Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India () v. Shri Krishan Kumar ().

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Aug 31, 1981

S.P Goyal, J.:— The respondent, Krishan Kumar, a Khalasi in the Railway Workshop, Jagadhri, was charge-sheeted on October 13, 1966, for theft on having been found carrying Railway articles in his bag when he was passing the main gate of the Workshop. After a regular enquiry, the Enquiry Officer vide report, Exhibit D-23, held that the charge against him was not proved. The Assistant Works Manager, the disciplinary authority, however, did not agree with the said report and vide his order, Exhibit D-15, came to the conclusion that the charge against the respondent stood proved. The respondent was consequently served with notice, Exhibit D-14 to show cause as to why he should not be removed from service. After taking into consideration bis explanation, the following order, Exhibit D.W 1.A, was passed:—

“I have thoroughly gone through the defence put up by Shri Krishan Kumar, T. No. 885. There is no new point put up by him which needs further consideration. He is considered guilty of the charge of theft of Railway material and is removed from service.”

2. The appeal filed by the respondent was also dismissed with the following order:—

“I have heard him on dated (13-1-1968). He had nothing else to say that what he has stated in his defence. I see no reason to revise A.W.M's order. He has been correctly dealt with. His appeal is rejected.”

3. These orders were challenged by him by way of this suit on various grounds but the trial Court quashed the dismissal order on the ground that the same did not contain any reason and were non-speaking orders.

4. On appeal, learned District Judge, Ambala, disagreed with the view of the trial Court but confirmed the decree on the ground that the Assistant Works Manager was not the appointing authority of the respondent, still dissatisfied, the Union of India has come up in this second appeal.

5. Learned counsel for the appellant after referring to the provisions of the rules, Exhibits D.W 1 and D.W 1.C contende???. that the Assistant Works Manager was also competent to take disciplinary action against the respondent. The learned counsel for the respondent did not dispute this proposition but sought to sustain the impugned judgment on the ground that the orders passed by the disciplinary and the appellate authority were cryptic orders containing no reasons. He further argued that in a case where the punishing authority differs with the finding of the Enquiry Officer, the delinquent officer gets only one chance to put up his defence before that authority when he submits his ???xplanation to the second show-cause notice and, therefore, the authority must pass a speaking order giving reasons for rejecting the explanation. In support of his contention, be relied on Harmander Singh v. The General Manager, Northern Railway, 1973 (1) S.L.R 846 and K.H Shukla v. The State of Gujarat, 1977 (2) S.L.R 270.

6. Learned counsel for the appellant, on the other hand, relying on State of Madras v. A.R Srinivasan, A.I.R 1966 S.C 1827 and the State of Haryana v. Shri Ram Chander, 1976 (2) S.L.R 690 argued that the punishing authority is not required to pass a reasoned order while passing the punishment order when a detailed order had been passed earlier while differing with the report of the Enquiry Officer. None of the two decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant, however, support his contention. In Srinivasan's case (supra), the punishing authority had noticed in detail the facts of the case and also referred to the advice given by the Public Service Commission in the dismissal order. So far as Ram Chander's case (supra) is concerned, there was no such question before the Full Bench and what was held in that case was that the disciplinary authority need not give detailed reasons if it agrees with the findings of the Enquiry Officer.

7. The order passed by the disciplinary authority and reproduced above does not show as to what were the points raised by the respondent and why were those found to be not tenable. All that has been said in the order was that there was no new point put up by him which needed further consideration. In the circumstances of this case from this observation it cannot be inferred that the disciplinary authority had considered the points raised by the respondent in his explanation and had rejected them rationally.

8. In view of the above discussion, I do not find any merit in this appeal and the same is hereby dismissed but without any order as to cost.

9. Appeal dismissed.