Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

N.K Vij, Superintending Engineer v. State Of Punjab .

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 7, 1991

N.K Sodhi, J.:— The petitioner was appointed as a Sub Divisional Engineer in the Punjab Service of Engineers Class II in the Punjab Public Works Department (B & R) in August, 1960. He was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer in Class I service in December, 1969 and he claims that he was declared as a ‘selected officer’ for discharging higher financial responsibility. As a member of the Punjab Service of Engineer Class I, he was further prompted on July 1, 1983, from the rank of Executive Engineer to that of Superintending Engineer. It is the case of the petitioner that he has been discharging his duties most efficiently and that he was never conveyed any adverse remarks after he got promoted to the post of Superintending Engineer nor were any defects brought to his notice. Some departmental proceedings were conducted against the petitioner in the past and, according to him, it was conclusively established that he was not guilty of the allegations made against him and that the reports had been manoeuvred. According to the petitioner, only one departmental enquiry was pending against him in respect of which a charge-sheet had been issued on December 19, 1985. He filed his reply in February, 1986 and an enquiry officer is said to have been appointed on April 2, 1989. The charge-sheet is said to relate to facts and allegations pertaining to the year 1980.- This enquiry is still pending. The petitioner also contends that the State Government constituted on Apex Body for considering the cases of various officers in regard to their premature retirement and the case of the petitioner was also considered by this high powered committee who after examining his entire service record opined that he could not be retired prematurely. The petitioner was placed under suspension on May 20, 1989 and while his suspension was still continuing the State Government by an order dated September 25, 1989 prematurely retired him from service on payment of three months pay and allowances in lieu of notice. This action was taken under Rule 3(1) of the Punjab Civil Services (Premature Retirement) Rules, 1975. It is this order which is challenged in the present writ petition.

2. In the written statement filed on behalf of the respondent State, an objection has, been taken that a writ petition filed by Shri V.K Jain another officer, in the department, who was also prematurely retired on the same day and on similar grounds, had been dismissed by this Court by a detailed speaking order and, therefore, the present petition also deserved to be dismissed.

On merits, it is stated that, several enquiries are pending against the petitioner with the Vigilance Department which have not been finalised so far. It is not disputed that the petitioner has not earned any adverse report after his promotion to the rank of Superintending Engineer in July, 1983. The stand of the government is that the annual confidential reports of the petitioner were not the only basis of his premature retirement and that it has specific/solid material against him for prematurely retiring him in public interest. A First Information Report is said to have been lodged against the petitioner in the year 1986 by the Vigilance Department and his prosecution was being handled by the said department and the same was still pending when he was compulsorily retired. The fact that a high level apex committee comprising of the senior-most officers of the State Government headed by the Chief Secretary was constituted and that the same considered the case of the petitioner and opined that he could not be prematurely retired is admitted. The stand taken in para 9 of the written statement is as under:—

“While taking decision for premature retirement of the petitioner, the enquiries pending against him were not the only basis of decision. The decision was taken by the Government after most careful deliberation, keeping in view all the available material, the rules and law applicable in the matter. Before taking the decision the matter was specifically got enquired from the Vigilance Deptt. and their report was also taken in account before passing the order of premature retirement.”

3. At the time of hearing, the respondent State placed before me the original service record of the petitioner as also the proceedings of the meeting of the apex committee which was held on 19-5-1989 under the Chairmanship of Sh. R.P Ojha, the then Chief Secretary to Government of Punjab.

4. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and having gone through the service record of the petitioner carefully as also the proceedings of the apex committee, I am of the considered view that the impugned order dated September 25, 1989 is wholly arbitrary and cannot be sustained under the law. It is well settled that an order of premature retirement of a government servant can be justified only on the basis of service record which obviously consists of his annual confidential reports about his work, conduct and integrity. If the annual confidential reports of a government servant are good or even average, he cannot be retired from service prematurely. The mere fact that some complaints had been received by the government against an officer which were either pending with the government on the date the decision to retire him was taken or those complaints had since been investigated or enquired into but without associating the concerned employee therewith would not be a sufficient ground to order his premature retirement. It is an essential requirement of the principles of natural justice that if any adverse material is to be taken into consideration by the employer to the prejudice of the employee, the latter must be associated with such consideration otherwise it would be wholly unfair to the employer to base the decision of premature retirement on complaints which can be easily managed by his colleagues and subordinates likely to be benefited by his premature retirement. From the service record of the petitioner, it is clear that he has not earned any adverse report after July 1983 when he was promoted as Superintending Engineer. After this he has earned three ‘good’ reports and three ‘average’ reports. One report has not been recorded on account of his being under suspension. In his annual confidential report for the period 8.7.1983 to 24.1.1984 he has been graded on the basis of his performance as ‘Very good’. Again he got a ‘good’ report for the period 1.4.1984 to 25.12.1984 and for the period 26.12.1984 to 31.3.1985 he was graded as an ‘average officer’. Again his overall assessment for the year 1985-86 was ‘good’ and it was stated that some complaints received against him a???ed to be motivated as a reaction to an enquiry initiated by the petitioner ???st an S.D.O on grounds of technical and financial irregularities committed by the latter. His annual confidential reports for the subsequent years have been ‘average’. Having gone through the record, I find that the apex committee stated in its report that the petitioner could not be retired prematurely. It is correct that a large number of enquiries were pending against the petitioner which have not concluded but these could not be taken into consideration for his premature retirement for ought we know that he might be exonerated in them. The apex committee recommended that the officer should be placed under suspension as his reputation was not good and that all the pending enquiries against him including those by the Vigilance Department should be pursued vigorously and got disposed of in a time bound manner. It appears that after the report of the apex committee the Chief Director of Vigilance Punjab sent a secret note to the Adviser to Governor Punjab stating therein that the petitioner was a corrupt officer who had amassed wealth disproportionate to his means and mentioned the details thereof in the note. This file with the secret note seems to have been put up before the concerned Secretary who on the basis of that note decided to prematurely retire the petitioner and also sought the approval of the Governor which was granted. It is thereafter that the order dated September 25, 1989 was passed prematurely retiring the petitioner. The petitioner was admittedly not associated with the enquiry which the Vigilance Department seems to have held with the result that the principles of natural justice have been given a go-bye. The impugned order of premature retirement cannot, therefore, be sustained.

5. It will not be out of place to mention here that in the case of Sh. V.K Jain, another officer of the Department, who was also prematurely retired on the same day and on almost similar grounds, the order of premature retirement has been quashed by their Lordships of the Supreme Court.

6. In the result, the writ petition succeeds and the order dated September 25, 1989 ordering the compulsory retirement of the petitioner is set aside. It is, however made clear that it shall be open to the respondent-State to proceed against the petitioner in accordance with law if any action is contemplated to be taken against him. The petitioner shall have his costs which are assessed at Rs. 500/-

7. Petition allowed.