- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Baldev Kapoor, P.C.S (Petitioner) v. The Union Of India And Others (S).
Summary of Opinion: Baldev Kapoor v. Union of India (C.W.P. No. 3336 of 1978) — Sukhdev Singh Kang, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
These three writ petitions (Nos. 3335–3337 of 1978) were heard together because they involved common questions of law and fact. The opinion sets out the facts of C.W.P. No. 3336, Baldev Kapoor v. Union of India, as representative. The petitioner (Baldev Kapoor) joined the Punjab Civil Service (Executive Branch) in November 1957 after a competitive examination and had a long service record, including varied training and important field and Secretariat assignments. He earned Selection Grade and Senior Selection Grade in 1976 and 1977 respectively.
A Selection Committee met on 16–17 December 1977 under Regulation 5 of the Indian Administrative Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 (the Promotion Regulations) and selected nine officers from the State Civil Service for inclusion in the select list for promotion to the Indian Administrative Service (respondents No. 5–13). Several senior State officers, including some petitioners, alleged wrongful supersession, procedural irregularity and arbitrariness in the selection process. The Punjab Government forwarded a select list to the Union Public Service Commission (the Commission) in a manner that petitioners alleged violated Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations. The Commission approved the list; the petitioners challenged that approval by writ petitions contending, inter alia, that mandatory procedural steps were not followed, that the Promotion Regulations (and amendments) were ultra vires, and that specific officers with adverse records were improperly included.
The High Court examined the statutory scheme (Recruitment Rules, Promotion Regulations and their amendments), the conduct of the Selection Committee, and the actions of the Commission and State Government, and ultimately dismissed the writ petitions. There was no order as to costs.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Regulation 6 of the Indian Administrative Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 (which requires that the select list and specified service records and reasons be forwarded to the Union Public Service Commission) is mandatory (i.e., non-compliance vitiates the Commission's approval) or merely directory.
- Whether the amendment (dated 3 June 1977) to Regulation 5 (sub-regulations (4) and (5)) introduced arbitrariness or rendered the Promotion Regulations ultra vires the Recruitment Rules or the Constitution (specifically Articles 14 and 16).
- Whether the Selection Committee's decision to include certain private respondents (respondents No. 5–13) and to supersede petitioners was arbitrary or lacked reasons sufficient to satisfy principles of fair play and the requirements of law.
- Whether adverse confidential reports and related material in the case of respondent K.S. Raju were improperly expunged or withheld so as to vitiate his inclusion in the select list.
- Whether other alleged omissions (failure to consider certain qualifications, certificates, commendation letters, or differences in confirmation dates in Selection/Senior Selection Grades) rendered the selection invalid.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The mandatory requirements of Regulation 6 were violated because the State Government did not forward the service records of all eligible officers (including those proposed to be superseded), the reasons for proposed supersession, and the State Government's observations; this prevented the Commission from applying its independent mind and amounted to a mechanical approval by the Commission.
- The Promotion Regulations (and the amendment of 3 June 1977) were ultra vires the Recruitment Rules and the Constitution; the amendment introduced arbitrariness and offended Article 14.
- Certain selected officers (notably K.S. Raju) had adverse confidential reports and letters; those adverse entries were improperly dealt with (including alleged illegal expunction), and the relevant records were not placed before the Selection Committee.
- Important qualifications, certificates and commendation letters of the petitioners were not taken into account.
- Petitioners had earlier confirmations (in Senior Selection Grade) than some selected officers; some selected officers were not even confirmed in Selection Grade, which affected seniority and eligibility considerations.
- More generally, the petitioners contended that the Selection Committee gave no reasons for supersession and that selection was arbitrary.
Respondents' (Official and Private) Arguments
- The State Government asserted that the service records of all 69 eligible officers were sent to the Commission on 12 October 1977 and returned after perusal on 12 December 1977; thus records had been before the Commission and were available to the Committee when it met on 16–17 December 1977.
- The Promotion Regulations and their 3 June 1977 amendments were valid and constitutional.
- Adverse remarks regarding Shri K.S. Raju had been expunged by the orders of the Chief Minister and the letter conveying the remarks withdrawn; these actions were lawfully taken and the Commission was made aware of the expunction and of the State Government's comments that the Commission might reconsider Raju's inclusion.
- The service records of the petitioners (prepared according to Government instructions) were placed before the Committee; commendation letters and certain other documents are not placed on personal files as a matter of Government instruction and thus were not omitted unlawfully.
- It was admitted that the petitioner was confirmed in the Senior Selection Grade earlier than some selected officers; however the Selection Committee properly categorized officers by relative assessment of their service records.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Dattatraya Moreshwar v. The State of Bombay, A.I.R. 1952 S.C. 181 | Generally provisions creating public duties are directory, and those conferring private rights are imperative; where invalidation would work serious general inconvenience, such prescriptions are treated as directory. | The court relied on this principle to support the conclusion that Regulation 6 is directory rather than mandatory because it deals with a public duty and non-compliance would cause inconvenience to officers beyond their control. |
| Haridwar Singh v. Bagun Bumbrui, (1973) 3 SCC 889 | For determining whether a provision is mandatory or directory, courts must examine subject‑matter, importance of the provision and its relation to the statute's object; prohibitive words usually indicate mandatory intent. | The court cited this test in assessing Regulation 6 and concluded that the provision is procedural and directory, not prohibitive or mandatory in the sense of vitiating acts for non-compliance. |
| Jagan Nath v. Jaswant Singh & Others, A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 210 | Holds that a statutory provision is not mandatory unless non-compliance is made penal. | Used as support for the proposition that absence of a penal consequence militates against treating a procedural provision as mandatory when construing Regulation 6. |
| State of Punjab v. Satya Pal Dena, A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 90 | Distinction between mandatory and directory: mandatory provisions imply prohibition of alternative action; directory provisions can be satisfied by substantial compliance, especially to avoid general injustice. | The court applied this distinction to conclude that strict compliance with Regulation 6 is not a condition precedent to the validity of the Commission's approval; substantial compliance suffices. |
| State of Punjab v. V. Sheolal Murari, (1976) 1 SCC 719 | Procedural law should aid justice; where non-compliance will thwart fair hearing, rule is mandatory; where breach can be corrected without injury to justice, procedural requirements should not be enforced to defeat substantive justice. | The court invoked this approach to emphasize that procedural non-compliance should not be allowed to wreck substantive justice and to support treating Regulation 6 as directory where substantial compliance had occurred and no prejudice resulted. |
| Karam Singh Oswal v. The State of Punjab, 1975 (2) S.L.R. 189 (Full Bench of the High Court) | Reiterated that provisions creating public duties are generally directory; the word "shall" is not determinative; strict compliance is required only where necessary to secure the statute's object. | The court used this authority to reinforce that Regulation 6, though expressed in mandatory language, is to be treated as directory in the circumstances of the case. |
| Union of India v. Mohan Lal Capoor, 1973 (2) S.L.R. 824 | Selection by evaluation of service records is akin to an examination; service records "speak for themselves". The earlier requirement to state reasons for supersession (in the unamended regulation) was considered significant for fairness. | The court relied on the proposition that service records themselves show the basis for selection and held that under the amended Regulation 5 (classification into categories), the committee's categorisation provided the necessary rationale; Mohan Lal was distinguished because it addressed the unamended requirement to record reasons. |
| Associated Electrical Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Its Workmen, A.I.R. 1967 S.C. 284 and Collector of Manghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka, (1963) (1) S.C.R. 98 | Cases relied upon for the proposition that non-compliance with mandatory statutory requirements can render proceedings invalid (cited in Mohan Lal). | The court noted these decisions were relied upon in Mohan Lal when dealing with the unamended requirement to record reasons; however, because the relevant sub‑regulation requiring reasons was deleted by amendment, those authorities were not directly applicable to the amended scheme. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in two principal phases: (A) the statutory/interpretive question whether Regulation 6 is mandatory or directory, and (B) evaluation of whether, on the facts, there had been substantial compliance and whether the selection was arbitrary or infirm on merits.
A. Mandatory v. Directory (Interpretation of Regulation 6)
- The court examined authoritative statements of law on when statutory provisions should be treated as mandatory or directory, drawing on Maxwell, Craies, Crawford and several precedents (Dattatraya Moreshwar, Haridwar Singh, Jagan Nath, Satya Pal Dena, V. Sheolal Murari, and the High Court's own Full Bench in Karam Singh Oswal).
- The court applied these tests to Regulation 6 and observed the following attributes: the provision is procedural in nature, it relates to performance of a public duty rather than the conferment of private rights, it is not expressed in prohibitory language, and there is no penal consequence prescribed for non-compliance.
- The court further considered the practical consequences of treating Regulation 6 as mandatory—specifically, that invalidation of the Commission's approval for procedural non-compliance would cause serious inconvenience and injustice to private respondents who had no control over State Government action, without promoting the essential aim of the regulation.
- On this basis and guided by the cited precedents, the court concluded that Regulation 6 is directory: substantial compliance is all that is required rather than literal, condition‑precedent compliance that would invalidate the Commission's actions.
B. Substantial Compliance and Merits of Selection
- The court examined the factual record relating to transmission of service records to the Commission: the State Government had sent records of all 69 eligible officers on 12 October 1977; the Commission had perused them and retained compilations; those compilations were updated and found to tally with service records.
- The Commission had detailed compilations and had taken extracts from records; the record concerning Shri K.S. Raju (including the fact of expunction of adverse remarks and the State Government's comments) had been before the Commission. The Commission could have sought further records but did not deem it necessary.
- Given these facts, the court held there had been substantial compliance with Regulation 6; the Commission had the materials necessary to apply its independent judgment and had indeed applied its mind to the list and related materials before approving the select list.
- On the argument of arbitrariness and absence of reasons, the court analysed the amended Regulation 5 (sub-regulations (4) and (5) as substituted on 3 June 1977). The amendments required categorical classification of eligible officers as "outstanding", "very good", "good" or "unfit" and required preparation of the list by selecting first from "outstanding", then "very good", then "good". The Court observed that:
- Those amendments significantly curtailed the prior wide discretion of the Selection Committee and supplied clear guidelines for selection.
- The committee consisted of senior officers with a member or chairman from the Commission; their categorical classifications are an expression of the reasoning process and reflect the service records themselves.
- Because sub-regulation 7 (which had required recording reasons for proposed supersession) was omitted by the amendment, the statutory scheme no longer required separate written reasons; the classification itself and the underlying service records sufficed to disclose the basis of selection.
- Regarding Shri K.S. Raju, the court found that adverse entries had been expunged by the Chief Minister; although the expunction may not have followed internal instructions, those instructions were not statutory and their non‑observance did not render the expunction illegal. With adverse remarks removed, the court found Raju's record superior to petitioners' records and concluded the Selection Committee was entitled to include him.
- As to other officers with pending enquiries, the court held mere allegations or pending enquiries were insufficient to exclude officers from the list; their names were included subject to the outcome of inquiries and there was no evidence of blemish warranting exclusion.
- Finally, the court emphasized it was not sitting in appeal over the Committee's evaluation of service records; the decision had been made fairly and in accordance with principles of fair play and thus was not open to challenge in these writ proceedings.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: PETITIONS DISMISSED.
Implications and direct effects:
- The High Court held that Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations is directory; non-compliance in letter does not automatically vitiate the Commission's approval where substantial compliance exists and no prejudice to the parties is shown.
- The Commission's approval of the select list was not invalidated: the Court found substantial compliance with Regulation 6, that the Commission had the necessary service records and applied its mind before approving the list.
- The Court upheld the Selection Committee's categorisation under the amended Regulation 5 (as substituted on 3 June 1977) and rejected the contention that the selection was arbitrary or required separately recorded reasons under the amended scheme. The deletion of the old requirement to record reasons (sub-regulation 7) and the new categorical scheme meant that the committee's classifications and underlying service records furnished the basis for selection.
- The orders expunging adverse entries (in the case of K.S. Raju) were treated as effective for the purposes of assessment, even if they had not followed non-statutory internal instructions, and did not render the selection illegal.
- Direct consequence to parties: the select list and promotions approved by the Commission stand; the writ petitions were dismissed and there was no order as to costs.
- The opinion does not purport to set a novel principle of law beyond the application of existing tests for mandatory versus directory statutory provisions and the application of the amended Promotion Regulations; the court applied established precedents to the facts and did not announce a new broad precedent beyond its reasoning on the directory nature of Regulation 6 and the sufficiency of substantial compliance in the circumstances of this case.
Disposition: Petition dismissed. Prem Chand Jain, J. agreed. No order as to costs.
Sukhdev Singh Kang, J.:— These three writ petitions No. 3335 to 3337 of 1978 will be disposed of by this judgment as common questions of law and fact are involved. To fully appreciate the controversy between the parties the facts in C.W.P No. 3336 of 1978, Baldev Kapoor v. Union of India are given below.
2. The petitioner joined the Punjab Civil Service (Executive Branch) on November 23, 1957, on the basis of a competitive examination held in the year 1956. He completed all the courses of training like Judicial, Revenue, Treasury, General, Police, Jails, besides development training at the National Institute of Community Development, Hyderabad. He passed the departmental examinations. In higher standard within the prescribed period of his probation. He has during his service career held important assignments both in the field as well as in the Secretariat. He served as Sub Divisional Magistrate in different Sub-Divisions in Punjab and Delhi for about 8 years. He also served as Zonal Assistant Commissioner and Director of Vigilance in the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. The latter post had hitherto been always held by an I.A.S Officer. At the time of the filing of the petition, he was working in the Food Corporation of India on a post equivalent to the post of a Deputy Secretary to Government of India. The petitioner acquitted himself well to the entire satisfaction of his senior officers throughout his service.
3. While serving at Delhi, the petitioner improved his educational qualifications. He passed three L.L.B course in 1976 from the Delhi University. He was also sent abroad by the Central Government under Colombo Plan for three months in 1974, for the purposes of advanced practical course of studies in the “Management of Urban Development” at the University of Birmingham. He successfully completed his course there. The petitioner was granted Selection Grade in the scale of Rs. 1,300-50-1,500 with effect from November 8, 1976. He was confirmed in the Senior Selection Grade with effect from January 1, 1977, The Selection Grade and the Senior Selection Grade was granted to the petitioner on the basis of selection as envisaged under Rule 25(3) of the Punjab Civil Service Rules, 1930.
4. The service particulars of the other petitioners are also on the same lines.
5. The Indian Administrative Service along with the other Central Services has been formed under the All India Civil Services Act, 1931. By virtue of the powers given by this Act for the efficient management of the service, Indian Administrative Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1954 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules) were framed by the Government of India. The Central Government framed Regulations known as Indian Administrative Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the Promotion Regulations) in exercise of the powers conferred on it by Rule 8 of the Rules. It may be mentioned here that the members of the State Civil Service are promoted to the Indian Administrative Service and the Promotion Regulations have been framed to regulate these promotions. By Regulation 3 of these Promotion Regulations, provision is made for the constitution of a Committee to make selection of the State Service Officers. Regulation 3 of the Promotion Regulations provides conditions for eligibility for promotion, The procedure for preparation of the select list of suitable officers of the State Service is prescribed in Regulation 5 of the Promotion regulations.
6. The Selection Committee held its meeting on 16th/17th of December, 1977, for the purpose of preparing the select list of I.A.S Officers under Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations. It selected 9 Officers from the State Civil Service who are respondents No. 5 to 13. It is alleged that these 9 Officers, included many officers of doubtful integrity and the officers, like the petitioners, who were of unquestionable integrity were left out. It caused so much embarrassment to the Punjab Government that the Government had to withhold the list for a long time. However, after a period about 7 months, for the reasons best known to it, the Punjab Government sent the list to the Union Public Service Commission in a hush-hush manner without complying with the statutory requirement of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations. The list was approved by the Union Public Service Commission with undue haste and was cleared by the Home Ministry in the 1st week of July, 1978. The inter se seniority of the petitioners and other superseded State officers qua nine officers brought on the list in the Punjab Civil Service Executive; gradation list as it stood on April 1, 1978, was as under:—
Sl. No. Sl. No. in the seniority list Name of the officers Remarks 1. 1 Sh. Guldip Singh, Director, Small Savings, Punjab. Superseded 2. 2 Sh. Gurdial Singh Fiji, O.S.D Land Reforms. Superseded 3. 3 Sh. Iqbal Singh, Dy. Secy. Co-operation. Superseded 4. 4 Mrs. K. Goyal, Joint Director, Local Government. Superseded 5. 5 Sh. Karam Singh Raju, Dy. Secretary Irrigation. Selected 6. 6 Sh. Sher Singh Sindhu, Addl. Director, Consolidation of Holdings, Punjab, Chandigarh. Selected 7. 7 Mrs. Surjit Kaur Gill, Director, Social Welfare. Superseded 8. 8 Sh. G.D Bhasin, Dy. Secy., Local Govt. Superseded 9. 9 Sh. R.S Dass, Dy. Secretary, Finance. Superseded 10. 10 Sh. S.K Diwan, Dy. Secretary, Public Relations. Selected 11. 11 Sh. Randhir Singh, P.C.S, Asstt. Settlement Commissioner, Punjab, Jullundur. Selected 12. 12 Sh. Gulwant Singh, P.C.S, Additional Dy. Commissioner, Gurdaspur. Selected
13. 13 Sh. Gurnam Singh, Deputy Secretary, Development. Superseded 14. 14 Sh. Baldev Kapur, Joint Manager (Security) F.C.I Superseded 15. 15 Sh. K.D Arora, Deputy Secretary, Resident Commissioner. Selected 16. 16 Sh. K.K Dhir, Joint Manager, F.C.I Selected 17. 17 Sh. Manohar Singh Chandla, Principal Revenue Training School, Chandigarh. Superseded 18. 18 Sh. Raj Kumar Jain, Sy. Punjab Scheduled Cases Land Development & Finance Corporation. Selected 19. 19 Sh. M.P Mitra, Deputy Chief Administrator Selected.
7. Mrs. K. Goyal petitioner was admittedly senior to all the nine selected officers. Petitioners Shri Baldev Kapoor and Shri R.S Dass were also senior to many of the selected officers in the State service. The petitioners have challenged the selection of the nine officers who are respondents No. 5 to 13 in these petitions, inter alia on the following grounds:—
(i) The mandatory provision of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations has been violated in so far as the service records of all eligible State Civil Service Officers, including the petitioners and private respondents, had not been sent to the Union Public Service Commission (hereinafter called the Commission) leading to depriving the Commission an opportunity to apply its independent mind while approving the select list prepared by the Selection Committee under Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations. The approval was given without considering the reasons given by the Selection Committee.
(ii)(a) The Promotion Regulations were ultra vires of the Rules and the Constitution.
(b) The amendment made in the Promotion Regulations on June 3, 1977, introduced a vice of arbitrariness and as such these amended Promotion Regulations are ultra vires of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
(iii) Shri K.S Raju respondent had earned adverse confidential reports for a number of years, and one such report against Shri Raju was given by Shri K.D Vasudeva, I.A.S The representations against these adverse remarks and reports were rejected by the State Government. Still in flagrant violation of the Government's instructions dated March 24, 1968, on the subject, the then Chief Minister expunged these adverse remarks. The relevant record of Mr. Raju had not been placed before the Committee and was not taken into consideration.
(iv) Certain important qualifications, certificates and commendation letters issued to the petitioner were not taken into account.
(v) The petitioner had been confirmed in the Senior Selection Grade before some of the selected officers. Some of them had not been even confirmed in the Selection Grade.
8. The official and private respondents filed returns controverting the aforesaid plea. They averred that:—
(i) The service records of the State Civil Service Officers considered by the Selection Committee for preparation of the select list were sent to the Commission vide the State Government's letter No. 9008-ASI-(5) 77, dated October 12, 1977, which were returned by the Commission on December 12, 1977, after perusal,
(ii)(a) The Promotion Regulations were perfectly legal, valid and constitutional.
(b) The amendments made in the Promotion Regulations on June 3, 1977, were not in any way unconstitutional.
(iii) The adverse remarks in the Annual Confidential Reports of Mr. R.S Raju respondent and the letter issued to Mr. Raju conveying the adverse remarks had been expunged by the orders of the Chief Minister and the letter issued to him had also been withdrawn by the Government on the plea that these remarks were not adverse. It is admitted that the earlier representations of Mr. Raju against these remarks were not entertained, but, however, the remarks had been legally and validly expunged end the letter had been withdrawn in a legal manner. It was also contended that the concerned file was sent to the Commission and the fact regarding expunction of adverse remarks in the Annual Confidential Reports of Mr. Raju by the then Chief Minister Giani Zail Singh was pointedly brought to the notice of the Commission along with the comments of the State Government to the effect that the inclusion of Mr. K.S Raju in the select list may be reconsidered by the Commission.
(iv) That the service record of the petitioners prepared in accordance with the Government's instructions was placed before the Committee. The educational qualifications acquired and the commendation letters received by the officers for any major event or work done or special contribution made by an officer towards the implementation of a particular scheme, are not placed on the personal file of an officer, under the Government's instructions.
(v) It was admitted that the petitioner was confirmed in the Senior Selection Grade earlier to some of the selected officers.
9. At this stage it will be beneficial to notice the relevant statutory provisions contained in Regulations 5, 6 and 7 of the Promotion Regulations.
“5. Preparation of a list of Suitable Officers.
(1) Each Committee shall ordinarily meet at intervals not exceeding one year end prepare a list of such members of the State Civil Service as are held by them to be suitable for promotion to the service. The number of members of the State Civil Service included in the list shall not be more than twice the number of substantive vacancies anticipated in course of the period of twelve months, commencing from the date of preparation of the list, in the posts available for them under rule 9 of the Recruitment Rules, or 10 per cent of the senior posts shown against items 1 and 2 of the cadre schedule of each State or group of States, whichever is greater.
(2) The Committee shall consider, for inclusion in the said list, the cases of members of State Civil Service in order of seniority in the State Civil Service upto a number not less than five times the number referred to in sub-regulation (i).
Provided that, in computing the number for inclusion in the field of consideration, the number of officers referred to in sub-regulation (3) shall be excluded.
Provided further that a Committee shall not consider the case of a member of the State Civil Service unless on the first day of the January of the year in which its meets, he is substantive in the State Civil Service and has completed not lees than eight years of continuous service (whether officiating or substantive) in a post of Deputy Collector or any other post or posts declared equivalent thereto by the Government.
(2-A) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-regulations (1) and (2) the list referred to sub-regulations (i) shall be prepared separately in respect of each State Civil Service. The numbers of members of the State Civil Service included in each such part of the list shall not be more than twice the number of substantial vacancies anticipated in the course of the period of twelve months, commencing from the date of the preparation of the list in the posts available for them under rule 9 of the Recruitment Rules of 10 per cent of the senior posts shown against item 1 of the Cadre in the Schedule to the Indian Administrative Service (Fixation of Cadre Strength) Regulations, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as the Cadre Schedule) under the Government of Constituent State concerned and the senior posts shown against item 2 of the Cadre Schedule notionally reckoned against that State whichever is greater.
Explanation: xxx xxx
(3) The Committee shall not ordinarily consider the case of the members of the State Civil Service who have attained the age of 52 years on the first day of January of the year in which it meets.
Provided that a member of the State Civil Service whose name appears in the select list in force immediately before the date of the meeting of the Committee shall be considered for inclusion in the fresh list to be prepared by the Committee even if he has in the meanwhile attained the age of 52 years.
(4) The selection for inclusion to such list shall be based on merit and suitability in all respects.
Provided that where the merits of two or more officers are found to be equal seniority shall be taken into account.
(5) The names of the officers included in the list shall be arranged in order of seniority in the State Civil Service.
Provided that any junior officer who in the opinion of the Committee is of exceptional merit and suitability may be assigned a place in the list higher than that of officers senior to him.
(6) The list so prepared shall be reviewed and revised every year.
(7) If in the process of selection, review or revision it is proposed to supersede any member of the State Civil Service, the Committee shall record its reasons for the proposed supersession.”
10. These Promotion Regulations were amended on June 3, 1977 and Sub-Regulations (4) and 5) of Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations were substituted by the new Sub-Regulations (4) and (5) which are reproduced below
“(4) The Selection Committee shall classify the eligible officers as “outstanding”, “very good”, “good” or “unfit” as the case may be, on an overall relative assessment of their service records.
(5) The list shall be prepared by including the required number of names, first from amongst the officers finally classified as “outstanding” then from amongst those similarly classified as “very good” and thereafter from amongst those similarly classified as “good” and the order of names inter se within each category shall be in the order of their seniority in the State Civil Service.”
11. Sub-Regulation 7 was omitted.
“6. Consultation with the Commission:—
The list prepared in accordance with Regulation 5 shall then be forwarded to the Commission by the State Government along with:—
(i) the records of all members of the State Civil Service included in the list;
(ii) the records of all members of the State Civil Service who are proposed to be a superseded by the recommendations made in the list;
(iii) the reasons as recorded by the Committee for the proposed supersession of any member of the State Civil Service; and
(iv) the observations of the State Government on the recommendations of the Committee.
“7 Select List (1) The Commission shall consider the list prepared by the Committee along with the other documents received from the State Government and unless it considers any change necessary, approve the list,
(2) If the Commission considers it necessary to make any changes in the list received from the State Government, the Commission shall inform the State Government of the changes proposed and after taking into account the comments, if any, of the State Government, may approve the list finally with such modification, if any, as may, in its opinion, be just and proper.
(3) The list as finally approved by the Commission shall form the select list of the members of the State Civil Service.
(4) The Select List shall ordinarily be in force until its review and revision, affected under sub-regulation (4) of Regulation 5, is approved under sub-regulation (1) or, as the case may be finally approved under sub-regulation (2):
Provided that, in the event of any new Service or Services being formed by enlarging the existing State Civil Service or otherwise being approved by the Central Government as the State Civil Service under clause (i) of sub-regulation (1) of Regulation 2, the select list in force at the time of such approval shall continue to be in force until a new list prepared under Regulation 5 in respect of the members of the new State Civil Service, is approved under sub-regulation (1) or, as the case may be, finally approved under sub-regulation (2):
Provided further that in the event of a grave lapse in the conduct or preference of duties on the part of any member of the State Civil Service included in the select list, a special review of the Select List may be made at any time at the instance of the State Government and the Commission may, if it so thinks fit, remove the name of such members of the State Civil Service from the Select List.”
12. On behalf of the petitioners, it has been argued that the provisions of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations are mandatory. The State Government was duty bound to send to the Commission, alongwith select list prepared under Regulation 5, the records of the officers included in the lists, the records of the officers who are proposed to be superseded reasons as recorded by the Committee for the supersession of these officers and the observations of the State Government on the recommendation. It is stressed that the select list becomes final when the recommendations made by the Selection Committee are approved by the Commission. The Committee only makes recommendations for inclusion in the list. The Commission is not bound by these recommendations and can make any changes in the list. The list prepared by the Commission is final for all intents and purposes. The appointments, to the Indian Administrative Service can be made only from the list. The Commission cannot approve the list if the records of all the officers included in and excluded from the list as also the reasons for such exclusion along with the observations of the State Government are before the Commission. In the absence of any of these documents the Commission can not perform its duties properly and is bound to just rubber stamp the recommendations of the Committee and net result is that select list is prepared by the Committee and not by the Commission. The rule-making authority advisedly couched its intention in a peremptory and affirmative language as it used the word ‘shall’. There is a positive command to the State Government. It is duty bound to send the records heretofore mentioned to the Commission. There is no option with the State Government. The language of the Sub-Regulation is mandatory in the present case by not sending the requisite documents to the Commission, the Government had made it impossible for she Commission to apply its mind to the list prepared by the Committee. In the absence of the records the Commission could not form its independent judgment regarding the suitability of the Officers included in the list. It was deprived of having the advantage of the views of the State Government on the recommendations made by the committee. The Commission did not apply its mind to the list and has Proved it in a mechanical manner without referring to the records of the members of the service. The approval of the list by the Commission is thus vitiated by violation of the mandatory Provisions of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations.
13. It has to be seen whether the provisions of Regulation 6 of the promotion Regulations are mandatory or only directory. In Maxwell “the Interpretation of Statutes” 10th edition, at page 381, it is record:—
“On the other hand, where the prescriptions of a statute relate to the performance of a public duty and where the invalidation of acts done in neglect of them would work serious general inconvenience or injustice to persons who have no control over those entrusted with the duty without promoting the essential aims of the legislature, such prescriptions seems to be generally understood as mere instructions for the guidance and government of those on whom the duty is imposed, or, in other words, as directory only. The neglect of them may be penal, indeed, but it does not affect the validity of the act done in disregard of them”
14. Similarly in Craies on Statute Law, 5th edition, the following passage appears at page 242:—
“No Universal rule can be laid down as to whether mandatory enactments shall be considered directory only or obligatory with an implied nullification for disobedience. It is the duty of Courts of Justice to try to get at the real Intention of the legislature by carefully attending to the whole scope of the statute to be construed.”
15. The views of Crawford in his boob “on the construction of statutes” at page 516 are also helpful in his connection:—
“The question as to whether a statute is mandatory or directory depends upon the language in which the Intent is clothed. The meaning and intention of the legislature must given, and these are to be ascertained, not only from the phraseology of the provision, but also by considering its nature, its design, and the consequences which would follow from construing it the one way or the other…………”
16. In Dattatraya Moreshwar v. The State of Bombay, A.I.R 1952 S.C 181, it was held:—
“………it was settled that generally speaking the provisions of statute creating public duties are directory and those conferring private rights are Imperative. When the provisions of a statute relate to the performance of a public duty and the case is such that to hold null and void acts done in neglect of this duty would work serious general inconvenience or injustice to persons who have no control over those entrusted with the duty and at the same time would not promote the main object of the legislature. It has been the practice of the Courts to hold such provisions to be directory only the neglect of them not affecting the validity of the acts done……”
17. The same view was taken in Haridwar Singh v. Bagun Bumbrui, (1973) 3 SCC 889, which is in the following terms:—
“(iii) For determing the question whether a provision in a statute or a rule is mandatory or directory, no universal rule can be laid down. Is each case one must look to the subject-matter and consider the Importance of the provision disregarded and the relation of that provision to the general object intended to be secured.
Prohibitive or negative words can rarely be directory and are indicative of the intent that the provision is to be mandatory.
Where a prescription relates to performance of a public duty and to invalidate acts come in neglect of them would work merious general inconvenience of injustice to persons who have to control over chose entrusted with the duty, much prescription is generally understood as more instruction for the guidance of those upon whom the duty is imposed. Where, however, a power or authority is conferred with a direction that certain regulation or formality shall be complied with, it seems neither unjust nor incorrect to exact a rigorous observance of it as essential to the acquisition of the right or authority.”
18. In Jagan Nath v. Jaswant Singh & Others, A.I.R 1954 S.C 210 their Lordships have held that “a provision of sastututee is not mandatory unless non-compliance with it is made penal”. Again in State of Punjab v. Satya Pal Dena, A.I.R 1959 S.C 90, it was held:—
“The distinction between a mandatory provision of law and that which is merely directory is this that in a mandatory provision there is an implied prohibition to ??? the act in any other manner while in a directory provision, substantial compliance is considered sufficient. In those cases where a strict compliance is indicated to be condition precedent to the validity of the act itself, the neglect to perform it is fatal. But in cases where although a public duty is imposed and the manner of performance is also indicated in imperative language, the provision is usually regarded as merely directory when general injustice or inconvenience results to others and they have no control over those exercising the duty.”
19. Recently in The State of Punjab v. V. Sheolal Murari, (1976) 1 SCC 719, it was held:—
“Processual law is not to be tyrant but a servant, not an obstruction but an aid to justice. Procedural prescriptions are the handmaid and not the mistress, a lubricant, not a resistant in the administration of justice. Where the non-compliance, though procedural, will thawart fair bearing or prejudice doing of justice to parties, the rule is mandatory. But, grammer apart, If the breach can be corrected without injury to a just disposal of the case, the Court should not enterone a regulatory requirement into a dominant desideratum. After all, courts are to do justice, not to wreck this and product on technicalities. So even that it regarded as mandatory traditionally may, perhaps, have to be moderated into wholesome directions to be compiled with in time or in extended time”
20. In a Full Bench of this Court in Karam Singh Oswal v. The State of Punjab, 1975 (2) S.L.R 189 the majority held:—
“The provisions of a statute creating public duties are directory and those conferring private rights are Imperative. The use of the word “shall” in a statute, though generally taken in a mandatory sense, does not necessarily mean that in every case it shall have that effect, that is to say, that unless the words of the statute are punctiliously followed, the proceeding or the outcome of the proceeding, would be invalid. On the other hand, it is not always correct to say that where the word ‘may’ has been used, the statute is only permissible or directory in the sense that non-compliance with those provisions will not render the proceeding invalid. The distinction between a mandatory provision of law and that which is merely directory is this that in a mandatory provision there is an implied prohibition to do the act in any other manner while in a directory provision substantial compliance is considered sufficient. In those cases where strict compliance is Indicated to be a condition precedent to the validity of the act itself, the neglect to perform it is fatal. But in case where although a public duty is imposed and the manner of performance is also indicated in imperative language, the provision is usually regarded as merely directory when general Injustice of Inconvenience results, to others and they have no control over those exercising the duty”
21. In the light of, the principles enunciated in the above mentioned authorities, let us examine whether Regulation of the Promotion Regulations is mandatory or only directory. It is not touched in a prohibitive or negative language. No penalty is provided for non-compliance. It relates to the performance of a public duty. It does not confer private rights. The invalidation of the approval by the Commission would work serious inconvenience and injustice to the private respondents who had no control over the State Government and it will not promote the essential aim of the regulation. There cannot be spelt out any implied nullification for disobedience. It contains only a procedural provision.
22. From the above attributes of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations, it becomes crystal clear that the Promotion Regulation is only directory and it is not mandatory. As such, the non-compliance with Regulation 6 in letter and spirit will not vitiate and nullify the approval given by the Commission.
23. But it does not mean that directory statutory provisions are meant to be observed in their violation. The salient difference between mandatory and directory provisions is that the mandatory provisions have to be complied in letter and spirit whereas a substantial compliance in the case of directory provisions is regarded as sufficient.
24. It has been argued by the respondents that there has been a substantial compliance of the requirements of regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations. The service records of all the 69 eligible officers, including the petitioners and private respondents, were sent to the Commission on October 12, 1977 and remained there till December 12, 1977, when they were received back. They were produced before the Committee on 16th and 17th December, 1977. The file containing service record of Shri K.S Raju respondent was sent to the Commission along with the list. The comments of the State Government were also sent along. The fact regarding the expunction of the adverse remarks in the Annual Confidential Reports of Shri Raju by the then Chief Minister Giani Zail Singh was pointedly brought to the notice of the Commission along with the recommendations of the State Government that the inclusion of Shri Raju in the Select List may be reconsidered by the Commission.
25. Mr. Kuldip Singh, learned counsel for the Commission, has produced the relevant records of the Commission before us. The Annual Confidential Reports of all the eligible officers are complied. These compilations are revised every year and brought up to date by the Commission. These compilations are faithful records on the basis of confidential records, of the officers concerned. We checked these compilations and tallied them with service records of a few of the petitioners and private respondents. We did not find any discrepancy. We showed these records to the learned counsel for the petitioners to satisfy themselves that nothing favourable to the petitioners and adverse to the private respondents had not been omitted therefrom.
26. The learned counsel for the petitioners next argued that these records were taken into account by the Commission while approving the Select List. The Commission also took into account the comments of the State Government on the Select List. The main thrust of the petitioners was against the inclusion of Shri K.S Raju in the list. But as noticed earlier, all the records pertaining to his case were with the Commission. So it cannot be said that the records of the concerned officers were not before the Commission. The Commission had applied its mind and then approved the list. The list was sent to the Commission. The records had earlier been sent, of all the officers, to the Commission. They had been perused and in fact necessary extracts from them had been taken down by the office of the Commission, and the Commission had a detailed and exhaustive compilation of the service records of all the officers. The records of Shri K.S Raju and the comments of the State Government thereon were also with the Commission. Moreover, it was always open to the Commission to send for any records from the State Government which they deemed necessary before approving the list. The Commission did not deem that necessary. In fact, the petitioners mainly made a grievance that the record of Mr. K.S Raju was unsatisfactory. That record, as noticed, earlier, was before the Commission along with the comments of the State Government. The Commission after taking into account all these facts approved the list. The Commission fully applied its mind to the list and the relevant materials and then approved the list. So a substantial compliance of Regulation 6 of the Promotion Regulations had been made. Hence there is no merit in the contention of the learned counsel that there has been non-compliance of Regulation ??? of the Promotion Regulations and that the whole proceedings of the Commission are violated.
27. It has been then argued that the decision of the Committee in selecting the private respondents is wholly arbitrary. No reason whatsoever has been given why the names of private respondents have been included in the list and why the petitioners and other officers have been excluded. There is no merit in this contention of the learned counsel. Sub-Regulations (4) and (5) have been substantially changed. Earlier to the amendment of June 3, 1977, very wide powers were with the Selection Committee because they had to include a person in the select list on the basis of merit and suitability in all respects. However, now the rule making authority has curtailed the discretion of the Committee to a great extent. It has given very clear-cut and precise guidelines for the selection. Sub-Regulation (4) of Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations provides that the Selection Committee has to classify the eligible officers as “outstanding” “Very good” “good” or “unfit” on the over fall assessment of their service records. Now it may be pertinent to point out that the Selection Committee consists of very senior officers of the State Government. The Chairman or a member of the Union Public Service Commission presides over the meetings. These officers are experts in the act of governance and administration. The words ‘outstanding’, ‘very good’, ‘good’ or ‘unfit’ in the context of service records have very clear connotations. They are illuminating guidelines. So the Committee has assessed the relative records of the concerned officers, including the petitioners end private respondents and then categorised them. We have been provided with the minutes of the meeting of the Selection Committee. All the 69 eligible officers, including the petitioners and private respondents, were categorised, Out of these the private respondents were put in the category of ‘very good’. The petitioners and other seven officers were considered only ‘good’. As such, those officers who were found to be ‘very good’ were selected in comparison to the officers who were only ‘good’. The classification has been done on the basis of the service records and with a view to select the most meritorious officers. It is vehemently contended that the committee has not given any reasons. The service records speak for themselves. The Lordships of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Mohan Lal Capoor, 1973 (2) S.L.R 824 have in clear terms held i—
“Just as the answer given by candidates at a written test reveal respective merits so also the service records, during the preparation of lists by selection, speaks for these whose records are examined. The process of selection by evaluation of respective records of service is more akin to that as an: examination of candidates than to any quasi-judicial proceeding.”
28. The Commitee has only compiled these service reports and then classified these officers. We have seen from the records that the officers who had received larger number of ‘very good’ reports have been classified as ‘very good’ and the officers who had not reached ‘very good’ reports or had received lesser number of ‘very good’ reports then the reports received by the selected officers were classified is ‘good’. As observed by their Lordships, the records spoke for those officers whose records were examined and the Committee only recorded these voices. The categories themselves are self-eloquent. No further reasons are required. The categories truly reflect the service records of the officers considered. The reasons for the conclusions reached on the basis of certain facts only show the application of the mind and the process of reasoning. There is no magic in the word ‘reasons’ as such. The Promotion Regulations have given precise and clear cut guidelines for categorising the officers on the basis of their service record. The petitioners have not made any specific grievance against the categorisation by the Committee. The rule making authority has by the amendment of June 3, 1977, omitted Sub-Regulation 7 of Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations. This Sub-Regulation provided for the recording of reasons for the supersession of officers. This has been done because the wide discretion which was conferred on the Selection Committee had been taken away by the amended Regulation, and clear guidelines were provided. Only officers with better record could be included in the select list. There cannot be any arbitrary, whimsical and capricious selection now in view of the amended Sub Regulations (4) and (5) of Regulation 5 of the Promotion Regulations. The conclusion which culminated in the categorisation are themselves replete with the reasons. Mr. J.L Gupta, the learned counsel for the petitioner, invited our attention to a passage in Mohan Lal's case (supra) which reads as follows:—
“In the context of the effect upon the right of aggrieved persons as members of a public service who are entitled to just and reasonable treatment, by reason of protections conferred upon them by Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, which are available to them throughout their service, it is incumbent on the Selection Committee to have stated reasons in a manner which would disclose how the record of each officer superseded stood in relation to records of others who were to be preferred, particularly as this is practically the only remaining visible safeguard against possible in justice and arbitrariness in making selections. If that had been done, facts on service records of officers considered by the Selection Committee would have been collated to the conclusions reached. Reasons are the links between the material on which certain conclusions are based and the actual conclusions. They disclose how the mind is applied to the subject matter for a decision whether it is purely administrative or quasi-judicial. They should reveal a rational nexus between the facts considered and the conclusions reached. Only in this way can opinions or decisions recorded be shown to manifestly just and reasonable. We think that it is not enough to say that preference should be given because certain kind of process was gone through by the Selection Committee. This is all that the supposed statement of reasons amount to, we therefore, think that the mandatory provisions of Regulation 5(5) were not complied with. We think that reliance was rightly placed by respondents on two decisions of this court relating to the fact of non-compliance with such mandatory provisions. These were: Associated Electrical Industries ??? Pvt. Lid. Calcutta v. Its Workmen, A.I.R 1967 S.C 284 and the Collector of Manghyr v. Keshav Prasad Goenka, (1963) (1) S.C.R 98).
29. Their Lordships were dealing with the unamended Regulation. At that time, requirement of recording reasons was there in the form of Sub-Regulation (7) of Regulation S. of the Promotion Regulations. That has specifically been deleted by the rule making authority. This is an indication of its mind. The classification, as observed earlier, into the ‘outstanding’, ‘very good’ ‘good’ and ‘unfit’ is clearly indicative of the process of reasoning. So Monan Lal's case (supra) is not any way helpful to the petitioners.
30. It was argued that the service record of Mr. K.S Raju, respondent No. 5 was such that he could not be selected by any Commitee and that the adverse reports given to Mr. Raju had been illegally expunged by the State Government. There is no merit in these contentions also. The adverse report given to Mr. Raju were expunged by the orders of the Chief Minister. Simply because these orders of the Chief Minister were not in accordance with the instructions dated March 24, 1960 the orders cannot be said to be illegal. These instructions are only meant for the guidance of the authorities concerned. They do not have and statutory force and their violation or non-compliance does not render the decision illegal. When these adverse remarks had been expunged, then there was no blemish on his service record. We have carefully gone through the record of Mr. Raju and find that this is better then the record of any of the petitioners. Moreover, it was for the Selection Committee to evaluate the service records. We are not sitting in appeal over the decisions of the Selection Committee. The decision has been taken fairly and in accordance with the principles of fair play. It is not open to challenge on merits in these proceedings.
31. The mere fact that certain enquiries were pending against respondents Randhir Singh and Gulwant Singh, was not sufficient to exclude their names from the Select List. The mere accusation against an officer is not sufficient to exclude him from the promotion list. After all they had not been held guilty. If they had been excluded, they would have been punished, without their being any enquiry, Moreover, their names were included subject to the result of the enquiry. The petitioners have not been otherwise also to point out any blemish in the records of these two officers. Before us the constitutionality on the validity of the Rules has not been challenged. No arguments have been addressed on this aspect of the case. For the reasons recorded above, there is no merit in these writ petitions and the same are dismissed, but there shall be no order as to costa.
Prem Chand Jain, J.:— I agree.
32. Petitions dismissed.
Alert