Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

T.N Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 4, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The order arises from a series of interlocutory applications in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 202 of 1995 and connected matters concerning mining operations in several States, most prominently the State of Goa. The Central Empowered Committee (CEC) had submitted reports evaluating the legality and environmental compliance of various mining activities conducted under temporary licences. The Supreme Court examined these reports, the submissions of State authorities, and statements made on behalf of the affected licence-holders. The order primarily deals with (a) permission for sixteen temporary licence-holders in Goa to continue mining, (b) procedural lapses affecting two other licences, and (c) directions regarding compensatory afforestation funds and other pending interlocutory applications.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

Submissions of the Central Empowered Committee (CEC)

  • Out of eighteen temporary mining licences in Goa, sixteen were found to be operating in accordance with earlier directions, subject to further conditions.
  • Two licences (TC No. 63/51 and TC No. 67/52) suffered from procedural lapses in their grant.
  • Suggested utilisation of compensatory afforestation funds for forest improvement, mangroves, national parks and wildlife sanctuaries if degraded forest land was unavailable.
  • Reported that portions of the “land bank” had been re-utilised for mining contrary to earlier court directions.

Counsel for Sixteen Temporary Licence-Holders

  • Asserted that the entirety of the Net Present Value (NPV) demanded had been paid.
  • Informed the Court that compensatory afforestation work was already underway.

Forest Department, State of Goa

  • Stated that no degraded forest land was available within the State for compensatory afforestation, making utilisation of the funds difficult.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court relied chiefly on the factual assessments of the CEC and the undisputed payment of NPV by sixteen licence-holders. Accepting the CEC’s recommendation, the Court allowed these sixteen operators to continue mining but made the permission conditional on:

  • Payment of NPV for the entire forest area covered by each lease, after crediting amounts already paid.
  • Deposit of sums equivalent to the cost of compensatory afforestation on degraded forest land twice the size of the leased forest area (with specific exclusions for land broken up before 1987 or with valid permissions).
  • In cases where mining continued after 20-6-1987 without approval under the Forest Conservation Act, payment of penal compensatory afforestation charges on degraded land twice the forest area involved.
  • Preparation of a realistic reclamation and rehabilitation plan with time-bound activities and an effective monitoring mechanism.

For the remaining two licences affected by procedural defects, the Court granted three weeks for the holders to respond to the CEC’s findings and directed deposit of any outstanding NPV within four weeks of demand.

Regarding the absence of degraded forest land in Goa, the Court sought the State’s response within six weeks to the CEC’s proposal of utilising funds for alternate ecological improvements. Other pending interlocutory applications were either listed for future dates, disposed of for non-prosecution, or limited to issuance of notice.

Holding and Implications

Permitted: Sixteen temporary mining licence-holders in Goa may continue operations subject to strict conditions on NPV payment, compensatory afforestation, penal charges where applicable, and formulation of a rehabilitation plan.

For two licences with procedural lapses, the Court allowed time to respond and required prompt payment of any outstanding NPV.

Additional directions were issued for filing of responses, listing of matters on specified future dates, and potential re-allocation of compensatory afforestation funds.

The order resolves immediate operational questions for specific licence-holders but does not articulate a new legal precedent; its implications are confined to enforcing environmental compliance in the ongoing litigation.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The State of Rajasthan has filed Annual Progress Report 2006-2007. CEC will file its response regarding the report within a period of two weeks. All the matters relating to mining operation of both States of Haryana and Rajasthan be posted on 25-1-2008.

IAs Nos. 1413-14, 1426, 1428, 1440, 1454, 1459, 1460, 1662-63, 1675, 1778, 1796, 2005-06, 2121-32 and 2133 in 1413 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

2. Eighteen temporary licences were granted in the State of Goa and the licensees were doing mining activities. CEC has examined the viability of the functioning of these mining activities and found that out of the eighteen temporary licensees, sixteen licensees are working properly. CEC has stated that subject to fulfilment of certain conditions, they can function.

3. The learned counsel appearing for the said sixteen temporary licence-holders submitted that the entire NPV amount demanded by the authority has been paid by the licensees and the compensatory afforestation work is under way. Therefore, we permit the sixteen temporary licence-holders to carry out the mining activities, subject to fulfilment of the following conditions:

(i) NPV for the entire forest area included in the mining lease will be payable by the mining lease-holders after deducting the amount of NPV already paid;
(ii) the amount for carrying out compensatory afforestation in degraded forest land, twice the forest area included in the mining lease after excluding the forest area broken up prior to 1987 and broken thereafter with valid permissions, will be payable by the lease-holders;
(iii) in respect of mines where mining has continued beyond 20-6-1987 without obtaining the approval under the Forest Conservation Act i.e after the constitutional validity of the Goa, Daman and Diu Concession (Abolition and Declaration) Act, 1987 has been upheld by the Hon'ble High Court of Bombay, Panaji Bench in Writ Petition No. 293 of 1989, penal compensatory afforestation charges are payable by the lease-holders for carrying out mining during the period between 1987 and till the date on which the approvals under the Forest Conservation Act were accorded. It is recommended that in such cases the lease-holders may be asked to pay charges for penal compensatory afforestation over degraded forest land, twice the forest area included in the mining leases; and
(iv) a realistic and effective plan for reclamation and rehabilitation of mined area should be drawn up along with specific time-limits for each prescribed activity and an effective monitoring mechanism should be put in place for this purpose.

4. As regards the rest two temporary licence-holders, TC No. 63/51 C.F Naik (TWP application by Rajesh Timblo) and TC No. 67/52 of M/s A.V.S Velingkar, according to CEC there are procedural lapses in granting the licences. These parties may reply to the report of CEC within a period of three weeks. Adjourned by four weeks. If any NPV remains to be paid, the same has to be deposited within a period of four weeks from the date of demand.

5. The Forest Department, State of Goa has stated that there is no degraded forest land available for afforestation work and the State is finding it difficult to utilise the money received towards the compensatory afforestation. CEC has suggested that if the degraded forest land is not available, the money can be utilised for improving forests and also mangroves, national parks and wildlife sanctuaries. The State Government to file its response within a period of six weeks whether such activities could be carried out. List thereafter.

Third Report of CEC

6. Third report of CEC in IAs Nos. 1413 and 1414 be listed after three weeks.

IAs Nos. 1335, 1356 and 1388 in 989 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

7. Ministry of Coal and M/s Aryan Coal Benefication (P) Ltd. shall file response to the CEC report within a period of four weeks.

IA No. 1345 in 1252

8. No orders are required to be passed for the time being.

IA No. 1346 in 1227-28

9. As requested by the learned counsel for the applicant, list after one week.

IA No. 1348 in 1036

10. The applicant is not present. The IA is disposed of accordingly.

IA No. 1349 in 1246-47, 1378-80, 1446-47 and 1502

11. CEC has pointed out that some of the lands included in the land bank have been again utilised for the mining activities contrary to the direction of this Court. The matter requires consideration. The State as well as the Union of India has filed their affidavits. The matter be posted for hearing on 1-2-2008.

IA No. 2065 @ Contempt Petition No. 61 of 2007 in 21145-2115 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

12. List on 1-2-2008.

IA No. 2120 in 1360 in 1130 and 1152 in WP (C) No. 202 of 1995

13. Issue notice. Notice to CEC.

14. Learned counsel appearing for State of West Bengal accepts notice. The State and CEC to file reply within a period of four weeks. IA No. 1429 (Sawmills of West Bengal) be also posted along with this matter.

IA No. 3 in WP (C) No. 314 of 2006

15. Issue notice. Copy to be supplied to the learned amicus curiae who shall examine the matter.

Court Masters