laying; the Court therefore treated the omission/delay in laying the amendment before Parliament as not fatal to legal validity.
- Natural justice and the State's revocation of the October 1964 order: The Court found that the December 1965 order (Annexure G) superseding the October 1964 order affected the petitioner's financial right. Citing a series of authorities on natural justice (State of Orissa v. Binapani Dei, A.K. Kraipak, Ridge v. Baldwin, etc.), the Court held that administrative orders which affect civil/financial rights require that the affected person be given an opportunity to be heard before variation. The State had not afforded the petitioner such an opportunity; consequently Annexure G was invalid.
- Practicality of relief: The respondents argued the right would be infructuous because Home Treasury payments were no longer practicable. The Court rejected this as a ground to deny relief, noting other CSR provisions continued to contemplate Home Treasury or High Commissioner payment procedures and that the respondents could arrange payment through appropriate channels; the petitioner had limited his prayer to a direction to pay in sterling at the fixed minimum, leaving the mode of respondents' compliance to them.
- Distinguishing other authorities: The Court considered but distinguished the Full Bench of Allahabad and the Patna Division Bench decisions relied upon by respondents as involving different statutory/regulatory provisions and facts; consequently those decisions did not control the present outcome.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The writ petition is allowed. The Court held that the petitioner is entitled to the pension rights as provided in Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations as they stood before the 1957 substitution (i.e., as amended in 1921 and prior to the 1957 substitution), read with the Secretary of State resolutions of 29 September 1926 and 25 February 1928. In particular, the petitioner is entitled to opt for payment of his annuity in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000 per annum in the United Kingdom.
Consequential orders and direct effect:
- The December 15, 1965 order (Annexure G) of the State of Punjab is quashed.
- The respondents are directed to pay the pension/annuity to the petitioner at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000 per annum as originally ordered by the Punjab Government in the October 20, 1964 order (Annexure E), in the United Kingdom. The petitioner’s expressed option in Annexure E was recognized as effective.
- Costs are awarded to the petitioner fixed at Rs. 250/-.
Broader implications: The judgment is confined in its operative ratio to officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service who had not become members of the Indian Administrative Service. The Court expressly limited its holding to that category; it did not pronounce a general rule altering the position of officers who became IAS members. The opinion does not assert that it creates a wider precedent beyond the described factual and legal ambit.
T.V.R Tatachari, J.:— This writ petition has been filed by Shri I.M Lall regarding the payment of annuity to him. The respondents in the writ petition are (1) the union of India, through the Ministry of Home affairs, and (2) the State of Punjab, through the Chief Secretary to the Government of Punjab.
2. The petitioner was appointed to the Indian Civil Service, and he served his usal term in various capacities. He was permitted to resign his commission in the Indian Civil Service with effect from 2nd October, 1957, by the Governor of the State of Punjab (respondent No. 2), as the petitioner was serving in the said State at the time. Under Article 561 of the Civil Service Regulations as amended in 1921, “an officer, who has been twenty five years in service counting from the date of his covenant, or from the date of the despatch of the Secretary of State announcing his appointment (whichever may have been earlier); and who has rendered twenty one years' active service is entitled, on his resignation of service being accepted to an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8”, and “the annuity is subject to a minimum of £1,000”. Article 983 of the Civil Service Regulations as amended in 1921, was as follows:
“983(a). When payment of annuities or gratuites is taken at the Home Treasury, it may be taken at the option of the recipient either in rupees converted into sterling at the rate of exchange declared to exist on the date on which payment falls due or at the fixed sterling minimum:
(b) When payment is taken in India, it may be taken at the option of the recipient either in rupees or at the fixed sterling minimum converted into rupees at the rate of exchange declared to exist on the date on which payment falls due:
Provided that annuitants of the following classes may, at their option receive the fixed sterling minimum converted into rupees at the rate of 1s. 4d. to the rupee, so long as they continue to reside in India:—
(i) annuitants resident in India who were in receipt of annuities converted at this rate on the 1st February, 1921;
(ii) annuitants of Indian domicile who were, on the 1st February, 1921, temporarily drawing their annuities in sterling;
(iii) annuitants of Indian domicile who were serving in the Indian Civil Service on the 1st February, 1921:”
3. Subsequently, by a resolution (Annexure R-2) of the Secretary of State of India in Council, the words “the rate of exchange declared to exist on the date on which payment falls due” in Article 983(a) and (b) of the Regulations were substituted by the words “such rate of exchange as the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribed”. By another resolution (Annexure R-3), dated 29th September, 1926, the Secretary of State in Council decided that “where a rule made by the Secretary of State in Council regarding payment or recoveries refers to a rate of exchange which the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribe, that rate shall, until further orders, be the rate notified by the Controller of the Currency for telegraphic transfers from Calcutta on London on the 20th of the month preceding that in which the payment or recovery is made.” Again, by a resolution (Annexure R-4), dated 25th February, 1928 the Secretary of State in Council decided that “where a rule made by the Secretary of State in Council refers to the rate of exchange which the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribe, the rate shall until further orders, be 1s. 6d.” According to the respondents, no further alteration in the said rate of exchange was made by the Secretary of State, and the said rate of exchange continued to be in force.
4. By a notification No. F-7(19) EV/57, dated 29th June, 1957, the Government of India substituted the Articles 561 and 983 by two new Articles which run as under;—
“561.—Retirement and Annuity—
An officer who has been twenty five years in the service counting from the date of his covenant or from the date of the despatch of the Secretary of State announcing his appointment whichever may have been earlier and who has rendered 21 years' active service is entitled on his resignation of the service being accepted, to an annuity of Rs. 13,333-5-4 (Rs. 13,333.33 Paise with effect from the 1st April, 1957), if he is an Indian Officer or, being a non Indian Officer, draws his pension in India, and to an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 (Rs. 10,666.66 Paise with effect from the 1st April, 1957), subject to a minimum of £ 1,000 if he is an non-Indian Officer and draws his pension through the High Commissioner for India in London.
983.—Payment of annuities shall be made in India and in rupees.
Provided that in the case of non-Indian Officers such payment may be made as under:—
(a) in India, in rupees
(b) through the High Commissioner for India in the United Kingdom in sterling at such rate of exchange as the President may, by order, prescribe.”
5. It was stated in the said notification that the said substitution shall be deemed to have effect from the 12th June, 1956 in its application to members of the Indian Administrative Service, who, before becoming such members, were members of the India Civil Service.
6. As the resignation of the Petitioner was to have effect after the 1st April, 1957, the Punjab Government, by its letter (Annexure ‘C’) dated 7th January, 1964, granted him an annuity of Rs. 13,333.33 per annum under the amended Article 561. It was stated in the letter that the annuity will commence with effect from the 2nd October, 1957 and will be payable from the Treasury mentioned in the petitioner's application for the grant of annuity. The petitioner appears to have drawn the annuity of Rs. 13,333.33. But on 6th June, 1964, the petitioner, claiming to be entitled to draw a minimum annuity of £ 1000 in sterling, wrote a letter to the Accountant General, Punjab, requesting that an amended pension payment order mentioning therein that the petitioner was entitled to draw the minimum sterling annuity of £ 1000 may be sent to him. The Accountant General of Punjab sent a communication (vide Annexure ‘D’) to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Punjab, Chandigarh, containing a revised certificate and report regarding the annuity payable to the petitioner. The relevant portion of the communication is as follows:—
“In supersession of this Office C. & R. No. PEN (R) I/L-7/40-41/67-17, dated 27-11-1958, it is certified that (subject to the remarks recorded below) qualifying service of Shri I.M Lall, I.C.S, has been duly proved for 25/21 years gross/active service and that an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 subject to a minimum of £ 1000 per annum is admissible under unamended Article 561 read with unamended Article 983 of the Civil Service Regulations (Central).
2. The annuity is provisionally chargeable as follows and is voted:
Provisional Revenues Punjab-Pension of Officers retiring from East Punjab after 14th August, 1947.
3. The annuity will commence from the 2nd October, 1957.
4. When payment of annuity is taken at the Home Treasury (i.e in U.K) it may be taken at the option of the recipient, either in rupees converted into sterling at rate of exchange of 1s. 6d. per rupee or at the fixed sterling minimum. When payment of annuity is taken in India, it may be taken at the option of the recipient either in rupees or at the fixed sterling minimum converted into rupees at the exchange rate of 1s. 6d. per rupee. (The sterling minimum of £ 1000 per annum when converted into rupees at the exchange rate of 1s. 6d. per rupee for taking payment in India will fetch him Rs. 13,333-33 Paise per annum as he is drawing at present).
5. A reference is also invited to Article 984 of CSR (Central) under which transfer from Home Treasury (i.e U.K) to an Indian Treasury and vice-versa is permitted twice only.
6. In view of para 4 above, the officer is being asked to intimate his option whether he wants payment of his annuity in India, either in rupees or at fixed sterling minimum converted into rupees at the exchange rate of 1s. 6d. per rupee or in U.K in rupees converted into sterling at the fixed sterling at the rate of exchange of 1s. 6d. per rupee at the fixed sterling minimum.
7. He has already been authorised an annuity of Rs. 13,333.33 Paise per annum from 2-10-1957, which will be adjusted.
8. Sanction may kindly be accorded early so that revised P.P.O may be issued to the officer.
(Sd.) …,
Asstt. Accounts Officer.
7. A copy of the said communication was sent to the petitioner along with a covering letter (Annexure D), dated 3rd October, 1964, by which the petitioner was required to intimate his option regarding withdrawal of his annuity in terms of para 6 of the communication (report), so that a revised pension payment order may be issued in his favour accordingly as soon as the revised sanction of the Government was received. According to the petitioner, he intimated the Accountant-General that he preferred to receive annuity in the United Kingdom in pounds sterling, and requested that arrangement may be made accordingly. The Accountant-General communicated the same to the Chief Secretary, and the Punjab Government cancelled its order (Annexure ‘C’), dated 7th January, 1964, and passed a new order (Annexure ‘E’), dated 20th Octoter, 1964. It was stated in this order that in supersession of the earlier order, dated 7th June, 1964, a revised sanction of the Governor of Punjab was accorded to the grant to the petitioner of an annuity of Rs. 10,666.66 Paise subject to a minimum of £1000 per annum under unamended Article 561 read with unamended Article 983 of the Civil Service Regulations (Central), that the annuity will commence with effect from the 2nd October, 1957, and that the same will be payable from the Treasury to be intimated by the petitioner to the Accountant-General, Punjab. It was also stated therein that the annuity of Rs. 13,333.33 which had already been authorised will be adjusted, and that the concurrence of the Finance Department had been obtained. A copy of the said order was forwarded to the Accountant-General, Punjab, who was asked to take necessary action as regards payment in sterling or in rupees in the light of the option of the petitioner. A copy was also forwarded to Secretary the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, for information. On 27th November, 1964, the Accountant-General, Punjab, wrote a letter (Annexure ‘F’) to the Accountant-General of Central Revenues, New Delhi, referring to the revised order (Annexure ‘E’), dated 20th October, 1964, and requesting the Accountant-General of Central Revenues to arrange the payment of annuity to the petitioner. It was stated in the said letter that at that time the petitioner was drawing his annuity at New Delhi Treasury, that he had desired the payment from November, 1964, onwards in the United Kingdom, and that necessary action to authorise the payment accordingly may be taken by the Accountant-General of Central Revenues, under intimation to the petitioner and to the Accountant General, Punjab. A copy of the said letter was sent to the petitioner, and he was asked to contact the Accountant General of Central Revenues, New Delhi, as regards the payment of the annuity in the United Kingdom. No action appears to have been taken by the authorities for some time, and the petitioner, gave a notice to the Accountant-General, Punjab, intimating him that he world resort to legal action. Then in December, 1965, he received a copy of an order (Annexure ‘C’) of the Punjab Government, dated 15th December, 1965, whereby the earlier order (Annexure ‘E’), dated 20th October, 1964, was superseded, and the Governor of Punjab accorded a revised sanction to the grant to the petitioner of an annuity of Rs. 13,333.33 Paise per annum under the amended Article 561 of the Civil Service Regulations. It was stated in the said order that the annuity will commence with effect from 2nd October, 1957 and will be payable from the Treasury mentioned in the application of the petitioner for the grant of annuity. Thus, the earlier order, dated 20th October, 1964, was revised, and the annuity was made payable in rupees in India, and was not subject to any sterling minimum. No reasons were given in the said order for the revision of the earlier Order. According to the petitioner, however, the said order was passed in anticipation of the devaluation of the Indian rupee, which took place subsequently on 6th June, 1966. The petitoner wrote letters to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Punjab, asking why the earlier order, dated 20th October, 1964 was revised, but he was not given any reply. He then served the respondents with notices that if the annuity was not paid in the United Kingdom in pounds sterling, he would take legal action. He, however, did not receive any reply to the said notices and, therefore, filed the present writ petition praying (1) that “the order (Annexure ‘G’), dated 15th December, 1965, which made the annuity due to petitioner payable in depreciated Indian rupee”, may be quashed, and (2) that a writ of mandamus may be issued to the respondents directing them to “pay the annuity to the petitioner at the fixed minimum of £ 1000 as originally ordered in the order (Annexure ‘E’), dated 20th October, 1964, in the United Kingdom.”
8. In opposition to the writ petition, an affidavit of Shri A.N Batabyal Under Secretary to Government of India Ministry of Home Affairs was filed on behalf of respondent No. 1, and an affidavit of Sardar Gyan Singh Kahlon, Chief Secretary to Government of Punjab, was filed on behalf of respondent No. 2. The petitioner filed a rejoinder in reply to the said affidavits. A supplementary affidavit of Shri Batabyal was also filed on behalf of respondent No. 1, and the petitioner filed a rejoinder to the supplementary affidavit.
9. The main claim of the petitioner is that he is entitled to the payment of his annuity at the fixed minimum of £ 1000 in sterling in the United Kingdom, as provided in the unamended Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations, that the said right has been preserved and guaranteed under Article 314 of the Constitution, and that the amendment of the said Articles affecting his right is without jurisdiction and, therefore, invalid. The said claim is contested, by the respondents, according to whom the petitioner is entiled only to an annuity of Rs. 13,333.33 payable in rupees in India as provided by the amended Articles 561 and 983, that under Article 314 of the Constitution the petitioner is entitled to receive from the Government only “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit as he was entitled to immediately before the commencement of the Constitution”, that because of the changed circumstances the Government of India was competent and deemed it proper to amend Articles 561 and 983, that the President made the amendments in exercise of the powers conferred on him by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution and sub-section (1) of section 3 of the All India Services Act, 1951, and the amendment was perfectly justified, legitimate and valid, and that there has been no infringement of constitutional guarantee. They also pleaded that the order (Annexure E), dated 20th Octobe., 1964 was issued by the Accountant General, Punjab, under a bona fide mistake as the amended provisions of articles 561 and 983 were not brought to his notice at the time when the order was issued that in the middle of September, 1965, it was pointed out to the State Government by the Government of India that the said order of the Punjab Government, dated 20th October, 1964, was not in consonance with the provisions of Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations as ameded, and that thereupon the State Government superseded the said order and issued a revised order (Annexure ‘G’), dated 15th December, 1965.
10. Before dealing with the contentions of the parties, it is necessary to refer to the provisions relating to the Constitutional guarantee regarding the annuity relied upon by the petitioner. The petitioner appended as Annexure ‘A’ to his rejoinder a brief statement of the history of the annuity to which officers of the Indian Civil Service have been entitled ever since the institution of the Indian Civil Service, and also the history of the Articles 551 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations. In that statement, the petitioner traced the annuity back to the days of the East India Company. He pointed out that it appears from the English statute 37 Vict. Ch. 12 (8th June, 1874) that the East India Company had established ??? funds for its servants, that the fund for Bengal was known as ‘Bengal Civil Service Annuity Fund’ and it was established by the authority of the Court of Directors of the Company “for the grant of annuities to the Civil servants of the said Company on their retiring from service, who should become subscribers to the said institutions”, and that similar Funds had teen established in Madras and Bombay for the grant of similar annuities. He then pointed out that after the mutiny in 1857, the Crown took over the administration of the country, and the British Parliament passed the Act, 21, 22 Vict. Ch. 106 (2nd August, 1858), by which a new post of “Secretary of State” was created and he was given a Council. Sanction 58 of the said Act continued the services of all persons who held offices under the Company and they were deemed to be holding their respective offices under Her Majesty. Their claims to pension, or any claims “on the various Annuity Funds of the several Presidencies in India” were preserved. Section 2 of the Statute 37 Vict. Ch. 12, provided, inter alia, as follows:—
“Every covenanted civil servant, who shall be subscriber to any of the said Civil Annuity Funds at or after the date of such notification shall be entitled on retirement to the benefits granted by the despatch of the Secretary of State in Council to the Government of India, dated the tenth of February one thousand eight hundred and seventy one, namely, if he shall have completed twenty five years' service and twenty one years' residence in India a full annuity of one thousand pounds payable in England, or Company's rupees ten thousand six hundred and sixty six ten annas and eight pies payable in Bengal, or Comppny's rupees ten thousand six hundred and fifty payable in Medras or Bombay.”
11. In 1861, the Parliament passed the Indian Civil Service Act, 1861, (24, 25 Vict. Ch. 54). In 1915, the Govt. of India Act, 1915 (5 and 6 Geo. 5. Ch. 61) was enacted. Sanction 130 of the said Act repealed several previous Acts including the India Civil Service Act, 1861, but by clause (c) of the proviso to the said section, “the tenure of office, conditions of service, terms of reference or right to pension of any officer appointed before the commencement of this Act” were left unaffected. The English statute, 37 Vict. Ch. 12, however, was not repealed, and the annuities to the servants of the East India Company who had become the servants of Her Majesty continued to be regulated by the said Act.
12. In 1919, the Government of India Act, 1919 (9 and 10 Geo. 5 Ch. 101), whereby the 1915 Act was amended, was enacted. It is sufficient to refer to the provisions of Section 96-B inserted by the said Act. Sub-section (1) of Section 96-B provided that;—
“Subject to the provisions of this act and of rules made thereunder every person in the Civil service of the Crown in India holds office during His Majesty's pleasure,……………”
13. Sub-section (2) provided that—
“The Secretary of State in Council may make Rules for regulating the classification of the civil services in India, the methods of recruitment, their conditions of service pay and allowances, and discipline and conduct………”
14. Sub-section (3) provided that—
“The right to pensions and the scale and conditions of pensions of all persons in the Civil service of the Crown in India appointed by the Secretary of State in Council shall be regulated in accordance with the rules in force at the time of the passing of the Government of India Act, 1919. Any such rules may be varied or added to by the Secretary of State in Council and shall have effect as so varied or added to but any such variation or addition shall not adversely affect the pension of any member of the service appointed before the date thereof.
Nothing in this section or in any rule thereunder shall prejudice the rights to which any persons may or may have become entitled under the provisions in relation to pensions contained in the East India Annuity Funds Act, 1874.”
15. Then in 1935, the Government of India Act, 1935 (26 Geo. 5 Ch. 2) was enacted. Section 247 of the said Act dealt with the conditions of service, pensions etc. of the persons recruited by the Secretary of State. The relevant portion of the section is as under:—
“247(1). The conditions of services of all persons appointed to a civil service or a civil post by the Secretary of State shall;—
(a) as respects pay, leave and pensions, and general rights in regard to medical attendance, be such as may be prescribed by rules to be made by the secretary of State;
(b) as respects other matters with respect to which express provision is not made by this Chapter, be such as may be prescribed by rules to be made by the Secretary of State in so far as he thinks fit to make such rules, and, in so far and so long as provision is not made by such rules, by rules to be made as respects persons serving in connection with the affairs of the Federation, by the Governor-General or some person or persons authorised by the Governor-General to make rules for the purpose and, as respects persons serving in connection with the affairs of Province, by the Governor of the Province or some person or persons authorised by the Governor to make rules for the purpose;
Provided that no rule made under this sub-section shall have effect so as to give any person appointed to a civil service or civil post by the Secretary of State less favourable terms as respects remuneration or pension than were given to him by the rules in force on the date on which he was first appointed to his service or appointed to his post.”
16. Thus, by virtue of the proviso to clause (b) of sub-section (1) no rule could be made under the sub-section so as to give a person appointed to a civil service less favourable terms as respects pension than were given to him by the rules in force on the date on which he was first appointed to his service or to his post. It may be stated here that section 274 of the Act proved that the East India annuity Funds Act 1874, shall continue to have effect but subject to certain adaptations viz. that in the place of the “Secretary of State in Council”, “Secretary of State” had to be read, and in the place of the “Revenues of India”. “Revenues of the Federation” were made liable.
17. Then in 1947, the India Independence Act, 1947 (10 and II Geo. 6. Ch. 30 was enacted. Sub-sections (1) and (2) of section 10 of the Act provided as follows;
“10(1) The provisions of this Act keeping in force provisions of the Government of India Act, 1935, shall not continue in force the provisions of that Act relating to appointments to the civil services of and civil posts under, the Crown in India by the Secretary of State, or provisions of that Act relating to the reservation of post.
(2) Every person who—
(a) having been appointed by the Secretary of State, or Secretary of State in Council, to a Civil service of the Crown in India continues on and after the appointed day to serve under the Government of either of the new Dominions or of any province or part thereof: or
(b) ***
shall be entitled to receive from the Governments of the Dominions and Provinces or parts which he is from time to time serving or, as the case may be, …………………………………. the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or, as the case may be as respects the tenure of his office, or rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit, as that person was entitled to immediately before the appointed day”.
18. In pursuance of the provisions in Section 8(2), 9(1)(c) and 19(4) of the Indian Independence Act 1917, the Governor General made the India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947, whereby certain omissions, additions, adaptations and modifications were made in the provisions of the Government of India Act, 1935. By this order, the old section 247 was substituted by a new section 247, which runs as under;—
“Conditions of service of persons originally recruited by Secretary of State:—
The conditions of service of all persons who, having been appointed by the Secretary of State or the Secretary of State in Council to a civil service of the Crown in India, continue on and after the date of the establishment of the Dominion to serve under the Government of the Dominion or of any Province, shall—
(a) As respects persons serving in connection with the affairs of the Dominion be such as may be prescribed by rules made by the Governor General;
(b) As repects persons serving in connection with the affairs of a Province—
(i) in regard to their pay, leave, pensions, general rights as medical attendance and any other matter which immediately before the establishment of the Dominion was regulated by rules made by the Secretary of State, be such as may be prescribed by rules made by the Governor-General; and
(ii) in regard to any other matter, be such as may be prescribed by rules made by the Governor of the Province.”
19. The constitution of India came into force on 26th January, 1950. Article 314 of the Constitution contains the provision for the protection of existing officers of certain services. It runs as follows:—
“Except as otherwise expressly provided by this Constitution, every person who having been appointed by the Secretary of State or Secretary of State in Council to a civil service of the Crown in India continues on and after the commencement of this Constitution to serve under the Government of India or of a State shall be entitled to receive from the Government of India and the Government of the State, which he is from time to time serving, the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit as that person was entitled to immdiately before such commencement.”
20. In 1960, the British Statues (Application to India) Repeal Act, 1960 was enacted. The said Act repealed amongst others the East India Annuity Funds Act, 1874 (37 and 38 Vict. Ch. 12), but it however saved the operation of the said Act “in relation to India and to persons and things in any way belonging to or connected with India in any country to which the India (Consequential Provision) Act, 1949 (12, 13 and 14 Geo. VI. Ch. 92) extends.”
21. In support of his claim for payment of his annuity in sterling in the United Kingdom, the petitioner relied upon the provisions in Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations as they stood before they were amended in 1957. The said Articles, as amended in 1921 and before they were amended in 1957, have already been set out earlier in this Judgment. A reading of the said Articles show that Article 561 fixed the amount of annuity, and Article 983 prescribed the manner and the places of payment. Article 561 fixed the annuity at Rs. 10,666-10-8, and it was subject to a minimum of £1,000/-. In other words, the annuitant or the recipient of the annuity was ensured of a fixed minimum annuity of £1,000/- sterling. Article 983 had two clauses, (a) and (b). Under clause (a), when the recipient of the annuity takes the payment at the Home Treasury i.e in the United Kingdom, he may, at his option, take the annuity either in rupees converted into sterling at the rate of exchange which the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribe, or at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000/-. Under clause (b), when he takes the payment in India he may take the same, at his option either in rupees or at the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000/- converted into rupees at the rate of exchange which the Secretary of State in Council may, by order, prescribe. A reading of the two clauses shows that, though they did not expressly state so, it is implicit in the clauses that the annuitant or the recipient of the annuity is given the option to take the payment at the Home Treasury under clause (a) or in India under clause (b). Thus, the two Articles, when read together, entitled the annuitant or the recipient of the annuity to an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 subject to a minimum of £1,000/-, and they also entitled him to take payment of the annuity at his option either at the Home Treasury or in India. When he opts to take the payment at the Home Treasury he was given a further option to take the payment either in rupees converted into sterling or at the fixed sterling minimum. When he opts to take the payment in India, he was again given the option to take the payment either in rupees or at the fixed sterling minimum converted into rupees. It is thus clear that if the petitioner is governed by the said Articles as they stood before they were amended in 1957, he has the option to opt for the payment of his annuity in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom. The said Articles, however, were amended in 1957 with retrospective effect from 12th June, 1956. The Articles, as amended in 1957, have already been set out earlier in this Judgment. Under the amended Articles 561 and 983, the annuitants or the recipients of annuity have been classified into two categories viz. Indian Officers and non-Indian Officers. An Indian officer is to take payment of his annuity in India only, and that too only in rupee fixed at Rs. 13,333-5-4 (Rs. 13,333-33 Paise) with effect from the 1st April, 1957. On the other hand, a non-Indian Officer has been given the option to draw his pension or annuity either in India or through the High Commissioner for India in London (United Kingdom). If he opts to draw his pension in India, he can take the same only in rupees fixed at Rs. 13,333-5-4 (Rs. 13,333.33 Paise), and if he opts to draw his pension through the High Commissioner for India in London (United Kingdom), he has been given an annuity of Rs. 10,666-10-8 (Rs. 10,666.66 Paise) with effect from 1st April, 1957, subject to a minimum of £1,000/- and the payment of the same to him may be made through the High Commissioner for India in the United Kingdom in sterling at such rate of exchange as the President may, by order, prescribe. In other words, while under the unamended Articles every annuitant or recipient of annuity was given the option to draw his pennon in sterling in the United Kingdom, the said option has been taken away under the amended Articles in the case of officers who are Indians, and it has been retained in the case of non-Indian officers.
22. The contention of the petitioner is that he is governed by the unamended Articles, that the option to draw his pension in sterling in the United Kingdom has been guaranteed by the various constitutional provision from time to time and finally by Articles 314 of the Constitution of India and that the amendment of the said Articles in 1957 omitting the minimum sterling and taking away the option is violative of the constitutional guarantee and, therefore, without jurisdiction and invalid. On the other hand, the contention of Shri Mehta, learned counsel for respondent No. 1 and Shri Anoop Singh, learned counsel for respondent No. 2 is that the petitioner is governed by the Articles as amended in 1957, that the amendment has been made in view of the changed circumstances as provided in Article 314 of the Constitution, that the amendment is not violative of any constitutional guarantee, and that the amendment is quite valid, and the amended Articles govern the payment of annuity to the petitioner.
23. The petitioner, Shri I.M Lall, contended firstly that the conditions of his service which have been guaranteed by the Constitution and could not be changed or altered at all, and that the Articles 561 and 983 were not amendable at all so as to take away or drop the option to receive payment in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom. The various constitutional provisions relating to the service conditions of, and the payment of pension to the officers of the Indian Civil Service have already been set out earlier in this judgment. The proviso to section 247(1)(b) of the Government of India Act, 1935, clearly prohibits the framing, of any rule by the Secretary of State which has the effect of giving an officer of the Civil Service “less favourable terms as respects remuneration or pension” than were given to him by the rules in force on the date on which he was first appointed to his service or appointed to his post. Admittedly, the petitioner joined the Indian Civil Service on 2nd October, 1922, and the Articles as amended in 1921 were the Articles in force on the date on which he was first appointed to the service or appointed to his post. The guarantee contained in section 247 was reiterated in section 10(2) of the Indian Independence Act, 1947, section 247 of the Government of India Act, 1935, as adopted and modified by the India (Provisional Constitution) Order, 1947, and Article 314 of the Constitution of India. In the said Article, it has been clearly stated that the officer “shall be entitled to receive from the Government of India and the Government of the State, which he is from time to time serving, the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters as rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit as that person was entitled to immediately before such commencement.”
24. In view of the said constitutional guarantee, the petitioner contends that the option to draw his annuity in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom as provided in the unamended Articles 561 and 983 continues to be available to him and could not be taken away. The only answer of the respondents to the said contention is that the conditions of service could be altered and the Articles could be amended in view of the changed circumstances as provided in Article 314 of the Constitution. But, this answer is untenable on the very language of Article 314. The words “as changed circumstances may permit” in Article 314 qualify only the words “and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or rights as similar thereto”. As pointed out by the Supreme Court in R.P Kapur v. Union of India, A.I.R 1964 SC 787, 791, the latter portion of Article 314 consists of two parts, the first being “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension”, and the second part being” and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit.” The words “as changed circumstances may permit” qualify the second part and not the first. We are concerned in the present case only with the first part, and according to it the officer concerned is entitled to “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension…………as that person was entitled to immediately before such commencement.” This interpretation of the Article derives support from the fact that a comma was placed after the word “permit” in section 10(2) of the Indian Independence Act, 1947, the language of which is similar to the language used in Article 314. The relevant portion of the said sub-section is: “shall be entitled to receive……the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension, and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters…………………………………or rights as similar thereto as changed circumstances may permit as that person was entitled to immediately before the appointed day.” It is the same guarantee which was vouchsafed in the Indian Independence Act that has been reiterated in Article 314, and the insertion of the comma in section 10(2) after the word “permit” is significant and shows that the words “as changed circumstances may permit” were intended to qualify the words “and the same rights as respects disciplinary matters or rights as similar thereto”, and not the words “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension”. It therefore, follows that the Articles, as they stood before 1957, could not be amended taking away or dropping the option to receive payment in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom in the case of Indian Officers on the ground of “changed circumstances”.
25. Shri Lall also argued that even if the words “as changed circumstances may permit” qualify the words “the same conditions of service as respects remuneration, leave and pension”, the changed circumstances mean only the constitutional changes which occurred after the transfer of power in August, 1947 and the coming into force of the Constitution in January, 1950, and they “do not mean that as time passes circumstances change and, therefore, new rules may be framed to meet the new circumstances due to passage of time “as pointed out by the Supreme Court in R.P Kapur's case (supra) at page 791, and that in any case it has not been stated by the respondents in their counter-affidavits what were the changed circumstances which necessitated the amendment of the Articles in question. This argument of Shri Lall appears to have considerable force. But, I would rather base my conclusion on the interpretation of Article 314 than on the fact that the respondents did not set out or state specifically the changed circumstances.
26. Shri Mehta contended that the Secretary of State in Council had fixed the rate of exchange at 1sh. 6d., that the fixed sterling minimum of £1,000/-, when converted into rupees at 1sh. 6d. per rupee, would come to Rs. 13,333.33 Paise which is the amount of annuity fixed for Indians under the amended Articles 561 and 983, and therefore, the provision as respects pension or annuity in the amended Articles cannot be said to be less favourable than the provision as respects pension in the unamended Articles. But, this is not an answer to the contention of the petitioner. The contention of Shri Lall is that under the unamended Articles, he is entitled to an option to draw his annuity in sterling at the fixed minimum sterling of £1,000/- in the United Kingdom, that the said option has been taken away by the amended Articles, and that the provisions as respects pension or annuity in the amended Articles is, therefore less favourable than the provision as respects pension in the unamended Articles. Further there is a difference between the language of the earlier constitutional provisions and the language used in Article 314 of the present Constitution. Article 314 does not speak of “less favourable terms”, but states that the person concerned shall be entitled to receive “the same conditions of service” as respects pension as that person was entitled to immediately before the commencement of the Constitution. The terms of the amended Articles omitting the option to draw the pension at the fixed minimum sterling in the United Kingdom cannot be said to be the same conditions of service as respects pension which persons like the petitioner were entitled to before the commencement of the Constitution under the unamended Articles. The amendment of the Articles was, therefore violative of the Constitutional quarantee contained in Article 314, and was consequently invalid, and ineffective. This invalidity and in effectiveness has, however, to be restricted to officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service who have not become members of the Indian Administrative Service as the legal position of only such officers has to be considered in this case, as will be seen presently.
27. The second contention of Shri Lall was that even if the Articles in question could be changed or amended, the said change or amendment could be made only by an express provision in the Constitution and it could not be made by a Notification by the President of India because of the opening words “except as otherwise expressly provided by this Constitution” in Article 314. This contention also, in my opinion, has to be accepted as well founded. The said opening words can only mean that the guarantee given under the Article that the persons mentioned therein shall be entitled to receive from the Government of India and the Government of the State the same conditions of service as respects “remuneration, leave and pension” as they were entitled to immediately before the commencement of the Constitution cannot be changed or whittled down, unless such a change is “expressly” provided by the Constitution itself. That seems to me to be the significance of the words “except as otherwise expressly provided by this Constitution”. In other words, even if the guarantee regarding remuneration, leave and pension is to be changed by reason of “changed circumstances”, the said change can be effected only by an “express” provision in the Constitution. It was stated in the affidavits filed on behalf of the respondents that the amendment of the Articles 561 and 983 was made in exercise of the power conferred upon the President by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution. But, the opening words “subject to the provision of this Constitution” in Article 309 show that the provisions in the said Article are subject to the provisions in Article 314, and that the operation of the Article 309 is limited by Article 314. The provision in the proviso to Article 309 cannot be regarded as an express provision of the Constitution referred to in the words “except as otherwise expressly provided by this Constitution” in Article 314, as the proviso to Article 309 is a transitional provision which confers a general power on the President or the Governor or Rajpramukh of a State to make rules regulating the recruitment and the conditions of service of persons appointed to services and posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or the State, and is not an “express provision” which provides for a change of the guarantee in Article 314 as respects remuneration, leave and pension. Thus, the respondents cannot derive any support for the validity of the amendment from the proviso to Article 309. In other words, the President of India was not competent to take away or drop the option to receive payment in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom in the case of Indian officers and whittle down the guarantee contained in Article 314 by amending the Articles 561 and 983 by a Notification in exercise of the power conferred upon him by the proviso to Article 309.
28. It was also stated in the affidavit filed on behalf of respondent No. 1 that the amendment of the Articles in question was made also in exercise of the power conferred on the President by section 3(1) of the All India Services Act, 1951.
29. Shri Lall submitted that while Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations are regulations, section 3(1) of the All India Services Act speaks of rules, that regulations are distinct and different from rules, that the said distinction has been recognised in the various articles of the constitution, that the articles 561 and 983 can be changed or amended, if at all, by a regulation only and not by a rule, and that section 3(1) of the All India Services Act cannot, therefore, he held to empower the President to amend by a rule the Articles 561 and 983. There is no force in this submission. An examination of the Civil Service Regulations shows that each of the 996 provisions therein have been called “Articles” and the provisions in the Articles are referred to as “rules”. For instance, Article 4 speaks of “the right of changing the rules in these Regulations regarding pay and acting allowance and leave and pension”, and also states that “An Officer's claim to pay and allowances is regulated by the rules in force…………………; to leave by the rules in force…………………; and to pension by the rules in force……………………” Similar reference to “rules” has been made in Article 4A. Part II containing Articles 49 to 195 has been given the heading “Rules regarding pay and Allowances”. Part III containing Articles 196 to 348 has been given the heading “Leave Rules”. In Part IV which contains provisions regarding ordinary pensions, Chapter XV is stated to contain “General Rules”. Chapter XVI is stated to contain “Rules for reckoning service”, and Chapter XX is stated to contain “Special Rules for the Police”. Part V has been given the heading “Rules applicable to special departments or special officers. Articles 442 to 444 are stated to contain rules regarding Medical certificates. Articles 468-468-A are stated to contain General Rules regarding amount of pension. Articles 728-738 are stated to contain General Rules regarding wound and other extraordinary pensions. Articles 846 to 860 are stated to contain rules regarding chaplains and Military officers. Articles 930 to 935 are stated to contain General Rules regarding payment of pensions. Thus, while the various Articles have been described compendiously as Civil Service Regulations, the contents or provisions in the Articles have been referred to as rules. It is thus clear that the provisions in articles 561 and 983 are rules, and, therefore, the submission of Shri Lall cannot be accepted.
30. Shri I.M Lall next submitted that even if the provisions in the Articles in question are rules and could be ammended by a rule still the Articles could not be amended by the President in exercise of the power conferred by section 3(1) of the All India Services Act. To appreciate this submission, reference has to be made to Article 312 of the Constitution and Rule 3 of the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules 1954. Article 312 of the Constitution empowers the Parliament to provide by law for the creation of one or more All India Services Common to the Union and the State, and subject to the other provisions in Chapter I of Part XVI of the Constitution, regulate the recruitment and conditions of service of the persons appointed to any such service. Clause (2) of article 312 provides that the services known at the commencement of the Constitution as the “Indian Administrative Service” and the “Indian Police Service” shall be deemed to be services created by Parliament under Article 312. The aforesaid All India Services Act was enacted by the Parliament in 1951. In section 2 of the Act the expression “an All India Service” was defined as meaning, inter alia, the service known as the “Indian Administrative Service”. Section 3(1) of the Act empowered the Central Government to make rules for the regulation of recruitment and the conditions of service of persons appointed to an All India Service. In pursuance of this provision, the Central Government made the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1954. Rule 3 of the said Rules is as follows:—
“3. Constitution of the Service-(1) The service shall consist of the following persons, namely:—
(a) Members of the Indian Civil Service not permanently allotted to the judiciary;
(b) members of the Indian Civil Service permanently allotted to the judiciary who have been holding executive posts from the date of the commencement of the Constitution and who may be deck red by the Central Government to be members of the service in consultation with the State Government.
31. In the first place, these provisions i.e the Act and the Rules made thereunder, enacted by Parliament and the Central Government respectively, are subject to the other provisions of Chapter I of Part XIV of the Constitution as stated in Article 312. Article 314 occurs in the said Chapter. It is, therefore, clear that the All India Services Act and the Rules made thereunder are subject to the provisions in Article 314. But, the opening words of Article 314 make the guarantee contained in the Article subject to any other express provision in the Constitution. Article 312 may be regarded as such an express provision as the said article empowers Parliament to create by law an All India Service common to the Union and the States and also regulate the recruitment and the conditions of service of persons appointed to such a services. The Indian Administrative Service is deemed under Article 312 to be a service created by Parliament. The All India Services Act provides for the making of rules for the regulation of recruitment and the conditions of service of persons appointed to the Indian Administrative Service. In 2Grewal v. State of Punjab, A.I.R 1959 SC 512, 517, the Supreme Court held that the said delegation of the power to frame rules to carry out the purposes of the Act made by Parliament was quite valid. Rule 3 of the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1954, made under the said Act provides for the Constitution of the Indian Administrative Service consisting of inter alia, the persons mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) of the Rule 3 which have been set out above, who include members of the Indian Civil Service. Therefore the guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution could be changed or amended by the said Rules, but they did not, in fact, purport to make any such change, as sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 clearly states that “nothing contained in these Rules shall be construed to affect the provisions contained in Article 314 of the Constitution in so far as the sid provisions apply to the members of the Indian Civil Service”. Therefore, the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules 1954, by themselves are of no help in determining the power of the President to amend the Articles in the Civil Service. Regulations as respects remuneration, leave and pension of the officers of the Indian Civil Service. Further Shri I.M Lall filed an affidavit, dated 10th October, 1969 in which he stated that he was a member of the Indian Civil Service in the pre-partition Province of Punjab, and as such had been permanently attotted to the judiciary, that from the date of the commencement of the Indian Constitution, he held some executive posts in various Ministries of the Government of India, that on reversion from the Central Government to the State of Punjab, he was posted to a judicial post at Ambala District in the State of Punjab, that he resigned from the Indian Civil Service from a judicial post in the State of Punjab, that right upto the time of resignation or even after that he never received any communication either from the Central Government or from the Government of the State of Punjab that the former in consultation with the latter had declared him to be a member of the Indian Administrative Service, and that no rules of the Indian Administrative Service including the rules in respect of pension or annuity have ever been applied to him either by the Central Government or the Government of the State of Punjab. Shri Anoop Singh, learned counsel for respondent No. 2, took time for getting instructions regarding the aforesaid averments of Shri Lall, and subsequently informed that he does not propose to file any counter-affidavit regarding the said averments. In the circumstances, the averments of Shri Lall in his affidavit have to be taken as correct. In view of the said averments, neither clause (a) nor clause (b) of Rule 3 of the Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules 1954 would apply to him. Thus, the said rules, as already stated are not of any help in deciding the question as to whether the President had the power to amend Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations so as to affect the provisions in Article 314 of the Constitution as respects remuneration, leave and pension of the officers of the Indian Civil Service.
32. Coming row to the All India Services Act, section 3(1) thereof empowers the Central Government to make rules for the regulation of recruitment and the conditions of service of persons appointed to an All India Service like the Indian Administrative Service. Hence, officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service who have not become members of the Indian Administrative Service like the petitioner, are outside the pale of the All India Services Act. Therefore, section 3(1) cannot be regarded as a provisions which empowers the President to amend Articles 561 and 983 affecting the guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution as respects pension or annnity of officers of the Indian Civil Service who have not become members of the Indian Administrative Service, and the amendment of Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations cannot, in any case, apply to officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service like the petitioner. It is not necessary to consider in this case the question as to whether the amended Articles apply to officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service who have since become members of the Indian Administrative Service.
33. Another submission of Shri Lall was that even in the case of officers of Indian Civil Service who have become members of the Indian Administrative Service, and even if the amendment of Articles 561 and 983 is regarded as a rule made under section 3(1) of the All India Services Act, 1951, still it has to be held as invalid and ineffective since, admittedly, the said rule (amendment) was not placed before Parliament after it was made as required by sub-section (2) of section 3 of the aforesaid Act. The sub-section requires that “all rules made under this section shall be laid for not less than 14 days before Parliament as soon as possible after they are made, and shall be subject to such modifications whether by way of repeal or amendment, as Parliament may make on a motion made during the Session in which they are so laid”. The learned counsel for respondent No. I admitted that the said amendment was not placed before Parliament till recently, but stated that a Bill in respect of the same is now pending before Parliament. He however, contended that the provision in section 3(2) is not a manadatory provision, and referred to the decision in 3Jan Mohammad v. State of Gujarat, A.I.R 1966 SC 385, 392. In that case, the validity of the rules framed under the Bombay Agricultural Produce Markets Act No. XII of 1939, was challenged. By section 26(1) of the said Act, The State Government was authorised to make rules for the purpose of carrying out the provisions of the Act. It was provided by sub-section (5) of section 26 that the rules made under Section 26 shall be laid before each of the Houses of the Provincial Legislature at the session thereof next following and shall be liable to be modified or rescinded by a resolution, in which both Houses concur and such rules shall, after Notification in the Official Gazette, be deemed to have been modified or rescinded accordingly. It was contended in that case that the rules framed under the aforesaid Act were not placed before the Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council at the first session and therefore, they had no legal validity. The rules were, however, placed on the Assembly table in the second sessions before the Legislative Assembly which was held about four months after the first session. Dealing with the said contention, Shah, J. observed as follows:—
“Section 26(5) of Bombay Act 22 of 1939 does not prescribe that the rules acquired validity only from the date on which they were placed before the Houses of Legislature. The rules are valid from the date on which they are made under section 26(1). It is true that the Legislature has prescribed that the rules shall be placed before the Houses of Legislature, but failure to place the rules before the Houses of Legislature does not affect the validity of the rules, merely because they have not been placed before the Houses of the Legislature. Granting that the provisions of sub-section (5) of section 26 by reason of the failure to place the rules before the Houses of Legislature were violated, we are of the view that sub-section (5) of section 26 having regard to the purposes for which it is made, and in the context in which it occurs, cannot be regarded as mandatory.”
34. Shri Mehta relied upon the above observations and submitted that they apply to the present case. The said submission is well-founded, and the reasoning contained in the above observations of the Supreme Court applies to the present case, as the language used in section 3 of the All India Services Act, 1951, is almost the same as the language used in section 26 of the Bombay Act. By sub-section (1) of section 3 the Central Government was authorised to make rules for regulation of recruitment, etc. to an All India Service. Sub-section (2) provides that all rules made under sub-section (1) shall be laid before Parliament as soon as possible after they are made. But, it does not prescribe that the rules acquire validity only from the date on which they are placed before Parliament. Therefore, the rules will be valid from the date on which they are made under Section 3(1), and the failure to place the rules ??? Parliament as prescribed in sub-section (2) does not affect the validity of the rules merely because they are not placed before Parliament. It is true that in the present case the amendment of Articles 561 and 983 has not been placed for about 12 years, while the rules in the case before the Supreme Court were placed on the Assembly. Table in the second session of the Legislative Assembly, which was held about four months after the first session. But, since sub-section (2) does not prescribe that the rules made thereunder acquire validity from the date on which they are placed before Parliament, the length of the delay is immaterial. Further, though the word “shall” has been used in sub-section (2) of section 3, the said sub-section cannot be regarded as mandatory in view of the circumstance that the Legislature did not fix any particular time within which the rules should be laid before Parliament, but required only that the rules should be so laid as soon as possible after they are made. The said circumstance shows that the time within which the rules are to be laid before Parliament was not regarded by the Legislature as maternal. Moreover, the purpose for which the provision was made and the context in which it occurs show that the provision is only directory was not mandatory. This contention of Shri Lall cannot therefore, be accepted.
35. Shri Metl a also referred to Article 4 of the Civil Service Regulations which provides that “the Government of India reserve to themselves the right of changing the rules in these Regulations regarding Pay and acting allowance and leave and pension, from time to time at their discretion, and of interpreting their meaning in case of dispute.” But, it is obvious that the right to change the rules mentioned in this Article cannot override, but is subject to the constitutional guarantee in Article 314 of the Constitution.
36. Shri Mehta also referred to Article 367 of the Constitution and section 21 of the Central General Clauses Act, and contended that Article 367 of the Constitution makes the provisions of the General Clauses Act applicable for the interpretation of the Constitution, and that section 21 of the General Clauses Act empowers the President to amend the Civil Service Regulations. section 21 of the General Clauses Act provides that—
“Where by any Central Act or Regulation, a power to issue Notifications, orders, rules, or bye-laws is conferred then that power includes a power exercisable in the like manner and subject to the like sanction and conditions (if any) to add to, amend, vary or rescind any notifications, orders rules or bye-laws soissued.”
37. The power conferred by the section is obviously subject to the Constitutional guarantee in Article 314 of the Constitution and cannot override the said guarantee. Shri Mehta cannot, therefore, derive any assistance from the said provision in section 21.
38. For the above reasons, the second contention of Shri Lall has to be accepted, and it has to be held that even if the Articles in question could be changed or amended, the said change or amendment could be made only by an express provision in the Constitution empowering the change or amendment, and that in the absence of such and express provision, the President of India was not competent to amend the Articles in question so as to affect the guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution as respects the pension or annuity payable to officers of the erstwhile Indian Civil Service who have not became members of the Indian Administrative Service like the petitioner.
39. The third contention of the petitioner was that even if the President had the power to amend Articles 561 and 983 in exercise of the power conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution, he had no power to make the said amendment with retrospective effect from 12-6-1956. In support of this contention, Shri Lall relied upon the decision of the High Court of Mysore in 4Govindarju v. State of Mysore, A.I.R 1963 Mysore 265. But, when his attention was drawn to the decision of the Supreme Court in 5B.S Vadera v. Union of India, A.I.R 1969 S.C 118, in which the aforesaid decision in Govindarju's case was overruled, he did not press the contention further.
40. The fourth contention of Shri Lall was that the amended Articles 561 and 983 are violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, and are consequently invalid. His argument was that the amended Articles 561 and 983 violate Articles 14 in the following aspects:
(1) They discriminate between Indians who retired or resigned before 12-6-1956, and Indians who retired or resigned after the said date, as the former are permitted to get their annuity at their option in rupees or pounds, while the latter are allowed annuity in rupees only. In support of this ground, he relied upon the “Government of India's decision (4)” printed below Article 561 in Chaudri's compilation of the Civil Service Regulations, Vol. I (6th Edition, 1967) which is as follows:—
“(4) The effect of devaluation on pensions sanctioned under Civil Rules has inter alia been examined and the position is as under:—
I.C.S, Offers.
Officers who retired after 12-6-1956. In the case of officers who retired on or after 12-6-1955 annuity is payable only in India and in rupees at the rate of Rs. 13,333.33. Non-Indian Officers drawing annuity in U.K will, however, be eligible for a minimum of £1000. In other words in neither of these cases devalution will have any effect.
Officers who retired prior to 12-6-1956.
(a) Where the annuity has been expressed in sterling in the Pension payment Order. In the case of those who retired prior to 12-6-1956 the wording of the Pension Payment. Order would indicate the amount of the annuity as well as the currency in which it is to be paid. If they are residing abroad and their annuity has been expressed in sterling already, no change is called for. Where in such cases, the pensioner is resident in India, the current rate of exchange will apply.
Where such a pensioner is resident neither in India nor in U.K and he draws the annuity in foreign currency through official channels it will be treated as if he draws this annuity in sterling through the High Commissioner.
(b) Where the annuity has been expressed in rupees in the Pension Payment Order.
(i) In regard to cases of retirement before 12-6-1956 where, the annuity is received in rupees under the provisions of Article 983(2) as it stood before 12-6-1956, the amount of annuity will remain unchanged.
(ii) Where a pensioner is resident neither in India nor in U.K, but draws annuity in India and has it remitted through normal banking channels, the current exchange rate will apply.”
41. He also argued that there is nexus between the date 12-6-1956 and the purpose of the amendment, which has not been clearly stated even in the affidavits filed by the respondents.
(2) The amended Articles discriminate between Indians and those who have been called non-Indians. Shri Lall argued that the two expressions, “Indians” and “non-Indians” have not been defined, and that the non-Indians can draw their annuity under the amended Articles subject to a fixed minimum of £1000/- in London through the High Commissioner of India, while the Indians can draw their annuity only in rupees and that too in India only.
(3) The amended Articles discriminate between those Indians who refused to continue to serve the Government of India and those who consented to continue to serve the Government of India.
42. On the other hand, Shri Mehta contended that the classification of the officers of the Indian Civil Service into Indians and non-Indians was founded on an intelligible differentia which distinguishes the two sets of officers, in that the former normally reside in India and are, therefore, paid in rupees in India, while the latter normally do not reside in India and are therefore, paid in sterling through the High Commissioner for India in the United Kingdom, that the object sought to be achieved was to save Foreign Exchange, and that the aforesaid differentia had a rational relation to the object sought to be achieved. However, in the view taken by me that the omission in the amended Articles of the option to draw the annuity in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom in the case of Indians, was violative of the guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution, it is not necessary to decide the question as to whether the amended Articles are violative of Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution.
43. The fifth contention of Shri Lall was that since the Government of Punjab had issued the order (Annexure ‘E’). dated 20th of October, 1964, granting him an annuity of Rs. 10,666.66 Paise subject to a minimum of £1000/- per annum under the unamended Article 561 read with the unamended Article 983 of the Civil Service Regulations in supersession of the earlier order (Annexure ‘C’), dated 7th January, 1964, the Government of India had no power to direct or advice the State Government to change that order, and that the State Government also had no competency or power to revise the said order and issue the impugned order (Annexure‘C’), dated 15th December, 1965. He also contended that even if the Government of Punjab had the power, principles of natural justice required that he should have been given an opportunity to show cause against the revision, as the proposed revision affects his financial right. As regards the first part of the contention, the respondents pleaded in the affidavits filed on their behalf that the order dated 20th of October, 1964, was issued by the Accountant General, Punjab, under a bona fide mistake, that the Government of India pointed cut to the State Government that the said order, dated 20th of October, 1964 was not in consonance with the provisions of the amended Article 561 of the Civil Service Regulations and the State Government was advised that the same should be cancelled immeditaly and the original order, dated 7th January, 1964, should be revived and that consequently the Punjab Government restored their earlier decision and issued the third order (Annexure ‘G’) dated 15th December, 1965. Shri Mehta pointed out that under Article 256 of the Constitution, the executive power of every State has to be so exercised as to ensure compliance with the laws made by Parliament and any existing laws which apply in that State, and the executive power of the Union extends to the giving of such directions to a State as may appear to the Government to be necessary for that purpose, that “existing law”, as defined in Article 366(10), means any law, ordinance, order, bye-law, rule or regulation passed or made before the commencement of the Constitution by any Legislatures, authority or person having power to make such a law, ordinance, order, bye-law, rule or regulation, that the Civil Service Regulations are existing laws within the meaning of Article 556, and that the Central Government could, therefore, give directions to the State Government under the said Article regarding the non-compliance with the amended Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations. In reply thereto, Shri Lall argued that his pension was charged on the Consolidated Fund of the State of Punjab, and, therefore, the Central Government had no concern with the orders made by the State Government regarding his pension, that the amended Articles of the Civil Service Regulations were not ‘existing laws’ within the meaning of Article 256, and that the Government of India, therefore, could not have given any directions by virtue of the provision in Article 256. He also pointed out that it was not correct to say that the order, dated 20th of October, 1964, was passed by the Accountant General Punjab, under a bona fide mistake, and that the said order was passed after the petitioner had made representations against the earlier order, dated 7th January, 1964, relying upon decisions of the Supreme Court. There is no substance in this contention of Shri Lall. Whether the Government of India had the power to give directions to the State Government or not, the fact remains that it was the State Government that superseded the orders dated 20th of October, 1964, and issued the order, dated 15th of December, 1965. The question as to whether the order, dated 20th of October, 1964, was made by the State Government under a bona fide mistake or not is also immaterial. If, in fact, the petitioner was not governed by the un-amended Articles 561 and 983, the order, dated 20th of October, 1964, on the basis of the said unamended Articles would be a wrong order, and the State Government cannot be said to have no power to supersede the said wrong order by a proper order.
44. The second part of the contention of Shri Lall, however, is well founded. In support of this part of this contention, Shri Lall referred to the decisions in State of Orissa v. Dr. (Miss) Binapani Dei, A.I.R 1967 SC 1269, 6A.K Kraipak v. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 262 Lapointe v. L. Association, 1906 A.C 535, 540, Ridge v. Baldwin, 1962 (2) All England Reports 66, 10 Duryappa v. Fernando, 1967 (2) All England Reports 152 and R. v. Senate of University of Aston, 1969 (2) All England Reports 964. The order, dated 20th of October, 1964 was passed superseding the earlier order, dated 7th January, 1964, after a consideration of the representations made by the petitioner against the said earlier order. The said orders do affect the financial right of the petitioner and, therefore, even if the orders are administrative orders, they could be changed or revised only after giving an opportunity to the petitioner to show cause against the proposed change or revision. It is now well settled by the decisions referred to by Shri Lall that even administrative orders which affect the Civil rights of a citizens or have civil consequences should be passed in accordance with principles of natural justice. The impugned order (Annexure ‘G’), dated 15th December, 1967, is therefore, liable to be struck down on the ground that the petitioner was not given an opportunity to show cause against the same before it was passed superseding the previous order, dated 20th of October, 1964.
45. Shri Mehta contended that if it is held that the petitioner is entitled to draw his pension or annuity in sterling at the Home Treasury, it would be an ifructuous right which cannot be given effect to as the Home Treasury (i.e in the United Kingdom) is no longer liable to make the payment. In reply to the said contention, Shri I.M Lall referred to Articles 962, 964, 965, 967, 985 and 986 of the Civil Service Regulations, and submitted that the said Articles which, admittedly, were not amended, continued to contemplate payment at the Home Treasury and laid down a procedure for payment at the Home Treasury. Shri Mehta could answer to the said submission of Shri Lall by saying only that the said Articles have to be regarded as obsolete. It is difficult to accept the said answer of Shri Mehta, as the said provisions continue to exist in the Civil Service Regulations, and it is not clear how they can be regarded as obsolete Mr. Lall, however, explained that his prayer is not for payment at the Home Treasury, that he only wants a direction to the respondents to pay him in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom, that it is for the respondents to arrange for the payment either by the Home Treasury or through the High Commissioner for India in the United Kingdom, and that the respondents may send the necessary papers and instructions to the High Commissioner to arrange the payment in sterling to the petitioner in the United Kingdom. The explanation of Shri Lall has to be accepted as correct. Once the petitioner is held to be entitled to a payment in sterling in the United Kingdom, it is for the respondents to make the neceesary arrangements for the payment. Even under the amended Articles 561 and 983 payment of pension has to be made to the non-Indians in sterling through the High Commissioner for India in the United Kingdom. It cannot, therefore, be said that the right of the petitioner would be infructuous or that it cannot be given effect to.
46. Shri Anoop Singh contended that the petitioner accepted payment of Rs. 13,333.33 Paise in India and cannot, therefore, go back upon the same and ask for payment in sterling in the United Kingdom. The contention is untenable. Merely because the petitioner received payment of Rs. 13,333.33 Paise on some occasions, it cannot be said that he is estopped or precluded from claiming what has been guaranteed to him by the Constitution.
47. Shri Anoop Singh also argued that the petitioner resigned in 1957 and the writ petition was filed in 1966, and that the writ petition should be rejected in view of the said delay. There is no force in this contention also. Whatever it was that might have happened prior to 1964, the Government of Punjab accepted his representation and issued the sanction order (Annexure ‘E’) on 20-10-1964 in supersession of its earlier order (Annexure ‘C’), dated 7-1-1964. But the Government of Punjab subsequently superseded the said order, dated 20-10-1964, and issued the impugned order (Annexure ‘G’) on 15-12-1965. The petitioner made his representation to the Chief Secretary to the Government of Punjab, but did not get any reply. He then served notices on the respondents, but, there was no reply to the said notices. He thereupon filed the writ petition on 12-7-1966. In the circumstances, the petition cannot be said to suffer from any laches or delay.
48. The learned counsel for the respondents referred to two decisions, the first being a decision of a Full Bench of the High Court of Allahabad, dated 10th September, 1969, in Civil Miscellaneous Writs Nos. 3006 of 1967 and 1646 of 1968, filed respectively by Shri B. Malik and Shri M.C Desai, two retired Chief Justices of the said High Court, and the second being a decision of a Division Bench (S.C Misra, C.J and S. Wasiuddin) of the High Court of Patna, dated 1st July, 1969, in Civil Writ No. 720 of 1968 filed by Shri C.K Raman. The said decisions, however, are distinguishable as the provisions which were considered in the said decisions are different from the provisions relied upon by, Shri I.M Lall in the present case.
49. In the case before the High Court of Allahabad, both the petitioners claimed that they were entitled to have their pensions fixed in sterling and to be paid every month after coverting the amount into rupees at the rates of exchange prevailing on the dates of the payments. Shri Desai further claimed a right to receive his pension in sterling in the United Kingdom, if and when he so wishes. Both the petitioners were appointed as Judges when the Government of India Act was in force. Section 221 of the said Act provided, inter alia, that Judges of the several High Courts shall be entitled to such rights in respect of leave and pensions, as may, from time to time, be fixed by His Majesty in Council. There was a proviso to the said section according to which the rights of a Judge in respect of pension shall not be varied to his dis-advantage after his appointment. Under the provision in section 221, the Government of India (High Court Judges) Order, 1937 (hereinafter referred to as the Order of 1937) was made by an order in Council, dated March 18, 1937, which came into force from April 1, 1937. Paragraphs 17 to 24 of the said Order read with Schedule III to the Order, dealt with pensions of Judges, and the pensions were expressed in sterling only. The Constitution of India came into force on 26-1-1950. After the constitution came into force, there were two types of Judges in the High Courts, viz., (1) those who were Judges in a High Court in any province holding office immediately before 26-1-1950, and became Judges on 26-1-1950 under Article 376 of the Constitution, and (2) those who were appointed as Judges after the said date under Article 217(1). Both types of Judges were entitled only to such rights of pension as were provided for in Article 221 of the Constitution. The said Article provided that Judges of each High Court shall be entitled to such rights in respect of person, as may, from time to time, be determined by or under law made by Parliament, and until so determined, to such rights as are specified in the Second Schedule to the Constitution. There is a proviso to Article 221 according to which the rights of a Judge in respect of pension shall not be varied to his disadvantage after his appointment. Then, in 1954, the Parliament enacted the High Court Judges (Conditions of Service) Act, which came into force on May 20, 1954. Section 15 of the Act provided that a Judge who is a member of the Indian Civil Service shall, on his retirement, be paid a pension in accordance with the scale and provisions in Part II of the First Schedule. The pensions were originally expressed in sterling, but subsequently, by amendment, they were expressed in rupees.
50. The main contention of the petitioners before the High Court of Allahabad was that the Act of 1954 was violative of the proviso to Article 221 of the Constitution inasmuch as it varied the rights of the petitioners in respect of their pensions to their disadvantage. They claimed that they acquired three rights under the Order of 1937, namely—
(i) the right to a certain amount of pension expressed in the 1937 Order in sterling;
(ii) the right to receive the pension in sterling; and
(iii) the right to receive the pension in sterling in the United Kingdom.
51. G.C Mathur, J. with whom the other two learned Judges, though by separate judgments agreed, held that there was no doubt regarding the first right. As regards the second right, the learned Judge held that there was no express provision in the Order of 1937 which conferred upon Judges the right to receive their pension in sterling and to compel the Government to pay it in sterling, and that, on the date on which the Act of 1954 came info force, the petitioners had no right to receive their pensions in sterling. As regards the 3rd right, Shri Desai claimed the said right to receive the pension in sterling in the United Kingdom by virtue of Article 933-A of the Civil Service Regulations, which provided that—
“When a pension is stated in sterling, it is payable at the Home Treasury, or, at the option of the pensioner, if he be residing in India, at any treasury in India converted into rupees at such a rate of exchange as the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribe.”
52. The learned Judge pointed out that this contention of Shri Desai assumed that under the Order of 1937 he was entitled to his pension in sterling, that even if that were so, Article 933-A was not applicable to Judges of High Courts and did not confer any right to receive the pension in sterling in the United Kingdom, as the Article was contained in Chapter XLVIII of the Civil Service Regulations, while the rules relating to the pensions of Judge of High Courts were contained in Chapter XXIII, and that the said Article was not made applicable to Judges of High Courts by Paragraph 26 of the Order of 1937. In the result, the learned Judge held that Shri Desai failed to establish that he had any right to receive his pension in sterling in the United Kingdom. The learned Judge then considered the question as to whether the Act of 1954 varid the rights of the petitioners in respect of that pension which they had acquired before the Act came into force, to their disadvantage, and ultimately held that the Act did not do so that it was not violative of the proviso to Article 221 of the Constitution, and that after the Act came into force, the rights of the petitioners in respect of their pensions had to be determined in accordance with the provisions of that Act. It will thus be seen that the provisions which were considered by the Full Bench were entirely different from the provisions in Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations and Article 314 of the Constitution on which Shri I.M Lall relies in the Present case. The said decision cannot, therefore be of any assistance to the learned counsel for the respondents.
53. In the other case, Shri C.K Raman, a retired member of the Indian Civil Service, filed the writ petition praying (1) for the issuance of a writ of certiorari striking down the amendments to Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations, and an order by which the amount of his pension was fixed after deducting the death-cum-retiring gratuity sanctioned to him by the Government of Bihar, and (2) for the issuance of a writ mandamus directing the Government of Bihar to pass his pension order in proper form. He sought for the quashing of the amendment of the Articles on the ground that the amendment affected his right to claim his pension at the rate provided in the Articles before their amendment in 1957 and thus violated the constitutional guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution. It was stated in paragraph 2 of the judgment that the main contention put forward on behalf of the petitioner was that the right to receive as annuity a minimum amount of £ 1000/- as provided in Article 561 cannot be affected by any notification or by any rule made by the President of India under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution or under section 3(1) of the All India Services Act, 1951, in its application to the members of the Indian Administrative Service including those who before they became such members, were members of the Indian Civil Service. It was further stated in paragraph 2 of the judgement that the petitioner had—
“Felt impelled to make the application in view of the devaluation of the rupee on 6th June, 1966, and its alteration on 19th November 1967, devaluing the pounds, which have reduced its value in terms of sterling and, if the petitioner would exercise his option of claiming the minimum amount of £ 1000/- in sterling at the present rate of exchange, he should be entitled to a much higher sum than Rs. 10,666-10-8 which represented a general correspondence by way of rate of exchange between the value of a rupee and a pound-sterling being merely two shillings equivalant to a rupee.”
“At present, however, the disparity in the value of the two currencies is so apparent that the petitioner, who as a member of the service was entitled to draw his pension in sterling but has been actually paid in terms of rupees at a fixed rate prescribed by the President of India, would suffer a loss of several thousand rupees per annum”.
and that—
“According to the petitioner, the amendment of Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations amounts to altering the conditions of service of the petitioner adversely to him, which is not permissible on account of be distinct guarantee held out to the members of the Indian Civil Service under the East India Annuity Funds Act, 1874, the Government of India Act, 1915–19, Government of India Act, 1935, and the Indian Independence Act, 1947, as also under Article 314 of the Constitution of India.”
54. Thus, the contention of the petitioner in that case was that he was entitled to the payment of the minimum of £ 1000/- converted into rupees at the current rate of exchange, and that the amendment of the Articles by the President providing a fixed a amount of Rs. 13,333.33 was invalid. The contention on behalf of the Union of India, as pointed out in paragraph 4 of the judgment, was that by the words “at such rate of exchange as the Secretary of State in Council may by order prescribe” in the unamended Article 983, power was “given to the Secretary of State to fix the rate of exchange in respect of one thousand pounds”, that the said power “was untrammelled and he could determine the rate of exchange in respect of the payment of annuity which would not necessarily conform to the rate of exchange fixed the international payment for trade purposes”, and that “that power has now been vested in the President of India after the coming into force of the Indian Constitution, 1950, in terms of which the existing amount of annuity payable to a member of the Indian Civil Service has been determined by the President of India in exercise of the power under Article 309 of the Canstitntion”. After referring to the various arguments advanced on behalf of both the parties, the learned judges came to the conclusion in paragraph 12 of the judgment that:
“So far as the wording of Article 983, even as in unamended form, is concerned, in clause (2) it gives ample power to the Secretary State in Council to prescribe the rate at which conversion is to be made, and if this power has devolved on the President of India, it is still open to the President of India to prescribe the rate of 1s. 6d. being the par value of rupee as it was when the Constitution of India was brought into operation. It is not that the rate of Rs. 13,333.33P. has been arbitrarily fixed but the figure has been arrived at, as has been appointed out in the counter affidavit, taking the par value of rupee being 1s. 6d. for which the members of the Indian Civil Service were themselves contending in 1958 ……………………………… In my opinion, therefore, I am not able to see any lacuna in the amendments of these two Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations contained in annexure 4 to the petition, so far as it is sought to be challenged on the ground that it amounts to a violation of the guarantee of preservation of the service conditions of the members of the Indian Civil Services provided by Article 314 of the Constitution.”
55. Thus the prayer of the petitioner in that case was for payment of his annuity at the minimum of £ 1000/- sterling converted in to ruppees at the current rate of exchange, ??? the amendments of Articles 561 and 983 by the President of India ??? fixed amount of Rs. 13,333.33 Paise be held to be invalid as being violative of Article 314 of the Constitution of India. The High Court considered the validity of the amendments of the Articles from the same stand point, and rejected the contention of the petitioner, holding that the President of India had the power to so fix the pension, and that the amount fixed in the amended Articles was not fixed arbitrarily. It was not the prayer of the petitioner in that case that under the urar ended Articles he had an option to take his pension at the fixed sterling minimum in the United Kingdom, and it was not his contention that the omission of the said option in the amended Articles was violative of the guarantee contained in Article 314 of the Constitution, which is the contention of Shri I.M Lall in the present case. Consequently, the learned Judges were not called upon to consider the validity of the amendment of the Articles 561 and 983 from that stand-point, and the decision cannot, therefore, be of any assistance to the learned counsel for the respondents in the present case, in which the validity of the amendments is being questioned by Shri I.M Lall on the ground that the omission of the aforesaid option in the amended Articles was a violation of the guarantee in Article 314 of the Constitution. Thus, the learned counsel for the respondents can not derive any assistance from either of the decisions.
56. For the above reasons, I hold that the petitioner, Shri I.M Lall, is entitled to receive the same conditions of service as respects pension as he was entitled to immediately before the commencement of the Constitution as provided by Article 314 of the Constitution of India, i.e that he is entitled to receive pension as provided in Articles 561 and 983 of the Civil Service Regulations, as amended in 1921 and before they were amended in 1957, read with the Resolutions of the Secretary of State in Council, dated 29th September, 1926 (Annexure B-3), and 25th February, 1928 (Annexure R-4), and not as provided in Articles 561 and 983 which were substituted by Notification No. F. 7(19) EV/57, dated 29th June, 1957. He is therefore, entitled to opt to take his pension in sterling at the fixed sterling minimum of £1000/- in the United Kingdom, which option has already been expressed by him on receiving the Order (Annexure ‘E’), dated 20th October, 1964.
57. I accordingly allow the writ petition, quash the Order (Annexure ‘G’), dated 15th December, 1965, and direct the respondents to pay the pension or annuity to the petitioner at the fixed sterling minimum of £1000/- per annum as originally ordered by the respondent No. 2 in the Order (Annexure ‘E’) dated 20th October, 1964, in the United Kingdom. The petitioner is entitled to his costs in this writ petition from the respondents, which are fixed at Rs. 250/-.
58. Petition Allowed.
Alert