Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vijay Bansal v. State Of Haryana

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Sep 4, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion: Surya Kant, J. (4 September 2009)

Factual and Procedural Background

This order disposes of two Civil Miscellaneous Applications (CM No. 12170 of 2009 and CM No. 13502 of 2009) seeking clarification of this Court's earlier order dated 15 May 2009 which had disposed of CWP No. 20134 of 2004 (Vijay Bansal and others v. State of Haryana & Ors). The earlier decision divided the controversy into six issues, including Issue No. 1: the legal impact of notifications issued under Sections 3 and 4 (and 5) of the Punjab Land Preservation Act, 1900 (PLPA).

The State of Haryana (through its Forest Department) filed CM No. 12170/2009 seeking clarification of the Court's conclusions on Issue No. 1. The Forest Department set out facts about the total forest area and the acreage notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA, and argued that only lands subject to absolute prohibitions on clearing/breaking-up/cultivation under Section 4[a] or 5[a] should be treated as 'forest land'.

Non-applicant petitioners placed on record a notification dated 29 January 1993 (issued under Section 4 of the PLPA). The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests filed an affidavit and annexures (Annexure A-1 and A-2) disclosing copies of notifications under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA said to subsist and listing areas and totals (77 notifications covering 12,527.94 hectares).

The Court found that an incomplete copy of notification dated 28.11.1997 had been relied upon in the earlier order and that a distinction between types of PLPA notifications (those imposing absolute prohibition on clearing/breaking-up/cultivation and those imposing more limited restrictions such as cutting of trees) had not been drawn in the prior decision because the full set of notifications had not been on record at that time. The Court therefore heard clarification applications and modified its earlier order as to Issue No. 1, and issued additional directions including demarcation, dissemination, and interim prohibitions on mining pending demarcation. The second application (CM No. 13502/2009) sought clarification on whether the Central Government's notification dated 14 September 2006 under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 applied to mining throughout Haryana; the Court clarified that it did apply statewide to all mining activities.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the legal impact of notifications issued under Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Punjab Land Preservation Act, 1900 (PLPA) — specifically, which notified areas qualify as 'forest land' for the purposes of the Indian Forest Act and the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and are thereby restricted from being used for 'non-forest purposes' including mining?
  2. Does the Central Government notification dated 14 September 2006 issued under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 govern mining activities throughout the State of Haryana, or is its operation restricted only to mining areas in the Shivalik Ranges?

Arguments of the Parties

State of Haryana (Forest Department) — Applicant (CM No. 12170/2009)

  • The Forest Department set out that the State's total forest area is 154,706 hectares, which includes 12,527.94 hectares notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA, and that these lands are recorded as 'forest land' in Forest Department records.
  • Historically, only 11,513 hectares were recorded as notified under Sections 4 and 5 (as per an affidavit filed before the Supreme Court in Environmental Awareness Forum v. State of J&K & Ors), but the area is now reflected as increased to 12,527.94 hectares.
  • The State sought exclusion of privately owned land from the 'forest area' in proceedings before the Supreme Court (IA No. 839 of 2002 in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulkpad), but that application was dismissed; the Forest Department has therefore treated and maintained the noted area as 'forest land'.
  • The Forest Department asserted that not all lands/areas notified under Section 4 or 5 of the PLPA are 'forest lands': only those where clearing, breaking up or cultivation has been prohibited (i.e., notifications under Section 4[a] or 5[a]) should be treated as 'forest lands'.
  • Where notifications under Sections 4 and 5 merely restrict cutting of trees or collection of forest products (for example under clauses 4[c], 4[d], 5[c], 5[d]) those lands are not to be treated as 'forest lands' and can be used for non-forest purposes.
  • The State prayed that only lands subject to prohibitions under Section 4[a] or 5[a] be treated as 'forest lands' for purposes of the relevant forest laws.

Non-applicant-petitioners / Other parties

  • The non-applicant petitioners placed on record a notification dated 29 January 1993 issued by the State under Section 4 of the PLPA (regarding lands reserved for grazing or recorded as Ghasni, Charand and Shamlat Deh) — this notification was taken on record by the Court. Beyond the filing/placing of that notification, the opinion does not contain a detailed account of the petitioners' legal arguments in these clarification proceedings.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T.N. Godavarman Thirumulkpad v. Union of India & Ors., [1997] 2 SCC 267 Dictum concerning legal status and protection of forest lands and the relevance of notifications and restrictions under PLPA in treating areas as forest land. The Court cited and followed the dictum in this case (along with M.C. Mehta) when addressing the legal impact of PLPA notifications and when initially concluding that areas notified under Section 4 in respect of land notified under Section 3 could be treated as 'forest land' for the purposes of the Indian Forest Act and the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. The Court later clarified the scope of that conclusion after fuller material was placed on record.
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, JT 2004 SC 214 Authority on the question whether areas notified under Sections 4[a] or 5[a] of PLPA could be excluded from forest cover and the treatment of such notified lands as 'forest lands'. The Supreme Court in M.C. Mehta refused the State's plea to exclude areas notified under Sections 4[a]/5[a] from forest cover; this Court relied on that outcome to the extent that lands prohibited from clearing/breaking-up/cultivation under Sections 4[a]/5[a] should be treated as 'forest lands'. The Court noted that M.C. Mehta did not decide whether areas subject only to restrictions under 4[c]/[d] or 5[c]/[d] are forest land.
Environmental Awareness Forum v. State of J&K & Ors. (WP No. 171 of 1996) Referenced for factual disclosure made in an affidavit about the extent of land earlier noted as notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA. The Court referred to an affidavit filed before the Supreme Court in that matter which had stated that earlier the land notified under Sections 4 and 5 measured 11,513 hectares. The reference was used to trace the history of the areas recorded as notified and to contrast the earlier figures with the material presently on record.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in the following analytical steps, relying solely on the material placed on record and on applicable statutory provisions:

  1. Context: The Court recalled that its order dated 15 May 2009 had divided the controversy into issues and had, in respect of Issue No. 1, concluded that areas where directions under Section 4 of the PLPA prohibited cutting of trees or timber in areas notified under Section 3 (for conservation of sub-soil water or prevention of erosion) constitute 'forest land' for the purposes of the 1927 and 1980 Acts and cannot be used for non-forest purposes; it had also observed that such prohibition did not automatically apply to the entire area forming part of a Section 3 notification.
  2. New material / incompleteness: The Court identified that an incomplete copy of the notification dated 28.11.1997 had been relied upon in the earlier order and that the full set of notifications under Sections 4 and 5 had not been on record at the time. After the clarification application, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests filed an affidavit with Annexure A-1 (copies of all notifications said to subsist) and Annexure A-2 (area particulars), revealing 77 notifications covering 12,527.94 hectares.
  3. Distinction between types of notifications: The Court recognised a critical distinction between (a) notifications issued under Section 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA which expressly prohibit clearing, breaking-up or cultivation (i.e., absolute prohibitions on the acts that constitute "non-forest purpose" under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980), and (b) notifications that merely impose general restrictions such as prohibiting cutting of trees or collection of forest produce but which permit other activities or contain express exceptions (examples: provisions permitting quarrying of stone without prior permission in certain notifications).
  4. Statutory support: The Court relied on Section 2(ii) read with the Explanation of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 which defines "non-forest purpose" as breaking up or clearing of forest land for cultivation or similar uses, to support the proposition that only lands where clearing/breaking-up/cultivation is prohibited by notification (i.e., Section 4[a]/5[a]) should be regarded as forest land for the purposes of the conservation regime requiring prior central approval for de-reservation or use for non-forest purposes.
  5. Correction of earlier order: The Court acknowledged that because both sets of notifications were not before it earlier, it had not drawn the distinction between notifications imposing absolute prohibitions and those imposing limited restrictions. The Court concluded that the earlier order's declaration treating the entire area notified under Sections 4 and 5 as 'forest land' irrespective of the nature of restrictions was an error that needed correction.
  6. Modification and directions: Applying the law to the fuller factual record, the Court modified its earlier order to declare as 'forest lands' only those lands/areas (forming part of Section 3 notifications) in respect of which restrictions against clearing, breaking up or cultivation are imposed under Section 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA. It held these areas cannot be used for non-forest purposes (including mining) for purposes of the Indian Forest Act and the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. The Court then issued detailed administrative and protective directions (distribution of notifications, demarcation by revenue authorities with mining officers, interim prohibition on mining until demarcation, requirement to upload notifications on website, videograph scheme, etc.) to ensure protection and clarity on ground realities.
  7. Second clarification (environmental notification): On CM No. 13502/2009 the Court found and clarified that the Central Government notification dated 14 September 2006 under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 governs all mining activities throughout the State of Haryana (applicable to both major and minor minerals and to mining areas including the Shivalik Ranges).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court modified its earlier order dated 15 May 2009 and held that only those lands/areas forming part of notifications issued under Section 3 of the PLPA in respect of which restrictions against clearing, breaking up or cultivation have been imposed under Sections 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA, 1900 are to be declared as 'forest lands' for the purposes of the Indian Forest Act and the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, and such areas shall not be used for 'non-forest purposes' including the mining of major or minor minerals.

Additional direct effects and consequences imposed by the Court (summary):

  • The Court directed that copies of all notifications under Sections 4 and 5 (Annexure A-1) and the compilation of total covered area (Annexure A-2) be circulated to Divisional Forest Officers, Range Forest Officers and State/District Mining Officers within one month and a compliance report be placed before the Court.
  • The Court directed demarcation on ground by revenue authorities in coordination with Divisional Forest Officers and District Mining Officers within two months, with joint demarcation reports signed by the relevant officers.
  • Until notifications are circulated and demarcation completed, no mining or other non-forest activity shall be allowed even over lands abutting the notified 'forest lands'; mining in adjoining permissible areas shall be allowed only after demarcation is complete.
  • The Court ordered special treatment for lands covered by the 29 January 1993 notification (grazing/Ghasni/Charand/Shamlat-deh in Kalka and Panchkula): no mining or non-forest activity shall be allowed until such lands are taken out of the notification's purview by the competent authority on application/consent of right-holders; if permission is declined, those lands shall be treated as 'forest lands'.
  • The State was directed to evolve a videographing scheme for the entire forest area, especially private forest lands, and to periodically update such records to assess actual forest cover.
  • All notifications issued under Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the PLPA (including those not in Annexure A-1 and the 29 January 1993 notification) were ordered to be uploaded on the Forest Department website within three months for public access.
  • Clarification on central notification: The Court declared that the Central Government notification dated 14 September 2006 under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 applies to all mining activities throughout Haryana (major and minor minerals and all mining areas including the Shivalik Ranges).

Implications regarding precedent and broader law:

The decision corrects and narrows the Court's earlier pronouncement by distinguishing between different categories of PLPA notifications and tying the classification of 'forest land' to prohibitions on clearing/breaking-up/cultivation (i.e., Section 4[a]/5[a] notifications), consistent with the definitions and restrictions in the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. The opinion does not purport to establish a new broader legal doctrine beyond the application of extant statutory definitions and previously cited Supreme Court dicta; its immediate effect is to clarify the earlier order and to prescribe administrative measures to protect notified forest lands and regulate mining pending demarcation and dissemination of notifications.

Disposition: CM No. 12170 of 2009 stands disposed of (as modified). CM No. 13502 of 2009 also stands disposed of with the clarification that the 14 September 2006 central notification governs all mining activities throughout Haryana.

End of summary based exclusively on the provided opinion.

Show all summary ...

SURYA KANT, J.

This order shall dispose of Civil Misc. No. 12170 and 13502 of 2009 moved by two different applicants, seeking clarification of our order dated May 15, 2009, whereby CWP No. 20134 of 2004 [Vijay Bansal and others v. State of Haryana & Ors.] were disposed of.

CM No. 12170 of 2009.

This application has been moved by the State of Haryana through its Forest Department for clarification of the order dated 15th May, 2009 with regard to Issue No. 1, namely, “the legal impact of notifications issued under Sections 3 and 4 of the Punjab Land Preservation Act, 1900” [in short PLPA].

[2]. Vide order dated 15 May, 2009, we disposed of a Public Interest Litigation seeking investigation into indiscriminate and callous mining operations in the lower Shivalik Hills in District Panchkula, as also a writ petition, challenging the Central Government notification dated 14 September, 2006 which has mandated ‘pre-environmental clearance’ before permitting the mining operations. The whole gamut of controversy was divided into six issues including Issue No. 1 as to “what is the legal impact of the notification issued under Sections 3, 4 or 5 of the PLPA, 1900?”

[3]. Relying upon notification dated 28.11.1997 issued by the Forest Department, Government of Haryana under Section 4 of the PLPA, 1900 and following the dictum of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in T.N Godavarman Thirumulkpad v. Union of India & Ors. [1997] 2 SCC, 267 and M.C Mehta v. Union of India, JT 2004 SC, 214, we have concluded as follows in respect of Issue No. 1:-

“The only inescapable conclusion would be that if directions against cutting of trees or timber etc. have been issued under Section 4 in respect of an area or a part thereof notified for the purpose of ‘conservation of sub-soil water’ or ‘prevention of erosion’ under Section 3 of the PLPA, such an area being ‘forest land’ for the purposes of 1927 and 1980 Acts, can not be used for ‘non-forest purposes’ save as permitted by the Central Govt. We, however, hasten to add that the afore-stated prohibition against use for “non-forest purposes” does not ipso-facto apply to the entire area forming part of the notification under Section 3 of the PLPA”.

[4]. The Forest Department, Government of Haryana now seeks clarification of our conclusion drawn against Issue No. 1, inter-alia, pointing out that -

[i] the total forest area of the State, at present, is 1,54,706 hectares, including 12,527.94 hectares of the land notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA, 1900, which is duly recorded as ‘forest land’ in the records of the Forest Department;

[ii] the ‘forest land’ notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA, 1900 earlier contained 11,513 hectares only and this fact was duly mentioned in the affidavit dated 8.12.1996 filed by the then Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in WP No. 171 of 1996 [Environmental Awareness Forum v. State of J&K & Ors.].

[iii] the State Government later on wanted to exclude the afore-stated privately owned land from the ‘forest area’ and moved IA No. 839 of 2002 to this effect before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Writ Petition [Civil] No. 202 of 1995 [ T.N Godavarman Thirumulkpad v. Union of India & Ors], but the same having been dismissed while issuing directions in M.C Mehta's case [supra], the Forest Department has always treated and maintained the afore-stated area measuring 11513 hectares [now increased to 12527.94 hectares] as the ‘forest land’;

[iv] all the lands/areas notified under Section 4 or 5 of the PLPA are not ‘forest lands’. Only those lands where clearing, breaking up or cultivation has been prohibited, are being treated as ‘forest lands’;

[v] where the notifications under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA restricts only “the cutting of trees or timber or collection or removal or subjection to any manufacturing process” those lands are not to be treated as ‘forest lands’ and such lands can be used for ‘non-forest purposes’.

[5]. It has been accordingly prayed that only those lands where clearing, breaking-up or cultivation has been prohibited by a special order notified under Section 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA, 1900 may be treated as ‘forest lands’ as has been so held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M.C Mehta's case [supra] and not those lands in respect whereto general restrictions have been imposed under Section 4[c] and [d] or Section 5[c] and [d] of the PLPA, 1900.

[6]. Notice of this application was issued and in response thereto, non-applicant-petitioners have also placed on record a notification dated 29 January, 1993 issued by the State of Haryana under Section 4 of the PLPA by which activities for clearing or breaking-up for cultivation or for any other purpose forbidden over lands reserved for grazing purposes or mere as Ghasni, Charand and Shamlat Deh which were ordinarily not under cultivation. After taking that notification on record, we, vide our order dated 21st August, 2009 directed the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana to produce copies of all the notifications issued under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA and specifically state on affidavit that there are no other notifications except the ones enclosed by him with the affidavit so that all such notifications as have been issued are brought on record and also made available to the public through Internet.

[7]. In compliance thereto, Dr. D.R Ramesh Singh, IFS, Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana, has filed an affidavit along with copies of “all the notifications issued under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA which subsist as per the tenure given in the notifications” and have been collectively attached as Annexure A-1. The affidavit further states that “there is no other notification issued under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA which subsists as per the tenure of its operation given in the notifications” The details of the areas, villages and Tehsil-wise, covered under the notifications [Annexure A-1 (Colly)] have also been appended as Annexure A-2. The affidavit further explains that the area covered by the notification dated 29.1.1993 placed on record by the petitioners has never been treated and maintained as ‘forest land’ for the reason that the said notification is general in nature and there is no absolute prohibition on clearing or breaking up of the land for ‘non-forest purposes’ without the consent of the right-holders for such prohibition and, in any case, clause 8 of the notification expressly permits the quarrying of stone or burning of lime without any prior permission. In this manner, the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests has stated on oath that there are in all 77 notifications [Annexure A1] covering an area of 12527.94 hectares of land under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA and spread-over in various villages, Tehsils and Districts of the State of Haryana, particulars whereof have been compiled in Annexure A-2. The land covered by these notifications alone has been treated as ‘forest land’ in the records of the Forest Department, as stated on oath before us. This very plea was taken by the Forest Department before the Hon'ble Supreme Court firstly while disclosing the total ‘forest cover’ of the State and later on while making an unsuccessful attempt for exclusion thereof from the ‘forest area’.

[8]. The record further reveals that just an incomplete copy of the notification dated 28.11.1997, extensively relied upon by us while deciding Issue No. 1, was placed on record. The said notification imposes general restrictions on the ‘cutting of trees or timber except eucalyptus and popular or collection or removal of the forest products etc.’ and it applies throughout the State in the following areas:-

SCHEDULE

District Tehsil Villages Panchkula Kalka Ambala Naraingarh

Y. Nagar Jagadhri

Area lying on North side of Metalled and unmetalled road connecting Chandigarh, Panchkula, Ramgarh, Raipur Rani, Naraingarh, Sadhaura, Bilashpur, Chhachhrauli, Dadupur, and reaching Jamuna river near villages Nathanpur and Lakur.

Faridabad Ballabgarh Area lying on Western side of Delhi - Ballabgarh road and northern side of Ballabgarh - Sohna road.

Gurgaon Nuh Areas lying on Western side of Delhi Alwar road.

Ferozepur Jhirka All revenue estates of Ferozepur Jhirka Tehsil. Gurgaon All revenue estates of Gurgaon Tehsil Sohna All revenue estates of Sohna Tehsil Pataudi All revenue estates of Pataudi Tehsil Mohindergarh Narnaul All revenue estates of Narnaul Tehsil

Mohindergarh All revenue estates of Mohindergarh Tehsil Rewari Rewari All revenue estates of Rewari Tehsil

Bawal All revenue estates of Bawal Tehsil Kosli All revenue estates of Kosli Tehsil Bhiwani Dadri

Bhiwani

Loharu

Areas lying on western side of Dadri, Bhiwani, Tosham & Hisar road.

[9]. The Advocate General assisted by Mr. Narender Hooda, Advocate, appears to be right in contending that the total land forming the subject matter of this notification measures over four lac hectares and includes even those areas of the National Capital Region [Gurgaon & Sohna] which stand completely urbanised.

[10]. In M.C Mehta's case [supra], also, the only question that arose for consideration before the Supreme Court was as to whether the State of Haryana could take a complete somersault and be permitted to exclude the areas notified under Sections 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA from its total forest cover, even if such areas had always been treated and recorded as ‘forest lands’ by the Forest Department? Their Lordships turned down the State's plea and consequently the above notified lands continued to be treated as ‘forest lands’. To be more precise, the question as to whether or not the areas regulated by different restrictions imposed under Sections 4[c] & [d] and 5[c] & [d] of the PLPA also constitute ‘forest lands’, was neither deliberated upon nor responded to by the Supreme Court in that case.

[11]. Contrary to it, our order dated 15 May, 2009 has declared the entire area notified under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA as the ‘forest land’ irrespective of the nature of restrictions imposed vide such notification(s). The error has apparently crept up for the reason that neither a complete copy of the notification dated 28.11.1997 was placed on record nor, to our dismay and surprise, the notifications issued under Sections 4[a] and 5[a] of PLPA [Annexure A-1(Colly)] prohibiting clearing, breaking-up or cultivation of the lands, now being treated as ‘forest lands’, were brought on record by the Forest or the Mines and Geology Departments of the State of Haryana. The same have been brought on record for the first time after the main decision.

[12]. In the absence of both sets of notifications, namely, one which prohibits clearing, breaking up or cultivation of the land and the other which simply restricts the cutting of trees and timber etc., we had no occasion, while passing our order dated 15 May, 2009, to draw any distinction in respect to their legal implications or the nature of land covered by these notifications.

[13]. The contention that only those lands where clearing, breaking up or cultivation has been prohibited under Section 4[a] or 5[a] of the PLPA are to be treated as ‘forest lands’ finds force and is consistent with Section [2] [ii] read with the Explanation, of the Forest [Conservation] Act, 1980 which reads as follows:-

“2. Restriction on the dereservation of forests or use of forest land for non-forest purposes.- Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force in a State, no State Government or other authority shall make, except with the prior approval of the Central Government, any order directing.-

[i] xx xx

[ii] that any forest land or any portion thereof may be used for any non-forest purpose,

xx xx

Explanation.- For the purposes of this Section “non-forest purpose” means the breaking up or clearing of any forest land or portion thereof for -

[a] the cultivation of tea, coffee, spices, rubber, palms, oil bearing plants, horticulture, crops or medicinal plants;

[b] any purpose other than reafforestation, but does not include any work relating or ancillary to conservation, development and management of forests and wild-life, namely, the establishment of check-posts, fire lines, wireless communications and construction of fencing, bridges and culverts, dams, waterholes, trench marks, boundary marks, pipelines or other like purposes”.

[14]. We are, however, aghast to know [as has been brought to our notice during the course of hearing of this application as well as in other related matters] that copies of the notifications issued under Sections 4 or 5 of the PLPA [Annexure A-1(Colly)] are neither readily available with the Divisional Forest Officers/other Forest Officers nor have been brought to the notice of the Mines and Geology Department of the State. Resultantly, no demarcation appears to have been done, at the spot, of the lands covered by these notifications by the revenue department. This has not only led to a large scale illegal mining in the prohibited areas but has also become a source of loss to the State exchequer and/or corruption at various levels. It further appears that the private forest land measuring 12527.94 hectares exists more on papers than on the ground and the intrusion by the quarrying contractors into the forest areas, with or without the connivance of the authorities of the Forest and Mines and Geology Departments, has led to a spate of litigations including various writ petitions filed in Public Interest. We are, therefore, of the view that the ‘forest lands’ covered by the notifications [Annexure A-1(Colly)] need to be saved from the illegal and unscientific mining, which is bound to have devastating effects in the area leading to ecological imbalance.

[15]. We, therefore, allow this application and modify our order dated 15 May, 2009 qua Issue No. 1 read with direction No. [i] contained in Paragraph 57 thereof, and clarify that only those lands/areas forming part of the notification issued under Section 3 of the PLPA, 1900 in respect of which restrictions against clearing, breaking up or cultivation have been imposed under Sections 4[a] or 5[a] of the said Act, are declared as ‘forest lands’ for the purposes of the Indian Forest Act and the Forest [Conservation] Act, 1980 and the said areas shall not be used for ‘non-forest purposes’ including the mining of major or minor minerals. This shall, however, not preclude the State Government from imposing such restrictions in respect of the remaining area[s] notified under Section 3 of the Act, if so required to be done in public interest.

[16]. In addition to the directions already issued vide our order dated 15 May, 2009, we deem it appropriate to issue the following additional directions as well:-

[i] copies of all the notifications issued under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA, 1900 [Annexure A-1(Colly)] along with compilation of the total covered area [Annexure A-2] shall, within one month from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, be sent to all the Divisional Forest Officers and Range Forest Officers of the Forest Department as well as to the State and District Mining Officers of the Mines and Geology Department of the State of Haryana. A compliance report shall also be placed before this Court;

[ii] all the Divisional Forest Officers within whose jurisdiction the land covered by the above-stated notifications under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA is located, shall within two months from the date of receipt of the copies of the notifications, get the ‘forest lands’ demarcated by the revenue authorities and in the presence of the District Mining Officer concerned. The Tehsildars of the concerned areas and other revenue authorities shall comply with this order forthwith. The demarcation reports shall be jointly signed by the Divisional Forest Officer, the State/District Mining Officer as well as the Tehsildar of the concerned area;

[iii] every Divisional Forest Officer and the District Mining Officer shall be personally responsible to ensure that no mining activity or any other non-forest activity is allowed to be carried out in the ‘forest lands’ covered under the notifications [Annexure A-1(Colly)]. The Director, Mines and Geology as well as the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Haryana shall ensure meticulous compliance of these directions;

[iv] till copies of the notifications are made available to the Divisional Forest Officers/Range Forest Officers and State/District Mining Officers, as directed above, and until the demarcation of the area is completed in association with the revenue authorities as per direction No. [ii] above, no mining or other non-forest activity shall be allowed even over the lands abutting the ‘forest lands’ covered by the notifications issued under Sections 4 and 5 of the PLPA [Annexure A-1(Colly)]. We make it clear that the mining activities in the adjoining permissible areas shall be allowed only after the demarcation of the ‘forest lands’ is complete;

[v] as regards the lands located in Kalka and Panchkula Tehsils reserved for common grazing or recorded as Ghasnis, Charand, Shamlat-deh, which were ordinarily under cultivation prior to the issuance of the notification dated 29 January, 1993 [Annexure P-23] and are stated to have been vested with the Gram Panchayats under the Punjab Village Common Lands & Regulation Act, 1961, we direct that no mining activities or any other non-forest activity shall be allowed over the said lands until such lands or any part thereof is taken out of the purview of the afore-stated notification by the Competent Authority on an application/consent of the right-holders. In case the Competent Authority declines the permission, the lands covered by the notification dated 29 January, 1993 shall also be treated as ‘forest lands’ for all intent and purposes;

[vi] the State Government through its Forest and Mines and Geology Departments shall immediately evolve a scheme for videographing the entire forest area of the State, especially the private forest lands which shall be periodically updated to assess the actual forest cover at the spot;

[vii] all the notifications issued under Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the PLPA, 1900, including the notifications other than the notifications [Annexure A1 (Colly)] as well as the notification dated 29 January, 1993 [Annexure P-23], are directed to be uploaded on the website of the Forest Department, Haryana within a period of three months to facilitate public access to these notifications.

[17]. We further clarify that direction No. [xii] contained in our order dated 15 May, 2009 shall remain un-affected and shall have to be complied with.

[18]. CM No. 12170 of 2009 stands disposed of.

CM NO. 13502 OF 2009.

[19]. This application seeks clarification of the order dated 15 May, 2009 as according to the applicant it is not clear from our above-stated order as to whether the notification dated 14 September, 2006 issued by the Central Government under the Environment Protection Act, 1986 governs the mining activities in the entire State of Haryana or its operation is restricted only to the ‘mining areas’ in the Shivalik Ranges of Himalyas.

[20] Notice of this application was issued and in response thereto, learned State Counsel fairly concedes that direction No. [ii] contained in para 57 of the order dated 15 May, 2009 explicitly holds that the above-stated notification dated 14 September, 2006 governs all the ‘mining activities’ through out the State of Haryana.

[21]. We also find from the above referred direction that the notification dated 14 September, 2006 is applicable to all the ‘mining activities’ irrespective of the fact that the minerals are major or minor and it applies to all the ‘mining areas’ including those in the Shivalik Ranges of Himalyas.

[22]. CM No. 13502 of 2009 also stands disposed of accordingly.

(SURYA KANT) JUDGE

September 4, 2009. (T.S THAKUR)

dinesh CHIEF JUSTICE