Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dharampal v. State Of Punjab

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 10, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary: Nirmaljit Kaur, J. (10.03.2010)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal challenges the Order dated 20.11.1996 of the Special Judge, Rupnagar, which convicted the appellant Dharampal under Section 13(2) read with Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act and sentenced him to rigorous imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs. 3,000/-, with a further direction that in default of payment of fine he should undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months.

The prosecution case, as recorded by the trial court, was that on 18.08.1993 the complainant Gurdip Singh (with Pola Singh as a "shadow witness") came to the Vigilance Bureau, Rupnagar seeking copies of certain mutation entries and orders to be prepared by Dharam Pal Kanungo, Record Keeper, Revenue. The prosecution alleged that Dharam Pal demanded Rs. 400 as illegal gratification and that the complainant, acting under the direction of the vigilance inspector, carried four notes of Rs. 100 each which were handed over (or placed) and a raiding party subsequently apprehended the accused.

Procedurally, the appellant Dharampal died on 29.10.2008. Crl. Misc. Application No. 56956 of 2008 under Section 394(2) read with Section 482 CrPC sought leave for his son Amarjit Singh to continue the appeal; that application was allowed by order dated 22.12.2008. The present judgment disposes of the appeal on merits and sets aside the conviction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved the essential ingredient of "demand" or "request" of a pecuniary advantage by a public servant, as required to establish an offence under the relevant provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  2. Whether the evidence adduced (including the complainant turning hostile, the shadow witness not being available for cross-examination, and the conduct of personal search) sufficed to sustain the conviction.
  3. Whether the presumption under Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act could be raised in the absence of proof of demand.
  4. Whether procedural irregularities in the search (specifically, the investigating officer not offering himself for search before an official/independent witness) rendered the search and recovery inadmissible or illegal and thereby necessitated acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Arguments

  • The prosecution relied on the raid, the demonstration using Phelon Phathalian powder on the four currency notes, and the evidence that the accused had handled the currency (alleged change in water colour when the accused's hands were dipped) to establish that gratification in cash had been paid or accepted by the public servant.
  • On that basis the State urged that once gratification (cash) was established, the legal presumption (referred to in Madhukar Bhaskarrao Joshi v. State of Maharashtra) would operate that the gratification was given or accepted as a motive or reward to do an official act.

Defence / Points relied on by the Accused

  • The complainant (PW-1) resiled from the prosecution case and denied that Dharam Pal demanded Rs. 400; this undermined proof of demand.
  • The shadow witness (PW-2, Pola Singh) could not be cross-examined because he was not available, so his evidence could not be treated as competent corroboration.
  • The independent/official witness (PW-8, Jagdish Chand) did not support that the investigating officer offered himself for personal search before conducting search of the accused; this raised a question about the legality of the search and recovery.
  • Therefore, according to defence contentions as recorded, the prosecution failed to prove the essential ingredient of demand and acceptance required under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A. Subair v. State of Kerala, 2009 (3) Supreme Court Cases (Crl.) 85 The primary requisite of an offence under Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act is proof of a demand or request of a valuable thing or pecuniary advantage from the public servant. Relied upon to emphasize that in absence of proof of demand the offence under Section 13(1)(d) cannot be held established.
Shiv Narain Sharma v. State of Haryana, 2009 (2) R.C.R (Criminal) 372 (relying on Subash Parbat Sonvane) Illustrates that mere acceptance of money without other corroborative evidence is insufficient to convict under Section 13(1)(d)(i). Used to support the proposition that when complainant turns hostile and other witnesses do not establish demand or acceptance, conviction cannot safely follow.
Subash Parbat Sonvane v. State Of Gujarat, 2003 (2) RCR (Criminal) 541 Authoritative treatment relied upon regarding requirement of proof of demand/acceptance and the quality of corroboration needed. Referenced through the Shiv Narain Sharma discussion to underscore need for clear proof of demand/acceptance.
Badri v. State Of Rajasthan, 1976 A.I.R. (S.C.) 560 Untested evidence (evidence not subjected to cross-examination on material points) cannot be accepted as corroboration. Relied upon to hold that the shadow witness (PW-2), whose cross-examination remained incomplete or unavailable, cannot be accepted as corroborative evidence.
Kuldip Kumar & ors. v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1993 (3) R.C.R (Criminal) 349 Where a witness is examined but not available for cross-examination, such evidence may be rendered inadmissible and conviction cannot be based on it. Applied to the facts where PW-2 was not available for cross-examination; the Court treated PW-2's evidence as not available for corroboration.
State Of Punjab v. Kushal Singh Pathania, 2004 (4) RCR (Criminal) 498 If the police officer fails to offer himself for search by the accused, then the search conducted on the accused is apparently illegal and acquittal may follow. Used to support the proposition that because PW-8 did not corroborate that the investigating officer offered himself for search, the search of the accused was tainted and could not support conviction.
Madhukar Bhaskarrao Joshi v. State Of Maharashtra, 2000 (4) RCR (Criminal) 705 Once gratification in any form (cash or kind) is established, court is under a legal compulsion to presume it was given/accepted as motive or reward for an official act. Relied on by the State to urge presumption of corrupt motive; the Court considered but ultimately rejected its application here because demand was not proved.
V. Venkata Subbarao v. State represented by Inspector of Police, A.P., 2007 (2007) 3 SCC (Criminal) 175 Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act raises a presumption only if a demand is proved; absent proof of demand presumption cannot be raised. Held decisive: because demand was not proved in the present case, the presumption under Section 20 could not be invoked to sustain conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court evaluated the evidence and legal principles in the following sequence:

  1. Assessment of the complainant's testimony: PW-1 Gurdip Singh had been declared hostile. His formal statements in court denied knowledge of the accused and denied that the accused demanded Rs. 400. In other portions he described being directed by the vigilance inspector to approach the accused and that he had placed currency notes in the pocket of a shirt on a chair; these variations showed that the complainant had resiled from the prosecution's core case on demand.
  2. Treatment of the shadow witness (PW-2): Pola Singh, the shadow witness, had been examined but could not be cross-examined because he was not available in India. The Court explained, by reference to Badri and Kuldip Kumar, that such untested evidence cannot be accepted as corroboration; consequently PW-2's evidence could not be relied upon to prove demand or acceptance.
  3. Examination of the official/independent witness and the search: PW-8 Jagdish Chand, an official witness, stated that the inspector did not offer himself for personal search before taking the personal search of the accused. The Investigating Officer claimed he had offered himself, but this was not supported by PW-8. Relying on State of Punjab v. Kushal Singh Pathania, the Court treated this failure as casting doubt on the legality of the search and recovery, making the search infirm for purposes of proving acceptance.
  4. Assessment of the prosecution's attempt to raise presumptions: The State relied on evidence of handling (change in water colour after accused dipped hands) and cited Madhukar Joshi to argue that once gratification is established a presumption arises. The Court rejected this approach because, following V. Venkata Subbarao, the statutory presumption under Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act can only be raised if a demand is proved; here demand had not been proved.
  5. Overall evaluation: On the combined facts — a hostile complainant denying demand, an untestable shadow witness, and a conflict over whether the investigating officer offered himself for search — the Court concluded that the prosecution had failed to establish the requisite elements of the offence (notably proof of demand) and that the trial court had failed to properly consider these aspects.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is accepted and the accused Dharampal (since deceased) stands acquitted of the charge framed against him. The Order dated 20.11.1996 passed by the Special Judge, Rupnagar is set aside.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The conviction and sentence recorded against Dharampal by the trial court are vacated; the accused is acquitted. The appeal succeeds on the basis that the prosecution failed to prove the essential ingredient of demand and the other evidentiary and procedural defects noted.
  • Broader implications: The Court's decision rests on application of established precedents concerning proof of demand under the Prevention of Corruption Act, the inadmissibility of untested evidence, and the requirement that officers offer themselves for search where appropriate. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying these existing authorities to the facts of the case.

Decision authored by: NIRMALJIT KAUR, J. — dated 10.03.2010.

Show all summary ...

NIRMALJIT KAUR, J.

This is an appeal against the Order dated 20.11.1996 passed by Special Judge, Rupnagar vide which the present appellant has been convicted under Section 13(2) read with Section 7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs. 3,000/- with a further direction that in default of payment of fine, he shall further undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months.

Before proceeding with the appeal, it is necessary to record that the appellant-Dharampal died on 29.10.2008 Accordingly, the Crl. Misc. Application No. 56956 of 2008 under Section 394(2) read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was moved, praying that leave may be granted to his son Amarjit Singh to continue the appeal which would have otherwise abated on the death of his father. The said application was allowed vide Order dated 22.12.2008

The prosecution case as recorded by Special Judge, Rupnagar is that “on 18.08.1993 Gurdip Singh complainant and Pola Singh son of Maghi Ram resident of Bann Majra came to the Office of Vigilance Bureau, at Rupnagar. Gurdip Singh made a statement that he was a resident of Village Ban Majra and was a labourer. On 30.07.1993, he gave two applications No. 1460 and 1461 for the supply of copies of mutation No. 351 and copy of order dated 20.08.1994, copy of mutation No. 183 and copy of Order dated 06.11.1993 and 06.08.1993 He also wanted to get copy of mutation No. 350 and order dated 08.07.1944 and copy of mutation No. 360 and order dated 22.11.1945, relating to village Mathari, Hadbast no. 124. Those copies were to be prepared and supplied by Dharam Pal Kanungo, Record Keeper, Revenue, Mini Secretariat, Rupnagar, Gurdip Singh want to Dharam Pal Kanungo and made a request for the supply of those copies. Kanungo told Gurdip Singh that he was to prepare the copies and he would not do his work unless he was paid Rs. 400/- as illegal gratification. He made many requests to him. But he remained adamant. On 17.08.1993 he came to the office of the Kanungo and requested Dharam Pal Kanungo for doing his work. Kanungo again told him that he would not do his work unless he was paid a sum of Rs. 400/- as bribe. Gurdip Singh needed the copies of mutations and decisions for producing the same in the case pending in the Court. He made a false promise to the Kanungo for giving the bribe. He produced four notes of Rs. 100/-denomination each before Sukhwinder Singh Inspector Vigilance and stated that he was not in favour of giving the bribe. His statement was recorded by the Inspector and sent a ruqa for the registration of the case. Sukhwinder Sing Inspector applied the Phelon Phathalian powder to those four currency notes of Rs. 100/- denomination each. He gave a demonstration to the complainant and the witness. He prepared the memo relating to the notes. The witnesses were made to wash their hands with soap. Notes were handed over to the complainant with a direction that he should go to Dharam Pal Kanungo and hand over the notes to him. He was further instructed not to shake his hands with Dharam Pal. Pola Singh was sent with him as a shadow witness with a direction that he should give the signal as soon as the money was passed over to Dharam Pal by Gurdip Singh. Jagdish Chand Mechani Office of the Chief Agriculture Officer, Rupnagar was joined as a witness in the raiding party. The complainant and the shadow witness were sent together to the office of the accused. The raiding party hid themselves nearby and started waiting for the signal. After some time a signal was received from Pola Singh shadow witness whereupon Sukhwinder Singh Inspector Vigilance Bureau along with Jagdish Chand and other members of the raiding party reached where the accused was sitting. Gurdip Singh complainant told that he was Dharam Pal Kanungo who demanded Rs. 400/- from him as a bribe for the supply of copies. Inspector Sukhwinder Singh introduced himself and the witnesses to the accused. Dharam Pal was apprehended with the help of the police officials.”

Learned counsel for the parties are heard. Record is perused. The prosecution examined Gurdip Singh, complainant as PW-1. He was declared hostile and was cross-examined by public prosecutor. Pola Singh, Shadow witness was examined as PW-2 but he could not be tendered for his cross-examination because of his non-availability in India. The other relevant witnesses are Jagdish Chand, who appeared as PW-8 and supported the prosecution case, as well as, Sukhminder Singh, DSP, Vigilance, PW-10, the Investigating Officer who also supported the prosecution case.

PW-1 Gurdip Singh stated as under :-

“I do not know Dharam Pal Kanungo who is now present in the Court. Accused was not prepared the said copies. He did not demand from me Rs. 400/- as illegal gratification.”

Gurdip Singh, PW-1 further stated as under :-

“The Vigilance Inspector directed me to approach Dharam Pal Kanungo accused now present in the Court. I then sent to his Office. He was busy in arranging the files. It was summer season. He was taken off his shirt which was hanging by the chair. I again requested the accused to supply me the copies and he put me off. I then put the currency notes in the pocket of the shirt which was hanging by the chair. The accused could not come to know of it. I said to him that I had put certain money for his frast, in the pocket of the shirt.

The accused then called me when I turned. However, I did not stop. The vigilance staff was standing outside the room. They arrested the accused.”

From the reading of the above statement of the complainant-Gurdip Singh, it is evident that he turned hostile. Reference has been made to the judgment of Hon'ble the Apex Court, rendered in the case of A. Subair v. State of Karala 2009 (3) Supreme Court Cases (Crl.) 85 to substantiate that the demand was necessary to substantiate offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The said judgment reads thus :- “The legal position is no more res integra that primary requisite of an offence under Section 13(1)(d) of the Act is proof of a demand or request of a valuable thing or pecuniary advantage from the public servant. In other words, in the absence of proof of demand or request from the public servant for a valuable thing or pecuniary advantage, the offence under Section 13(1)(d) cannot be held to be established.”

This Court in the case of Shiv Narain Sharma v. State of Haryana 2009(2) R.C.R (Criminal) 372, while relying on the judgment of Subash Parbat Sonvane v. State Of Gujarat. 2003(2) RCR (Criminal) 541, observed as under :-

“17. xxx xxx xxx xxx

Hon'ble Supreme Court observed in this case that mere acceptance of money without there being any other evidence would not be sufficient for convicting the accused under Section 13(1)(d)(i). By making reference to various other judgments, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under :-

“10. In the background of aforesaid settled legal position, we would now refer to the relevant part of the evidence. Before the trial Court, it was submitted by the learned A.P.P that complainant has not supported the prosecution case on main ingredients of demand and acceptance and was treated hostile. In cross-examination also, he has not supported the prosecution version on demand or acceptance of the amount. The trial Court has also observed that the complainant deliberately does not support on the points of demand and acceptance. However, the Court relied upon the evidence of panch Shailesh Devshankar Pandya (P.W.2). We were taken through the evidence of P.W.2-Pandya and from his evidence, it is difficult to find out any statement made by him that accused demanded any amount from the complainant. The relevant part of the evidence of this witness suggests that when the prosecution party went at the police chowki, accused asked the complainant as to why he had come there at that time? To that, complainant replied that he was waiting since One O'clock and that he has brought one witness to be examined. Accused informed him to come in the evening as his writer was not present. When the accused started to go towards toilet, the complainant following him and he gave something from his pocket to the accused who took the same and put that in his pocket. From this evidence, it cannot be inferred that accused demanded any amount from the complainant or that he had obtained the same. It is apparent that the trial Court and the High Court misread the evidence of P.W.2 and held that there was demand by the accused and the amount was paid to him by the complainant, it was unreasonable to hold that accused demanded money from the complainant. Complainant denied the said story and P.W.2 had not stated so.”

18. In this case also, there is no evidence of demand and acceptance. The complainant or the shadow witness who could have supported this part of the prosecution case are totally against the prosecution and were declared hostile. The evidence of shadow witness is of no assistance to the prosecution as he has completely turned away from the prosecution case. Rather, in this case, there is a valid and probable explanation offered by the defence, which can explain the recovery of the amount, even if it be from the persons of the appellants.”

From the evidence of the complainant, it is evident that the money was not demanded by Dharampal accused. Moreover, the money was kept in the pocket of his shirt lying on a chair. Thus, the prosecution has not been able to prove the demand of gratification.

PW-2 is the Pola Singh, shadow witness. It is an admitted position that Pola Singh could not be cross-examined as he was not available for the same, wherein, in a given case, the examination of the witness remains incomplete because of his non-appearance in the cross-examination, such a witness cannot be treated as a competent witness and his evidence cannot be considered.

Reliance has been placed by the learned counsel on the judgment of Hon'ble the Apex Court rendered in the case Badri v. State Of Rajasthan 1976 A.I.R (S.C) 560. Para 6 of the judgment reads as under :-

“6. The trial Court has committed a serious error in disallowing the above questions on the ground that these were mere omissions not amounting to contradictions. These questions were clearly admissible under Section 162, Criminal P.C, read with Section 145, Evidence Act. The High Court has failed to notice this aspect while accepting the evidence of Lachhiram. The evidence of Lachhiram, therefore, stands untested by cross-examination on a very material point and it is not possible to accept this untested evidence as corroborating Patram.”

Admittedly, the shadow witness could not be cross-examined as he was not available for the same. Thus, his statement cannot be accepted as the corroboration of the statement of other witnesses. Statement of PW-2, Pola Singh cannot be taken into consideration for convicting Dharampal. Attention has been brought to the judgment of Himachal Pradesh High Court titled as Kuldip Kumar and ors. v. State of Himachal Pradesh 1993(3) R.C.R (Criminal) 349, wherein, the conviction was set aside which was based on the evidence of a witness who was examined but was not available for cross-examination. Para 5 of the same reads as under :-

“5. Now the question arise what is the effect if the record speaks that no cross-examination was conducted on behalf of one of the accused though he as well as his counsel were present. Admittedly, it is not a case where right to cross-examine was refused. Had it been there, the answer would have been simple and straight. On the other hand, it is also not a case where it could be presumed that opportunity was given and there is no defect in the evidence. It is a case in which, from the record, it appears that for some reason, may be any, cross-examine was not given to the accused. In the result such evidence is rendered inadmissible and no judgment can be based on it.’

Learned counsel for the petitioner has also invited the attention of the Court to the statement of PW-8 Jagdish Chand, the Investigating Officer, who did not offer himself for search. PW-8 Jagdish Chand who is the independent witness, specifically stated as under :-

“The Inspector did not give me his personal search before taking the personal search of accused Dharam Pal.”

Although, the Investigating Officer stated that he had offered himself for personal search to the official witness Jagdish Chand, however, Jagdish Chand did not support the version of the Investigating Officer on this aspect. This Court, while relying on the judgment of State Of Punjab… v. Kushal Singh Pathania… 2004(4) RCR (Criminal) 498, held in para 20 as under :-

“20. xxx xxx xxx

that if the police officer failed to offer himself for the search by the accused then the search conducted on the accused is apparently illegal and acquittal is bound to follow.”

Thus, the demand has not been proved either by way of independent witness or by the official witness. The complainant has already turned hostile.

Learned counsel for the State vehemently submitted that the witnesses had washed their hands and that when both the hands of Dharampal were dipped in the glass of water, the colour of the water had changed to light pink, thereby showing that Dharampal had handled the money. Reliance was placed on the judgment of Madhukar Bhaskarrao Joshi v. State Of Maharashtra. 2000(4) RCR (Criminal) 705 to state that once the prosecution established that gratification in any form, cash or kind had been paid or accepted by a public servant the court is under a legal compulsion to presume that the said gratification was paid or accepted as a motive or reward to do (or forbear from doing) and official act.

However, the said submission cannot be accepted in view of the judgment of Hon'ble the Apex Court, rendered in the case of V. Venkata Subbarao v. State represented by Inspector of Police, A.P, 2007(1) RCR(Criminal) 519 : 2007(1) RAJ 321 : (2007) 3 SCC (Criminal) 175, wherein, Hon'ble the Supreme Court has been pleased to lay down as under :-

“24. Submission of the learned counsel for the State that presumption has rightly been raised against the appellant, cannot be accepted as, inter alia, the demand itself had not been proved. In the absence of a proof of demand, the question of raising the presumption would not arise. Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 provides for raising of a presumption only if a demand is proved.”

Thus, it is evident from the above discussion that the prosecution has not been able to prove the case against Dharampal accused. Gurdip Singh PW-1 resiled and did not support the prosecution case. The shadow witness did not make himself available for cross examination. The Investigating Officer did not present himself for search before the independent/official witness. The trial Court has failed to take into consideration that aspect, as a result of which, injustice has occurred.

Accordingly, the Order dated 20.11.1996 passed by Special Judge, Rupnagar, is not based on correct appreciation of evidence and law on points and the same is liable to be set aside. For the reasons recorded here-in-above, the appeal is accepted and the accused Dharampal, since deceased stands acquitted of the charge framed against him.

(NIRMALJIT KAUR) Judge

10.03.2010 gurpreet