- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Haryana () v. Mohan Singh ().
Pritpal Singh, J.:β Mohan Singh respondent was employed as a Conductor in the Haryana Roadways, Chandigarh. His services were terminated on the ground that he had misappropriated a sum of Rs. 2.40 paise. A departmental enquiry was held against him and it was held by the Inquiry Officer that although Mohan Singh had collected Rs. 2.40 paise as fare from six passengers but he had not issued tickets to them. Mohan Singh challenged the termination of his services by filing a suit which was decreed on 14th November, 1975, by the Senior Subordinate Judge, Chandigarh. It was declared that the order of termination was illegal and that as such Mohan Singh continued to be in service of the Haryana Government. The appeal against this judgment and decree filed by the State of Haryana was dismissed by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, on 28th of May 1976. Against the judgment of the Additional District Judge, the State of Haryana has come up in second appeal before this Court.
2. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and in my view there is no scope for interference in the concurrent findings of the Courts below.
3. The appellant's case is that on 21st of March, 1973, Madan Lal Chief Inspector had checked the bus on Chandigarh-Morni route and had found that the respondent-Conductor had received Rs. 2.40 as fare from six passengers but had failed to issue tickets to them. A complaint in this respect was filed by Madan Lal upon which a departmental enquiry was held against the respondent. In the enquiry proceedings Madan Lal, Chief Inspector, had appeared and reiterated the aforesaid allegations against the respondent. Placing reliance on the statement of Madan Lal, the Inquiry Officer had come to the conclusion that the respondent had misappropriated the sum of Rs. 2.40 Pursuant to the enquiry report services of the respondent was terminated.
4. The only point for determination in this case is whether the impugned order of termination should be held lawful on the solitary statement of Madan Lal, Chief Inspector. The learned first appellate Court answered this query in the negative on the strength of a judgment of this Court in Tarlochan Singh v. State of Punjab (1). Relying upon the ratio of this judgment, the lower appellate Court held that in the absence of the testimony of the passengers, who are said to have paid Rs. 2.40 to the respondent, the statement of Madan Lal, Chief Inspector, assumes the character of hearsay evidence and as such it is inadmissible. The Court concluded that since there was no legal evidence against the respondent the order of his termination from service cannot be sustained. The judgment relied upon by the lower appellate court was, however, subsequently overruled by a Full Bench of this Court in the State of Haryana v. Shri Ram Chander (2). In this judgment it was held that there is no bar against the reception of hearsay evidence of the Checkers by domestic tribunals but the extent to which such evidence may be received and used must depend on the facts and circumstances of each case. In the present case, therefore, the order of termination of the respondent cannot be said to be void simply on the ground that the testimony of Madan Lal, Chief Inspector, was hearsay evidence. However, the evidentiary value of this testimony is to be objectively considered.
5. It is revealed from the statement of Madan Lal, Chief Inspector (Exhibit P. 5) which was recorded in the enquiry proceedings that he neither recorded the statements of the passengers who statedly gave a sum of Rs. 2.40 to the respondent nor the cash in hand of the respondent was checked. The same situation arose before a Single Bench of this Court in The State of Punjab v. Mohan Lal (3), which was decided on April 12, 1982. The learned Judge held as follows:β
βOn the charge levelled in this case, the minimum that ought to have been done was that either the statements of those three passengers or some other passengers should have been recorded at the time of checking or they should have been produced during the enquiry. Even if the cash with the Conductor had been tallied with the tickets issued and if there had been difference between the two by Rs. 2.40, some adverse inference could be drawn against the plaintiff and if nothing of the sort is done then I fail to understand on what material the plaintiff could have been held guilty of the charge. It is not the case that Shri H.S Randhawa, the Traffic Manager, was an eye-witness to the payment of Rs. 1.40 by the three passengers to to the Conductor. Accordingly, it would be a case of no evidence.β
6. I am in complete agreement with this view and, therefore, hold that in the present case too the termination of service of the Conductor cannot be upheld.
7. For these reasons there is no merit in this appeal and the same is dismissed with costs. Counsel's fee Rs. 100.
8. Appeal dismissed.
Alert