- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
People'S Union For Civil Liberties (Pds Matters) v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The present order is an interlocutory direction issued in long-running public interest litigation concerning the effectiveness of the Public Distribution System (PDS) and the identification of families living Below the Poverty Line (BPL). The case has been pending for several years, during which Justice D.P. Wadhwa (retired) has submitted eighteen reports documenting pervasive “pilferage and corruption” at every stage of PDS operations. Earlier initiatives include pilot projects for computerisation of the Targeted Public Distribution System (TPDS) in selected States and Union Territories, and an Integrated Information System for Foodgrains Management (IISFM) developed by the National Informatics Centre for the Food Corporation of India. Dissatisfied with the slow progress of these programmes, the Court now issues further directions and schedules the matter for continued monitoring.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Union of India and concerned States can be directed to expedite full computerisation of the Public Distribution System and create an effective monitoring mechanism.
- Whether the Planning Commission’s cap on the number of BPL families, fixed on 1-3-2000, is rational and legally sustainable when State-specific surveys show larger numbers of eligible families.
- Whether the existing monetary thresholds for determining BPL status (Rs 12 per day in rural areas and Rs 20 per day in urban areas) are outdated and require revision.
- What urgent measures are necessary to investigate and prevent alleged starvation deaths in Dantewada District, Chhattisgarh.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners’ Arguments (Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Senior Advocate)
- The Central Government’s cap of 106.79 lakh BPL families in Uttar Pradesh—and similar caps elsewhere—has prevented distribution of ration cards to all eligible families, despite States’ adherence to Union-prescribed parameters.
- The poverty-line thresholds of Rs 12 (rural) and Rs 20 (urban) per day are “unrealistic” in 2011 and exclude a large segment of needy population from PDS benefits.
- National Family Health Survey-3 data show alarming levels of anaemia, malnutrition and low Body Mass Index among children, women and men, necessitating immediate enhancement of food security schemes.
- The 2010 Global Hunger Index ranks India 67th, below countries such as Sudan and Cambodia, further underscoring systemic deficiencies.
- Media reports of six alleged starvation deaths in Dantewada District demand prompt judicial attention and field verification.
Union of India’s Submissions (Mr. Mohan Parasaran, Additional Solicitor General)
- An affidavit dated 28-3-2011 outlines ongoing pilot projects for computerisation and smart-card delivery of TPDS commodities in selected States and Union Territories.
- The Government proposes an Integrated Information System for Foodgrains Management (IISFM) to place real-time data on the FCI’s foodgrain stocks online.
- The Additional Solicitor General seeks time to obtain instructions on: (a) constitution of a High-Powered Committee to fast-track computerisation, and (b) the rationale behind the Planning Commission’s cap on BPL numbers.
State of Chhattisgarh’s Submission
- State counsel undertakes that the Collector or Deputy Collector, along with a representative of the petitioner-organisation, will visit the affected villages in Dantewada and file a report before the next hearing.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court notes with concern that “no real progress is made” in computerising the PDS despite prior approvals and pilot schemes. Citing the severity of pilferage identified in Justice Wadhwa’s reports, the Bench deems computerisation “absolutely imperative” and calls for a High-Powered Committee—including petitioners, relevant organisations and State representatives—to oversee and accelerate the process.
Regarding BPL identification, the Court states it “fails to comprehend the rationale and justification” for the Planning Commission’s cap once eligibility parameters are fixed. It signals that all persons meeting those parameters should receive benefits and directs the Union of India to explain the cap’s basis at the next hearing.
On nutritional indicators and alleged starvation deaths, the Court treats the data and media reports as credible and orders immediate fact-finding, reflecting its broader concern with the constitutional imperative to ensure food security and prevent hunger.
Holding and Implications
INTERLOCUTORY DIRECTIONS ISSUED
Key directions include: (i) the Union of India to consider constituting a High-Powered Committee for PDS computerisation and report back on 4-4-2011; (ii) clarification from the Planning Commission on the BPL cap; (iii) State authorities to investigate alleged starvation deaths in Dantewada; and (iv) extension of Justice Wadhwa’s term as Court Commissioner by six months. The matter is listed for further hearing on 4-4-2011 at 2:00 p.m. Because this is an interim order, no new legal precedent is set, but the directions intensify judicial oversight and signal potential future mandates on PDS reform and poverty-line criteria.
Order
1. Mr Mohan Parasaran, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India has filed an affidavit of the Joint Secretary, Government of India on 28-3-2011. In the said affidavit it is mentioned that a pilot scheme on computerisation of Targeted Public Distribution System (TPDS) had been approved in August 2009 to be implemented in three districts in each of the four pilot States i.e Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Chhattisgarh and Delhi. A pilot scheme on smart card based delivery of TPDS commodities had also been approved for the Union Territory of Chandigarh and State of Haryana.
2. Integrated Information System for Foodgrains Management (Iisfm) is an application developed by the National Informatics Centre (NIC) for Food Corporation of India (FCI). The project aims at putting an online management system in place to give information about foodgrains management in FCI.
3. Justice D.P Wadhwa (since retired) has submitted about 18 reports. In each of the report it is categorically stated that there is pilferage and corruption in each and every stage of the Public Distribution System (for short “PDS”) and according to him the situation can be salvaged to a large extent by computerisation.
4. This matter is pending for several years but no real progress is made in computerisation programme. It is absolutely imperative that computerisation be put in place as expeditiously as possible. Looking to the grave urgency of the matter, we requested the learned Additional Solicitor General to take appropriate steps to have a High Powered Committee which can take assistance of the petitioners and other organisations concerned to ensure that computerisation of PDS is carried out as expeditiously as possible. The Committee must monitor the programme of computerisation on regular basis. They may take into consideration the computerisation programme already carried out by some of the States. The representatives of the States may also be associated with the programme of computerisation.
5. Mr Parasaran assured this Court that he would take up the matter at the highest level and would revert to this Court with proper instructions on next Monday i.e on 4-4-2011.
6. The other main question which has been canvassed today was about the statistics of the BPL population given by the Union of India which are in clear conflict with the figures of BPL population in their respective States.
7. Mr Gonsalves submits that even in those States which meticulously followed the parameters laid down by the Union of India, the actual population of BPL is much larger than what has been indicated by the Central Government. He has particularly drawn our attention to the affidavit filed by the Special Secretary, Food and Civil Supply Department, State of U.P In the said affidavit it is mentioned that as per the Central Government estimate made on 1-3-2000, the number of BPL families (inclusive of AAY families) in the State of Uttar Pradesh was 106.79 lakhs. As stated, the Government of India has fixed limit of 106.79 lakhs of BPL families on the basis of ration cards issued to 106.79 lakhs BPL families. Although the number of BPL families in U.P is much more than 106.79 lakhs, but due to the rider imposed by the Central Government, the BPL ration cards could not be distributed to all eligible members of BPL families. Almost all other States have endorsed the same thing.
8. We fail to comprehend the rationale and justification of putting a cap by the Planning Commission. Once the parameters have been crystallised by the Central Government and according to those parameters, the actual population of BPL should be entitled to get the benefit of the BPL schemes.
9. Mr Parasaran submitted that he would take instructions from the Planning Commission about the rationality and justification of putting a cap and make his submissions on the next date of hearing.
10. Mr Gonsalves, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that those who are earning/spending more than Rs 12 in rural areas and Rs 20 in urban areas are outside the purview of BPL. In 2011 these unrealistic limits need to be redrawn. He submitted that a large BPL population is deprived of the benefit of the entire PDS programme.
11. Mr Gonsalves has also drawn our attention to the key indicators for India from the National Family Health Survey 3. This survey has been conducted by an organisation of the Government of India which indicates that among children in the age group of 6 to 35 months, 78.9% are anaemic. Even married women between 15-49 years, among them 56.2% are anaemic and pregnant women among age group 15-49 years, 57.9% are anaemic. He has also drawn our attention to the figure pertaining to the children. Children under 3 years who are stunted are 44.9%, children under 3 years who are wasted 22.9% and children under 3 years who are underweight 40.4%. Women whose body mass index is below normal is 33.0% and the men whose body mass index below normal is 28.1%. There is no reason to disbelieve the authenticity of the survey conducted by the Government of India. All efforts must be made to combat this problem as expeditiously as possible.
12. Mr Parasaran submits that he would take proper instructions and submit on the next date of hearing.
13. Mr Gonsalves has also drawn our attention to the 2010 Global Hunger Index published from the International Food Policy Research Institute. According to the Global Hunger Index Scores India ranked 67, even after countries like Sudan, Zimbabwe, Togo and Cambodia. Similarly, comparison of hunger across the States gives a very dismal picture of India as a whole and the State of Madhya Pradesh in particular.
14. Mr Parasaran submits that he would take proper instructions and make his submissions on the next date of hearing.
15. Mr Gonsalves has also drawn our attention to the media report of six alleged starvation deaths which had occurred in three villages of Dantewada District of the State of Chhattisgarh.
16. The learned counsel appearing for the State submits that the Collector or the Deputy Collector, along with the Commissioner of the petitioner organisation, will visit the place and submit a report to this Court before the next date of hearing.
17. On the request of the parties, the term of Justice Wadhwa (since retired) is extended by another six months.
18. List this matter for further hearing on 4-4-2011 at 2.00 p.m
Court Masters
Alert