- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
G.S Randhawa v. State Of Punjab .
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner underwent heart surgery at the Escort Heart Institute, New Delhi, and sought reimbursement of the medical expenses from the Punjab Government. The Government refused to grant ex-post facto approval for the treatment and returned the petitioner's bill for follow-up treatment. The petitioner challenged these refusals by filing a writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to reimbursement of medical expenses incurred for treatment at a recognised Institute outside the State without prior approval from the Director Health Services, Punjab.
- Whether the Government's refusal to reimburse the petitioner based on the Medical Attendance Rules, 1940 and related instructions is lawful and justified.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents' Arguments
- The reimbursement of medical claims for Punjab Government employees and pensioners is governed by the Medical Attendance Rules, 1940, specifically Clause K of Rule 2, which provides for free treatment and attendance by government doctors only.
- The petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for treatment obtained from the Escort Heart Institute as prior approval from the Director Health Services, Punjab, Chandigarh was not obtained for treatment outside the State.
- The Government's instructions dated 25.1.1991 prohibit reimbursement without such prior approval.
Petitioner’s Position (Implied from Court's Discussion)
- The petitioner underwent urgent heart surgery at a recognised Institute and claims reimbursement for medical expenses incurred.
- The petitioner relied on the recognition of the Institute by the Government and the urgency of treatment as grounds for reimbursement despite the absence of prior approval.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sadhu R. Pall v. State of Punjab, 1994 (1) SCT 552; 1994 (7) SLR 457 (Pb. & Hry.) | Recognition of Institutes and liberal construction of rules for reimbursement of medical expenses to State Government employees; urgency and necessity of treatment justify reimbursement despite procedural non-compliance. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that once an Institute is recognised by the State, the Government cannot refuse reimbursement, especially in urgent cases like heart treatment. The rules must be construed liberally in favour of employees and not used to deny rightful relief. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that the Escort Heart Institute is a recognised Institute of the Government of Punjab. It referred to the precedent in Sadhu R. Pall v. State of Punjab, which held that the State cannot refuse reimbursement to its employees for treatment received at a recognised Institute, particularly in urgent medical situations such as heart problems. The Court emphasized that the Medical Attendance Rules and related instructions are welfare provisions and must be interpreted liberally to benefit employees rather than to adopt a rigid or technical approach that would deprive them of due relief.
The Court found the respondents’ refusal to reimburse based on lack of prior approval to be arbitrary and an attempt to defeat justice. It underscored that the instructions were meant to serve human beings and must be applied with a purposive approach rather than a mechanical one.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed. The Court quashed the Government's orders dated 22.10.1993 and 21.12.1993 refusing reimbursement of the petitioner’s medical expenses. The respondents were directed to reimburse the petitioner the full amount incurred for treatment at the Institute along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum from 7.1.1994 until payment.
The decision directly benefits the petitioner by ensuring reimbursement and clarifies that recognised Institutes’ treatments, especially in urgent cases, warrant reimbursement even if prior approval was not obtained. No new precedent beyond the reaffirmation of existing principles was established.
R.P Sethi, J.:— Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2. Vide order dated 22.10.1993 (Annexure P-8), the Government refused to grant ex-post facto approval of the treatment (heart surgery) of the petitioner from Escort Heart Institute, New Delhi (for short the ‘Institute’) and the bill of the petitioner for follow up treatment was returned in original vide Annexure P/9.
3. It is submitted on behalf of the respondents that the reimbursement of medical claim of the Punjab Government employees and the pensioners is regulated under the Medical Attendance Rules, 1940. Clause K of Rule 2 lays down free treatment and attendance by the government doctors only. It is submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to the reimbursement of medical expenses incurred by him for getting treatment from the Institute. It is further submitted that as the petitioner has not got prior approval of Director Health Services, Punjab, Chandigarh for his treatment outside the State, he is not entitled to the grant of the relief prayed for in view of the government instructions dated 25.1.1991
4. It is not disputed that the Institute is recognised Institute of the Government of Punjab. Such a question arose for consideration in Sadhu R. Pall v. State of Punjab, 1994 (1) SCT 552: [1994 (7) SLR 457 (Pb. & Hry.)], wherein it was held:—
“In our considered view, once an Institute is recognised and it is decided that the State Government employees can take treatment from there, the State cannot be permitted to turn back and decline the reimbursement to its employees particularly in view of the urgency for treatment like heart problems. There is no reason nor any has been pointed out to restrict the right of the petitioner to get the best medical treatment available in the country from an Institute recognised by the State Government. Since provision of free medical treatment or reimbursement in lieu thereof is a beneficial act of the welfare State for its employees, the rules/instructions have to be construed liberally in favour of the employees, for granting them the relief, rather than adopting a wooden attitude to deprive a person of his due. The respondents appear to have patently used excusals in refusing full reimbursement, when the factum of treatment and the urgency for the same has been accepted by the respondents by reimbursing the petitioner the expenses incurred by him, which he would have incurred in the A.I.I.M.S, New Delhi. We cannot loose sight of factual situation in the A.I.I.M.S, New Delhi, i.e with respect to the number of patients received there for heart problems. In such an urgency/one cannot sit at home and think in a cool and calm atmosphere for getting medical treatment at a particular hospital or waif for admission in the some Government Medical Institute. In such a situation, decision has to be taken forthwith by the persons or his attendants if precious life has to be saved.
xxxxxx
We are of the considered view, by reading the instructions dated 8.10.1991 in pith and substance that the instructions do not authorise the respondents to refuse reimbursement as suggested by them. The instructions are meant for human beings and have to be read liberally and with an object to serve the purpose and the persons for whom they are meant. The defence taken by the respondents is nothing else but a frivolous defence which cannot be sustained in the eye of law. The very act of the respondent is arbitrary and an attempt at defeating justice.”
5. Under the circumstances, the writ petition is allowed by quashing the order dated 22.10.1993 (Annexure P-8) and order dated 21.12.1993 (Annexure P-9) issued by the respondents refusing the reimbursement of the medical charges incurred by the petitioner on his treatment with a direction that the respondents shall reimburse the petitioner the amount he has incurred on his treatment at the Institute with interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum calculated with effect from 7.1.1994 till the amount is actually paid.
6. Petition allowed.
Alert