Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohammadbhai Kasambhai Sheikh And Others v. Abdulla Kasambhai Sheikh .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 28, 2004
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal concerned a dispute over the respondent’s claim to his share in family property. The respondent filed a suit against the appellants in 1988. The trial court dismissed the suit as barred by limitation, holding that the respondent’s right to a share arose on the death of his surviving parent (his mother) in 1968.

On appeal, the District Judge reversed the trial court, holding that the cause of action arose not from the mother’s death but from the date of the respondent’s ouster. The High Court declined to interfere with the first appellate court’s decision. The matter then came before the Supreme Court in the present appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent’s 1988 suit for his share in family property was barred by limitation.
  2. Whether, in an heir’s suit for share/possession, a plea of limitation can succeed in the absence of a specific defence of adverse possession by the defendants.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahomedally Tyebally v. Safiabai AIR 1940 PC 215 For Mohammedan heirs, succession is in specific shares as tenants-in-common; a suit by an heir for his/her share in immovable property is governed by Article 144 of the Limitation Act, 1908 (re-enacted materially as Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963), with a 12-year period running from when defendant’s possession becomes adverse to the plaintiff. Used to identify the correct limitation framework for an heir’s claim to a share in immovable property and to emphasize that limitation turns on the commencement of adverse possession, not merely on death or an asserted ouster, within the stated statutory scheme.
Mohd. Mohammad Ali v. Jagadish Kalita (2004) 1 SCC 271 (SCC para 20) Unless the defendant raises the defence of adverse possession to an heir’s claim for a share in ancestral property, the defendant cannot raise an issue relating to limitation of the plaintiff’s claim (as discussed by the Court with reference to Article 65). Applied to hold that, since no adverse possession plea was taken in the written statement, the appellants could not rely on limitation to defeat the respondent’s suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court stated that it agreed with the conclusion reached by the High Court and the first appellate court (i.e., that the suit was not barred), but found their reasoning to be “fallacious.” The respondent’s own case was that he had been ousted in 1968. The Court observed that if the approach of the first appellate court and the High Court were accepted—treating limitation as running from the date of ouster—then a suit filed only in 1988 would be barred.

The Court then identified the correct legal framework for limitation. Relying on Mahomedally Tyebally v. Safiabai, it noted that the parties were Mohammedans and that heirs succeed as tenants-in-common. For such a claim relating to immovable property, the governing rule is reflected in Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (materially re-enacting Article 144 of the 1908 Act): a suit for possession based on title must be brought within 12 years from the date the defendant’s possession becomes adverse to the plaintiff.

Crucially, the Court held (with reference to Mohd. Mohammad Ali v. Jagadish Kalita) that unless the defendants plead adverse possession, they cannot raise an issue of limitation against an heir’s claim for a share. Since it was undisputed that the appellants had not raised any adverse possession plea in their written statement, the Court concluded that the limitation plea was not available to them.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED (leave granted; no order as to costs).

The direct consequence was that the appellants could not defeat the respondent’s suit on limitation in the absence of a pleaded defence of adverse possession. The Court affirmed the result reached by the High Court/first appellate court, though on a different rationale tied to Article 65 and the requirement of adverse possession being raised. The opinion does not indicate that any broader new precedent was set beyond applying the cited principles to the parties’ dispute.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. The only issue in this appeal relates to the period of limitation with regard to the claim of the respondent to his share in the family property. The respondent's suit was filed against the appellants in 1988. The trial court dismissed the respondent's suit on the ground of limitation holding that the right of the respondent to a share in the property arose on the death of his surviving parent, namely, his mother which took place in 1968. Therefore, the claim of the respondent-plaintiff was barred.

3. The District Judge reversed the finding of the trial court holding that the cause of action in fact would not arise from the date of the death of his mother but from the date of his ouster. The High Court did not interfere with the decision of the first appellate court.

4. In our view, the conclusion of the High Court and the first appellate court is correct. However, the reasoning given in support of such conclusion is fallacious. The respondent had come with the clear case that he had been ousted in 1968. If the reasoning of the first appellate court and the High Court were to be accepted then as the suit had been filed only in 1988, it was barred by limitation. But as has been held in Mahomedally Tyebally v. Safiabai AIR 1940 PC 215 the heirs of Mohammedans (which the parties before us are) succeed to the estate in specific shares as tenants-in-common and a suit by an heir for his/her share was governed, as regards immovable property, by Article 144 of the Limitation Act, 1908. Article 144 of the Limitation Act, 1908 has been materially re-enacted as Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 and provides that the suit for possession of immovable property or any interest therein based on title must be filed within a period of 12 years from the date when the possession of the defendant becomes adverse to the plaintiff. Therefore, unless the defendant raises the defence of adverse possession to a claim for a share by an heir to ancestral property, he cannot also raise an issue relating to the limitation of the plaintiff's claim. [See, in this regard, the decision of this Court in Mohd. Mohammad Ali v. Jagadish Kalita (2004) 1 SCC 271 (SCC para 20).]

5. It is not in dispute that the appellants had not raised any issue of adverse possession in their written statement. In that view of the matter, the plea of limitation was not available to the appellants. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed but without any order as to costs.