- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Anjani Chaudhary v. State Of Bihar .
Factual and Procedural Background
On 6 February 1989, Prem Kumar Chaudhary was fatally assaulted near his home. According to the First Information Report (FIR) lodged by his brother, Ram Pukar Chaudhary (PW 2), three nephews—Anjani Chaudhary (allegedly armed with a pistol and lathi), Bhimsen Chaudhary (with a farsa) and Kin Kin Chaudhary (with a bhala)—inflicted multiple injuries that caused his death. The motive asserted was an intra-family dispute over property gifted by the family matriarch, Suhagwati, to PW 2’s wife, which other family members contested.
A police investigation culminated in a charge-sheet against all three accused under Sections 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The trial court convicted each accused and imposed life imprisonment and a fine. The Patna High Court upheld the conviction. Two of the convicted persons—Anjani Chaudhary and Kin Kin Chaudhary—sought special leave to appeal before the Supreme Court, resulting in the present judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the concurrent findings of guilt recorded by the trial court and High Court were sustainable when two eyewitnesses turned hostile and the medical evidence allegedly failed to corroborate the presence of one accused (Anjani Chaudhary).
- Whether the testimony of PW 2, who had acknowledged animosity with the accused, could be relied upon as the primary basis for conviction.
- Whether medical evidence corroborated the prosecution’s ocular testimony so as to justify upholding or setting aside the convictions of the individual appellants.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- PWs 4 and 5, initially cited as eyewitnesses, retracted their statements; PW 14 was disbelieved, and PW 1 was only a “chance witness” from another village, leaving PW 2 as the sole supporting eyewitness whose testimony was tainted by personal hostility over land.
- The medical evidence showed no injuries attributable to a lathi or pistol, undermining the alleged presence of Anjani Chaudhary.
State's Arguments
- The prosecution evidence, accepted by both lower courts, was sufficient, and no ground existed for the Supreme Court to interfere with concurrent findings of fact.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court acknowledged that family feuds in agrarian contexts often necessitate corroboration beyond ocular testimony. It noted:
- The land-gift dispute provided a clear motive, supported by depositions of PW 1 and PW 2.
- Hostility of PWs 4 and 5 was unsurprising given their relationship to both sides.
- Medical evidence revealed thirteen injuries: twelve incised wounds and one penetrating wound. These injuries were consistent with weapons allegedly carried by Bhimsen (farsa) and Kin Kin (bhala) but not with a lathi or pistol allegedly held by Anjani.
- Because the medical record failed to show injuries attributable to a lathi or pistol, the Court found the evidence insufficient to sustain Anjani Chaudhary’s conviction. Conversely, it found the medical findings fully consistent with Kin Kin Chaudhary’s involvement.
Holding and Implications
Appeal of Kin Kin Chaudhary dismissed; conviction and sentence affirmed.
Appeal of Anjani Chaudhary allowed; he is acquitted and to be released forthwith unless required in another case.
Implications: The decision offers no new legal precedent but underscores the Supreme Court’s willingness to scrutinize medical corroboration where eyewitness testimony is uncertain, particularly in intra-family homicides.
H.S Bedi, J.— These appeals by way of special leave arise out of the following facts: on 6-2-1989 at about 2.45 p.m, the first informant, Ram Pukar Chaudhary (PW 2), had gone to ease himself when he heard some sounds coming from outside his house. On returning, he saw his nephews, Anjani Chaudhary armed with a pistol and a lathi, Bhimsen Chaudhary armed with a farsa and Kin Kin Chaudhary armed with a bhala assaulting his brother Prem Kumar Chaudhary, killing him on the spot. PW 2 raised an alarm, whereafter Satyadeo Chaudhary (PW 1), Madan Chaudhary (PW 5) and Ahsarfi Chaudhary (PW 4) also reached the site and saw part of the alleged occurrence.
2. The motive for the murder was that the family property had been partitioned amongst the four brothers and their mother, and the mother had started living with the deceased Prem Kumar Chaudhary and had also executed a gift deed in respect of her land in favour of PW 2's wife on which PW 2's brothers, Mukti Chaudhary and Ram Pukar Chaudhary as well as the appellants had raised a dispute.
3. On receiving information about the incident, a police party reached the village and recorded the statement of PW 2 and on that basis and after due investigation a charge-sheet was submitted against the appellants under Sections 302/34 of the Penal Code, 1860 to which they pleaded not guilty and were brought to trial.
4. The prosecution, in support of its case, examined inter alia: PW 3, Ramadhaar Chaudhary who proved the FIR (Ext. 2), CW 2, Sikan Shahani proved the gift deed dated 15-12-1987 executed between Suhagwati in favour of Dharamsheela Devi and several other formal witnesses who proved the animosity and prolonged litigation between the warring brothers. PW 4 Ahsarfi Chaudhary and PW 5 Madan Chaudhary who had been named as eyewitnesses, however, turned hostile and did not support the prosecution. The prosecution, accordingly, fell back on the eyewitnesses: PW 1 Satyadeo Chaudhary; PW 2 Ram Pukar Prakash Chaudhary; PW 13, Ram Padarath Chaudhary and PW 14, Tarawati Devi, the wife of the deceased.
5. The trial court held that the evidence of PW 14 could not be believed as her presence had not been noted in the FIR. The court then went into the eyewitness account of Satyadeo Chaudhary, PW 1 and observed that though he belonged to a village at a distance of about eight miles from the place of incident, his presence was proved on record as the wife of the deceased was his sister and on the day in question he had been present to participate in a religious ceremony in her house. The court also found that as the statement of this witness had been recorded by the police at about 5.00 p.m, that is, within half an hour of the recording of the FIR, his presence was proved on record for this additional reason.
6. Likewise, the trial court examined the evidence of PW 2 Ram Pukar Chaudhary, the brother of the deceased, who deposed that as his mother had gifted her share of the land in favour of his wife, the other members of the family were annoyed on that account. He further stated that Bhimsen Chaudhary had been armed with a farsa, Kin Kin Chaudhary with a bhala and Anjani Chaudhary with a lathi and they had inflicted injuries to the deceased with their weapons. The court also found that the ocular evidence was corroborated by the medical evidence as there were thirteen (13) injuries on the deceased, out of which twelve (12) injuries were incised and Injury 5 was a penetrating wound which could have been caused by a bhala. It was, however, noted that there was no injury with a lathi on the deceased.
7. The court further observed that there was absolutely no delay in the lodging of the FIR. The trial court accordingly convicted all the accused under Section 302 of the Penal Code and awarded a sentence of rigorous imprisonment for life and a fine of Rs. 15,000 with a default sentence as well. An appeal was, thereafter, taken to the High Court which has, by the impugned judgment, dismissed the appeal.
8. During the course of hearing, the learned counsel for the appellants has raised several arguments before us. It has been submitted that in the light of the fact that PWs 4 and 5, who were alleged to be the eyewitnesses to the incident, had not supported the prosecution and that the High Court had found that PW 14 was not an eyewitness as claimed by her, whereas PW 1 was a chance witness who belonged to a village situated at a distance of about 8 miles from the place of the incident. The entire prosecution story rested upon PW 2's statement and as he admittedly had grave animosity with the appellants on account of the land dispute, his evidence could not be relied upon. It has also been submitted that the medical evidence did not support the presence of Anjani Chaudhary who is said to have been armed with a lathi and no injury with a lathi had been found on the deceased.
9. The learned counsel for the State of Bihar has, however, supported the judgment of the High Court and the trial court. He has pointed out that in the light of the fact that the trial court and the High Court had given concurrent findings on the evidence, no interference was called for in this matter.
10. We have considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties. This is a case of parricide. It is clear that the incident was sparked off by a dispute between the brothers and their family members pertaining to the land which had been gifted by Suhagwati, mother of PW 2 to his wife Dharamsheela Devi which was resisted by the accused as they too had laid claim to the said land. This is apparent from the depositions of PW 1 and PW 2. PW 1 has also given a very cogent explanation for his presence at the time of the murder. In this view of the matter that PWs 4 and 5, who were related to both the parties, had turned hostile is not surprising.
11. We must however keep in sight that in a matter which involves close relatives belonging to farming families with deep set animosities some evidence beyond the ocular evidence should also be looked for. In this case the medical evidence corroborates the presence of Bhimsen Chaudhary and Kin Kin Chaudhary as they were armed with a farsa and a bhala which could have caused the incised and penetrating wounds found on the dead body. The medical evidence, however, does not support the presence of Anjani Chaudhary as there was no injury with a pistol or a lathi on the body of the deceased.
12. It is also apparent from the record that Bhimsen Chaudhary has not filed an appeal in this Court. Criminal Appeal No. 140 of 2004 has been filed by Anjani Chaudhary and Criminal Appeal No. 1739 of 2010 [arising out of Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. 5187 of 2003] by Kin Kin Chaudhary and both are being disposed of by this judgment.
13. In view of what has been stated above, we dismiss the appeal of Kin Kin Chaudhary but allow Criminal Appeal No. 140 of 2004 filed by Anjani Chaudhary and order his acquittal. He shall be released forthwith if not required in any other case.
Alert