Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Collector Of Central Excise, Kanpur v. Mineral Oil Corporation .

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 10, 2000
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s. Mineral Oil Corporation manufactured virgin transformer oil and also undertook reclamation of duty-paid, used transformer oil purchased from the market and supplied by the U.P. State Electricity Board on a job-work basis. The Commissioner of Central Excise, Kanpur, by order dated 24-12-1996, demanded Central Excise duty of Rs. 5,30,246.10 on the reclaimed transformer oil for the period 24-03-1996 to 30-06-1996, treating the reclamation process as “manufacture” classified under sub-heading 2710.90 of the Central Excise Tariff Act.

The assessee appealed to the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (CEGAT). On 25-06-1999, CEGAT set aside the Commissioner’s order, holding that no manufacture occurred because the product remained transformer oil both before and after the process. The Revenue carried the matter to the Supreme Court. By a brief order the Supreme Court condoned the delay and dismissed the civil appeal, thereby affirming the CEGAT decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reclamation (purification) of used transformer oil results in “manufacture” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act, 1944.
  2. If the process is not manufacture, whether any Central Excise duty is payable on the reclaimed transformer oil cleared during the relevant period.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (M/s. Mineral Oil Corporation)

  • The process merely removes impurities; no new product with a distinct name, character or use emerges.
  • Input and output are both transformer oil; therefore Section 2(f) is not attracted.
  • More stringent chemical treatment needed for producing virgin oil is absent in reclamation.
  • The Principal Collector, Kanpur, had earlier opined that such reclamation is not manufacture, and the Commissioner was bound by that view.
  • Relied on several authorities, including CCE v. Crescent Chemical Corporation (1990) 48 ELT 458 and CST v. Oil Processors (P) Ltd., 1997 SCC OnLine Bom 340, emphasising that marketability improvement alone is insufficient to constitute manufacture.

Respondent (Revenue/Commissioner of Central Excise)

  • Used oil received is unusable; after an elaborate chemical treatment—including sulphuric-acid treatment, clay treatment under vacuum, neutralisation, washing, addition of alkylate, filtration/centrifuging and blending with virgin oils—the product becomes usable transformer oil; this qualifies as manufacture.
  • Cited the definition of “manufacture” in Section 2(f) and contended that “sea change” in the product occurs.
  • Invoked precedents such as Apar (P) Ltd. v. Collector (1987) 28 ELT 70 and Brakes India Ltd. v. Superintendent of Central Excise (1997) 10 SCC 717 to support the proposition that processes conferring new usability amount to manufacture.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. CCE, (1985) 22 ELT 232 (Tri.) Process resulting in product fit for different use amounts to manufacture. Relied upon by Commissioner; Tribunal distinguished it as not applicable where end-product remains the same commodity.
CCE v. Jayant Oil Mills (P) Ltd., (1989) 3 SCC 343 Transformation that renders product marketable under a different classification is manufacture. Cited by Commissioner; Tribunal held no such transformation occurred here.
International Tractor Co. of India Ltd. v. Union of India, 1977 ELT 133 (Bom.) Broad test of manufacture under Central Excise law. Cited in Commissioner’s order; not specifically discussed by Tribunal.
Apar (P) Ltd. v. Collector, (1987) 28 ELT 70 (Tri.) Transformer base stock cannot be used as insulating oil without purification—process considered manufacture. Revenue relied; Tribunal held it inapplicable because input there was base stock, not finished transformer oil.
CCE v. Crescent Chemical Corpn., (1990) 48 ELT 458 (Tri.) Processing that merely improves quality without creating a new commodity is not manufacture. Cited by assessee; Tribunal adopted this reasoning.
CST v. Oil Processors (P) Ltd., 1997 SCC OnLine Bom 340 Removal of impurities from lubricating oil does not constitute manufacture; no new product emerges. Accepted by Tribunal as directly analogous.
State of Maharashtra v. Shiv Datt & Sons, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 222 Filtration of castor oil not manufacture when no new product results. Reinforced assessee’s position; noted by Tribunal.
Premji Haridas & Co. v. Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay, (1997) 89 ELT 658 (Bom.) Conversion of commercial castor oil to BP grade by filtration is not manufacture. Relied upon as analogous.
CCE v. Brooke Bond India Ltd., (1998) 101 ELT 296 (Tri.) Re-processing instant coffee not amounting to manufacture. Supportive authority for assessee.
CCE v. Maize Products Ltd., (1994) 73 ELT 390 (Tri.) Processing that does not create a distinct new product is not manufacture. Cited by assessee; Tribunal agreed with principle.
Collector v. S.K. Kabbur (P) Ltd., 1998 101 ELT 516 (Tri.) No manufacture where reformulation of dyes did not yield a product with different name, character or use. Tribunal quoted this case to illustrate Revenue’s failure to show emergence of a new product.
CCE v. Plastipeel Chemicals & Plastic (P) Ltd., (1998) 99 ELT 639 (Tri.) Absence of new commodity means no manufacture. Mentioned in support of assessee’s argument.
Brakes India Ltd. v. Supt. of Central Excise, (1997) 10 SCC 717 If a process imparts new character and use, it is manufacture. Relied on by Revenue; Tribunal distinguished on facts.
Hawkins Cookers Ltd. v. CCE, (1997) 11 SCC 309 Illustration of transformation test (specific facts not detailed in opinion). Cited by Revenue; not expressly addressed by Tribunal.
Honeyrex Products (P) Ltd. v. CCE, 1998 99 ELT 402 (Tri.) Mixing honey with other ingredients created a new product—manufacture. Revenue cited; Tribunal held circumstances different because reclaimed oil remained transformer oil.
Union of India v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills, AIR 1963 SC 791; 1977 ELT 199 Foundational test: manufacture requires emergence of a new commodity with distinct name, character or use. Tribunal applied this landmark test and found no manufacture.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal began with the settled principle from Delhi Cloth & General Mills that “every change is not manufacture; there must be transformation into a new article having a distinct name, character or use.” It observed that the used transformer oil, after removal of impurities, remained transformer oil. Marketability and specific-gravity changes alone do not create a new commodity.

The Commissioner’s order was faulted for focusing only on quality improvement rather than the legal test of emergence of a distinct product. Precedents relied on by the Revenue (e.g., Apar, Brakes India, Honeyrex) were distinguished because in those cases the input and output were different commodities, whereas here both before and after processing the substance was transformer oil. Conversely, decisions cited by the assessee (Crescent Chemical, Oil Processors, Shiv Datt, etc.) were found directly applicable as they involved purification processes that did not yield a new product.

Finding no evidence that the reclaimed oil was recognised in trade as anything other than transformer oil, the Tribunal concluded that the reclamation process did not amount to manufacture under Section 2(f). Accordingly, the demand of duty was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

SUPREME COURT HOLDING: Civil appeal dismissed; delay condoned.

By dismissing the Revenue’s appeal, the Supreme Court left intact CEGAT’s decision that reclamation of used transformer oil does not constitute manufacture and therefore attracts no Central Excise duty. The immediate consequence is that the demand of Rs. 5,30,246.10 against M/s. Mineral Oil Corporation stands annulled. The order is case-specific and does not articulate any new legal principle, but it implicitly reaffirms the established “distinct commodity” test for manufacture under Central Excise law.

Show all summary ...

Order of the Supreme Court

1. Delay condoned. The civil appeal is dismissed.

Impugned Order of Cegat dated 25-6-1999
[Before S.S Kang, Member (J) and V.K Agrawal, Member (T)]

The Order of Tribunal was delivered by

V.K Agrawal, Member (T).— The issue involved in this appeal filed by M/s Mineral Oil Corporation is whether the process of reclamation of transformer oil from used transformer oil amounts to manufacture so as to attract levy of duty of excise.

3. Briefly stated the facts are that the appellants manufacture virgin transformer oil. They are also engaged in the reclamation of duty-paid used transformer oil on their own account out of used transformer oil purchased from the market and also on job-work basis out of used transformer oil received from U.P State Electricity Board (Upseb). The Commissioner, Central Excise, Kanpur, under the impugned order dated 24-12-1996, confirmed the demand of Central excise duty amounting to Rs 5,30,246.10 on the reclaimed transformer oil cleared during the period from 24-3-1996 to 30-6-1996 after classifying the reclaimed transformer oil under sub-heading 2710.90 of the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, holding that manufacture is a process of converting some material into a form adopted for uses to which in its original form it could not be so used; that the appellants removes the impurities to enhance the insulating quantities of the transformer oil; that used transformer oil would be covered under broad category of transformer oil feed stock; that accordingly process undertaken by the appellants to change used transformer oil into transformer oil would amount to manufacture. The Commissioner had relied upon the following decisions:

(i) Hindustan Lever Ltd. v. CCE (1985) 22 ELT 232 (Tri)
(ii) CCE v. Jayant Oil Mills (P) Ltd. (1989) 3 SCC 343, (1989) 40 ELT 287
(iii) International Tractor Co. of India Ltd. v. Union of India 1977 ELT 133 (Bom)
(iv) Apar (P) Ltd. v. CCE (1987) 28 ELT 70 (Tri).

4. Shri R. Santhanam, learned Advocate, submitted that the reclamation of duty paid used transformer oil does not give rise to nor does it constitute manufacture of any excisable goods: that used transformer oil is subjected to the process of purification in which impurities, which had come in the oil in the course of its use, are removed; that the manufacture of fresh transformer oil requires drastic/strict treatment of chemicals whereas in the case of reclamation, the requirement of treatment of chemicals is very mild one depending upon the percentage of contamination of the used transformer oil; that the process of reclamation does not involve any change of the characteristics of oil as no new product emerges as a result of purification of duty paid waste oil; that input and output are the same and as such no manufacturing activity had been undertaken by the appellants; that the Principal Collector, Central Excise, Kanpur in Letter dated 15-11-1994, addressed to Upseb opined that reclamation of used transformer oil through the process undertaken for its purpose would not amount to manufacture within the provisions of Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act. The learned Advocate contended that the Commissioner was duty-bound to abide by and follow the order of the Principal Collector; that further the impugned order had been passed in disregard and defiance of the judicial pronouncements. He relied upon the decision in CCE v. Crescent Chemical Corpn. (1990) 48 ELT 458 (Tri) wherein it was held that “It is the production or manufacture of lubricating oil which attracts the charge of excise duty and not the processing of lubricating oil as such. One may add chemicals to lubricating oil, one may subject lubricating oil to a process by which its usability may be reduced or enhanced. That would not attract the applicability of Item 11-A so long as the lubricating oil retains its character as lubricating oil and does not become a different commodity. He also placed reliance on the decision of the Bombay High Court in CST v. Oil Processors (P) Ltd. 1997 SCC OnLine Bom 340, (1997) 3 Mah LJ 776 The Bombay High Court held that every process undertaken on the goods to make them fit for the market or improving their marketability does not amount to a process of manufacture; there must be a transformation as a result of the process undertaken on the product and a new and different article having a distinctive name or character must emerge. The Court, therefore, held that the process of removing impurities of lubricating oil would not amount to manufacture as nothing was manufactured as a result of the process; lubricating oil remained lubricating oil even after processing with the only difference that on removal of impurities, etc. it became fit for resale as lubricating oil. He also relied upon the decision in State of Maharashtra v. Shiv Datt & Sons 1993 Supp (1) SCC 222, AIR 1992 SC 692, Premji Haridas & Co. v. Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay (1997) 89 ELT 658 (Bom) wherein the conversion of castor oil (commercial) to castor oil (BP) by a process of filtration was held to be not amounting to manufacture as no new product emerged. The reliance was also placed on the following four decisions:

(i) CCE v. Brooke Bond India Ltd. (1998) 101 ELT 296 (Tri) Reprocessing of instant clotted coffee does not result in process of manufacture;
(ii) CCE v. Maize Products Ltd. (1994) 73 ELT 390 (Tri)
(iii) CCE v. S.K Kabbur (P) Ltd. (1998) 101 ELT 516 (Tri)
(iv) CCE v. Plastipeel Chemicals & Plastic (P) Ltd. (1998) 99 ELT 639 (Tri)

As no new commodity came into existence as a result of the addition of anti-oxidant and rust inhibitors to MoS2, which was already in the nature of a dry lubricant, the process does not amount to manufacture.

5. Countering the arguments, Shri Satnam Singh, learned SDR, submitted that the unusable material is received by the appellants from Upseb and by elaborate process of manufacture, the transformer oil is reclaimed which is usable as transformer oil. He drew our attention to the process of manufacture given in the show-cause notice which is reproduced below:

“The process of manufacture of reclaimed transformer oil from used oil is carried out by treating it with sulphuric acid and clay treatment under vacuum. Thereafter, acid treated oil is neutralised by alkali which is washed with water. And for removing petroleum sulphonates it is treated with heavy alkylate. Finally oil is filtered/centrifuged blended with virgin oils and additives according to use and tests of reclaimed oil.”

He contended that this process of reclamation of transformer oil definitely amounts to manufacture as per the definition of word “manufacture” in Section 2(f) of the Central Excise Act. He further mentioned that the product had undergone a sea change because of the treatment undertaken by the appellants. He relied upon the decision in Apar (P) Ltd. v. CCE (1987) 28 ELT 70 (Tri) in which it was held that transformer base stock cannot be used as insulating oil without purification.

6. Reliance was also placed by the learned SDR on the decision in Brakes India Ltd. v. Supt. of Central Excise (1997) 10 SCC 717, (1998) 101 ELT 241 in which it was held that drilling, trimming and chamfering of brake lining blanks amount to manufacture as without such process brake lining blanks cannot be used by owners of motor vehicles. It was further held that: (Brakes India case (1997) 10 SCC 717, (1998) 101 ELT 241)

“1. … When adopting a particular process, if a transformation takes place, which makes the product have a character and use of its own, which it did not bear earlier, then the process would amount to manufacture within the meaning of Section 2(f) irrespective of the fact whether there has been a single process or have been several processes.”

He also referred to the decision in Hawkins Cookers Ltd. v. CCE (1997) 11 SCC 309, (1997) 96 ELT 507. Finally he relied upon the decision in Honeyrex Products (P) Ltd. v. CCE (1998) 99 ELT 402 (Tri) wherein the Tribunal held that by process of mixing natural honey with sucrose, glucose and preservatives, a new product has emerged which cannot be called as natural honey. The process was, therefore, held to be amounting to manufacture.

7. The learned counsel, in reply, mentioned that every chemical change does not amount to manufacture; that the process applied is not material; what is material is that a new distinct product should come into existence as a result of the manufacture; that in the present matter transformer oil remains transformer oil; the only change that takes place is that the specific gravity of the oil changes which does not make it a new distinct product.

8. We have considered the submissions of both sides. It is well-settled law that to amount to manufacture, a new commodity having distinct name, character or use should emerge as a result of process of manufacture. Manufacture implies a change, but every change is not manufacture. The Apex Court in the landmark decision in Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. AIR 1963 SC 791, 1977 ELT 199, held that: (AIR p. 794, para 4)

“4. … The word ‘manufacture’ used as a verb is generally understood to mean as ‘bringing into existence a new substance’ … however minor in consequence the change may be.”

The Apex Court further quoted the following passage from an American judgment: (Delhi Cloth and General Mills case AIR 1963 SC 791, 1977 ELT 199, AIR p. 795, para 14)

“14. … ‘Manufacture implies a change, but every change is not manufacture and yet every change of an article is the result of treatment, labour and manipulation. But something more is necessary and there must be transformation; a new and different article must emerge having a distinctive name, character or use.’”

This judgment has been followed in numerous cases.

9. The true test for determining whether manufacture can be said to have taken place is whether the commodity which is subjected to the process of manufacture can no longer be regarded as the original commodity but is recognised in trade as a new and distinct commodity. In the present case, the appellants bring used transformer oil and by removing impurities, it is again made usable as transformer oil. Both before and after the processing, the product is only transformer oil. That being so, it cannot be said that a new and distinct commodity has come into existence consequent to the process undertaken by the appellants. Similar was the view of the Bombay High Court in Oil Processors (P) Ltd. 1997 SCC OnLine Bom 340, (1997) 3 Mah LJ 776 wherein it was held that “activity of converting the used waste lubricating oil into usable lubricating oil is not a refining process”.

10. The learned counsel, appearing for the appellants has referred to a number of decisions in which it has been held that a process will amount to manufacture only if a new and distinct commodity emerges as a result of manufacture. In S.K Kabbur case (1998) 101 ELT 516 (Tri), the Tribunal rejected the appeal filed by the Department as “the Revenue has not been able to substantiate its case that the conversion of already formulated/prepared/standardised S.O Dyes by mixing/grinding/adding of diluents into reformulations results in emergence of a distinct commercial commodity having a name, character, and use different from the raw material”. We observe that the Commissioner had confirmed the duty in the impugned order as the process undertaken by the appellants had improved the quality to be used as a transformer oil. He has nowhere given a finding that a new distinct commodity has emerged as a result of the process undertaken by the appellants. The ratio of the decision in Apar (P) Ltd. (1987) 28 ELT 70 (Tri) is not applicable to the facts of the present case. In Apar case (1987) 28 ELT 70 (Tri), the input was transformer oil base stock and not the transformer oil itself. The Tribunal, after referring to the definition of transformer oil and base stock as given in Indian Standard Glossary of Petroleum, observed the Transformer Oil Base Stock is primary material introduced into a plant for processing.

11. In other decisions relied upon by the learned SDR on behalf of the Revenue, the process was held to be amounting to manufacture as a new distinct commodity has emerged on account of process undertaken in those cases. For instance in Honeyrex Products (P) Ltd. case (1998) 99 ELT 402 (Tri), the Tribunal held that Honeyrex is a new commodity as it was not marketed as natural honey and because of addition of ingredients like sucrose, glucose and preservatives a new product different from natural honey has emerged. In Brakes India case (1997) 10 SCC 717, (1998) 101 ELT 241, also the Supreme Court considered the “character or use” before holding the process of drilling, trimming and chamfering of brake lining blanks as the process amounting to manufacture. The Supreme Court referred to the observation of the High Court that sometime it may suit the manufacturer to retain and stamp the same name to the end products also. Such is not the case in the present matter as used transformer oil remains to be transformer oil after the process undertaken by the appellants.

12. In these circumstances, we set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal.