- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Devender Kumar And Another v. State Of Haryana
Jasbir Singh, J.
JUDGMENT
This judgment will dispose of two appeals, i.e, Cr. A. No. 414-DB of 2008, filed by Davender Kumar (A-1) and Gian Singh (A-2) and 194-DB of 2008, filed by Sheoraj (A-3), arising out of a common judgment and order dated January 10, 2008 and January 12, 2008, respectively, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Faridabad, vide which they were convicted for commission of offences under Sections 364, 302 and 201 read with Section 34 IPC. Their co-accused, namely, Girish was acquitted of the charges framed against him. Vide impugned order dated January 12, 2008, A-1 to A-3, besides awarding lesser sentences/punishment for other offences, were ordered to undergo imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs. 2000/- each with a default clause for commission of an offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
It was allegation against them that they, with a common intention, had kidnapped, with intention to murder, Bhagirath alias Lala son of Likhi Ram, on March 14, 2002, at about 9.30 AM in the area of Bus Adda Chowk, Palwal. It was further allegation against them that they in fact had murdered Bhagirath and threw his dead body in Hazara canal with an intention to cause disappearance of evidence to save themselves from punishment. It was alleged against co-accused Girish that in the month of March, 2002, he had dishonestly forged chasis number, engine number and registration number of Tata Sumo vehicle bearing No. HR 26G 9301, owned by the deceased.
Process of law was set in motion on a statement Ex. PA, made by Khem Chand (PW3) (brother of the deceased) on April 4, 2002, which was recorded by ASI Ramesh Chand (PW2), at about 6.05, on the basis of which FIR Ex. PB was recorded in Police Station City Palwal on April 4, 2002 at 6.20 PM.
Dead body of Bhagirath alias Lala was not recovered in this case. There is no eye witness account to the occurrence, in which he was murdered. Girish, against whom it was an allegation that he had forged chasis number, registration number and registration certificate of the vehicle, owned by the deceased, was acquitted vide the impugned judgment.
Case of the prosecution rests upon circumstantial evidence, especially alleged recoveries made from A-1 to A-3. As per information supplied, the appellants have undergone about 7 ½ years of actual sentence.
The trial Judge has noticed following facts regarding case of the prosecution:
“Brief facts of the prosecution case are that on 14.3.2002 Bhagirath (since deceased), younger brother of complainant PW3 Khem Chand, had gone to Aligarh in his Tata Sumo vehicle No. HR 26G 9301 as accused Devender son of Devki Nandan had hired the aforesaid Tata Sumo vehicle. However, when Bhagirath @ Lala did not come back, then the complainant made his search but neither the deceased Bhagirath and vehicle nor Devender was found. Accordingly, complainant Khem Chand moved application Ex. PA to PW2 ASI Ramesh Chand, who made endorsement Ex. PD and sent the same to the Police Station on which PW1 ASI Wazir Singh recorded formal FIR Ex. PB and he also made endorsement Ex. PC.”
All the three appellants were in custody in connection with some other case. A-3 was formally arrested in this case on August 8, 2004. On interrogation, he suffered a disclosure statement Ex. PF, in pursuance of which he identified the spot where deceased was put to death in jungle, in the area of village Habibpur. Memo in that regard is Ex. PK and rough site plan is Ex. PK/1. On August 14, 2004, A-3 got recovered from his house one purse Ex. P1 containing photograph of the deceased, which was taken into possession against seizure memo Ex. PP.
A-2 was also formally arrested in this case on August 8, 2004. He suffered a disclosure statement Ex. PE, in pursuance of which he also demarcated the places where Bhagirath was killed and his body was thrown in a canal. He also got recovered trousers Ex. P4 from his house, which were taken into possession vide seizure memo Ex. P1.
Girish was also formally arrested in this case on August 8, 2004. He suffered a disclosure statement Ex. PD, which led to the recovery of vehicle Tata Sumo HR 26-G 9301. He again suffered a disclosure statement Ex. PR on August 16, 2004, identifying the place where registration certificate and dye used for changing the chasis number was thrown in a canal. In pursuance to the disclosure statement made by Girish a Tata Sumo vehicle without number, bearing chasis No. 421055M-22401236 was recovered from Police Station Kasganj, District Etah (UP).
It is necessary to mention here that actual chasis number of the stolen vehicle was 385003-HRQ-401385.
A-1 was formally arrested on August 13, 2004. His disclosure statement Ex. PS led to the verification of the places of occurrence. He also identified Tata Sumo No. UP 24C 1651, which was sold by him to Gian Singh accused, who further sold it to Mahesh Kumar. The Investigating Officer took into his possession above vehicle after moving an appropriate application before the competent Court.
After completion of investigation, final report was put in Court. Compliance was made to the provisions of Section 207 Cr.P.C by supplying copies of documents to the accused. Case was committed to the competent Court for trial vide order dated February 22, 2005. The accused were charge-sheeted, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
To prove its case, the prosecution produced 14 witnessess and also brought on record documentary evidence. On conclusion of prosecution evidence, separate statements of the accused were recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C Incriminating material existing on record was put to them. They denied allegations of the prosecution and pleaded false implication in this case. It was stated by them that they had never indulged in any criminal activity as alleged and made no statement to the police. They also led evidence in defence. The trial Judge on appraisal of evidence, found A-1 to A-3 guilty. They were convicted and sentenced as mentioned in earlier part of this order. Girish was given benefit of doubt and acquitted. Hence this appeal.
Counsel for the appellants have vehemently contended that it is a case of no evidence against the appellants. They were in custody of the police in some other case. The Investigating Officer to show that he has cracked this case, falsely involved them in the present case. Dead body was not recovered. The vehicle recovered from Police Station Kasganj, district Etah (UP) was not connected with the stolen vehicle, owned by the deceased. There is no explanation for huge delay in getting the FIR recorded and further the alleged disclosure statements and recoveries made consequent thereto do not inspire any confidence. He prayed that the appeals be allowed and the appellants - accused be acquitted of the charges framed against them.
Prayer made has vehemently been opposed by the State counsel, who by making reference to the statements made by the prosecution witnesses and documentary evidence on record, argued that case of the prosecution is proved on record. On disclosure statement made by the appellants, places of occurrence were identified and further their statements led to the recovery of the stolen vehicle, trousers of the deceased and his purse. He prayed that the appeals having no substance be dismissed.
As per case of the prosecution, deceased Bhagirath alias Lala along with his vehicle went missing on March 14, 2002. PW4 Devan had seen one person negotiating with the deceased to go to Aligarh. Rs. 1300/- were settled as fare. The customer and the deceased went to Aligarh. This witness has specifically stated that he had given name of A-1 Devender in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C
An application Ex. PA was moved by PW3 Khem Chand brother of the deceased to ASI Ramesh Chand (PW2) on April 4, 2002, i.e, after about three weeks when the deceased went missing. Nobody is named in this application and further no explanation where the family was searching the deceased during the intervening period. If name of A-1 was known to Devan (PW4), it was natural for PW3 to disclose the same in his application Ex. PA. During investigation also, delay in recording the FIR has not been explained. The dead body was not recovered from the canal where it was allegedly thrown. Name of A-1 is also not mentioned in the statement of PW4 Devan recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C
It is not in dispute that all the accused were in custody of the police in connection with some other case. How the police came to know about their involvement in this case is a big secret. A-2 and A-3 were formally arrested in this case on August 8, 2004. A-1 was shown to have been formally arrested on August 13, 2004. During investigation, it also came on record that three more persons, namely, Kishan Lal, Fateh Singh and Ved Veer were also involved in the crime. However, the Investigating Officer has failed to arrest the above culprits. In his statement, PW3 Khem Chand, brother of the deceased, has failed to give any plausible explanation for not intimating the police in time. His deposition regarding making of alleged disclosure statements and recoveries effected from the accused is also not trust-worthy. In his cross-examination, he has stated that he intimated the police on March 16, 2002, and not on April 4, 2002. However, above fact is not correct as per statement Ex. PA. He has further stated that he came to know the name of A-1 Devender, as an accused, on March 26, 2002. If that was so, it was incumbent upon him to disclose it in his application Ex. PA made to the police on April 4, 2002. He has further stated that A1 was arrested on February 5, 2004, which is not correct as per record. Qua Girish, he has specifically stated that this accused has not got recovered any vehicle as alleged by the prosecution. Qua recovery from A-2, he has said that it was recovered from some village but he did not remember the name. He has further stated that A-3 had got recovered one shirt of the deceased from his house. However, he did not know the name of his village. He is silent about the recovery of purse and photograph of the deceased from A-2. In view of above, his statement is not trustworthy.
Similarly, PW4 Devan's deposition does not inspire confidence. This witness has also not intimated the police regarding disappearance of the deceased and his vehicle. In cross-examination, this witness has admitted that the police had shown him the photograph after arrest of A-1. However, this witness failed to tell the date on which he was shown the photograph. PW5 HC Ram Babu, PW6 C. Surender Singh, PW7 HC Rajinder Kumar, PW8 HC Udham Singh and PW9 ASI Ajit Singh were witnesses to the alleged disclosure statements and recoveries effected. In view of facts of this case, their statements appear to be unreliable. PW11 Darshan Singh is an independent witness. He was associated in the investigation on August 13, 2004. However, this witness has categorically stated that A1 on the above date made no disclosure statement. He was declared hostile. It is case of the prosecution that SI Ram Phool (PW12) recovered trousers and purse of the deceased consequent to disclosure statements made by A2 and A3. Girish got recovered Tata Sumo vehicle from Police Station Kasganj, district Eta (UP). In cross-examination, this witness has admitted that at the time of alleged recoveries, no independent person was joined in the investigation. It is further admitted that all the three accused were interrogated and made disclosure statements at Khitwari Chowk, Palwal at 6.30 PM on August 8, 2004, but none from the public was joined in the process. On August 14, 2004, A-3 got recovered photograph, papers and purse of the deceased from his house. Persons from the locality were present. However, they were not joined in the investigation. Complete go bye was made to the provisions of Section 100 Cr.P.C It has also come on record that house was open and family members of A-3 were available but none was joined as a witness. The investigation appears to have been done in a casual manner. The entire process gave an idea that the appellants-accused were already in custody, they were arraigned as accused in this case in order to show that case has been solved.
Not only as above, the prosecution has failed to connect the vehicle recovered with the stolen vehicle. As per facts on record, Tata Sumo vehicle owned by the deceased was having No. HR 26G 9301. As per statement of Chander Pal Singh HCP (PW13), the recovered Tata Sumo vehicle was not having any number plate. It has also come on record that chasis number of the recovered vehicle was 421055M-22401236, whereas as per registration certificate, chasis number of the stolen vehicle was 385003 HRQ401385. It was case of the prosecution that the chasis number, registration number and the registration certificate were forged by Girish, who was given benefit of doubt and acquitted. If that is so, there is nothing on record to show that the recovered vehicle belongs to the deceased.
It is a case of circumstantial evidence, a Division Bench of this Court in Criminal Appeal No. 289-DB of 2005 (Avtar Singh alias Tari v. State of Punjab), decided on February 16, 2012, has observed as under:
“It is a case of blind murder. There is no eye witness account. The prosecution case rests upon the circumstantial evidence. None had seen the deceased with the accused. In such like cases, the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn must be cogently and firmly established. Circumstances need to be of a definite tendency positively pointing towards guilt of the accused. All the circumstances taken together should form a complete chain so that there is no escape from a conclusion that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and not by anybody else. The circumstantial evidence must be complete and incapable of explanation of any hypothesis other than that of guilt of the accused. The evidence should be inconsistent with the innocence of the accused and it should not be capable of two opinions. Their lordships of the Supreme Court in Krishnan v. State, (2008) 15 SCC 430, a case where accused was sought to be convicted on the basis of circumstantial evidence, after considering a large number of its earlier judgments, observed as under:
“15…This Court in a series of decisions has consistently held that when a case rests upon circumstantial evidence, such evidence must satisfy the following tests:
(i) the circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be drawn, must be cogently and firmly established;
(ii) those circumstances should be of definite tendency unerringly pointing towards guilt of the accused;
(iii) the circumstances, taken cumulatively, should form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability the crime was committed by the accused and none else; and
the circumstantial evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence. (See Gambhir v. State Of Maharashtra(1982) 2 SCC 351: 1982 SCC (Cri) 431: AIR 1982 SC 1157).”
The above view was reiterated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Babu v. State Of Kerala, (2010) 9 SCC 189, and also in the case of Sk. Yusuf v. State Of West Bengal, 2011 (74) ACC 293. In the latter judgment, it was observed as under:
“Undoubtedly, conviction can be based solely on circumstantial evidence. However, the court must bear in mind while deciding the case involving the commission of serious offence based on circumstantial evidence that the prosecution case must stand or fall on its own legs and cannot derive any strength from the weakness of the defence case. The circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established. The facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty. The circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency. There must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
Similarly, in the case of Wakkar v. State of U.P, 2011 (3) SCC 306, it was opined by the Supreme Court that merely on the basis of some offending articles, an accused cannot be declared guilty of commission of murder. Similarly in the case of Mustkeem Alias Sirajudeen v. State Of Rajasthan, 2011 AIR (SC) (Cri) 1683, it was opined by the Supreme Court that “where the case rests squarely on circumstantial evidence, the inference of guilt can be justified only when all the incriminating facts and circumstances are found to be incompatible with the innocence of the accused or the guilt of any other person”.
In the present case, evidence of the prosecution has been analysed keeping in mind the parameters set down by this Court in Avtar Singh alias Tari's case (supra). The Court is satisfied that the chain of circumstances is not complete and it does not indicate towards guilt of the appellants - accused only. None had seen the appellants in the company of the deceased. Statement of PW4 Devan that he had seen A-1 in the company of the deceased is not trust-worthy. There is delay in recording the FIR, which has not been explained. The disclosure statements were made by A-1 to A-3, on interrogation, are not believable. The prosecution has failed to connect the recovered vehicle with the stolen vehicle. Nobody had seen the appellants committing murder of the deceased. Merely because they were seen near to the place of occurrence is no ground to burden them with criminal liability. The process of investigation was not fair. All the accused were in custody of the police in connection with some other case. How their involvement in this case came to the notice of the Investigating Officer is not disclosed on record. The police officials are discrepant stating the mode and manner in which they went to Kasganj Police Station, district Etah (UP) and also with regard to effecting the recoveries.
In view of facts, mentioned above, these appeals are allowed and the impugned judgment and order qua the appellants are set aside and the appellants are acquitted of the charges framed against them. The appellant, who is in custody, be set at liberty forthwith if he is not required in any other case.
Alert