- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Municipal Corporation Of Delhi v. Its Workmen
S. Ranganathan, J.:— This is a writ petition filed by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi against an order of the Labour Court in I.D No. 59/68 dated 3-4-1970. By that order the Labour Court dismissed an application filed by the present petitioner for the amendment of its written statement. The petitioner's application had been made towards the fag end of the proceedings praying for permission to amend the written statement in order to raise two contentions; (1) That the reference was incompetent because the Terminal Tax Agency (a) Department of the present petitioner) in respect of which the dispute had arisen was not an ‘industry’ within the meaning of Industrial Disputes Act: and (2) That the reference was incompetent because it had been made by the Lt. Governor of Delhi whereas according to the petitioner it could have been made only by the Central Government. The Labour Court, however, referred in its order only to the first of these contentions and refused permission for amendment because the request of that amendment has been made at a belated stage apparently only with the view to delay the further proceedings.
2. After having heard the learned counsel for the petitioner I do not see any reason to interfere with the order of the Labour Court. The Labour Court was right in pointing out that the reference had been made in 1968: that the written statement had been made on 25-7-1969 and that the application for amendment had been made some time after the evidence of the parties had been closed.
3. It is not as if the petitioner was not aware of the possibilities of raising this contention bat apparently the contention was not raised earlier because of certain decisions of the Supreme Court and the prayer for amendment was made at a belated stage when the petitioner found that the similar issue was pending again before the Supreme Court for its decision. The point is also not purely out of law and may need an investigation of facts. In any event the rejection of the application by the Labour Court on the grounds given by it cannot be said to be erroneous and I therefore decline to interfere with the order dated 3-4-1970.
4. Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the Labour Court had not considered the other question raised by it namely that the reference should have been made by the Central Government not by the Lt. Governor. Counsel for the respondents states that this question has been concluded against the petitioner by a Division Bench of this Court in Leela Separators Pvt. Ltd. v. The Secretary (Labour) Delhi Administration(1). It is not necessary for me to deal with the contention in this writ petition. It is sufficient for me to observe that the dismissal of this writ petition will not preclude the petitioner from raising this contention in appropriate proceedings after the award is given by the Industrial Tribunal and that the order dated 3-4-1970 will not stand in the way of the petitioner since this contention has not been dealt with by the Labour Court in the said order. And as it raises a question of law and to the validity of the reference. With this clarification this writ petition is dismissed but no order as to costs.
Alert