- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. K.V Wall Mount Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Petitioners v. State Bank Of India
Summary of Legal Opinion — SURESH KAIT, J. (ORAL)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed the instant petition seeking directions to quash letter No. SME/GKB/518 dated 03.12.2013 and to restrain publication of the petitioner's photographs in the newspaper. A similar issue had earlier been before the High Court of Bombay in W.P(L) No. 2808/2013, which was decided by the Division Bench by an order dated 28.11.2013. The Bombay High Court's order discussed the scope of Rule 8 and whether publication of photographs by the bank was ultravires. The petitioner in that matter challenged the Bombay High Court order before the Supreme Court in SLP No. 37726/13, which was dismissed by order dated 14.07.2014. The present court observed that, in view of those earlier decisions having attained finality, the present petition had no merit and was dismissed. An ancillary application (C.M. No. 17300/2013) was held to be infructuous and dismissed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether letter No. SME/GKB/518 dated 03.12.2013 should be quashed and publication of the petitioner's photographs restrained.
- Whether a bank, under Rule 8 (as referenced in the Bombay High Court order), is authorised to publish names and addresses of wilful defaulters and whether publication of photographs is barred or constitutes ultravires.
- Whether the issue raised in the instant petition remains open for adjudication after the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court decision in W.P(L) No. 2808/2013 and the dismissal of SLP No. 37726/13.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| W.P(L) No. 2808/2013 (Division Bench of High Court of Bombay; order dated 28.11.2013) | The Division Bench applied the principle that actions fairly incidental to or consequential upon things the legislature has authorised should not be held ultravires; it noted Rule 8 specifically authorised the bank to publish the names and addresses of wilful defaulters and observed no express prohibition on publishing photographs. | The present court treated the Bombay High Court's decision as determinative of the same issue, relying on its reasoning that publication of photographs could not be held ultravires and that the petition challenging such publication could not be sustained. |
| Apex Court | Quoted principle: "whatever has to be done fairly and is also regarded as incidental to or consequential upon those things which the legislature has authorised to do ought not to be held by judicial construction to be ultravires." | The Bombay High Court invoked this Apex Court principle to conclude that the bank's action in publishing photographs was not ultravires; the present court recognized that reasoning in dismissing the petition. |
| SLP No. 37726/13 (order dated 14.07.2014) | Procedural outcome: the special leave petition challenging the Bombay High Court order was dismissed by the Supreme Court. | The present court treated the dismissal of the SLP as causing the issue to attain finality, which formed the basis for dismissing the instant petition as having no merit. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a succinct, stepwise manner:
- Identified the relief sought by the petitioner: quashing of letter No. SME/GKB/518 dated 03.12.2013 and restraint on publication of photographs.
- Noted the existence of a directly analogous decision by the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in W.P(L) No. 2808/2013 (order dated 28.11.2013), which had applied an Apex Court principle concerning actions incidental to legislatively authorised powers and had held that Rule 8 authorised publication of names and addresses and that there was no express bar to publishing photographs, concluding such publication was not ultravires.
- Observed that the Bombay High Court decision was challenged in SLP No. 37726/13, which was dismissed on 14.07.2014, thereby rendering the issue final.
- Concluded that because the same question had already been authoritatively resolved and attained finality, the present petition lacked merit and warranted dismissal.
- Addressed the connected miscellaneous application (C.M. No. 17300/2013) by declaring it infructuous once the main petition was dismissed and dismissed it accordingly.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED
Holding: The petition seeking quashing of letter No. SME/GKB/518 dated 03.12.2013 and restraining publication of the petitioner's photographs is dismissed as having no merit.
Implications: The direct consequence is that the petitioner did not obtain the relief sought; the earlier Division Bench decision of the Bombay High Court and the dismissal of the subsequent SLP were treated as having finally resolved the issue. The connected miscellaneous application (C.M. No. 17300/2013) was dismissed as infructuous. The opinion does not announce or discuss any new legal precedent beyond applying the prior decisions and their finality.
SURESH KAIT, J (ORAL)
1. Vide the instant petition, the petitioner seeks directions thereby quashing the letter No. SME/GKB/518 dated 03.12.2013 and further restraining from publication of petitioner's photographs in the newspaper.
2. The similar issue came before the High Court of Bombay in W.P(L) No. 2808/2013 and same was decided by order dated 28.11.2013 by Division Bench of High Court of Bombay as under:
“The Apex Court has therefore clearly held that whatever has to be done fairly and is also regarded as incidental to or consequential upon those things which the legislature has authorised to do ought not to be held by judicial construction to be ultravires. In the present case Rule 8 specifically authorised the bank to publish the names and addresses of the wilful defaulters. There is no legal bar either in the said rule or under any provision of the Act which expressly prohibits the bank from publication of photographs and therefore the action of the bank in publishing the photographs cannot be held to be ultravires. Ratio of the judgment in our view squarely applies to the facts of the present case. In the result, it is not possible to accept submissions of learned counsel appearing on behalf of the bank, the petition therefore is dismissed. At this stage, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners states that the statement made by the bank not to publish the photographs may be extended for a period of four weeks from today. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the banks submits that the said statement is extended for a period of one week. In our view it would be appropriate if this statement made by the bank is extended for a period of three weeks.”
3. Being aggrieved, the petitioner (therein) challenged the order passed by Bombay High Court in SLP No. 37726/13, the same has been dismissed vide order dated 14.07.2014 Thus the issue raised in the instant petition has attained finality.
4. In view of the above, the present petition has no merit; accordingly the same is hereby dismissed.
C.M No. 17300/2013
With the dismissal of the present petition, instant application has become infructuous and dismissed as such.
Alert