- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Krishan Kumar v. Dharam Paul
M. JEYAPAUL, J. (Oral)
1. The defendant has preferred the present appeal aggrieved by the concurrent verdict of the Courts below granting permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff.
2. It is contended by the plaintiff that Muni Lal, father of the plaintiff and the defendant, purchased a vacant plot and put up residential house over there. The house has two gates. Both the parties are using the same separately for entering into their respective portions. The defendant enters to his portion through gate No. 1, whereas the plaintiff enters through gate No. 2. The defendant had started demolishing a window in his portion with an intention to carve out a door to make an opening in the portion of the plaintiff.
3. The defendant in his written statement contended that the parties are not in exclusive possession of the house property constructed by Muni Lal. The house in question is still joint. There was no proper partition of the same. The defendant contends that the plaintiff is not entitled to any injunction as against the co-sharer.
4. Both the Courts below have come to a conclusion that the plaintiff and the defendant who are the sons of Muni Lal have been in possession and enjoyment of the respective portion of the house constructed by their father Muni Lal and therefore, the defendant cannot interfere with the portion which is in the exclusive possession of the plaintiff.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant would contend that there was no mutual arrangement between the parties to live in the separate exclusive portion of the house constructed by their father Muni Lal. It is his submission that the Courts below failed to appreciate the point of law that a co-sharer cannot seek for an order of injunction as against the other co-sharer.
6. Learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff/respondent would submit that the very fact that the plaintiff and the defendant have been residing in the exclusive portions in the house constructed by their father with two gates would go to show that they have been in exclusive possession under the mutual agreement. Therefore, the defendant cannot demolish the window in his portion to have access to the portion in exclusive possession of the plaintiff.
7. It is a well settled position of law that a co-sharer cannot seek an order of injunction as against the other co-sharer. But if a co-sharer is in exclusive possession of a portion of the property and the other co-sharer also is in exclusive possession of the other portion, one co-sharer cannot interfere with the possession of the other co-sharer.
8. In the instant case, DW1 has admitted that the heirs of Muni Lal including the plaintiff and defendant have been in exclusive possession of the respective portion of the house. They have two entrances to have access to their portion in their exclusive possession.
9. It has been demonstrated by the plaintiff that carving a door by demolishing the window in the portion of the defendant would pave way for entering into the exclusive portion in occupation of the plaintiff.
10. The manner in which the legal heirs of Muni Lal have been in exclusive occupation of the respective portions would go to demonstrate that by mutual arrangement the legal heirs of Muni Lal have been in exclusive possession of the respective portions of the house constructed by Muni Lal.
11. It is very much pertinent to refer to the decision of this Court that in Karam Singh v. Lakhbir Kaur, 2011 (2) PLR 698, wherein it has been held as follows:-
“12. The relief of injunction can be sought by a co-sharer against other co-sharers when such a co-sharer happens to be in exclusive possession of the land to the exclusion of other co-sharers, but when the possession of all the co-sharers is joint, relief of injunction cannot be sought by either of the co-sharers and the only relief which is available to the co-sharer is to seek partition by metes and bounds.”
12. Applying the above ratio, I hold that a co-sharer is entitled to seek for an injunction against the other co-sharer when exclusive possession of respective portions by co-sharers has been demonstrated.
13. Learned counsel appearing for the defendant/appellant cited very many decisions to support his view that a co-sharer cannot claim an order of injunction as against the other co-sharer. There is no quarrel with such a proposition at all.
14. In view of the above, I find that there is no merit in the appeal and therefore, it stands dismissed.
Alert