Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anwar Ali And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .

Supreme Court Of India
Jun 7, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal before the Supreme Court arose out of a village‐level feud that culminated in the fatal assault on one Jeet Bahadur Singh on 13 September 1980. According to the prosecution, the altercation stemmed from longstanding enmity between Lal Bahadur Singh and his family on one side and the village pradhan, Daroga, and his relatives on the other. Armed with lathis, ballams, bogdas, knives and country-made pistols, Daroga, his sons and associates allegedly attacked Jeet Bahadur Singh while he was conversing with Triyugi Narain Mishra. After inflicting multiple injuries, two assailants fired shots to disperse by-standers before fleeing.

An FIR was lodged the same morning, leading to charges under Sections 452, 307 and 302 of the Indian Penal Code. The trial court acquitted all the accused on 14 December 1981, disbelieving the eyewitnesses. On 16 September 2005 the Allahabad High Court reversed the acquittal, convicting five accused under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC (life imprisonment) and Section 148 IPC (two years’ rigorous imprisonment), with sentences to run concurrently. Daroga died during the pendency of the High Court proceedings. The Supreme Court appeal challenged that conviction.

At the outset of the Supreme Court hearing, defence counsel noted that the appellants had neither surrendered nor obtained bail, which ordinarily would preclude listing. The Court treated this as a bona fide procedural lapse and proceeded to decide the appeal on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in reversing the trial court’s acquittal and convicting the appellants primarily on the testimony of three eyewitnesses who were related to the deceased.
  2. Whether any procedural defect arising from the appellants’ failure to surrender affected the maintainability of the appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The conviction rested solely on the statements of three eyewitnesses—Lal Bahadur (PW-1), Triyugi Narain (PW-2) and Sipahi (PW-3)—all of whom were relatives or close associates of the deceased and therefore interested witnesses whose evidence should have been discarded.

Respondent’s Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P v. Daroga, 2005 Cri LJ 4547 (All.) Impugned High Court judgment that reversed the trial court’s acquittal. The Supreme Court examined this decision and ultimately affirmed the convictions entered by the High Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reiterated the settled legal principle that testimony cannot be discarded merely because the witnesses are related to the victim. Once the prosecution proves its case through cogent and admissible evidence—oral, documentary and medical—the relationship of witnesses to the deceased does not, by itself, render their evidence unreliable.

The Court found that the statements of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were consistent, corroborated one another and aligned with the medical evidence provided by Dr. D.P. Mishra, who conducted the post-mortem and recorded twenty-nine ante-mortem injuries causing death by shock and haemorrhage. This medical testimony buttressed the eyewitness accounts of a brutal group assault.

Accordingly, the Court held there was no misappreciation of evidence or other legal infirmity in the High Court’s judgment. The preliminary procedural irregularity regarding surrender was treated as a bona fide error that did not prejudice the merits of the appeal.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The appellants are to be taken into custody forthwith to serve the remainder of their life sentences.

The decision affirms the High Court’s power to reverse an acquittal where reliable, even if related, eyewitness testimony is corroborated by medical and other evidence. No new legal precedent was set, but the ruling reinforces the principle that kinship alone does not vitiate credibility.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant, at the very outset, pointed out a defect in the listing of the present appeal. The appellant had neither surrendered nor was granted bail by this Court. Thus, the appeal could not have been listed for hearing. According to him, this is the result of a bona fide error.

2. Apparently, as per rules and practice of this Court, the accused ought to have surrendered before the leave was granted or the appeal was admitted and listed for final hearing. However, vide order dated 6-3-2006, delay was condoned and the appeal was admitted. Thus, the counsel appearing for the appellants cannot be faulted with on this ground. Be that as it may, we have decided to hear the appeal on merits and pass appropriate orders.

3. The present appeal is directed against the judgment of the Allahabad High Court dated 16-9-2005 in State of U.P v. Daroga 2005 Cri LJ 4547 (All) which was preferred against the judgment of acquittal passed by the learned trial court on 14-12-1981. It will be useful to refer to the case of the prosecution in brief and facts giving rise to the present appeal.

4. Lal Bahadur Singh and his brother, Jeet Bahadur Singh were on inimical terms with Daroga, the village pradhan and others due to litigation going on between them. Akbar Ali alias Ghagghu, Anwar Ali, Hazrat Ali and Rauab Ali are sons of Daroga and Satlu is his son-in-law. Lais Mohammad, Hanif and Razzak are cousins of Daroga. Ayuub Mohammad and Akbar Ali are sons of Hanif. Insan Ali is the son of Razzak. On 13-9-1980 at about 8.30 a.m, Jeet Bahadur Singh was returning back from his fields to his house. On the way, he sat with Triyugi Narain Mishra near dheki (paddy thrashing machine) in the verandah of his house and started talking to him and his family members. At that time, Satbir alias Sadiq reached there and started talking to Jeet Bahadur Singh in connection with going to Bombay and went back. After some time, Daroga along with his sons and other acquaintances and one unknown person armed with lathis, ballams, bogda, knives and country-made pistols reached there. They started beating and attacking them with the weapons that they were carrying.

5. Watching the assault, Ferai and Sipahi rushed to the scene of occurrence. On hearing the hue and cry, others also came there. After causing injuries to Jeet Bahadur Singh, Satlu and the unknown person accompanying him fired with country-made pistols with an intention to scare away the co-villagers collected there who then ran away and all the other miscreants also fled away with the accused. Finally, the FIR was registered at 11.15 a.m of the same noon upon a statement of the brother of the deceased Lal Bahadur Singh. The police registered a case against the accused under Sections 452, 307 and 302 IPC. After investigation, charge-sheet was filed in the court. The accused were tried.

6. The trial court vide its judgment dated 14-12-1981 acquitted all the accused disbelieving the eyewitnesses and the entire occurrence. However, the High Court differed with the view taken by the learned trial court and by a detailed judgment convicted five accused, namely, Daroga, Anwar Ali, Ghagghu alias Akbar Ali, Hazrat Ali, Ayuub Mohammad and Akbar Ali under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced them to imprisonment for life. They were also convicted under Section 148 IPC and sentenced to two years' rigorous imprisonment. The sentences were directed to run concurrently. Daroga died during the pendency of the appeal before the High Court and the other remaining accused were also acquitted by the High Court.

7. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants while impugning the judgment of the High Court, has contended that there are only three eyewitnesses who are interested witnesses and the High Court could not have relied upon their statements. They are, namely, Lal Bahadur, PW 1; Triyugi Narain, PW 2 and Sipahi, PW 3. The High Court, while noticing and discussing the evidence of all these witnesses, came to the conclusion that their presence on the place of occurrence cannot be doubted.

8. It is a settled principle of law that merely because the witness is a relative or friend of the deceased, it would not be a sufficient ground to discard his statement. Once the prosecution has been able to prove its case by leading admissible and cogent evidence with reference to statement of the witnesses, the investigation conducted by the police officer and documentary evidence, then the statements of the eyewitnesses which are corroborating the prosecution case cannot be brushed aside only because they are relatives of the deceased. These statements even otherwise are reliable and trustworthy. This is further supported by the medical evidence of Dr D.P Mishra who had performed the post-mortem upon the body of the deceased, he noticed as many as 29 injuries upon the body of the deceased including injuries caused by knife, lacerated wounds, punctured wounds and it was clearly stated by the doctor that the death was caused due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of ante-mortem injuries caused upon the body of the deceased.

9. The cumulative effect of this evidence is that the death of the deceased was as a result of brutal attack by the accused persons. The statements of PW 1, PW 2 and PW 3 cannot be brushed aside merely because of their being relatives of the deceased. Therefore, we find no infirmity in the appreciation of the evidence or any other legal infirmity in the judgment of the High Court convicting the accused-appellants herein.

10. For the foregoing reasons, the appeal is dismissed. The appellant-accused be taken into custody forthwith to serve out the remaining portion of their sentence.