- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Voluntary Health Association Of Punjab v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The proceedings arise out of a batch of matters concerning implementation of the Pre-Conception and Pre-Natal Diagnostic Techniques (Prohibition of Sex Selection) Act, 1994 (PC-PNDT Act). Earlier directions (reported in (2014) 16 SCC 433) required all States and Union Territories to file affidavits on steps taken to curb female foeticide and improve the child sex ratio. On 25-11-2014 the Court noted that several States had not filed affidavits, took exception to their “lackadaisical attitude,” and fixed a two-week deadline.
The Court decided to address States in clusters, first focusing on Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and the National Capital Territory of Delhi. Affidavits filed by these three States were examined, their statistical tables on sex ratio criticised for lack of methodological clarity, and directions were issued for verification of underlying records by a specially convened meeting of the National Inspection and Monitoring Committee (NIMC) on 03-12-2014.
Following that meeting, a further order dated 13-01-2015 recorded that the Committee had verified the data of the three States. Additional directions were issued, particularly to the State of Uttar Pradesh, regarding expeditious disposal of pending PC-PNDT prosecutions, compulsory birth registration and training of investigating officers.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the statistical data supplied by Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and NCT of Delhi accurately reflected the child sex ratio and compliance with the PC-PNDT Act.
- What immediate directions were necessary to ensure effective enforcement of the PC-PNDT Act, including verification of records, prosecution of offences and monitoring mechanisms.
- Whether additional measures such as incentives for families with girl children and public disclosure of sex-ratio data should be mandated.
Arguments of the Parties
State of Uttar Pradesh
- Filed an affidavit relying primarily on the 2011 census and Annual Health Survey figures (2010-2013), but, when queried, counsel could not explain the methodology behind the numbers.
State of Haryana
- Submitted a district-wise, month-wise chart for 2014, stating that the figures were based on certain registers, but provided no supporting documentation.
NCT of Delhi
- Claimed an improvement of nine points in sex ratio at birth in 2013 compared with the previous year, supported by Civil Registration System data.
Petitioners’/Intervenors’ Submissions
- Mr. Colin Gonsalves, Senior Advocate, criticised Uttar Pradesh for failing to ensure proper birth registration and sought permission to attend the NIMC meeting.
- Mr. Sanjay Parekh submitted that birth-registration figures were not being uploaded on government websites.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. The Bench found the affidavits of several States either missing or inadequate and emphasised that census figures alone are insufficient for assessing compliance with the PC-PNDT Act. Authentic, contemporaneous registers had to be produced for verification.
2. Observing that the data supplied by Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Delhi lacked transparency, the Court directed an NIMC-supervised verification meeting with senior health officials and the deponents of the affidavits. The purpose was to confirm whether the reported figures indicated improvement, stagnation or decline in the sex ratio.
3. After the Committee’s verification, the Court accepted that Uttar Pradesh’s figures were correct but discovered long-pending prosecutions under the Act. It therefore ordered trial courts to dispose of all such cases (without any stay order) within three months starting 20-01-2015, and required the Director of Prosecution to report the outcomes.
4. Recognising administrative lethargy, the Court mandated district-wise birth registration, uploading of ratio data on official websites, and public dissemination.
5. The Court identified inadequate training of competent authorities as a root cause for poor enforcement. It requested the Chief Justice of the Allahabad High Court to arrange a training programme at the U.P. Judiciary Training and Research Institute, with the Director of Prosecution in personal attendance throughout.
6. The Court also sought suggestions from all States on providing incentives to families that “show respect and honour for the girl child.”
Holding and Implications
Key Directions (Orders, not final disposal):
- Defaulting States must file affidavits within two weeks.
- NIMC meeting held on 03-12-2014 to verify data of Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Delhi; States ordered to produce original registers.
- Trial courts in Uttar Pradesh to conclude pending PC-PNDT prosecutions within three months from 20-01-2015; compliance report to be filed by the Director of Prosecution.
- Uttar Pradesh to issue a circular mandating immediate birth registration and maintain district-wise sex-ratio data.
- State officers to receive compulsory training in February 2015; schedule to be coordinated with the High Court.
- Sex-ratio data to be published on government websites.
- Next cluster of States (Tamil Nadu, Himachal Pradesh, Bihar and Rajasthan) to furnish prosecution records.
Implications: The orders intensify judicial monitoring of the PC-PNDT Act by compelling States to verify data, accelerate prosecutions, train enforcement officers and enhance transparency through public dissemination of sex-ratio figures. While no new legal precedent was set, the directions reinforce the Court’s continuing supervisory role in tackling female foeticide.
(Before Dipak Misra and Uday U. Lalit, JJ.)
Writ Petition (C) No. 349 of 2006, Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. 5800 of 2013 and Writ Petition (C) No. 575 of 2014
1. In pursuance of our earlier order (2014) 16 SCC 433, affidavits by certain States have been filed and certain States, by adopting a lackadaisical attitude, have not filed the affidavits. The States, namely, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Bihar, Goa, Gujarat, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Orissa, Tripura and UT of Daman and Nagar Haveli and Puducherry have not filed the affidavits. This attitude is not appreciated. However, they shall file their respective affidavits within two weeks hence.
2. As advised at present, we are inclined to think that the suggestions we had recorded in our previous order shall be adverted to in respect of cluster of States first. To elaborate, we shall deal with the problem that has occurred by dividing the States into certain clusters. Presently, we have decided to deal with the controversy pertaining to the States of Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and NCT of Delhi.
3. On a perusal of the affidavit of the State of Uttar Pradesh, we find that the affidavit is absolutely non-informative from all corners. A census chart of 2011 has been filed. We are absolutely unimpressed by the chart given during the census conducted in 2011 relating to the sex ratio that cannot be the guideline for the purposes of the PC-PNDT Act. There has to be a different methodology to be adopted by the State. We would be failing in our duty if we do not refer to Para 28 of the affidavit. It reads as follows:
“28. That it is pertinent to mention herein that according to ‘annual health survey (AHS)’ for the years 2010-2011, 2011-2012 and 2012-2013, improvement has been revealed in the State in respect of Sex Ratio at Birth, Sex Ratio of Child (0 to 4 years age) and Sex Ratio in all age groups, which is clear with the table given below:
Year of Annual Health Survey Sex Ratio (At birth) Sex Ratio (0 to 4 years of age) Sex Ratio (In all ages) 2010-2011 904 913 943 2011-2012 908 914 944 2012-2013 921 919 946”
4. On a query being made by the Court, the learned counsel for the State was not in a position to explain on what basis the said figures have been arrived at, for the same is not reflectible from the assertions made in the affidavit.
5. As far as the State of Haryana is concerned, though the affidavit appears to be comprehensive, the chart given in Para 15 of the affidavit gives districtwise and monthwise sex ratio of births during the year 2014. It is as follows:
“Districtwise and monthwise Sex Ratio at Birth during the year 2014 in Haryana State as per CRS (Prov)
Sl. No. District Up to Jan 14 Up to Feb 14 Up to Mar 14 Up to Apr 14 Up to May 14 Up to Jun 14 1. Ambala 1012 993 959 939 913 910 2. Bhiwani 824 812 843 848 846 832
3. Faridabad 929 892 889 884 890 890 4. Fatehabad 859 898 890 888 886 874 5. Gurgaon 829 856 851 854 855 839 6. Hissar 892 872 883 878 885 880 7. Jhajjar 797 793 793 801 800 811 8. Jind 886 876 878 911 915 899 9. Kaithal 953 921 920 928 927 918 10. Karnal 911 899 888 881 889 894 11. Kurukshetra 956 904 900 892 890 888 12. Mewat 920 942 932 923 920 919 13. Mohindergarh 777 776 797 786 782 770 14. Palwal 867 871 871 871 876 875 15. Panchkula 853 837 860 914 902 914 16. Panipat 924 931 915 904 903 895 17. Rewari 856 850 849 822 816 806 18. Rohtak 894 884 865 863 859 889 19. Sirsa 897 872 879 885 892 886 20. Sonepat 859 884 850 838 834 835 21. Yamunanagar 906 940 916 897 894 869 Haryana State 889 884 881 878 878 874”
Nothing has been filed stating as to how this figure has been reached except making a statement that the base is of certain registers.
6. On a perusal of the affidavit filed by the State of Delhi, we find in Para 5, it has been stated, thus:
“5. It is submitted that sex ratio at birth in Delhi, which is a reliable indicator of violations under the PC and PNDT Act, has improved by 9 points in 2013 over the previous year. The data available from Civil Registration System indicates that Sex Ratio at Birth was 809 females per 1000 males in the year 2001 and it is currently at 895 in 2013 Annexure R I.”
A document has been filed as indicated therein supporting the same.
7. In our considered opinion, there should be a verification of the documents that form the basis on which these figures have been arrived at. Let it be clarified that the figures that have been put forth do not show any indication of improvement but we would like to have it verified to satisfy ourselves whether the figure that has been put forth is correct or not. The purpose is to find out whether there is degradation of the sex ratio or a stagnation or any steps have really been taken by the States concerned to improve/enhance the sex ratio or not?
8. In view of the aforesaid, we direct that a meeting be held under the auspices of National Inspection and Monitoring Committee wherein the Additional Secretary who has filed the affidavit for the Union of India and two other Joint Secretaries of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare shall remain present. The deponents who have filed the affidavits before this Court on behalf of the States of Uttar Pradesh and NCT of Delhi shall remain present. The Director General, Health Services, State of Haryana shall remain present in the meeting. The Principal Secretary along with the Special Secretary, State of Uttar Pradesh shall remain present in the meeting. To avoid any amount of controversy, we fix the date for the meeting on 3-12-2014 at 10.30 a.m The State shall produce the relevant registers/records before the said Committee. We are sure, the States should be in a position to produce the registers/record in the meeting so that it can be scrutinised. Any discrepancy in this respect shall not be appreciated for the States must have prepared the chart on the basis of such registers/records.
9. We recapitulate the saying, “Awake, Arise, Oh! Parth” and we say this to the States so that they can really wake up to take the issue of female foeticide with all seriousness and sincere concern.
10. As requested by Mr Gonsalves and Mr Parekh that they should be allowed to be present at the meeting and we permit them to participate. The report shall be filed before this Court by 10-12-2014.
11. Apart from the child sex ratio, the aforesaid three States shall also bring records with regard to the prosecutions levied by the State yearwise and the stage of the prosecution. The next States shall be addressed to for this limited purpose are the States of Tamil Nadu, Himachal Pradesh, Bihar and Rajasthan.
12. At this juncture, without expressing any opinion, we would require the States to give suggestions by a separate affidavit, if some incentives can be given to the family who show respect and honour for the girl child and give birth to girl child so that the sex ratio is improved.
13. The learned counsel, Mr Gonsalves shall file a status report by giving a compilation of convenience in respect of all the States. Let the matter be listed on 11-12-2014.
Writ Petition (C) No. 341 of 2008
14. Let the matter be listed on 4-12-2014. Let a copy of the writ petition be sent to the Central Agency to be given to the Solicitor General of India.
15. Mr Kaul, learned Additional Solicitor General would apprise the learned Solicitor General about the issue in question.
Court Masters
Order dated 13-1-2015
(Before Dipak Misra and Prafulla C. Pant, JJ.)
16. Pursuant to order dated 25-11-2014, the Committee has been constituted. It has verified the data submitted by three States, namely, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Delhi.
17. As far as the State of U.P is concerned, on a perusal of the report, it transpires that the figures that were submitted by the State of Uttar Pradesh have been verified by the Committee and found to be correct.
18. On a perusal of the report along with the documents that have been annexed to, it is noticed that certain cases are pending for trial before the trial court. Regard being had to the fact that they have been instituted long back, we direct that the proceedings that are pending for trial and where there is no stay order of the High Court or this Court, the same shall be taken up in promptitude and be disposed of within a period of three months commencing 20-1-2015. The finalisation of the trial and the result thereof shall be submitted to this Court by way of an affidavit filed by the Director of Prosecution. The order passed today be sent by the Registry to the Registrar General of the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad for circulation to the courts concerned.
19. The competent authority of the State of U.P shall make 75 copies of the list contained at p. 15 onwards of the report of the Committee and file before the Registrar General of the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad on or before 17-1-2015 and the said authority shall scrutinise those copies and send it to the District and Sessions' Judges concerned where the cases are pending for taking appropriate steps. Any deviation shall be seriously viewed.
20. Quite apart from the above, it is directed that the State of U.P shall issue a circular requiring the competent authorities as nominated by it to register the births of children (male or female) at the time of birth so as to effectively show the progress or regress of the sex ratio. We have been compelled to issue such a direction as Mr Gonsalves, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner would contend with vehemence that the State of Uttar Pradesh has not taken pains to get such registration done. If the State of Uttar Pradesh has already taken such steps in accordance with law, it shall be put on record by way of an affidavit duly sworn to by the Principal Secretary, Department of Health and, if not, the same shall be complied with as directed hereinabove. It is directed that the sex ratio shall be maintained district-wise so that it would be appreciated in which district the ratio is not properly maintained and accordingly steps can be taken.
21. Be it noted that the competent authorities under the Act who are required to launch the prosecution must be adequately trained. We are of the convinced opinion that as they are not trained, a sense of lethargy and lackadaisical propensity has prevailed in the scenario. Such an activity can be at bay, if they are given requisite training. On a query being made, Mr Ratnakar Dash, learned Senior Counsel, submitted that all the officers can be trained by U.P Judiciary Training and Research Institute, Lucknow. We request the learned Chief Justice, High Court of Judicature of Allahabad to make such an arrangement in the month of February. The Chief Secretary of the State shall enter into communication with the Registrar General of the High Court of Judicature of Allahabad for determination of the schedule. The Director of Prosecution shall remain personally present during the entire period of training and there should not be any truancy. We are using the word “truancy” as we have been apprised that the Director of Prosecution is a government servant and it is his sanguine duty to see that the officers avail all training in all seriousness.
22. At this juncture, it is submitted by Mr Sanjay Parekh, learned counsel appearing for the applicant that in certain cases, the figures that are collected as regards the birth of children are not put on the website. It is directed that the said figures/data shall be put on the government website and the said website shall be adequately publicised.
23. As far as other States are concerned, let the matter be listed on 20-1-2015.
Court Masters
Alert