- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bhag Singh And Another Petitioners v. Commissioner, Jalandhar, Division And Ors. S
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners' land was acquired under the National Highways Act, 1956. The Land Acquisition Collector announced an Award on 8.5.2007. Other landowners aggrieved by the compensation amount sought References, which were referred to the Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, as Arbitrator. The Arbitrator enhanced compensation for other landowners by an Award dated 28.1.2009. The petitioners' Reference was decided by an Award dated 11.2.2011 based on the earlier Award.
The petitioners subsequently filed an application for correction of the Award to grant solatium and interest, which was declined on 7.7.2011 with the observation that "No action is required". The petitioners challenged this order by way of Civil Writ Petition No. 17022 of 2011, which was decided on 19.9.2011 directing the respondent to decide the petitioners' claim. However, the claim was again declined by the order dated 5.3.2012, which is the subject matter of the present petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to solatium and interest under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, despite acquisition under the National Highways Act, 1956.
- Whether the denial of solatium and interest under the National Highways Act amounts to discrimination violating Article 14 of the Constitution.
- Whether the Commissioner, acting as Arbitrator, was justified in dismissing the petitioners' claim for solatium and interest on the ground of alleged illegality in the Award.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners relied on the Division Bench judgment in Golden Iron and Steel Forgings v. Union of India, 2011 (4) R.C.R (Civil) 375, which held that landowners cannot be deprived of solatium and interest as provided under Sections 23 and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
- They argued that the National Highways Act does not disclose a valid classification to justify denial of solatium and interest, and such denial amounts to discrimination violating Article 14 of the Constitution.
- Solatium is a statutory right and cannot be denied merely because of alleged illegality in the Award; the correct remedy is to challenge the illegality before the appropriate forum.
Respondents' Arguments
- The Commissioner dismissed the claim on the basis that granting solatium and interest would compound the illegality already committed in the Award.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Golden Iron and Steel Forgings v. Union of India, 2011 (4) R.C.R (Civil) 375 | Landowners cannot be deprived of solatium and interest under Sections 23 and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894; denial must satisfy tests of reasonable classification and rational nexus. | The Court relied on this binding precedent to hold that denial of solatium and interest under the National Highways Act amounts to discrimination and is ultra vires Article 14 of the Constitution. |
| Bhag Singh v. Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, Jalandhar (Civil Writ Petition No. 17022 of 2011) | Direction to the respondent to decide the claim of the petitioners for solatium and interest. | The Court noted that despite this direction, the claim was again declined, prompting the present challenge. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed whether the National Highways Act, 1956, justifies denial of solatium and interest that are statutory rights under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. It considered the principles from the Golden Iron and Steel Forgings case, emphasizing that solatium is a statutory compensation component, not a discretionary largesse. The Court found no valid classification or rational nexus in the National Highways Act to justify denial of solatium and interest. It rejected the argument that procedural differences justify differential treatment of landowners. The Court held that the denial constitutes discrimination violating Article 14 of the Constitution and is therefore ultra vires the Constitution. The Court further held that alleged illegality in the Award does not defeat the statutory right to solatium and interest, which must be claimed through appropriate legal channels rather than denied outright by the Arbitrator.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the petition and directed the respondents to pay solatium and interest to the petitioners in accordance with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, within three months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of the order.
The decision directly affects the parties by ensuring the petitioners receive their statutory entitlement of solatium and interest. No new precedent beyond the application of existing binding authority was established.
HEMANT GUPTA, J.
Challenge in the present petition is to the order dated 5.3.2012 (Annexure P-8) passed by the Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, Jalandhar, whereby the claim of the writ petitioners for grant of solatium and interest by correction of Award dated 11.2.2011 stands dismissed.
The land of the petitioners became the subject matter of acquisition under the National Highways Act, 1956. The Land Acquisition Collector announced its Award on 8.5.2007 Aggrieved against the amount of compensation awarded, the other land owners have sought References which was referred to Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, Jalandhar as an Arbitrator to decide the question of amount of compensation. Learned Arbitrator announced its Award on 28.1.2009 (Annexure P-1), determining the amount of compensation by enhancing the amount in respect of the other land owners. The Reference of the petitioners was decided vide the Award dated 11.2.2011 on the basis of the order dated 28.1.2009
Subsequently, the petitioners filed an application for correction of the Award so as to grant solatium and interest which was declined on 7.7.2011 by observing “No action is required”. The said order was challenged by the petitioners by way of a Civil Writ Petition No. 17022 of 2011, Bhag Singh v. Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, Jalandhar, which was decided on 19.9.2011, directing the respondent No. 1 to decide the claim of the petitioners. Again the claim of the petitioners has been declined vide the order dated 5.3.2012 which is now the subject matter of challenge before this Court.
Learned counsel for the petitioners relies upon a Division Bench judgment of this Court reported as Golden Iron and Steel Forgings v. Union of India, 2011 (4) R.C.R (Civil) 375, wherein, it has been held that in the matter of determining compensation, the land owners cannot be deprived of solatium and interest as provided under Section 23 and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The relevant extract from the judgment is:
61. Thus, the essential principles that emerge from a reading of the aforementioned precedents, are:-
(a) the public purpose shall not determine the amount of compensation;
(b) it is immaterial whether land is acquired under one statute or another;
(c) different compensation cannot be granted to different land owners based upon a different public purpose;
(d) where, however, a statute denies solatium and interest to a landowner, the said statutory provision must satisfy the tests of a reasonable classification based upon an intelligible differentia and must disclose a rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved.
62. The question that would now merit consideration is whether the public purpose underlying the National Highways Act discloses a valid classification based upon an intelligible differentia as would enable us to hold that the provisions of the Act, do not suffer from the vice of discrimination in matters of payment of compensation vis-a-vis lands, acquired under the Land Acquisition Act.
xxxx xxxx xxxxx
82. The expeditious constructions of Highways, the expeditious conclusion of acquisition proceedings, the reference of disputes regarding compensation to an arbitrator, the statutory power to associate private entrepreneurs and the legal ability to access private capital, in our considered opinion has no relevance to the assessment/payment of compensation. The expeditious acquisition of land can be validly achieved by resorting to the urgency provisions contained in Section 17A of the Land Acquisition Act. The impugned enactment merely replaces the procedure for acquisition, envisaged by the Land Acquisition Act with a new procedure, stated to be expeditious, more efficient and in tune with the need for an expeditious construction of national highways, but does not disclose a distinct or peculiar public purpose as would justify the denial of solatium and other statutory benefits relating to compensation.
xxxx xxxx xxxx
85. Solatium is not a largesse or a mere subsidy that the State doles out to a hapless landowner in discharge of some benevolent exercise of governmental power. Solatium is an amount, paid by the State to an unwilling land owner, for compulsory appropriation of his property. The word solatium draws its meaning from the word “solace” that is comfort money given as a statutorily recognized gesture of conciliation for compulsorily depriving a land owner of his property. The importance of “solatium” cannot be over emphasized and any departure therefrom would, in our considered opinion, be justified only where the enactment discloses a reasonable classification for treating land owners differently. Solatium forms an integral component of compensation and, therefore, can only be denied where the statute satisfies the tests of valid classification.
86. Difference in procedure would not govern rights of parties to compensation. The difference, as repeatedly emphasized herein before, must be such as would disclose a valid classification based upon an intelligible differentia and not mere differences of procedure. The public purpose must be such as cannot be achieved by resort to the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act and disclose such a distinct or peculiar object as could not be achieved under the Land Acquisition Act. We have carefully perused the Act, in our endeavour to understand the so called differentia sought to be pressed into service by counsel for the respondents and have made a concerted effort to understand their submissions but express our inability to determine any justification whether legal, factual or theoretical that would have us hold that the public purpose, underlying the amending Act constitutes a separate class and is so different from the public purpose under the Land Acquisition Act that denial of solatium and interest could be held to be based upon a valid classification and consequently a valid exercise of legislative power. We find no basis whether in the objects and reasons, in the written reply, the written submissions, as also from the assistance rendered to hold anything other than that as the provisions of the Act do not provide for grant of solatium and interest, they suffer from the vice of discrimination and violation of the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution and would, therefore, be held to be ultra vires.
The learned Commissioner has declined the claim of interest and solatium without any cogent reason by observing that any attempt to make any correction in this Award or to grant solatium and interest will further compound the illegality already committed.
We find that the solatium and interest is the statutory right of the land owner which a land owner cannot be deprived of such interest for the reason that there is an illegality in the Award announced by the Reference Court. Even if, there is an illegality in the order, the aggrieved party has to take recourse against such illegality before the appropriate forum but the right to claim solatium and interest cannot be defeated only on the basis of such presumed illegality by the Commissioner, Jalandhar Division, acting as an Arbitrator.
In view of the said fact and in view of the binding precedent of this Court in Golden Iron and Steel Forging's case (supra), the present petition is allowed. The Respondents are directed to pay interest and solatium in terms of the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
Disposed of.
Alert