Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Hemant Yashwant Dhag... v. Mrs. S.T Mohite, Psi...

Bombay High Court
Sep 8, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns the unnatural death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh, who sustained severe burn injuries at her residential quarters in Sangamner on 25/01/1991 and died on 16/02/1991 while undergoing treatment at Surya Hospital, Pune. Initially, she was taken to a hospital run by the second petitioner but was later shifted to Surya Hospital due to the availability of a burn ward. The police were intimated upon her admission to Surya Hospital, but no complaint was registered at that time. A post-mortem was conducted, but the cause of death was recorded only as "death on account of burn injuries" without specifying whether it was accidental, homicidal, or suicidal.

Following her death, an A.D. No. 8 of 1991 was registered with Sangamner Police Station on 17/2/1991, and a summary was granted on 30/10/1991. Several years later, complaints were filed against the second petitioner and others for offences including Sections 314, 302, and 207 read with Section 34 of IPC, but these complaints were dismissed for want of prosecution or on the complainants' requests.

In 2008, the first petitioner filed RCC No. 0402459 of 2008 alleging offences under Sections 201, 202, 417, 302 read with Section 34 of IPC regarding the unnatural death of Ms. Deshmukh. The learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Pune, directed the police to investigate under Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C.

The present petitions seek directions to register an FIR and transfer the investigation to an agency such as the CBI, and to quash the order dated 11/7/2008 and related proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an FIR should be registered regarding the unnatural death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh and the investigation transferred to another agency, preferably the CBI.
  2. Whether the order dated 11/7/2008 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Pune, and the related proceedings should be quashed.
  3. Whether the cause of death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh requires further investigation despite the passage of about 18 years and prior summary disposal.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the available records including medical papers, inquest panchanama, post mortem report, case summary, and police communications. It noted that Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh died an unnatural death due to burn injuries sustained at her residence. However, the cause of death—whether accidental, suicidal, or homicidal—remained unclear on the record. The Court observed that no police complaint was registered at the time of the incident despite intimation to the police and that the medical papers indicated limited treatment records. A purported dying declaration was produced but lacked the signature of the recording magistrate.

The Court emphasized that the summary disposal granted in 1991 could not preclude a fresh investigation into the cause of death. Given the ambiguities and the serious nature of the allegations, the Court held that a thorough investigation was warranted, notwithstanding the lapse of approximately 18 years. The Court determined that the investigation should be entrusted to a Special Investigation Team (SIT) led by a senior police officer to ensure a comprehensive and impartial inquiry.

The Court identified a list of potential witnesses and authorized the SIT to record statements from other relevant individuals, obtain complete medical records, and conduct lie detection tests if necessary. The Court further directed that the SIT be supported with adequate police personnel and assistance from relevant police authorities and mandated periodic reporting of the investigation's progress.

Holding and Implications

The Court appointed Smt. S.S Kalbande as the Special Investigating Officer to head the investigation into the unnatural death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh. It directed the registration of an FIR with the Sangamner Police Station and the commencement of a detailed investigation by the SIT.

The investigation is to be supported by additional police personnel and assistance from the Director General of Police, District Superintendent of Police, and Commissioner of Police, Pune. The SIT is required to submit progress reports, with the first report due within four weeks of taking charge and the entire investigation expected to conclude within approximately twelve weeks.

The decision directly affects the parties by mandating a renewed investigation into the death, but the opinion does not establish any new precedent beyond the immediate case context.

Show all summary ...

1. We have heard the learned counsel for the respective parties. In Criminal Writ Petition No. 2243 of 2008 the petitioner (hereinafter referred to as the first petitioner for short), who is the complainant in RCC No. 0402459 of 2008, has prayed for directions to the Faraskhana Police Station to register an F.I.R Pursuant to R.C.C No. 0402459 of 2008 and to transfer the investigation in the said case to any other investigating agency and preferably the C.B.I Whereas in Criminal Writ Petition No. 2482 of 2008 the petitioner (hereinafter referred to as the second petitioner for short) prays for quashing of the order dated 11/7/2008 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Pune in RCC No. 0402459 of 2008 and also to quash the said proceedings.

2. Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh, daughter of Shri Babanrao Deshmukh and aged about 30 years, was working as a Lecturer with the Engineering College at Sangamner and run by the Amrut Vahini Education Society. Her brother Shri Prataprao Babanrao Deshmukh was also a Lecturer in the very same college and both of them were provided residential accommodation by the Society. It is stated that at about 8.00 p.m on 25/01/1991 she sustained burn injuries to the extent of 85% and was immediately shifted to the hospital run by the second petitioner at Sangamner and after some treatment she came to be shifted to Surya Hospital at Pune (Kasba Peth). She was under treatment of Dr. Jaysing Krishnarao Shinde at Surya Hospital for more than three weeks and on 16/02/1991 at about 4.00 p.m she died. It appears that on her admission in Surya Hospital, an intimation was given to Police Constable Shri. Shinde (Buckle No. 5273) attached to Faraskhana Police Station and the medical case papers maintained by the said Hospital indicate that one Shri Gorakh Nivrutti Khule, driver and resident of Sangamner had accompanied her to the said Hospital and his name was shown as the next of kin. One Shri B.M Pujari appears to be the person who was also with the deceased when she was admitted in Surya Hospital and he was shown to be one of her care takers and he had endorsed the medical papers as having received the chain and other ornaments removed from the person of the deceased on 26/1/1991. On her demise, the dead body was handed over to Shri K.S Dalvi - Police Head Constable (Buckle No. 2832) and Shri Gaikwad - Police Constable (Buckle No. 2969), both from Faraskhana Police Station. The papers available on record further indicate that the dead body was handed over to the Sassoon Hospital for post-mortem so as to ascertain the cause of death i.e accidental, homicidal or suicidal as the medical certificate issued by Surya Hospital did not indicate the same. A copy of the post mortem report (not fully legible) has been placed before us, but it does not indicate the name of the doctor who conducted the autopsy and the cause of death as mentioned in the said report is “death on account of burn injuries”.

3. After the post mortem was conducted, the dead body was taken to Sangamner and A.D No. 8 of 1991 was entered on 17/2/1991 with the Sangamner Police Station. On 8/4/1991 the papers in A.D No. 8 of 1991 were submitted to the SDO, Sangamner for summary and summary was granted on 30/10/1991.

4. About three years later i.e On 4/7/1994 Shri Dashrath Hase filed M.A No. 300 of 1994 in the court of the learned JMFC at Sangamner for offences punishable under Sections 314, 302 and 207 read with Section 34 of IPC against the second petitioner and some of his relations regarding the unnatural demise of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh. On 5/7/1994 the learned JMFC at Sangamner passed an order to keep the witnesses present on 8/9/1994 to record their statements. However, instead of producing the witnesses, the complainant filed a pursis stating that he did not want to proceed with the complaint and hence requested for dismissal of his complaint, on 8/9/1994. The learned JMFC, accordingly, dismissed the complaint under Section 203 of Cr.P.C, on 12/9/1994.

5. Twelve years later i.e on 17/10/2006 Shri Vijay Thakur from Sangamner filed M.A No. 704 of 2006 against the second petitioner and his relations regarding the unnatural death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh. On 4/12/2006 this complainant applied for dismissal of the complaint and on the same day the complaint was dismissed for want of prosecution. This order came to be challenged by one Shri Sharad Kale in Criminal Writ Petition No. 524 of 2007 before the Aurangabad Bench of this Court and the petition was allowed on 1/4/2008. The trial court was directed to pass a fresh order on the application for dismissal of the complaint filed by Shri Vijay Thakur and a fresh order came to be passed on 21/4/2008 thereby dismissing the M.A No. 704 of 2006.

6. Two months later, Shri Hemant Dhage, the first petitioner, filed RCC No. 0402459 of 2008 for the offences punishable under Sections 201, 202, 417, 302 read with Section 34 of I.P.C regarding the unnatural death of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh and on 11/7/2008 the learned JMFC, Pune passed an order under Section 156(3) of Cr.P.C directing the police to investigate.

7. We have seen the record, including the medical papers and inquest panchanama, post mortem report, case summary and the letter dated 24/7/2009 addressed by the Sangamner Police Station. There is no dispute that Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh died an unnatural death on 16/02/1991 while she was under treatment at Surya Hospital, Pune and on account of the burn injuries she had sustained while in her house (official residential quarter) at Sangamner on 25/1/1991 at about 8.00 p.m Though at the first instance she was taken to the hospital of the second petitioner immediately after the incident, record does not indicate that any intimation was given to the police at Sangamner about the said incident. Though she was shifted for better treatment presumably to Pune, she was not admitted to the Sassoon Hospital (Govt. Hospital) and she came to be admitted to Surya Hospital, Kasba Peth, Pune (about 2 Kms. away from Sassoon Hospital) on the stated ground that it had a burn ward. She survived for about three weeks and the record does not indicate that the police had recorded her statement at any time during this period of three weeks. Even if it is claimed that police constable Shri Shinde (Buckle No. 5273) of Faraskhana Police Station was given intimation about her admission in Surya Hospital, there is no record whether the said police station had registered any complaint. However, our attention has been invited to a photo-stat copy of a purported dying declaration recorded by the Special Judicial Magistrate on 26/1/1991 and it appears to be a true copy issued by the SDO, Sangamner Division, Sangamner. The said document does not bear the signature of the person who recorded the same though the name of the Special Judicial Magistrate is stated to be Shri R. Retwade in the said document. A.D No. 8 of 1991 was registered by the Sangamber Police Station on 17/2/1991 when the dead body of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh was brought to Sangamner. It has also been pointed out by way of an affidaivt that Vijaya's father received the insurance claim subsequently on account of her accidental death and perhaps on the basis of the AD summary granted on 30/10/1991.

8. Having considered the record and the fact that there is nothing to indicate, prima facie, whether Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh died an accidental death, suicidal death or homicidal death, in our considered opinion, the cause of her death requires to be investigated, though by now about 18 years period has elapsed. The necessity of such an investigation is not in dispute before us. The AD summary granted on 30/10/1991, by itself cannot be a reason not to direct such an investigation. We have also noted that the medical case papers placed before us indicate the medical treatment only from 26/1/1991 to 27/1/1991. In the peculiar facts of this case and the record made available before us, we are also satisfied that the investigation is required to be handed over to a Special Investigation Team to be headed by a Police Officer not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police. We had requested Mr. Pol, In-charge P.P to place before us names of three police officers, as would be suggested by the Special I.G.P (Crime-West), C.I.D, M.S, Pune and the names of Smt. U.N Pingle, Smt. S.S Kalbande and Smt. Rekha Salunkhe have been placed before us.

9. Hence, we hereby appoint Smt. S.S Kalbande as the Special Investigating Officer and to head the investigation team. She will take immediate steps to register an F.I.R with the Sangamner Police Station regarding the incident i.e unnatural death (on account of burn injuries) of Ms. Vijaya Deshmukh and cause investigations. We have noted from the record the following persons could be the witnesses in the investigation to be carried out by the SIT:

(a) Dr. Sudhir Bhaskarrao Tambe Tambe Hospital, Sangamner.

(b) Dr. Jaysing Krishnarao Shinde Surya Hospital, Kasba Peth, Pune.

(c) Shri Ramesh Khule, Sangamner

(d) Dr. Prataprao Deshmukh (brother of the deceased)

(e) Shri Sahebrao Ramchandra Navale resident of Sangamner.

(f) Shri K.S Dalvi, Police Head Constable Buckle No. 2832, Faraskhana Police Station, Pune.

(g) Shri Gaikwad, Police Constable Buckle No. 2969, Faraskhana Police Station, Pune.

(h) Shri Gorakh Nivrutti Khule, Sangamner

(i) Shri B.M Pujari, Sangamner

(k) Shri Shinde - Police Constable Buckle No. 5273, Faraskhana Police Station, Pune.

(l) Shri R. Retwade, Special Judicial Magistrate, Pune.

10. We make it clear that the list of above witnesses is not exhaustive and the Special Investigating Officer may proceed to record the statement of other persons who are found to be concerned with the case. The Special Investigating Officer may take steps to obtain the medical papers of Surya Hospital at Pune for the entire period i.e from 26/1/1991 to 16/2/1991 and administer the lie detection test on any of the above mentioned witnesses, if deemed necessary.

11. We further direct that the Special Investigating Officer be provided additional police personnel, as she may require, by the Director General of Police, Maharashtra State and she be provided with all necessary assistance by the District Superintendent of Police, Ahmednagar as well as the Commissioner of Police, Pune from time to time. The Special Investigating Officer will submit the investigation report to this court from time to time and we expect the investigation to be completed within about 12 weeks period. The first such report shall be submitted within four weeks from the date the Special Investigating Officer takes charge. The Special Investigating Officer to contact the Registrar (Judicial) of this Court to obtain the present address of Dr. Prataprao Deshmukh.

12. Stand over to 16th October, 2009. Stay granted earlier to continue until further orders. The Spl. I.O to remain present before us on the next date with her first report.

13. A copy of this order be forwarded forthwith to the following authorities by the Registrar (Judicial):

(a) Director General of Police, Maharashtra State.

(b) Shri K.K Pathak, Spl. I.G.P (Crime-West) C.I.D, M.S, Pune.

(c) Commissioner of Police, Pune.

(d) District Superintendent of Police, Ahmednagar.