- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bharat Chandulal Nanavati & Ors. Petitioners v. Union Of India And Ors. S
ORAL JUDGMENT (PER A.S OKA, J.)
On the earlier date, when the Civil Application No. 466/2015 was placed on board, the parties were put to notice that the Petition will be itself taken up for final hearing in the light of observations made in second paragraph of order dated 21st January, 2015 passed by this Court in Civil Application No. 2954/2014.
2] At the outset, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioners stated that he is not pressing prayer clauses (a) and (b) of the Petition.
3] The lands subject matter of the dispute have been particularly described in Schedule ‘D’ to the Petition. The lands described in the Schedule ‘D’ are hereinafter described as “the said lands”. The first Petitioner along with others claim to have acquired the said lands by registered sale deeds dated 9th October, 1963, 14 October, 1963 and 6 January, 1964 respectively.
4] The contention of the Petitioners is that the Revenue Authorities granted the permission to use the area admeasuring 3,57,334 sq. meters for residential purposes. It is stated that N.A tax in relation to area of 4,64,900 sq. meters was paid by the Petitioner. It is pointed out that at the instance of the State Government, an entry of reserved forest was made in respect of the said lands in the 7/12 extract and the names of the Petitioners were shown in the other rights column.
5] On 9 June, 2006, notices were issued to the Petitioners under section 22 A of the Maharashtra Private Forests (Acquisition) Act, 1975 (for short “the said Act of 1975”) contending that with effect from 30 August, 1975 the said lands being private forest under the said Act of 1975 vested in the state Government. The Petitioners were informed that an inquiry under section 22A of the said Act of 1975 shall be held. The Petitioners by way of reply to the notices contended that neither the provisions of the said Act of 1975 nor the provisions of the Indian Forest Act 1927 (for short “the said Act of 1927”) are applicable to the said lands. Apart from prayer clauses (a) and (b) which are not pressed, the challenge in this Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is to action of making an entry of forest in the Revenue Records in relation to said lands and action of holding an inquiry under section 22A of the said Act of 1975.
6] The learned Senior Counsel representing the Petitioners has placed reliance on the judgment and order dated 30 January, 2014 of the Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 1102/2014 (Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra) along with connected Appeals. He urged that even going by the stand taken in the reply filed by the State Government, the only contention raised is that a notice under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 was issued to the predecessor in title of the Petitioners. However, it is not the case made out that the notice was served. He urged that even the description of the lands in the notice relied upon the Respondents does not show that the same relates to the said lands. He urged that in the light of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd., sub-clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 will not apply and, therefore, there is no question of the said lands vesting in the State Government under sub-section (1) of section 3 of the said Act of 1975.
7] The learned Government Pleader relied upon the affidavit of Shri Govind Tikaram Chavan, the Deputy Conservator of Forests, Thane Division, Thane. He pointed out that notice dated 17 February, 1956 under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 was issued to the predecessors-in-title of the Petitioners. It was published in the Official Gazette on 29 March, 1956. He submitted that the Petitioners are subsequent purchasers and, therefore, sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 is attracted and the said lands constitute Private Forest. He urged that by operation of law, by virtue of sub-section (1) of section 3 of said Act of 1975, the said lands vested with the State Government on 30 August, 1975. He submitted that the said lands are forest and, therefore, no interference is called for.
8] We have carefully considered the submissions. We have perused the affidavit-in-reply of Shri Govind Tikaram Chavan, the Deputy Conservator of Forests. The specific contention raised in the said affidavit is that as the notice dated 17 February, 1956 under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 was issued to the predecessors-in-title of the Petitioners and as the same was published in the Official Gazette, sub-clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 will apply and, therefore, the said lands will become a Private Forest. Thus, by virtue of sub section (1) of section 3 of the said Act of 1975, there is a vesting of said lands in the State Government with effect from 30 August, 1975. Clause(f) of section 2 of the said Act, 1975, defines Private Forest. Clause (f) of section 2 reads thus:-
“2(f) “private forest” means any forest which is not the property of Government and includes,—
(i) any land declared before the appointed day to be a forest under section 34A of the Forest Act;
(ii) any forest in respect of which any notification issued under sub-section (1) of section 35 of the Forest Act, is in force immediately before the appointed day;
(iii) any land in respect of which a notice has been issued under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the Forest Act, but excluding an area not exceeding two hectares in extent as the Collector may specify in this behalf;
(iv) land in respect of which a notification has been issued under section 38 of the Forest Act;
(v) in a case where the State Government and any other person are jointly interested in the forest, the interest of such person in such forest;
(vi) sites of dwelling houses constructed in such forest which are considered to be necessary for the convenient enjoyment or use of the forest and lands appurtenant thereto.”
9] The contention of the State Government is that as a notice has been “issued” under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 to the predecessors-in-title of the Petitioners, the said lands will become Private Forest within the meaning of clause (f) of section 2. We must note here that in the affidavit in reply that a specific reliance has been placed by the State Government on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Chintamani Gajanan Velkar v. State of Maharashtra 2000 3 SCC 143. The affidavit filed by Shri Govind Tikaram Chavan specifically relies upon the ratio of the said decision in paragraph 15. A reliance is also placed on a decision of the Full Bench of this Court in the case of Janu Chandra Waghmare v. State of Maharashtra AIR 1978 SC 119.
10] Thus, the contention raised by the State Government is that the act of issuing a notice under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 is sufficient to attract sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said act of 1975. The very issue came up for consideration before the Apex Court in the case of Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. The issue framed for its consideration has been incorporated by the Apex Court in paragraph 2 of the judgment which reads thus:-
“The principal question for consideration is whether the mere issuance of a notice under the provisions of section 35(3) of the Indian Forest Act, 1927 is sufficient for any land being declared a “private forest” within the meaning of that expression as defined in section 2(f)(iii) of the Maharashtra Private Forests (Acquisition) Act, 1975. In our opinion, the question must be answered in the negative. Connected therewith is the question whether the word “issued” in section 2(f)(iii) of the Maharashtra Private Forests Acquisition Act, 1975 read with section 35 of the Indian Forest Act, 1927 must be given a literal interpretation or a broad meaning. In our opinion the word must be given a broad meaning in the surrounding context in which it is used.”
(underline added).
11] In the said decision, the Apex Court referred to its earlier decision in the case of Chintamani Gajanan Velkar which holds that sub-clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 will be attracted even if it is established that a notice under sub-section (3) of section 35 was merely issued to the owners. The Apex Court held that the law laid down on this aspect in its earlier decision in the case of Chintamani Gajanan Velkar was not correct. It will be necessary to make a reference to what is held by the Apex Court in paragraph 61 of the said decision in the case of Godrej and Boyce which reads thus:-
“By making a reference in section 2(f)(iii) of the Private Forests Act to ‘issue’ in section 35 of the Forest Act, it is clear that the word is dressed in borrowed robes. Once that is appreciated (and it was unfortunately overlooked in Chintamani) then it is quite clear that ‘issued’ in section 2(f)(iii) of the Private Forests Act must include service of the show cause notice as postulated in section 35 of the Forest Act.”
(underline added).
12] Thus, the Apex Court held that the word “issued” under sub clause (iii) of section(f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 must include service of the show cause notice as postulated under sub-section(3) of section 35. In the present case, apart from the fact that a direct proof of service of the said notice to the predecessors-in-title of the Petitioners is not produced, even a contemporaneous record to show the service of notice dated 17 February, 1956 has not been produced.
13] Therefore, in the light of the law laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd., in absence of the service of notice under sub-section (3) of section 35 of the said Act of 1927 to the Petitioners or their predecessors-in-title, sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 will have no application and, therefore, only by virtue of an act of issuing a notice under section(3) of section 35, it cannot be said that the said lands are Private Forest within the meaning of the said Act of 1975. Hence, there cannot be a vesting of the said lands in the State Government under sub-section (1) of section 3 of the said Act of 1975 on that ground.
14] Thus, it follows that proceedings under section 22 A of the said Act of 1975 cannot be commenced on the ground that sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 is applicable.
15] We must observe there that the only issue examined by us in this Petition is whether sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 will apply to the said lands. Our finding is that relying upon the said sub-clause(iii) of clause (f) of section 2, it is not open for the Respondents to contend that the said lands constitute a Private Forest. We must make it clear that we have made no adjudication on the question whether said lands are otherwise a forest within the meaning of said Act of 1927. We have not examined whether any other sub clause of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 is applicable to the said lands. The said issues are kept open.
16] Hence, the Petition must succeed in part and we dispose of the Petition by passing the following order:-
(i) The prayers (a) and (b) are disposed of as not pressed;
(ii) We direct the second Respondent to delete the entry in the Revenue Records in relation to the said lands made on the basis that sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act 1975 is applicable to the said lands;
(iii) Necessary correction shall be carried out within a period of 3 months from today;
(iv) In view of the findings recorded in this judgment, the inquiry under section 22 A of the said Act 1975 shall not proceed further;
(v) As observed earlier, we make it clear that only finding recorded by us is that sub clause (iii) of clause (f) of section 2 of the said Act of 1975 is not attracted to the said lands. However, no adjudication is made on the issue whether the said lands are otherwise a Forest or a Private Forest;
(vi) Rule is partly made absolute on above terms with no order as to costs.
(vii) The Civil Application No. 466/2015 does not survive and the same is accordingly disposed of.
Alert