Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sanjay Adlakha v. State Of Haryana And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jun 1, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Smt. Kheri Bai, predecessor of the present petitioner, purchased a 640-sq-yard residential plot in Faridabad in 1962. On 11-10-1995 she obtained permission from the Municipal Corporation, Faridabad (“the Corporation”) to change the land use to commercial and to construct a basement, ground floor and first floor. She then erected a substantially larger structure—approximately 7450 sq. ft.—in blatant violation of the sanctioned plan and zoning regulations.

The Corporation offered to regularise the unauthorised construction upon payment of a compounding fee of Rs 39,49,920. Instead of paying, Smt. Kheri Bai initiated Civil Suit No. 816 of 1996 to challenge the demand and to restrain the Corporation from acting against the illegal construction. Interim relief was conditioned by the High Court on deposit of Rs 20 lakhs (order dated 2-9-1998), which she failed to deposit. The suit was dismissed on 7-1-2000 and no timely appeal followed.

After her death, the petitioner and other legal heirs pursued a series of unsuccessful proceedings: an out-of-time appeal before the District Judge, a Regular Second Appeal (dismissed 7-4-2005), a departmental appeal (dismissed 7-12-2004 with a demolition direction), and two writ petitions. The second writ petition (WP No. 15586 of 2006) was dismissed with costs of Rs 25,000 for abuse of process. A Letters Patent Appeal (LPA No. 523 of 2009) was likewise dismissed on 27-4-2011, with directions for immediate demolition.

The present Special Leave Petition under Article 136 of the Constitution challenges those concurrent High Court determinations.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Supreme Court should exercise its discretionary power under Article 136 to interfere with the High Court’s orders upholding the demand notice and directing demolition of the unauthorised structure.
  2. Whether any allegation of discriminatory treatment by the Corporation warranted judicial intervention after the petitioner’s repeated failures before civil and writ courts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The Corporation allegedly acted discriminatorily by demanding compounding fees from the petitioner while treating the constructions of one Shri Satish Parnami differently, as shown by certain notices relied upon by the petitioner (Annexures P-9, P-13 and P-14).

No detailed arguments of the respondents are recorded in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shanti Sports Club v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 705 Court must not condone or regularise illegal or unauthorised constructions; rigorous enforcement of planning laws is essential. The Supreme Court held that the High Court’s refusal to grant relief was “consistent” with this decision, reaffirming that no equitable indulgence is warranted for blatant violations.
K. Ramadas Shenoy v. Town Municipal Council, Udipi (1974) 2 SCC 506 Construction contrary to town-planning schemes cannot be legitimised merely because money has been spent. Mentioned within the quotation from Shanti Sports Club to underscore settled jurisprudence against regularising violations.
G.N. Khajuria v. DDA (1995) 5 SCC 762 Illegality in construction cannot be cured on grounds of hardship or expenditure. Cited within the quoted extract for the same proposition.
M.I. Builders (P) Ltd. v. Radhey Shyam Sahu (1999) 6 SCC 464 Courts should order demolition where public property or planning norms are violated. Appears in the quotation to reinforce the strict approach towards unauthorised development.
Friends Colony Development Committee v. State of Orissa (2004) 8 SCC 733 Regularisation of illegal constructions undermines urban planning. Cited within the quotation for emphasis.
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (2006) 3 SCC 399 Environmental and civic consequences of unplanned urban growth justify stringent enforcement. Referenced in the quotation to highlight broader public interest considerations.
S.N. Chandrashekar v. State of Karnataka (2006) 3 SCC 208 No compromise with planning laws despite individual hardship. Also part of the quotation illustrating consistent judicial stance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court characterised the petition as a “frivolous piece of litigation.” It found that the petitioner’s predecessor wilfully violated the sanctioned plan, refused to pay the stipulated compounding fee, and repeatedly abused judicial processes to delay enforcement. Having lost before three civil courts, departmental authorities, a Single Judge, and a Division Bench, the petitioner offered no “valid ground, much less justification” for Court interference under Article 136.

The Court endorsed the High Court’s reasoning and noted its consistency with Shanti Sports Club, which mandates strict adherence to planning statutes and condemns post-facto regularisation. The allegation of discrimination was dismissed as belated and legally irrelevant; even if another person had been treated leniently, the law does not require repetition of an illegality.

Given the prolonged 15-year delay engineered by the petitioner, the Court directed immediate execution of the High Court’s demolition order and warned municipal officials of contempt consequences for non-compliance.

Holding and Implications

Special Leave Petition DISMISSED.

Implications: The Corporation must demolish the unauthorised structure within 15 days of receiving the Supreme Court’s order and report to the High Court within the following week. Failure by municipal officials will invite contempt proceedings. While the judgment creates no new legal precedent, it reinforces existing jurisprudence that courts will not protect or regularise blatant violations of planning laws.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This petition filed against the order dated 27-4-2011 LPA No. 523 of 2009 passed by the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissing the letters patent appeal filed by the petitioner against the order dated 27-3-2009 passed by the learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition filed by him with cost of Rs 25,000 cannot but be termed as frivolous piece of litigation.

2. Smt Kheri Bai (predecessor of the petitioner) submitted an application dated 11-10-1995 to the competent authority of Faridabad Municipal Corporation (for short “the Corporation”) for change of land use in respect of residential plot measuring 640 sq yd, which she had purchased in 1962 and for permission to construct a commercial building comprising basement, ground floor and first floor. The Corporation granted permission for change of land use and also sanctioned the building plan.

3. However, in complete disregard to the sanctioned plan and zoning regulations, Smt Kheri Bai started huge unauthorised construction. The authorities concerned of the Corporation tried to persuade Smt Kheri Bai to stop illegal construction, but she did not pay any heed to their advice and made unauthorised construction measuring about 7450 sq ft. After completing the construction, Smt Kheri Bai made an application for regularisation of the illegal construction. The then Joint Commissioner of the Corporation obliged her subject to the payment of compounding fees amounting to Rs 39,49,920.

4. If the predecessor of the petitioner had paid the amount, the gross violation of the sanctioned plan and the zoning regulations would have been regularised. However, instead of paying the compounding fees, Smt Kheri Bai dragged the Corporation and the State Government into unwarranted litigation, which has culminated in the filing of this petition. She filed Civil Suit No. 816 of 1996 for grant of a declaration that the demand made by the Corporation is illegal. She also prayed for grant of a permanent injunction to restrain the functionaries of the Corporation from taking action against the illegal and unauthorised construction made by her. She also applied for temporary injunction but her prayer was rejected by the trial court and the first appellate court.

5. In the revision petition filed by Smt Kheri Bai, the learned Single Judge of the High Court passed an order dated 2-9-1998, which reads as under:

“Issue notice to the respondents to show cause why revision be not admitted returnable on 16-9-1998. The building of the petitioner will not be demolished subject to the condition that the petitioner deposits a sum of Rs 20 lakhs within two weeks from today. If the said amount is not deposited, the interim injunction shall be liable to vacated. Notice dasti.
If service is not effected on the respondents then the injunction would be liable to be vacated.”

Smt Kheri Bai did not deposit Rs 20 lakhs in terms of the aforesaid order.

6. The suit filed by Smt Kheri Bai was finally dismissed by the trial court vide judgment dated 7-1-2000. She did not pursue the matter by filing an appeal. After her death, the petitioner and other legal heirs of the deceased filed an appeal along with an application for condonation of 1320 days' delay. The District Judge, Faridabad dismissed the appeal on the ground of delay and also on merits. Regular Second Appeal No. 2134 of 2004 filed by the petitioner and other legal heirs of Smt Kheri Bai was dismissed by the High Court on 7-4-2005 RSA No. 2134 of 2004.

7. After having lost the case in three courts, the petitioner tried his luck by filing a departmental appeal against the demand notice dated 3-4-1996. The same was dismissed by the Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Haryana, Urban Development Department vide order dated 7-12-2004 with a direction that property bearing No. 21/12BPNIT, Faridabad be demolished.

8. The petitioner challenged the order of the Commissioner in Sanjay Adalkha v. State of Haryana WP (C) No. 4354 of 2005. After enjoying the interim protection for a period of one year and six months against the demolition of unauthorised construction and coercive measures, which could be taken by the Corporation for recovery of the compounding fee, the petitioner withdrew the writ petition with liberty to file fresh one. The order permitting withdrawal of writ petition was passed by the Division Bench of the High Court on 14-9-2006. Immediately thereafter, the petitioner filed Writ Petition No. 15586 of 2006, which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge with cost of Rs 25,000 by recording the following observations:

“It is quite unfortunate that the petitioner has been successfully hoodwinking the Corporation through sheer abuse of the legal process. It was more than 10 years back that this Court directed the petitioner's mother to deposit a sum of Rs 20 lakhs but the petitioner (or his deceased mother) failed to comply with the said direction. Still, they have been able to retain the unauthorised building and enjoying its fruits from last about 14 years. During the course of hearing of this writ petition also, the petitioner was advised to comply with the order dated 2-9-1998 at least at this stage to prove his bona fide. The suggestion has not found favour with the petitioner. The record reveals that the petitioner has scant respect for the municipal laws or the building bye-laws framed thereunder. The brazen violators like the petitioner need to be reigned in at the earliest, more so when the incident pertains to Faridabad whereby this Court has witnessed large scale unauthorised constructions/encroachments by land mafia, may be due to inaction or connivance of the local authorities.”

9. The letters patent appeal preferred by the petitioner was dismissed by the Division Bench of the High Court, which unequivocally disapproved the conduct of the petitioner. The new plea of discrimination raised by the petitioner was rejected by the Division Bench of the High Court in the following words:

“The sole argument raised by the learned counsel for the appellant in the present appeal is that the Corporation has dealt with the constructions raised by the appellant in a discriminatory manner, than the construction raised by Shri Satish Parnami in identical situation. The appellant relies upon notices dated 8-11-1995 (Annexure P-14), 4-4-1996 (Annexure P-13) and the communication dated 13-2-1997 (Annexure P-9) served upon Shri Parnami.
The conduct of the appellant is far from fair and reasonable. Once the challenge to the demand, calling upon the predecessor-in-interest of the appellant to deposit Rs 39,49,920 has remained unsuccessful before the civil court, the appellant could not approach the authorities under the Act for modification of the demand raised. Notices, which the appellant now relies upon, were available even when the civil suit was pending. But the appellant had not raised any grievance in respect of such notices issued to Shri Parnami, at that time. Even if, illegality has been committed in respect of one person, the appellant cannot claim same illegality to be committed in respect of him. The appellant having remained unsuccessful before the civil court, interference sought from this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction is clearly an abuse of process of law and is unwarranted.”

10. The concluding portion of the order passed by the Division Bench is extracted below:

“The appellant has raised unauthorised construction way back in 1996 and has been successful in delay of the action by the Municipal Corporation, Faridabad, for the last 15 years. The Municipal Corporation, Faridabad, is directed to take immediate action for removal of unauthorised constructions and submit its report to this Court within three months.”

11. We have heard Shri Manoj Swarup, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner at some length and carefully perused the record.

12. In our view, the reasons assigned by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench for refusing to entertain the petitioner's prayer quashing the demand notice and order dated 7-12-2004 passed by the Commissioner and Secretary, Urban Development Department are legally correct and there is no valid ground, much less justification, for exercise of power by this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution to restrain the respondents from demolishing the construction raised by the predecessor of the petitioner.

13. The approach adopted by the High Court is consistent with the observations made by this Court in Shanti Sports Club v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 705, paras 73-74 and 75 of which are extracted below:

“73. Before concluding, we consider it necessary to enter a caveat. In all developed countries, great emphasis has been laid on the planned development of cities and urban areas. The object of planned development has been achieved by rigorous enforcement of master plans prepared after careful study of complex issues, scientific research and rationalisation of laws. The people of those countries have greatly contributed to the concept of planned development of cities by strictly adhering to the planning laws, the master plan, etc. They respect the laws enacted by the legislature for regulating planned development of the cities and seldom there is a complaint of violation of master plan, etc. in the construction of buildings, residential, institutional or commercial. In contrast, scenario in the developing countries like ours is substantially different. Though, the competent legislatures have, from time to time, enacted laws for ensuring planned development of the cities and urban areas, enforcement thereof has been extremely poor and the people have violated the master plans, zoning plans and building regulations and bye-laws with impunity.
74. In the last four decades, almost all cities, big or small, have seen unplanned growth. In the 21st century, the menace of illegal and unauthorised constructions and encroachments has acquired monstrous proportions and everyone has been paying heavy price for the same. Economically affluent people and those having support of the political and executive apparatus of the State have constructed buildings, commercial complexes, multiplexes, malls, etc. in blatant violation of the municipal and town planning laws, master plans, zonal development plans and even the sanctioned building plans. In most of the cases of illegal or unauthorised constructions, the officers of the municipal and other regulatory bodies turn blind eye either due to the influence of higher functionaries of the State or other extraneous reasons. Those who construct buildings in violation of the relevant statutory provisions, master plan, etc. and those who directly or indirectly abet such violations are totally unmindful of the grave consequences of their actions and/or omissions on the present as well as future generations of the country which will be forced to live in unplanned cities and urban areas. The people belonging to this class do not realise that the constructions made in violation of the relevant laws, master plan or zonal development plan or sanctioned building plan or the building is used for a purpose other than the one specified in the relevant statute or the master plan, etc. such constructions put unbearable burden on the public facilities/amenities like water, electricity, sewerage, etc. apart from creating chaos on the roads. The pollution caused due to traffic congestion affects the health of the road users. The pedestrians and people belonging to weaker sections of the society, who cannot afford the luxury of air-conditioned cars, are the worst victims of pollution. They suffer from skin diseases of different types, asthma, allergies and even more dreaded diseases like cancer. It can only be a matter of imagination how much the Government has to spend on the treatment of such persons and also for controlling pollution and adverse impact on the environment due to traffic congestion on the roads and chaotic conditions created due to illegal and unauthorised constructions. This Court has, from time to time, taken cognizance of buildings constructed in violation of municipal and other laws and emphasised that no compromise should be made with the town planning scheme and no relief should be given to the violator of the town planning scheme, etc. on the ground that he has spent substantial amount on construction of the buildings, etc. [K. Ramadas Shenoy v. Town Municipal Council, Udipi (1974) 2 SCC 506, G.N Khajuria v. DDA (1995) 5 SCC 762, M.I Builders (P) Ltd. v. Radhey Shyam Sahu (1999) 6 SCC 464, Friends Colony Development Committee v. State of Orissa (2004) 8 SCC 733, M.C Mehta v. Union of India (2006) 3 SCC 399 and S.N Chandrashekar v. State of Karnataka (2006) 3 SCC 208].
75. Unfortunately, despite repeated judgments by this Court and the High Courts, the builders and other affluent people engaged in the construction activities, who have, over the years shown scant respect for regulatory mechanism envisaged in the municipal and other similar laws, as also the master plans, zonal development plans, sanctioned plans, etc. have received encouragement and support from the State apparatus. As and when the courts have passed orders or the officers of local and other bodies have taken action for ensuring rigorous compliance with laws relating to planned development of the cities and urban areas and issued directions for demolition of the illegal/unauthorised constructions, those in power have come forward to protect the wrongdoers either by issuing administrative orders or enacting laws for regularisation of illegal and unauthorised constructions in the name of compassion and hardship. Such actions have done irreparable harm to the concept of planned development of the cities and urban areas. It is high time that the executive and political apparatus of the State take serious view of the menace of illegal and unauthorised constructions and stop their support to the lobbies of affluent class of builders and others, else even the rural areas of the country will soon witness similar chaotic conditions.”

The special leave petition is, accordingly, dismissed.

14. The Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Faridabad is ordained to implement the direction given by the Division Bench of the High Court within a period of 15 days of the receipt of copy of this order and submit a report to the High Court within next one week. The Registry of the High Court shall list the case before the Bench which had decided LPA No. 523 of 2009. If the Bench concerned of the High Court finds that the authorities of the Corporation have failed to implement the direction contained in order dated 27-4-2011 LPA No. 523 of 2009, then it shall initiate proceedings against the erring officers under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

15. The Registry is directed to send copies of this order to Registrar (Judicial) of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh and Commissioner, Municipal Corporation, Faridabad by fax.

Court Masters