- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Top Notch Infotronix (I) Pvt. Ltd. v. Infosoft Systems
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from an application under section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking leave to file an appeal against an order of acquittal passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class (24th Court), Nagpur, in Summary Criminal Case No. 13119/2008. The case involves an acquittal in a complaint case under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. A preliminary objection was raised regarding the maintainability of the appeal before the High Court, contending that the appeal forum should be the Sessions Court as per the proviso to section 372 of the Criminal Procedure Code, inserted by the 2008 Amendment Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court is the appropriate forum to entertain an appeal against an order of acquittal passed in a complaint case under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, given the proviso to section 372 of the Criminal Procedure Code as amended in 2008.
- Whether the complainant in a complaint case qualifies as a "victim" under section 2(wa) of the Criminal Procedure Code and thereby has the right to appeal against acquittal under the amended provisions.
- The applicability and interaction between section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code and the proviso to section 372 regarding appeals against acquittal.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondents' Arguments
- The proviso to section 372, inserted by the 2008 Amendment Act, specifies that the victim has the right to appeal against an order of acquittal, and such appeal should lie to the court where appeals ordinarily lie against conviction, which in this case is the Sessions Court.
- The term "victim" should be given a broad meaning to include the complainant in a complaint case.
- Since appeals against conviction under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act are filed before the Sessions Court, appeals against acquittal should also lie before the Sessions Court.
Court's Response to Arguments
- The Court disagreed with the respondents' contention, emphasizing that section 378 specifically deals with appeals in cases of acquittal in complaint cases.
- The Court noted that two forums exist for appeals against acquittal: the Sessions Court for cognizable and non-bailable offences, and the High Court under section 378(4) for complaint cases where the complainant seeks leave to appeal.
- The proviso to section 372 and the definition of "victim" do not affect the provisions of section 378(4) concerning complaint cases.
- Therefore, the appeal against acquittal in this complaint case lies before the High Court, not the Sessions Court.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court analyzed the interplay between the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code, particularly section 378(4) and the proviso to section 372 as amended by the 2008 Act. It recognized that while the 2008 amendment introduced a right for victims to appeal acquittals to the court where appeals ordinarily lie against conviction, this right applies primarily to cases instituted on police reports. In contrast, section 378(4) explicitly provides for complainants in complaint cases to seek leave from the High Court to appeal acquittals. The Court emphasized that the definition of "victim" in the amendment does not override the existing rights under section 378(4) for complaint cases. Hence, the Court concluded that the High Court is the correct forum for the appeal in this case. The Court also noted admitted facts from the trial court's judgment indicating that arguable points exist, justifying the grant of leave to appeal.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court granted leave to file an appeal against the order of acquittal under section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code, holding that the High Court is the appropriate forum for such an appeal in complaint cases under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
Implications: This decision clarifies that the proviso to section 372, inserted by the 2008 Amendment Act, does not affect the existing right of complainants in complaint cases to appeal acquittals before the High Court under section 378(4). The ruling ensures that complainants retain a direct appellate remedy in the High Court, distinct from the forum designated for appeals in cases instituted on police reports. No new precedent beyond this clarification was established.
1. This is an application under section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking leave to file an appeal against the order of acquittal passed by learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class (24th Court), Nagpur in Summary Criminal Case No. 13119/2008.
2. Mr. Dawada, learned counsel appearing for the respondents, raised a preliminary objection about the maintainability of the appeal before this Court. According to him proviso to section 372, inserted by the Code of Criminal Procedure Amendment Act, 2008 (for short Act of 2008), which came into force with effect from 31st of December 2009, the forum for appeal would be the Sessions Court and not the High Court. Proviso to section 372 reads as under:—
“Provided that the victim shall have a right to prefer an appeal against any order passed by the Court acquitting the accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall lie to the Court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such Court.”
3. While inserting the aforesaid provision the definition of ‘victim’ has also been incorporated as section 2(wa) which reads as under:—
“victim” means a person who has suffered any loss or injury caused by reason of the act or omission for which the accused person has been charged and the expression “victim” includes his or her guardian or legal heir.
4. According to learned counsel for the respondents expression ‘victim’ has to be given wider meaning to include complainant in a complaint case. Being a victim he chooses to file complaint case as such, the complainant cannot be excluded from the term ‘victim’ occurring under section 2(wa) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Whenever there is an order of acquittal and if victim, may be in the capacity of complainant, is not satisfied with the said order, he has been conferred with a right to question the judgment and the forum has also been specified in the proviso to section 372 of the Criminal Procedure Code. According to him, forum would be the Court where ordinarily the appeal lies against the order of conviction of such Court. Admittedly, appeals against the order of conviction, recorded under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, are filed before the Court of Sessions. Therefore, an appeal against the order of acquittal should also lie before the Court of Sessions, he urged.
5. I am not in agreement with the contention raised by learned counsel for the respondents. Section 378 exclusively deals with appeal in case of acquittal. Because of the recent amendment which has come into force from 23-6-2006 two forums are available for filing an appeal against the order of acquittal. In respect of a cognizable and non-bailable offences, the District Magistrate may direct the Public Prosecutor to present an appeal to the Court of Sessions. In other cases, the State Government or the Central Government, as the case may be, may direct the Public Prosecutor to present an appeal the High Court. The Criminal Procedure Code makes distinction between the case filed by the complainant and the case filed on the police report. If the case is instituted otherwise than upon a police report that means if it is a complaint case and the accused is acquitted, the complainant has a remedy to assail an order by resorting to the provisions of section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code which reads as under:—
“If such an order of acquittal is passed in any case instituted upon complaint and the High Court, on an application made to it by the complainant in this behalf grants special leave to appeal from the order of acquittal, the complainant may present such an appeal to the High Court.”
6. Before Act of 2008 came into force, “victim” in a criminal case, instituted on a police report, had no right to file an appeal against the order of acquittal to any Court. However, in a complaint case, right in the form of provisions under section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code was already in existence. The Law Commission in its 154th report recommended comprehensive amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure relating to various provisions concerning arrest, custody, compounding of offences, victimology etc. In the statement of objects and reasons of Act of 2008 it is mentioned in para 2 that “at present, the victims are the worst sufferers in a crime and they don t have much role in the court proceedings. They need to be given certain rights and compensation, so that there is no distortion of the criminal justice system.”
7. Thus based on the ‘doctrine of victimology’ proviso to section 372 and the definition of ‘victim’ have been incorporated w.e.f 31st December 2009 thereby the victims have not been left at the mercy of the State Government or the Central Government (as the case may be) or the District Magistrate. The aforesaid provision does not in any manner affect provisions of section 378(4) of the Criminal Procedure Code dealing with the appeal against the order of acquittal in any case instituted upon complaint.
8. In this view of the matter, appeal against an order of acquittal, passed in the case instituted by the appellant, for the offence punishable under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act would lie to this Court. I, therefore, do not find any force in the preliminary objection, raised by the learned counsel for the respondents.
9. Turning to the facts of the case, learned Magistrate in para 11 of his judgment observed:
“It would be appropriate to mention the admitted facts on record. It is admitted by the accused persons that they used to purchase materials from the complainant. The signature on cheque at Exh. 24 is admitted by the accused person. Issuance of demand notice by the complainant is also admitted and reply to said notice by the accused persons is also admitted by the complainant.”
10. In this view of the matter, I find that the arguable points are involved. Hence leave, as prayed for, is granted.
Order accordingly.
Alert