Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Director Of Income Tax v. Shree Visheshwar Nath Memorial Public Ch. Trust

Delhi High Court
Aug 18, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent-assessee is a Charitable Trust whose aims and objectives qualified it as charitable under Section 2(15) of the Income Tax Act. Despite fulfilling these conditions, the Income Tax Officer denied the benefit of Section 11 of the Act, citing infringement of Section 13(1)(d) due to the assessee's investment in secured debentures and bonds of various companies. The Officer distinguished between debentures and bonds, excluding income from bonds from exemption. The assessee appealed, and the appellate authority held that bonds are included within the definition of debentures, thus entitling the assessee to exemption under Section 11. The Tribunal concurred with this view. The department sought reference to this Court under Section 256(1) which was rejected, leading to the present reference under Section 256(2) with the question whether the Tribunal was justified in granting the benefit of Section 11 despite the assessee's investment in bonds.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was legally justified in allowing the benefit of Section 11 of the Income Tax Act to the assessee when it had made investments in bonds, considering the provisions of Section 13(1)(d) of the Act.
  2. Whether the definition of “debenture” under the Companies Act can be applied for interpreting the term “debenture” under the Income Tax Act.
  3. Whether the term “debenture” under Section 11(5) of the Income Tax Act should be given a restrictive meaning excluding bonds for the purposes of exemption.

Arguments of the Parties

Department's Arguments

  • The Income Tax Officer argued that income from bonds should not be exempt under Section 11 as the assessee contravened Section 13(1)(d) by investing in bonds, which are distinct from debentures.
  • The department's counsel contended that for the purpose of Section 11(5), the term “debenture” should be narrowly construed to exclude bonds, relying on the specific mention of bonds in that subsection.

Assessee's Arguments

  • The assessee contended that bonds are included within the definition of debentures and therefore investments in bonds do not contravene Section 13(1)(d).
  • The appellate authority and Tribunal accepted that the term “debenture” includes bonds, entitling the assessee to exemption under Section 11.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income Tax, Kerala-I Vs. Cochin Refineries Ltd. [1983] 142 ITR 441 (Ker) Use of Companies Act definition of “debenture” to interpret the term under the Income Tax Act. The Court relied on this precedent to affirm that the Companies Act definition is applicable for interpreting “debenture” under the Income Tax Act.
British India Steam Navigation Co. v. IRC [1881] 7 QBD 165 Explanation of the flexible and non-technical nature of the term “debenture.” Quoted to illustrate that “debenture” encompasses various instruments including bonds and acknowledgments of indebtedness.
Levy v. Abercorris Slate and Slab Co. [1888] 37 Ch D 260 Absence of precise legal definition of “debenture.” Used to support the principle that the substance of the instrument determines if it is a debenture.
Edmonds v. Blaina Furnaces Co. [1887] 36 Ch D 215 Nature of debenture as a debt acknowledgment usually accompanied by security or covenant to pay. Reinforced the understanding of debenture as a wide and elastic commercial term.
Laxman Bharmaji v. Emperor AIR 1946 Bom 18 Substance over form approach in determining whether an instrument is a debenture. Supported the Court’s approach to look at the instrument’s substance rather than its label.
CIT Vs. Lakshmi Vilas Bank Ltd. Reliance on other enactments for definition of “debenture” due to absence in Income Tax Act. Affirmed that Courts must refer to definitions in other statutes when Income Tax Act is silent.
Noorie Manure Mill, Sambhal Vs. Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P (2007) 10 SCC 478 Meaning of undefined statutory terms should be as understood in common parlance for tax purposes. Supported the principle that “debenture” should be given its common parlance meaning in absence of statutory definition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by noting the absence of a definition of “debenture” in the Income Tax Act and considered the Companies Act’s definition under Section 2(12), which includes bonds within “debentures.” The Court analyzed authoritative judicial interpretations, including decisions of the Kerala and Madras High Courts, and English legal authorities, which emphasized the flexible and non-technical nature of the term “debenture.” The Court recognized that the term encompasses instruments that acknowledge debt, including bonds, and that the substance of the instrument governs its classification rather than its label.

The Court addressed the department’s argument that Section 11(5) requires a restrictive meaning of “debenture” excluding bonds by underscoring that Section 11(5) specifically deals with certain bonds but this does not limit the general understanding of “debenture” under Section 13(1)(d). The Court applied the principle that in absence of statutory definition, terms must be construed according to common parlance and commercial usage.

Accordingly, the Court upheld the Tribunal’s view that investments in bonds fall within the term “debentures” and therefore do not violate Section 13(1)(d), entitling the assessee to exemption under Section 11.

Holding and Implications

The Court affirmed the Tribunal’s decision allowing the benefit of Section 11 of the Income Tax Act to the assessee despite its investment in bonds, holding that bonds are included within the definition of “debentures” for the purposes of the Act.

This ruling directly benefits the assessee by confirming entitlement to exemption on income from such investments. The Court did not establish a new precedent beyond applying established principles of statutory interpretation and commercial understanding of “debenture.”

Show all summary ...

A.K SIKRI, J. (ORAL)

1. The respondent-assessee is a Charitable Trust. It is the opinion of the Income Tax Officer that the aims and objectives of the assessee Trust would make it charitable within the meaning of Section 2 (15) of the Income Tax Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’). However, notwithstanding the fact that the assessee fulfills these conditions, the Income Tax Officer refused to grant the benefit of Section 11 of the Act to the assessee on the ground that the assessee had infringed the provision of Section 13 (1) (d) of the Act. This opinion of the Assessing Officer was influenced by the act of the assessee in making investment in secured debentures of Indian Rayons, secured convertible Bonds of Voltas Ltd. and unsecured bonds of Telco. The view of the Assessing Officer was that the income derived from debentures was only examined and was not included as income of the Trust but this exemption would not extend to the income derived from investment in bonds. The case put up by the assessee was that the debentures include bonds but this plea was not accepted by the Assessing Officer. The matter was taken up in appeal by the assessee. The appellate authority relied upon the definition of ‘debentures’. On that basis, the appellate authority opined that ‘debentures’ would include bond as well and, therefore, by making investment in bonds, the assessee had not contravened the provisions of Section 13 (1) (d) of the Act and was entitled to the exemption and the income from the bonds as well as debentures was not to be included as income for the purpose of tax as provided under Section 11 of the Act. The Tribunal concurred with this opinion of the appellate authority in the following manner:-

“The submissions have been carefully considered. The question is whether in terms of proviso 2 to Sec. 13(1) (d) the assets in question were debentures by or on behalf of company or corporation acquired by the trust or institution before 1.3.1983 The definitions referred to on behalf of ‘assessee’ clearly show that ‘debentures’ are actually bonds though sometimes the term ‘debenture bond’ is used. It is a written obligation or acknowledgement in an impersonal form, and with conditions more elaborate than those of a promissory note, given by or for a corporation or a company to secure a sum of money. The order of the learned Appellate Asstt. Commissioner was therefore, eminently justified”

2. At this stage the department moved an application under Section 256 (1) of the Act seeking reference to this Court which was rejected by the Tribunal. After facing this rejection, the department approached this Court under Section 256 (2) of the Act and in that application, this Court directed the Tribunal to refer the following question of law for the opinion of this Court, alongwith statement of case:-

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was justified in law in allowing the benefit of Section 11 of the Income-tax Act to the assessee when it had made investment in the bonds etc.?”

3. The word ‘debentures’ is nowhere defined under the Income Tax Act. However, the Indian Companies Act specifically defines this term and as per the definition provided in Section 2 (12) of the said statute, ‘bond’ is covered under the expression ‘debenture’. Therefore, the first question that arises for our consideration is as to whether the definition contained in the Companies Act can be referred to and relied upon for the purposes of understanding the meaning of ‘debenture’ under the Income Tax Act as well. This very aspect came up for consideration before Kerala High Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Kerala-I Vs. Cochin Refineries Ltd. [1983]142ITR 441 (Ker). The issue was discussed with reference to Section 80J of the Income Tax Act. The question which arose before the Court was same as taken note of above. The court specifically defined the term ‘debenture’ and in the process referred to the aforesaid provision of the Companies Act. Since this aspect has been dealt with elaborately in the judgment passed by Kerala High Court, our purpose would be served by incorporating the extracted relevant discussion contained therein, which runs as follows:-

“The short question that really arises for our consideration is what is a debenture. Are the loans in the real sense of the term debentures? The I.T Act does not define a debenture. The Companies Act, 1956, in Section 2(12) gives an inclusive definition. It states that “debenture” includes debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not. The same is the meaning given in the English Companies Act of 1948 (Section 455). Palmer would state that the term securities in the definition clause is apparently used in a sense slightly in excess of its strict legal meaning.

. Lindley J. observed in an early case British India Steam Navigation Co. v. IRC [1881] 7 QBD 165 at pp. 172-173 :

“What the correct meaning of Rs. debenture’ is I do not know. I do not find anywhere any precise definition of it. We know that there are various kinds of instruments commonly called debentures. You may have mortgage debentures, which are charges of some kind on property. You may have debentures which are bonds;……You may have a debenture which is nothing more than an acknowledgment of indebtedness. And you may have a thing like this, which is something more; it is a statement by two directors that the company will pay a certain sum of money on a given day, and will also pay interest half-yearly at certain times and at a certain place, upon production of certain coupons by the holder of the instrument.”

Chitty J. said in Levy v. Abercorris Slate and Slab Co. [1888] 37 Ch D 260 at p. 264 :

“I cannot find any precise legal definition of the term, it is not either in law or commerce a strictly technical term, or what is called a term of art.”

Palmer quotes the same judge stating in another case, Edmonds v. Blaina Furnaces Co. [1887] 36 Ch D 215:

“The term itself imports a debt--an acknowledgment of a debt--and speaking of the numerous and various forms of instruments which have been called debentures without anyone being able to say the term is incorrectly used, I find that generally, if not always, the instrument imports an obligation or covenant to pay. This obligation or covenant is in most cases at the present day accompanied by some charge or security.”

After quoting these decisions the learned author states (Palmer's Company Law, 20th Edn., pp. 367-368) :

“In modern commercial usage a debenture denotes an instrument issued by the company, normally--but not necessarily--called on the face of it a debenture, and providing for the payment of, or acknowledging the indebtedness in, a specified sum--say, £100--at a fixed date, with interest thereon. It usually--but not necessarily--gives a charge by way of security, and is often--though not invariably--expressed to be one of a series of like debentures.

But the term, as used in modern commercial parlance, is of extremely elastic character, for

(1) it is sometimes used, both by lawyers and businessmen, to describe an instrument which is not called, on the face of it, a debenture, e.g, a bond;

(2) it is used of an instrument which is not one of a series. A single debenture may be issued to one man;

(3) it is not the less a debenture because

(a) it is not under seal; or

(b) it does not contain a charge; or

(c) it does not provide for payment at any fixed date but only in the event of winding up, or on some contingency; or

(d) there is no personal liability on the company to pay but the company charges its property as security for the debt of another person.

Although the modern meaning of the term Rs. debenture’ is thus very wide, it would go too far to assert that every document creating or acknowledging an indebtedness of the company is a debenture. Commercial men and lawyers would certainly not use this term when referring to bills of exchange or other negotiable instruments, deeds of covenant and many other documents in which a company stipulates to pay a sum of money.”

A debenture is certainly a document which either creates a debt or acknowledges it. While it may usually be one of a series, it need not necessarily be so. As Palmer has pointed out, a single debenture may be issued to one party. As Chitty J. in Edmond's case [1887] 36 Ch D 215 and a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Laxman Bharmaji v. Emperor, AIR 1946 Bom 18 : 16 Comp Cas 31 point out :

“In determining what is or is not a debenture within the section we are not bound to hold that an instrument is a debenture because it is called a debenture by the company issuing it, nor to hold it is not a debenture because it is not so called by the company. We must look at the substance of the instrument itself, and, without the assistance of any precise legal definition form the best opinion we can whether the instrument is or is not a debenture.”

4. Thus, the Court was of the opinion that in absence of any definition of ‘debenture’ in the Income Tax Act, reliance could be placed upon the definition given in Section 2 (12) of the Companies Act and also the common parlance in which this term is understood. Even the Madras High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Lakshmi Vilas Bank Ltd. had an occasion to deal with this very aspect and it also categorically held that as the Income Tax Act does not define “debenture” to understand the meaning of this term, the Court would have to depend upon various other enactments.

5. We are in agreement with the aforesaid view taken by the Kerala as well as Madras High Courts and thus hold that it would be appropriate to rely upon the definition of ‘debenture’ as contained in Section 2 (12) of the Companies Act and, therefore, it cannot be held that the assessee contravened the provision of section 13 (1) (d) of the Act.

6. For the purposes of Section 13 (1) (d) of the Act, Mr. Sabharwal, learned counsel appearing for the Department, however, has sought to give an altogether different twist to the argument. His submission was that for the limited purpose, i.e in the context of Section 11 (5) of the Act, the meaning to be assigned to the expression ‘debenture’; has to be restricted viz. exclude ‘bond’. In support of this submission, he referred to sub Section (5) of Section 11 which specifically deals with the investment in certain specific kinds of bonds. He, thus, argued that only those forms and modes of investments as prescribed under sub Section (5) of Section 11 of the Act, would be entitled for exemption for the purposes of Section 11 and the investment in other forms of bonds, by necessary implication of inference had to be excluded from the exemption list. Sub Section 5 of Section 11 deals with the investment in bonds of financial corporation, State Government or Central Government. No doubt, specific provision is made in respect of investment in these particular kinds of bonds, however, that would not mean that when we deal with the investment in ‘debentures’, which also clarifies for exemption, we have to give restrictive meaning to the term ‘debenture’ more particularly when this term is not defined under the Act. It is a trite principle of interpretation that in the absence of any definition given to a particular term in a statute, the meaning which is to be given to the said term is the meaning which is understood in common parlance. The Supreme Court in the case of Noorie Manure Mill, Sambhal Vs. Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P (2007), 10 SCC 478 observed as under:-

“In absence of any definition of the term in the statute, the meaning there of as understood in common parlance for the purpose of imposition of tax should be assigned”

Even as per new Gem dictionary, the term ‘debenture includes bond of a company or a corporation.

7. We, thus, concur with the opinion expressed by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment and answer the reference in affirmative i.e against the revenue.

(A.K SIKRI) JUDGE

(REVA KHETRAPAL) JUDGE

August 18, 2010. skb