- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan
Factual and Procedural Background
The order disposes of two criminal miscellaneous applications arising in pending criminal proceedings. In Crl. MP No. 3200 of 2005 in Crl. A. No. 1129 of 2004, the applicant/respondent (an elected Member of Parliament) sought directions to be taken from Tihar Jail to Parliament House to take oath as an MP. The CBI, through the Additional Solicitor General, informed the Court that the applicant had also filed a writ petition before the High Court seeking the same relief; the applicant undertook to withdraw it. In Crl. MP No. 1477 of 2005 in Suo Motu Petition No. 5410 of 2004 in Crl. A. No. 324 of 2004, the applicant sought medical treatment at AIIMS, stating he suffered from ailments requiring immediate treatment. The Court also permitted inspection of medical/jail records summoned from Patna Medical College Hospital and Beur Jail, and adjourned thereafter.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether jail authorities should be directed to escort a prisoner (an elected Member of Parliament) from Tihar Jail to Parliament House to enable him to take oath, subject to return to custody thereafter.
- What directions should be issued to assess and facilitate necessary medical treatment for an applicant in Tihar Jail, including examination and possible hospital treatment in Delhi.
- Whether the additional relief sought as “Prayer B” in Crl. MP No. 3200 of 2005 should be granted.
Arguments of the Parties
- The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
On the request to take the applicant from Tihar Jail to Parliament House for administering the oath, the Court stated that, on the facts and circumstances, it was appropriate to grant the relief. It structured the relief to balance the applicant’s request with continued custody by directing a one-day escorted visit on 21-3-2005 for the parliamentary oath, followed by return to Tihar Jail and continued custody “as per our earlier order.”
The Court recorded that the CBI pointed out the existence of a parallel writ petition before the High Court for the same relief, and it accepted the applicant’s undertaking that the writ petition would be withdrawn immediately.
For the medical-treatment request, the Court directed an expert assessment first: the Director General, Health Services was to nominate a competent doctor to examine the applicant in Tihar Jail within a week. The Court conditioned any hospital treatment in Delhi on the doctor’s recommendation and required the jail authorities to arrange such treatment as advised. It also required a health-condition report to be submitted to the Court within two weeks. Additionally, the Court allowed counsel to inspect records summoned from Patna Medical College Hospital and Beur Jail.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED IN PART / DISPOSED OF: In Crl. MP No. 3200 of 2005, the Court directed Tihar Jail authorities to escort the applicant to Parliament House on 21-3-2005 to take oath as an MP and return him to custody after the day’s parliamentary proceedings; “Prayer B” was rejected; the application was disposed of with these directions. In Crl. MP No. 1477 of 2005, the Court directed medical examination through a DGHS-nominated doctor, conditional hospital treatment if recommended, submission of a health report within two weeks, permitted inspection of summoned records, and then adjourned.
The direct effect was to enable the applicant to take the parliamentary oath under strict custodial controls and to establish a court-supervised process for medical evaluation and treatment while in custody. The order does not indicate any broader legal implications or creation of new precedent.
Order
Crl. MP No. 3200 of 2005 in Crl. A. No. 1129 of 2004
1. The first prayer in this application is to direct the authorities of Tihar Jail, New Delhi to take the respondent who is an elected Member of Parliament to Parliament House for taking oath as a Member of Parliament. On the facts and circumstances of this case we think it appropriate that this relief should be granted. We direct the authorities of Tihar Jail, New Delhi to make arrangements to take the applicant to Parliament House on 21-3-2005 to facilitate him to take oath as a Member of Parliament. After the proceedings of Parliament on that day he shall be brought back to Tihar Jail and kept in custody as per our earlier order.
2. Learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for CBI brings to our notice that the applicant herein has also filed an independent writ petition before the High Court for the same relief. The learned counsel for the applicant herein gives an undertaking that the said writ petition will be withdrawn immediately.
3. Prayer ‘B’ sought for in this application is rejected.
4. With the above directions this application is disposed of.
Crl. MP No. 1477 of 2005 in Suo Motu Petition No. 5410 of 2004 in Crl. A. No. 324 of 2004
5. By this application the petitioner is seeking medical treatment at All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi. He has stated that he is suffering from certain ailments which require immediate treatment. We direct the Director General, Health Services, Government of India, New Delhi to nominate a competent doctor to examine the applicant in Tihar Jail, New Delhi within a week from today and if recommended by the said doctor that treatment is necessary in any one of the hospitals in Delhi, the jail authorities will make arrangements for providing the applicant such treatment as advised by the said doctor. A report in regard to the applicant's health condition will be submitted in this Court within two weeks from today.
6. The learned counsel for the parties are permitted the inspection of the records summoned by this Court from Patna Medical College Hospital as well as Beur Jail pertaining to this case.
7. Adjourned.
Court Masters
Alert