- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
On 6 May 2016 the Supreme Court of India directed that a floor test be held in the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly to ascertain whether the first respondent enjoyed the confidence of the House. The order tasked the “Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand” with supervising and recording the vote. When the matter was mentioned again on 9 May 2016, the learned Attorney General informed the Court that no such post existed; instead, the Secretariat contains a “Secretary, Legislative Assembly” and a separate “Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs.” Because the Court’s intent was to appoint a neutral official, the discrepancy prompted an application for clarification/modification of the earlier order. The present opinion resolves that application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Supreme Court’s order dated 6 May 2016 should be modified to substitute an appropriate neutral officer for supervising the impending floor test in the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners / Union of India
- Pointed out that the designated post (“Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly”) does not exist; the correct posts are “Secretary, Legislative Assembly” and “Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs.”
- Emphasised the Court’s desire for a neutral officer, noting that the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs belongs to the District Judge cadre and would satisfy the neutrality requirement.
- Sought modification of the earlier order to reflect this change.
First Respondent
- Opposed the presence of any “outsider” in the House, arguing that only the Secretary, Legislative Assembly—appointed under the Uttarakhand Vidhan Sabha Secretariat Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2011—has a right of entry.
- Contended that the directions already given (including video recording) were sufficient to ensure a fair vote, making an external observer unnecessary and constitutionally impermissible.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India, (1999) 9 SCC 95 | The Supreme Court’s power to innovate procedures (e.g., ordering a composite floor test) to preserve constitutional governance. | Cited to justify judicial innovation in directing and structuring a floor test when political processes are disputed. |
| Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India, (2005) 3 SCC 150 | Example of the Court declining to appoint an observer but requiring video recording of Assembly proceedings. | Referenced as comparable precedent; the Court borrowed its language on video recording while fashioning present directions. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court acknowledged that its earlier assumption—that the Principal Secretary of the Legislative Assembly was a Higher Judicial Service officer—was incorrect. The resulting ambiguity, if unaddressed, could undermine confidence in the impending floor test. Drawing on its constitutional duty as the “sentinel on the qui vive,” the Court reasoned that democratic legitimacy demands absolute objectivity in the voting process. Because one side did not trust the other, an independent presence was essential.
Invoking Jagdambika Pal, the Bench observed that it may craft innovative procedural safeguards to uphold constitutional norms. It similarly referred to Anil Kumar Jha to emphasise transparency through video recording. Balancing the rival submissions, the Court concluded that neutrality would be secured by having both:
- The Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs (a District Judge–cadre officer) and
- The Secretary, Legislative Assembly
jointly supervise and record the vote. This arrangement, the Court held, would eliminate any apprehension of partisan interference while respecting the Assembly’s internal procedures.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The order dated 6 May 2016 is modified. The Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand, shall be present inside the House to oversee the floor test on 10 May 2016 alongside the Secretary, Legislative Assembly. Copies of the modified order are to be served on all concerned officers immediately.
Implications: The decision ensures that the forthcoming floor test proceeds under neutral supervision, thereby strengthening the credibility of the result and safeguarding democratic principles in Uttarakhand. The ruling is confined to the procedural conduct of this specific floor test and does not establish a broad new precedent beyond reaffirming the Court’s power to devise safeguards in exceptional constitutional situations.
1.-5. See at (2016) 16 SCC 748(1) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
6.-8. See at (2016) 16 SCC 748(2) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1850. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
9.-11. See at (2016) 16 SCC 749(1) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1851. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
12.-22. See at (2016) 16 SCC 749(2) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 442. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
23. On being mentioned, the matter is taken on board. On 6-5-2016, this Court, after taking note of the order passed on 22-4-2016, had passed an order to which both the parties had agreed. It was also conceded that the floor test should be conducted under the supervision of this Court. Ordinarily, there should not have been any difficulty or occasion to mention. However, submits Mr Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for India, that in paras 9 and 10 of the order, this Court had stated about the role of the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand. To have a complete picture, we think it appropriate to reproduce paras 16.9 and 16.10 of the previous order. They read as follows:
“16.9. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall see to it that the voting is appositely done and recorded.
16.10. The Members voting in favour of the motion shall singularly vote by raising their hands one by one and that will be counted by the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly. Similar procedure shall be adopted while the Members voting against the motion.”
24. It is urged by Mr Rohatgi that a communication was sent to the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand and a reply has been received from the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand on 7-5-2016 indicating, inter alia, that there is no post of Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand but there is a post which is called Secretary, Legislative Assembly and there is another post called the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand. The learned Attorney General would submit that this Court desired to have a neutral personality to remain present at the time of voting and an impression was given that the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, is from the cadre of Higher Judicial Service of the State and, therefore, a necessity has arisen for modification of the order.
25. Mr Harish Salve, learned Senior Counsel, supporting the argument of Mr Rohatgi, would contend that in a situation like this, there has to be an arrangement by this Court so that voting takes place in the manner the Court has intended. He has pointed out certain aspects of the order to highlight that when situations like this emerge, different steps have been taken by this Court and this is one of such instance.
26. Dr A.M. Singhvi, Mr Kapil Sibal and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent, have seriously opposed the prayer on the ground that there cannot be an outsider, namely, the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand, inside the House. Emphasising his plea on the Rules made to guide the functioning of the House, it is urged that the Secretary, Legislative Assembly is appointed by the Speaker who has been authorised under the Uttarakhand Vidhan Sabha Secretariat Service (Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2011 which have been framed under clause (3) of Article 187 of the Constitution of India. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent would contend that the persons who are outsiders will not be apt and it should be done by the Secretary, Legislative Assembly, who has a right to enter inside the House. It is also canvassed that the petitioners should not have any apprehension as the Court has directed the manner in which the voting shall take place, and also for video recording.
27. First of all, it is obligatory on our part to recapitulate what transpired in Court on 6-5-2016. We think it necessary to do so. In course of hearing on that day, it was debated upon with regard to the status of the Principal Secretary of the Legislative Assembly and we were apprised that he is a member of the Higher Judicial Services of the State of Uttarakhand. Today, it has been told to us that he is not so. The present situation, if we allow ourselves to say so, is a piquant one. The Court ordinarily would not have directed for having a Session and direct Respondent 1 to prove the majority in the floor test.
28. Be it noted, in Jagdambika Pal v. Union of India (1999) 9 SCC 95, the Court was under the constitutional obligation to innovate the method and accordingly, the following order was passed:
“1. (i) A special session of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly be summoned/convened for 26-2-1998, the session commencing forenoon.
(ii) The only agenda in the Assembly would be to have a composite floor test between the contending parties in order to see which out of the two contesting claimants of Chief Ministership has a majority in the House.
(iii) It is pertinently emphasised that the proceedings in the Assembly shall be totally peaceful and disturbance, if any, caused therein would be viewed seriously.
(iv) The result of the composite floor test would be announced by the Speaker faithfully and truthfully.
2. The result is expected to be laid before us on 27-2-1998 at 10.30 a.m. when this Bench assembles again.”
29. In Anil Kumar Jha v. Union of India (2005) 3 SCC 150, the language of which we had borrowed to some extent in the last order, the Court in para 6 had stated thus:
“6. We are not inclined to appoint any observer for the proceedings on the Assembly to be held on 11-3-2005. However, we desire and accordingly request the pro tem Speaker of the Legislative Assembly to have the proceedings of the State Legislative Assembly as held on 11-3-2005 to be video recorded and send a copy of the video recording to this Court forthwith.”
30. It is contended before us by the learned Senior Counsel for the first respondent with immense vigour that there should not be an observer as that would not be constitutionally permissible. The purpose is to save the sanctity of democracy which is the basic feature of our Constitution. This Court, being the sentinel on the qui vive of the Constitution is under the obligation to see that the democracy prevails and not gets hollowed by individuals. The directions which have been given on the last occasion, were singularly for the purpose of strengthening the democratic values and the constitutional norms. The collective trust in the legislature is founded on the bedrock of the constitutional trust. This is a case where one side even in the floor test does not trust the other and the other claims that there is no reason not to have the trust. Hence, there is the need and there is the necessity to have a neutral perceptionist to see that absolute objectivity is maintained when the voting takes place. Solely for the aforesaid purpose, we intend to modify the order by directing that the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs who belongs to the cadre of the District Judge shall remain present to conduct the affairs with perceptible objectivity and singularity of purpose of neutrality along with the Secretary, Legislative Assembly. The order is modified accordingly. We ingeminate it that we have so directed so that no party can raise a cavil with regard to the process of voting.
31. A copy of the order be sent to the Principal Secretary, Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs, State of Uttarakhand, Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand and the Chief Secretary of the State of Uttarakhand by the Registry in course of the day. The learned counsel for the parties are requested to apprise the said authorities about the order passed today. The voting shall take place on 10-5-2016 as directed on the earlier occasion. Let the matter be listed as scheduled.
32.-37. See at (2016) 16 SCC 755 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 488. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
38.-49. See at (2016) 16 SCC 757 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1852. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
50. See at (2016) 16 SCC 758 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1853. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
Alert