Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Nand Kishore Ojha v. Anjani Kumar Singh .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 13, 2011
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present order arises from Contempt Petition (C) No. 297 of 2007 in SLP (C) No. 22882 of 2004. The petition alleged breach of undertakings dated 18-1-2006 and 23-1-2006 given by the State of Bihar and recorded in the Supreme Court’s earlier order in State of Bihar v. Nand Kishor Ojha (2014) 11 SCC 404. Multiple writ petitions had challenged the State’s evolving policies on primary-school teacher recruitment. Because trained teachers then numbered fewer than vacant posts, the Court, as a one-time measure, directed the State to fill 34,540 vacancies with those teachers in order of seniority. Discrepancies later emerged concerning (i) the exact vacancy figure, (ii) the eligibility of certain candidates, and (iii) the authenticity of training institutions.

To resolve these issues, the Court first appointed Justice V. A. Mohta and, upon his request to be relieved, Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay as Special Officers to finalise a comprehensive seniority list. After several supervised sessions with all stakeholders, Justice Chattopadhyay submitted the final list; the State then prepared a reservation roster, which was placed before the Court in a sealed cover. The instant order issues clarifications sought by the State and finally disposes of the contempt proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claim of Shri Abhinesh Kumar, belatedly impleaded, required further consideration despite his low seniority ranking.
  2. Whether appointing authorities could scrutinise and reject defective certificates/documents produced at counselling.
  3. Whether candidates who would attain the retirement age of 60 years on or before 31-1-2012 should be excluded from appointment.
  4. To what extent the State’s Special Recruitment Rules stood modified by prior and present Supreme Court directions.
  5. How to address candidates whose institutions were treated as unrecognised or fake by the Special Officer.
  6. Whether excess vacancies in the Physical Education category could be transferred to the understaffed Urdu category.

Arguments of the Parties

State of Bihar

  • Pointed out that Shri Abhinesh Kumar’s seniority position (No. 62,551) fell well beyond the 34,540 available vacancies.
  • Sought clarification that authorities could verify certificates at counselling and reject non-conforming candidates.
  • Argued that candidates who would retire by 31-1-2012 should not be appointed, as they could not serve for a meaningful period.
  • Requested permission to reallocate surplus Physical Education posts (4972) to the Urdu category, which faced a shortfall (1509 versus 12,862 required).

The opinion does not record detailed counter-arguments from other parties.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Bihar v. Nand Kishor Ojha (2014) 11 SCC 404 Undertaking by State to fill teacher vacancies; basis of contempt jurisdiction. Formed the foundation for enforcing the 18-1-2006 and 23-1-2006 undertakings and for issuing present directions.
Order dated 9-12-2009 in the present proceedings (2010) 6 SCC 648 Directed preparation of fresh seniority list. Referred to when instructing the Special Officer to compile an exhaustive list.
Order dated 19-1-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 384 Identified incongruities in State’s candidate list; appointed Special Officer. Provided procedural roadmap for neutral finalisation of eligibility and seniority.
Order dated 24-2-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 566 Replaced Justice V. A. Mohta with Justice S. K. Chattopadhyay as Special Officer. Ensured continuity in finalising the disputed lists.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court methodically addressed each clarification sought:

  • Abhinesh Kumar’s claim: As his seniority rank lay far beyond available vacancies, no further consideration was warranted.
  • Scrutiny of documents: Authorities were expressly authorised to verify certificates during counselling and to take appropriate action where documentation failed to meet statutory requirements.
  • Candidates nearing retirement: Balancing delay with institutional interest, the Court held that applicants who would retire on or before 31-1-2012 should be excluded, as they could not contribute a reasonable term of service.
  • Modification of Recruitment Rules: The Special Recruitment Rules were “deemed modified” to the extent necessary to harmonise with all Supreme Court directions issued in these proceedings.
  • Candidates from disputed institutions: Those alleging wrongful exclusion may approach the Bihar Staff Selection Commission; genuine claims are to be considered for future vacancies in order of seniority.
  • Redistribution of subject-wise vacancies: Finding merit in the State’s request, the Court allowed excess Physical Education vacancies to be transferred to the Urdu category to better match subject-wise requirements.

Finally, the Court confirmed that the seniority list and roster prepared under judicial supervision were definitive and insulated from future litigation.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF – The contempt petition and all pending interlocutory applications are disposed of.

Key directives include: (i) implementation of the sealed seniority list and roster by the Human Resource Department, Government of Bihar; (ii) exclusion of candidates retiring by 31-1-2012; (iii) certificate verification during counselling; (iv) reallocation of excess Physical Education posts to Urdu; and (v) limited future recourse for aggrieved candidates through the Staff Selection Commission. The decision concludes prolonged litigation but sets no new precedent beyond the parties involved, as subsequent courts are barred from entertaining objections to the finalised list and roster.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Contempt Petition (C) No. 297 of 2007, filed in SLP (C) No. 22882 of 2004, arose out of an alleged breach of undertaking said to have been given on 18-1-2006 by the State of Bihar and the order passed on the basis thereof on 23-1-2006 by this Court in State of Bihar v. Nand Kishor Ojha (2014) 11 SCC 404. As we have indicated in our order dated 9-1-2009, a number of writ petitions had been filed against the State of Bihar, raising issues relating to recruitment of teachers in primary schools. At one stage, it was brought to our notice that on account of changes in the policy, trained teachers who were in place at the time when the undertakings were given, could not be accommodated. Accordingly, we had passed orders directing that the trained teachers who at one time were less than the number of vacant posts, should be given appointment in the vacancies that were available. Subsequently, however, there was some discrepancy as to the number of vacancies available as against the number of teachers to be accommodated. Accordingly, we adopted a figure from an advertisement which had been published for recruitment of primary school teachers and took the number of available vacancies to be 34,540.

2. We had directed that the said vacancies be filled up with the said number of trained teachers as a one-time measure to give effect to the undertakings which had been given on 18-1-2006 and 23-1-2006. Accordingly, without issuing a rule of contempt, we had directed that the said vacancies be filled up from amongst the trained teachers who are available in order of seniority. Subsequently, however, it came to light that the number of candidates available were much more than the number of vacancies and there were also serious doubts raised about the eligibility of some of the candidates and some of the institutions from which they alleged to have received their training.

3. In our order of 19-1-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 384, we had indicated that certain incongruities had been pointed out on behalf of the petitioners with regard to the list of eligible candidates furnished by the State of Bihar. As a result, the State of Bihar was directed to bring out a fresh list in terms of the orders which we had passed on 9-12-2009 and 12-5-2010 (2010) 6 SCC 648 in order of seniority, incorporating the names of each and every candidate and the category to which they belonged. As the lists prepared were disputed, we thought it fit that in order to resolve the anomalies, a neutral person should be entrusted with the work of settling the list over which the dispute had arisen and, accordingly, by the said order (2011) 14 SCC 384 we appointed Justice V.A Mohta, a retired Judge of the Bombay High Court, who retired as Chief Justice of the Orissa High Court, as Special Officer in whose presence the list could be settled. However, since Justice Mohta expressed his desire to be relieved of the responsibility, by our order dated 24-2-2011 (2011) 14 SCC 566, while relieving Justice V.A Mohta of the responsibility of acting as the Special Officer, we appointed Mr Justice S.K Chattopadhyay, a retired Judge of the Patna High Court in his place, to take up and complete the finalisation of the seniority list.

4. Subsequently, several sessions were held by the learned Special Officer, at which the parties and the institutions were duly represented by the counsel and His Lordship, thereafter, submitted a finalised list of the eligible candidates in order of seniority, taking into consideration the various institutions and the certificates produced by the candidates concerned. On the basis of the said list, we had requested the State of Bihar to prepare a roster for the purpose of reservation of seats according to the different reserved categories. Such exercise has also been undertaken and completed and the list prepared in terms of the roster has also been produced in the Court in a sealed cover.

5. Today, when the matter is taken up, Mr Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Bihar, has raised some issues, which need to be clarified.

6. The first issue relates to the claim of one Shri Abhinesh Kumar s/o Shri Babua Nand Pandey, that his case has not been considered by the learned Special Officer on account of the fact that he was not a party to the proceedings. On 13-7-2011 Mr Rama Murti, learned Senior Advocate, submitted that Shri Abhinesh Kumar had, in fact, been impleaded as a party and, accordingly, we had directed dated 24-5-2011 the State of Bihar to consider his place in the seniority list as well. Today, we are informed by Mr Kailash Vasdev that his position stands at Sl. No. 62,551 which is far beyond the number of vacancies to be filled up. Accordingly, nothing further is required to be said at the present, as far as his claim is concerned.

7. The second issue which has been raised by Mr Kailash Vasdev is with regard to the examination of the certificates and other documents that may be produced by the candidate concerned at the time of counselling and appointment. In the event, during scrutiny it is found that any of the documents do not conform to the requirements, the authorities concerned will be at liberty to take appropriate steps regarding the said candidate.

8. The third issue raised was with regard to the candidates, who are to retire at the age of 60 by 31-1-2012 within which period they would have attained the age of 60 years. It is no doubt true that this matter has been pending for a long time and there is possibility of some candidates being adversely affected on account of such delay, but at the same time we cannot also overlook the fact that a person cannot be allowed the benefits of appointment without serving the institution for at least some length of time. Accordingly, the cases of the candidates who will be retiring on or before 31-1-2012 need not be considered for appointment (sic retiral benefits).

9. Fourthly, the Special Recruitments Rules, which have been framed by the State for the purpose of appointment of primary teachers in these vacancies, shall be deemed to have been modified to the extent of the directions which have been issued by this Court from time to time and also by this order.

10. There is yet another group of candidates, who claim to be adversely affected by the deliberations and the findings of the learned Special Officer while preparing the list of eligible candidates. It has been claimed by some of the candidates that their institutions have been shown to be unrecognised/fake, whereas from the very same institution other candidates have been found eligible, although, this has not been admitted by Mr Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Bihar, we feel if that is the case, such candidates should not be deprived of an opportunity in future. Accordingly, we direct that such candidates will be at liberty to apply to the Bihar Staff Selection Commission for reconsideration of their status and the status of their institutions in respect of which objections have not been considered by the Special Officer. If such representations are made, the same should be considered and disposed of by the Commission, after giving the candidates an opportunity of hearing and placing their cases before the Commission and if it is found that their cases are genuine, the said candidates should be considered in future vacancies, when other vacancies are available, in order of seniority.

11. There is one more issue, which has been raised by Mr Kailash Vasdev, and that will be evident from the chart which has been submitted by him showing the distribution of posts. According to the requirement of the posts for Physical Education Teachers, the number shown is 1084, whereas in terms of the distribution of the number of vacancies amongst 34,540 candidates, the figure shown is 4972, which means that there is an excess number of posts vis-à-vis the number of candidates actually required. On the other hand, as far as Urdu as a subject is concerned, while the requirement is 12,862 in terms of the distribution of posts, the figure has been shown as 1509, which falls far short of the required number of candidates. Accordingly, Mr Vasdev has submitted that the excess number of posts in the Physical Education subject category may be allowed to be shifted to the Urdu subject category, which would compensate the Urdu subject category to some extent. We feel that there is substance in such a submission and, accordingly, we allow such prayer as well. The State Government will be at liberty to transfer the excess vacancies in the Physical Education group to the Urdu subject category.

12. This brings us to the end of a long and arduous journey regarding the appointment of trained teachers in terms of the undertaking given in this Court by the State Government.

13. We would like to express our deep sense of appreciation to Justice S.K Chattopadhyay for having undertaken the tedious and painstaking exercise of finalising the list of eligible candidates to be considered for filling up the 34,540 vacancies identified during these proceedings. We are informed that nothing remains to be paid to the learned Special Officer on account of his remuneration. We also express our appreciation to all the counsel who appeared and helped us to resolve this matter for the benefit of the large number of trained teachers in Bihar who were waiting for appointment all these years.

14. Let the original roster, as well as the seniority list, which have been produced before us in a sealed cover and is at present lying in the custody of Mr Gopal Singh, learned Standing Counsel for the State of Bihar, be sent to the Human Resource Department, Government of Bihar, for implementing this order. We make it clear that since the roster, as well as the seniority list, have been prepared in terms of the order of this Court, no court shall entertain any other objections or applications with regard to the same.

15. The contempt petition, as well as the pending interlocutory applications are also disposed of by this order.