- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shri Inder Raj Kakar (Petitioner) v. Delhi Transport Undertaking And Another (S).
Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Jagjit Singh, J.)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Shri Inderaj Kakar, filed the present petition on March 23, 1971 seeking to quash recommendations made by a departmental promotion committee and the General Manager of the Delhi Transport Undertaking (D.T.U.) and to restrain the Delhi Transport Committee of the D.T.U. from approving the appointment of Shri S.N. Ranjan as Works Manager. The petitioner was working on a temporary/probationary basis as Works Engineer with the India Tourism Development Corporation (ITDC) and had been granted leave without pay by the D.T.U. while his lien on the post of Assistant Works Manager was retained for one year.
No stay was granted on the ad hoc appointment because the petitioner was already in temporary employment elsewhere and the proposed appointment of Shri Ranjan was ad hoc. The Court, however, directed that pending disposal Shri Ranjan should not be confirmed as Works Manager. After the dismissal of a stay application, Shri Ranjan was appointed ad hoc as Works Manager from April 19, 1971 for a period stated at the bar to be six months. The petitioner alleged he was not considered by the departmental promotion committee and claimed contravention of the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) consultation regulations and mala fide conduct in constituting the committee.
The D.T.U.'s position was that the petitioner lacked the requisite degree qualification (his qualification was a certificate course), and that he was not on the rolls of the Undertaking and had not completed five years' service in the grade; the D.T.U. also relied upon the UPSC having found no suitable candidate from its recruitment exercise and having suggested an ad hoc arrangement.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the recommendations of the departmental promotion committee and the General Manager's ad hoc appointment of Shri S.N. Ranjan as Works Manager could be quashed on the grounds alleged by the petitioner (failure to consider him and mala fides in constituting the committee).
- Whether the requirement to consult the Union Public Service Commission applied to an ad hoc appointment not exceeding one year and whether the D.T.U.'s actions contravened the UPSC (Consultation by the Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations, 1959.
- Whether the petitioner was eligible to be considered for the post (in particular, whether he satisfied the educational and experience requirements and whether his lien/roll status entitled him to consideration).
- Whether any procedural irregularity in not calling the petitioner before the departmental promotion committee vitiated the ad hoc appointment of Shri Ranjan.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petition sought quashing of the departmental promotion committee's recommendations and the General Manager's approval of Shri Ranjan for the post of Works Manager.
- The petitioner alleged contravention of the UPSC (Consultation by the Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations, 1959, by not properly consulting or following the procedures for promotion/selection.
- It was alleged that the General Manager acted mala fide and arbitrarily, constituting the committee with the ulterior motive of promoting Shri Ranjan and not even considering the petitioner despite his retained lien on the post of Assistant Works Manager.
Respondents' (D.T.U.) Arguments
- The D.T.U. maintained that the petitioner did not possess the degree in mechanical or automobile engineering required by the recruitment rules (his qualification was a certificate course), and therefore lacked the essential educational qualification for the post.
- It was asserted the petitioner was not on the rolls of the Undertaking where the post was to be filled, and he had not completed five years' service in the grade of Assistant Works Manager, so he was not eligible to be considered by the departmental promotion committee.
- The D.T.U. denied allegations of mala fides and arbitrary action in constituting the departmental promotion committee.
- The D.T.U. relied upon the UPSC having interviewed candidates and found none suitable, and upon the UPSC's suggestion that an ad hoc arrangement could be made pending a fresh requisition after six months.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Manotosh Behera v. State of Orissa (1970 Lab I.C. 1478) | Ad hoc appointments made for a short period are intended to meet immediate needs and exigencies; there is no absolute rule that all eligible candidates must be given consideration for such temporary appointments and imposing such a rule would impede urgent management action. | The Court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that the ad hoc appointment of Shri Ranjan for a limited period (six months) was not vitiated merely because the petitioner was not called before the departmental promotion committee, given the UPSC's view and the temporary exigency. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through a sequence of factual and legal determinations based strictly on the record:
- Qualifications: The Court observed that the petitioner did not possess a degree in mechanical or automobile engineering of a recognized university; his qualification was a certificate course. The Court noted that Shri Ranjan likewise did not have a degree. The recruitment rules, however, allow that qualifications are relaxable at the Commission's discretion, meaning eligibility in practice could depend on UPSC relaxation.
- Experience: The Court found the petitioner did satisfy the requirement of approximately five years' experience in the relevant grade, because his promotion as Assistant Works Manager was made effective from September 1, 1965, giving him more than five years' service before he was relieved on October 23, 1970.
- Requirement of Consultation with UPSC for Ad Hoc Appointment: The Court examined Section 96 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, which provides that consultation with the UPSC is not necessary where the appointment is for a period not exceeding one year. On that basis, and in light of the UPSC's letter of January 14, 1971 reporting no suitable candidates and suggesting an ad hoc arrangement until a fresh requisition after six months, the Court held it was not open to say the General Manager's steps to fill the post ad hoc were mala fide.
- Application of UPSC Regulations: The Court analysed Regulations 4(b) and 5(c) of the UPSC (Consultation by the Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations, 1959 and concluded that the question of contravention did not arise for an ad hoc appointment not exceeding one year because the recruitment rules had already declared the post a selection post with qualifications laid down and Section 96 permitted non-consultation for short-term appointments.
- Lien and Roll Status: The Court addressed the D.T.U.'s contention that the petitioner was not on the rolls and was not working in the Undertaking where the post had to be filled. It found that because the petitioner’s lien had been retained for one year and he was granted leave without pay for that period, he remained an employee of the D.T.U. and was not off the rolls in the sense asserted by respondents.
- Procedural Irregularity and Vitiation: Although the Court described the stated reasons for not calling the petitioner before the departmental promotion committee as "badly tenable," it asked whether this procedural omission could vitiate the ad hoc appointment of Shri Ranjan for the six-month period. The Court concluded it did not. It noted that the persons who were called for interview were senior to the petitioner, and if any grievance were to be raised it would more appropriately be by a senior officer (Shri P.N. Raina), who had not challenged the appointment.
- Practical Considerations: The Court observed that the petitioner was already working on probation elsewhere on a post of equivalent pay scale; even if selected for a six-month ad hoc appointment he might lose the chance of confirmation in his present post. This practical element was relied on in concluding that the petitioner was not entitled to relief.
- Reliance on Authority: The Court invoked the Orissa High Court bench decision in Manotosh Behera to reinforce that ad hoc appointments for short periods, made to meet exigencies, are not always subject to the rigid rule that all eligible candidates must be considered, and that imposing such a rule would impede urgent administrative functioning.
- Future Consideration: The petitioner's counsel requested that if another ad hoc arrangement were made after the expiry of the present six months, the petitioner should be considered. The Court regarded this request as reasonable but said it would depend on whether the petitioner's lien remained at that time or whether he had exercised an option to return to the D.T.U. from the ITDC.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court's final decision was Petition dismissed.
Immediate Consequences:
- The petitioner was denied the relief of quashing the departmental promotion committee's recommendations and preventing the ad hoc appointment of Shri S.N. Ranjan.
- The ad hoc appointment of Shri S.N. Ranjan for the limited period in question (stated at the bar to be six months from April 19, 1971) was held not to be vitiated on the grounds advanced by the petitioner.
- The Court left open the possibility that if another ad hoc arrangement were required after the present period, the petitioner could be considered then, subject to whether his lien on the Assistant Works Manager post remained or he had elected to return to the D.T.U.
- The Court directed that the parties bear their own costs.
Broader Implications: The opinion did not purport to lay down any new broader precedent beyond applying existing statutory provisions and the cited authority on ad hoc appointments; its effect is confined to the direct dispositions above.
Jagjit Singh, J.:— On March 23, 1971, the present petition was filed by Shri Inderaj Kakar for getting quashed the recommendations made by a departmental promotion committee and the General Manager of the Delhi Transport Undertaking (to be hereinafter referred to as “the D.T.U”) for the appointment of Shri S.N Ranjan as the Works Manager. The petitioner also desired that directions be issued to the Delhi Transport Committee of the D.T.U not to approve the name Shri Ranjan as the Works Manager.
2. No stay was granted by this Court as the petitioner was already working on a temporary basis as Work Engineer in the office of the India Tourism Development Corporation and also because the proposed appointment of Shri Ranjan was only to be on an ad hoc basis. It was however, directed that pending disposal of the writ-petition Shri Ranjan should not be confirmed in the post of Works Manager.
3. It is the common case of the parties that after the stay application was dismissed appointment of Shri Ranjan as Works Manager of the D.T.U was made on ad hoc basis. According to the statement made at the bar by Shri G.K Sharma, on behalf of the D.T.U the present appointment of Shri Ranjan as works Manager is only for a period of six months with effect from April 19, 1971.
4. It may be mentioned that the petitioner had passed the automobile engineering examination from the Technical Collage, Agra in the year 1948. The qualification acquired by him was not of the standard of graduation in automobile engineering. In April 1957, however, he was employed by the D.T.U as an Assistant Engineer. The next higher post in the D.T.U to that of Assistant Engineer is that of Assistant Works Manager in the grade of Rs. 580-1000. Assistant Works Managers having certain qualifications and experience are eligible for the still higher selection post of Works Managers, a Class I post in the grade of Rs. 700-1250/-.
5. In due course the petitioner was promoted as Assistant Works Manager and his promotion was notified on April 1, 1966. Later on, however, as a result of a resolution passed on June 25, 1969 by the Delhi Transport Committee, a Committee of the D.T.U the promotion of the petitioner as Assistant Works Manager was made effective from September 1, 1965.
6. Shri P.N Raina and Shri S.N Ranjan were also Assistant Works Managers of the D.T.U and were senior, to the petitioner in that rank. Shri Raina was promoted to the post of Assistant Works Manager on June 15, 1964, and Shri Ranjan got his promotion on June 4, 1965. The promotion of the petitioner, as already stated above, was given effect to from September 1, 1965.
7. Shri V.A Rajamony was the Works Manager Sill March 23, 1968. From then onwards the post remained vacant till ad hoc appointment thereto was made by the appointment of Shri Ranjan in April, 1971.
8. In June 1970 the petitioner applied to the India Tourism Development Corporation for the post of Works Engineer in the grade of Rs. 700-1250. On his application the post of Works Engineer was offered to him on a temporary basis and on probation for a period of one year. It was mentioned in the letter of the India Tourism Development Corporation dated August 29, 1970 that the period of probation could be extended and during probationary period, including any extension thereof services of the petitioner were liable to termination on a day's notice on either side and even after confirmation the appointment could be terminated at any time by a month's notice or by payment of salary in lieu of notice on either side without assigning any reason therefor. Some other conditions of service were as well specified but it is not necessary to refer to them.
9. By an application dated September 2, 1970, addressed to the General Manager (Transport) of the D.T.U, the petitioner requested that he may be relieved of his duties to enable him to join the post of works Engineer of the India Tourism Development Corporation. He also desired that his lien may be kept in the D.T.U for two years as the post offered to him was purely temporary and he would have to serve a period of probation. A reply was sent to the petitioner on October 22, 1970 by which he was Informed that his lien would be retained on the post of Assistant works Manager for a period of one year and that he would be granted leave without pay from October 23, 1970 to October 22, 1971. He was however, required to give his option before October 22, 1971 whether he would like to continue to work with the India Tourism Development Corporation or revert to the post of Assistant works Manager. The petitioner agreed to the terms on which the D.T.U agreed to relieve him and on being relieved took up the appointment of works Engineer in the India Tourism Development Corporation, where he is still working on probation.
10. Appointment to the post of works Manager in the D.T.U is to be made in consultation with the Union Public Service Commission. As provided by Section 96 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 no such consultation with the Commission is, however, necessary in regard to the selection for appointment for a period not exceeding one year.
11. Section 97 of the Delhi Municiple Corporation Act gives power to the Union Public Service Commission of making regulations laying down the procedure to be followed by the Commission for selecting candidates for appointment and by the Municipal Corporation for consulting the Commission. Regulations, called the Union Public Service Commission (Consultation by the Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations, 1959, were published with the Union Public Service Commission Notification dated August 1, 1959. Regulation 4(b) is to the effect that where appointment to any post is to be by promotion, the appointing authority, shall in consultation with the Commission specify the posts the holders of which shall be eligible for promotion and that the appointing authority shall also decide in consultation with the Commission whether promotion shall be by seniority, subject to the rejection of the unfit or whether it shall be by selection according to merits. Further Regulation 5(c) provides that where promotion is to be made by selection according to merit, a departmental promotion committee shall be constituted by the Commissioner or the General Manager, as the case may be, in consultation with the Commission consisting of the Chairman or other member of the Commission who shall be the Chairman of the committee, and a nominee or nominess of the Corporation and that the recommendations of the departmental promotion committee shall be forwarded to the Commission and the Commission after considering them shall communicate their advice to the Commissioner or the General Manager, as the case may be. There is a proviso to clause (c) of Regulation 5 that no person shall be eligible for appointment by promotion unless he is in the service of the Corporation in the department or the Undertaking where the post is to be filled.
12. Recruitment rules for the post of Works Manager in the D.T.U were made by the Municipal Corporation in consultation with the Union Public Service Commission. These rules or regulations made under section 98 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act provide that the post of Works Manager is to be a selection post to which recruitment can be made either by direct recruitment or by promotion. The essential qualifications for direct recruits were prescribed as under:—
“(i) Degree in Mechanical or Automobile Engineering of a recognised University or equivalent.
(ii) About five years experience in repair and maintenance of Heavy duty automotive diesel vehicles in a responsible supervisory capacity in a large workshop.
(iii) Adequate knowledge of latest production techniques and quality control.
(iv) Capacity for administrative work and for handling civilian labour.
(Qualifications relaxable at Commission's discretion in case of candidates otherwise well qualified).
13. For promotees also educational qualifications prescribed for direct recruits are applicable.
14. Before the appointment of Shri Ranjan as Works Manager was made for a period of six months the D.T.U wanted to fill that post through the Union Public Service Commission; The Union Public Service Commission after advertising the post and interviewing the candidates who applied for it informed the General Manager of the D.T.U, by a letter dated January 14, 1971 that none of the candidates was found suitable. It was mentioned in the letter that twenty-nine persons had applied and out of them thirteen were summoned for interview, but four candidates failed to appear. The Union Public Service Commission suggested that a fresh requisition for filling the post may be sent after six months and in the meantime the Delhi Transport Undertaking may make ‘ad-hoc arrangement fill up the post if considered necessary.”
15. On March 3, 1971 the General Manager (Transport) of the D.T.U submitted a report for consideration of the Delhi Transport Committee. In his report it was stated by him that the post of Works Manager was advertised by the Union Public Service Commission and Interviews were held on the 5th January 1971 but none of the candidates was found suitable. It was added that as filling the post was necessary, therefore, a departmental promotion committee consisting of ‘D.G.M C.O.S & P. and C.M.E” to consider Sarvashri P.N Raina and S.N Ranjan for the post of Works Manager was constituted and the committee found Shri Ranjan suitable for the post. A recommendation was, therefore, made that Shri Ranjan be appointed to the post of Works Manager on ad hoc basis for a period of one year in the first Instance.
16. The petitioner's grievance is that he was not even considered for appointment as Works Manager even though he still has his lien on the post of Assistant Works Manager. Contravention of the Union Public Service Commission (Consultation by the Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations was alleged. It was also averred that in constituting the departmental promotion committee the General Manager acted in a mala fide and arbitrary manner with ulterior motive solely for the purpose of promoting Shri Ranjan to the post of Works Manager.
17. In the counter affidavit filed on be behalf of the D.T.U the stand taken was that it was wrong that the petitioner was holding the post of Assistant Works Manager or had the necessary qualifications for the post of Works Manager. It was stated that automobile engineering examination passed by the petitioner was not a degree course but was a mere certificate course. It was also mentioned that Shri P.N Raina and Shri S.N Ranjan were senior to the petitioner as Assistant Works Managers. The reasons given for not calling the petitioner for interview were stated to be that he was not on the “Rolls of the Corporation” and was not working in the Undertaking where the post was to be filled and moreover had not completed five years service in the grade of Assistant Works Manager. Allegations regarding the General Manager acting arbitrarily or in a mala fide way were denied.
18. There can be no doubt that the petitioner has no degree in mechanical engineering or automobile engineering of a recognized university or a qualification which may have been recognized as equivalent to such a degree. For that matter Shri Ranjan has also no degree in mechanical or automobile engineering. Unless, therefore, qualifications are relaxed by the Union Public Service Commission while making a selection for the post of Works Manager neither the petitioner nor Shri Ranjan would be eligible. This was, however, incorrect that the petitioner did not fullfil the qualification of five years experience as Assistant Works Manager. His promotion as Assistant Works Manager was made effective from September 1, 1965 and, therefore, even before he was relived on October 23, 1970 for joining the post of Works Manager in the India Tourism Development Corporation he had already more than five years experience to his credit.
19. The Union Public Service Commission not having recommended any candidate as suitable for appointment as Works Manager and having itself suggested that if necessary ad hoc arrangement may be made till selection could be made on a fresh requisition to be sent after six months the steps taken by the General Manager to have the post filled on ad hoc basis cannot be said to be mala fide. The question of contravention of the provisions of regulation 4(b) and 5(c) of the Union Public Service Commission (Consultation by Delhi Municipal Corporation) Regulations, 1959 did not arise. By the recruitment rules the post has been already declared to be a selection post and the qualifications for eligibility as direct recruits and promotes had also been laid down. For ad hoc appointment not exceeding one year, as already stated above, no consultation with the Union Public Service Commission was necessary.
20. The lien of the petitioner having been kept for a period of one year and further as he was granted leave without pay for that period it has to be said that till his lien is not terminated be remains an employee of the D.T.U and it is not correct that he is neither on the rolls of the Corporation nor of the Undertaking where the post had to be filled up. The reasons given for not calling the petitioner for interview by the departmental promotion committee, as mentioned in the return submitted on behalf of the respondents, are badly tenable. The question, however, arises whether due to the petitioner not being called by the departmental promotion committee the ad hoc appointment of Shri Ranjan for a period of six months, which would expire in the month of October 1971, can be considered to have been vitiated. In my opinion, the answer is in the negative. As the persons called for interview were admittedly senior to the petitioner if any one could have a grievance against not being selected that could be Shri Raina who is even senior to Shri Ranjan but the former has not in any way challenged the ad hoc appointment of the next junior officer. The petitioner is already-working on probation on a post of equivalent pay scale to that of the Works Manager and even if he had been selected for six months he would have lost his chances of getting confirmed against the present post on which he is working. A bench of the Orissa High Court in Manotosh Behera v. State of Orissa (1970 Lab I.C 1478) observed as under in respect of ad hoc appointments made for a short period:—
“Ad hoc appointments, meant only for a temporary period, are mostly made to meet immediate needs and exigencies of service, and as such we cannot lay down as a rule that before making any such ad hoc appointments due consideration of the cases of all eligible candidates must be made as of principle. There is no sanction in law for such a proposition, and in our opinion such on imperative rule would adversely affect the management of public institutions by disabling them from urgently filling up important and emergent vacancies which might arise at times due to various contingencies.”
21. Even Shri D.N Vohra, learned counsel for the petitioner, requested that if after the expiry of the present ad hoc arrangement for six months another ad hoc arrangement has to be made then the petitioner may be duly considered and afforded an opportunity of appearing before the departmental promotion committee alongwith the other Works Managers. The request appears reasonable but it would depend whether at that time the lien of the petitioner is still on the post of Assistant Works Manager or he has given his option for coming back to the D.T.U from the India Tourism Development Corporation.
22. As the matters stand the petitioner is not entitled to any relief. The petition filed by him is dismissed but in view of the circumstances of the case I leave the parties to bear their own costs.
23. Petition dismissed.
Alert