Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Krishan And Others v. State Of Haryana .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 23, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The trial court convicted fifteen individuals under various sections of the Indian Penal Code, including Sections 302/149, 307/149, 324, and 148. Each received life imprisonment for murder, lesser concurrent sentences for other offences, and fines. On appeal, the High Court acquitted ten of the accused while affirming the convictions of five others. The five convicted persons obtained special-leave to appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 801 of 2005). Concurrently, the State of Haryana filed Criminal Appeal No. 674 of 2005 challenging the High Court’s acquittal of nine of the ten discharged accused (no appeal was filed regarding Accused 6, Krishan-II). The present opinion resolves both appeals.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions of the five appellants, affirmed by the High Court, were sustainable on the evidence of the two injured eyewitnesses corroborated by medical testimony.
  2. Whether the High Court’s acquittal of nine accused persons was so perverse or unsustainable as to warrant interference on the State’s appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court closely scrutinised the testimony of the two injured eyewitnesses, PW 12 (Chhabil Dass) and PW 13 (Prithavi Singh). Both witnesses consistently supported the prosecution in their police statements and in-court evidence. Their accounts were corroborated by medical findings: the post-mortem doctor confirmed that injuries to the deceased were caused by firearms and blunt/sharp weapons and were sufficient, in the ordinary course, to cause death. The Court held that such corroboration rendered the eyewitness testimony credible.

The defence contention that the prosecution failed to explain injuries sustained by the accused was rejected. The Court reiterated the settled principle that unexplained injuries on the accused do not, by themselves, vitiate otherwise trustworthy prosecution evidence.

Regarding the State’s appeal against the acquittals, the Court examined the High Court’s reasoning and found no perversity warranting reversal. Consequently, the High Court’s judgment of acquittal stood.

Holding and Implications

Both Criminal Appeal No. 801 of 2005 and Criminal Appeal No. 674 of 2005 are dismissed.

As a result, the convictions and sentences of the five appellants are upheld, and the High Court’s acquittal of nine other accused persons remains undisturbed. The decision turns solely on an assessment of credibility and does not establish new legal precedent beyond reaffirming existing principles on eyewitness reliability and unexplained injuries.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

2. The trial court convicted fifteen accused persons, including the five appellants of Criminal Appeal No. 801 of 2005 under Sections 302/149 of the Indian Penal Code (for short “IPC”) and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay fine of Rs 5000 each. They were further convicted under Sections 307/149 IPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years and to pay a fine of Rs 1000 each, in default, to undergo further imprisonment for a period of one month. The accused persons were then convicted under Sections 324 and 148 IPC and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years and one year respectively. The sentences were, however, ordered to run concurrently.

3. On appeal being preferred, the High Court acquitted other ten accused persons whereas upheld convictions of the appellants of Criminal Appeal No. 801 of 2005. Hence, Criminal Appeal No. 801 of 2005 has been filed by special leave by the convicted accused persons. The State of Haryana has filed Criminal Appeal No. 674 of 2005 against the order of acquittal rendered by the High Court in relation to nine persons whereas no appeal has been preferred against the order of acquittal of Krishan-II (Accused 6).

4. In the present case, prosecution has relied upon the evidence of two eyewitnesses, namely, Chhabil Dass (PW 12) and Prithavi Singh (PW 13). Both these witnesses were injured persons and out of them, PW 12 was the informant and PW 13 has been named as an eyewitness in the first information report itself. These two witnesses have consistently supported the prosecution case in their statements made before the police as well as in court. We have been taken through their evidence and we do not find any ground to discard their evidence, more so, when their evidence is corroborated by medical evidence as the doctor, who conducted post-mortem on the dead bodies of deceased Banwari and Duli Chand, opined that the injuries were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature and the same were caused by firearm as well as other weapons like kulhari and lathi. In view of these facts, it is not possible to disbelieve the evidence of these two witnesses. It is well settled that merely because prosecution has failed to explain injuries of the accused, the same cannot be a solitary ground for doubting the prosecution case, if otherwise, evidence relied upon is found to be credible. In the case on hand as we are of the view that no ground is made out to disbelieve the evidence of PWs 12 and 13 who are the eyewitnesses and whose evidence is corroborated by the medical evidence, non-explanation of injuries of the accused by the prosecution cannot be a ground to record acquittal of the appellants. So far as the State appeal is concerned, having perused the judgment of acquittal rendered by the High Court in relation to some of the accused persons, we do not find that the same can be said to be perverse in any manner.

5. Accordingly, both the appeals fail and the same are, accordingly, dismissed.