Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M. Kudubdeen v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 27, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was apprehended at Chennai Airport carrying 140 mobile phones and certain gold ornaments valued at approximately Rs 7,29,000. A customs declaration completed by the petitioner reflected a declared value of only Rs 30,000. Relying on this incident, the detaining authority issued an order dated 9-5-2002 under Section 3(1)(i) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA), directing preventive detention to forestall future acts of smuggling. While in custody as a remand prisoner, the petitioner invoked Article 32 of the Constitution seeking quashing of the detention order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the alleged non-supply of a Tamil translation of the English portion of the customs declaration violated the petitioner’s right under Article 22(5) to make an effective representation, thereby vitiating the detention order.
  2. Whether, in view of the petitioner’s continued custody, repeated refusal of bail and seizure of his passport, there existed a “compelling necessity” for issuing a preventive detention order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner, who has studied only up to fifth standard and understands only Tamil, was not supplied with a Tamil translation of the English front page of the customs declaration, adversely affecting his constitutional right to representation under Article 22(5).
  • There was no compelling necessity for preventive detention because:
    • He was already in judicial custody with three bail applications rejected.
    • His passport had been seized, making future international travel—and hence smuggling—impossible.
    • The Supreme Court’s decision in Rajesh Gulati v. Govt. (NCT of Delhi) (2002) 7 SCC 129, para 14, supports the view that seizure of a passport forecloses the likelihood of smuggling.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rajesh Gulati v. Govt. (NCT of Delhi) (2002) 7 SCC 129 Retention of passport may negate the likelihood of future smuggling, undermining “compelling necessity” for detention. Distinguished. Court held the present facts showed additional material (frequent foreign visits, nature of goods, etc.) demonstrating potential for continued smuggling despite passport seizure.
Abdul Sathar Ibrahim Manik v. Union of India (1992) 1 SCC 1 Subjective satisfaction of detaining authority regarding “compelling necessity” is generally not justiciable, even where the detenu is already in custody and passport is seized. Relied upon to uphold the detaining authority’s subjective satisfaction and to reject the petitioner’s challenge on grounds of absence of necessity.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

First Ground – Non-supply of Tamil Translation:

  • The customs declaration is a relied-upon document. Its reverse side, containing the critical figure of Rs 30,000, was written predominantly in Tamil by the petitioner himself.
  • The English front page contained only rudimentary particulars—name, flight number, package details, tick mark against value, and signature—all of which the petitioner had filled in.
  • Given the Tamil reverse side and the petitioner’s own completion of the English fields, the Court found no prejudice to the right of effective representation. Accordingly, the allegation under Article 22(5) lacked merit.

Second Ground – Absence of Compelling Necessity:

  • The Court noted factual distinctions from Rajesh Gulati: the petitioner possessed an additional passport booklet, had undertaken numerous foreign trips despite limited means, and carried goods inconsistent with bona fide passenger baggage under the Export & Import Policy 1997-2002 and Section 79 of the Customs Act, 1962.
  • Smuggling can occur through channels other than personal foreign travel; seizure of a passport does not, by itself, eliminate the risk.
  • Relying on Abdul Sathar Ibrahim Manik, the Court emphasized that the adequacy of material underlying the detaining authority’s subjective satisfaction is not open to scrutiny in writ jurisdiction where some relevant material exists—as it did here.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is dismissed.

Direct Consequence: The detention order dated 9-5-2002 under COFEPOSA remains in force, and the petitioner continues to be preventively detained.

Broader Implications: The decision reiterates that (a) partial translation deficiencies do not vitiate detention when no real prejudice is shown, and (b) seizure of a passport, even coupled with custody, does not automatically negate “compelling necessity”; the detaining authority’s subjective satisfaction will not be interfered with if supported by some material. No new legal precedent was established.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India has been filed seeking quashing of order of detention dated 9-5-2002 passed under Section 3(1)(i) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 whereby the petitioner has been ordered to be detained with a view to prevent him from smuggling goods in future.

2. Though various grounds have been taken in the writ petition challenging the order of detention and continued detention of the petitioner, Mr K.K Mani, learned counsel for the petitioner, however, pressed only two grounds.

3. The first ground pressed by the learned counsel is about the non-supply of documents in the language known to the petitioner which, it is claimed, has adversely affected the detenu's valuable right of making effective representation under Article 22(5) of the Constitution. The detenu claims to have studied up to fifth standard. He does not know how to read, write and understand English and claims to know only the Tamil language. The documents whereof the English (sic Tamil) translation has not been supplied to the detenu is a customs declaration. According to the facts noticed in the ground of detention, the petitioner was apprehended at Chennai Airport with 140 mobile phones and certain gold ornaments. The total value of the goods was approximately Rs 7,29,000. In the customs declaration the value of the goods was mentioned as Rs 30,000. The details about Rs 30,000 are noticed on the reverse of the document in respect of which the complaint has been made that the English (sic Tamil) translation has not been supplied. It is apparent from a look at the document, namely, the customs declaration that the reverse side of it is predominantly in the Tamil language. It is written by the petitioner. The grievance made is in respect of the front portion of the customs declaration. That is in English. It is contended that the Tamil translation of the front portion has not been supplied. It is a relied-upon document.

4. A perusal of the said document (front portion) shows that the material particulars therein are the name of the passenger, flight number, numbers of the packages, checked baggage, hand baggage, total value of the dutiable goods being imported and signature. All these particulars have been filled in that document. The name, flight number and number of packages have been mentioned in the document in question. Against the value of the goods tick mark has been made. The document has been signed by the detenu. In the face of the above details given by the detenu in the aforesaid declaration, the contention that the translation thereof has not been supplied particularly keeping in view that the reverse is in the Tamil language, is without any substance. Therefore, there is no merit in the contention that non-supply of the English (sic Tamil) translation of the document has resulted in depriving the petitioner from making an effective representation under Article 22(5) of the Constitution. The first contention is therefore rejected.

5. The second contention urged by the learned counsel is that there was no compelling necessity to make an order of detention since the detenu was already in custody as a remand prisoner and his three bail applications had been rejected and his passport had been seized. The submission of the learned counsel is that there was no compelling necessity since the petitioner could not, even if released on bail, indulge in prejudicial activity of smuggling for the reason that his passport had been seized by the authorities and therefore he could not travel abroad. In support, reliance has been placed on the decision in Rajesh Gulati v. Govt. (NCT of Delhi) (2002) 7 SCC 129 in particular on the observations made in para 14 to the effect that the likelihood of the appellant, in that case, indulging in smuggling activities was in any case effectively foreclosed by the retention of his passport by the Customs Department. It was found that the conclusion that despite the absence of the passport the detenu therein could or would be able to continue his activities is based on no material but was a piece of pure speculation on the part of the detaining authority.

6. It is apparent that on the facts and circumstances of Rajesh Gulati case (2002) 7 SCC 129, that the Court came to the conclusion that in view of the seizure of the passport there was absence of material for coming to the conclusion that the detenu would continue in his prejudicial activities. The facts of the present case are that the petitioner had an additional booklet attached to his passport. The passport of the petitioner indicated various foreign visits made by him abroad. The further material before the detaining authority was that he was not a big businessman; did not own any immovable property and was not a person who was holding such a position so as to make frequent trips abroad; was not a person returning to India from a foreign tour or after serving abroad for a considerable period of time. The baggage brought by the detenu did not conform to the bona fide passenger baggage as per the relevant provisions of the Export and Import Policy for 1997-2002 read with Section 79 of the Customs Act, 1962. We have already noticed the articles which were being attempted to be brought and the value thereof.

7. In view of these facts, in the present case, it is not possible to accept the contention that there was no material before the detaining authority to arrive at a conclusion that there was compelling necessity to detain the petitioner with a view to prevent him in indulging in prejudicial activity, namely, smuggling of the goods despite seizure of his passport. Further, making foreign trips is not the only mode of smuggling.

8. Abdul Sathar Ibrahim Manik v. Union of India (1992) 1 SCC 1 was a case where the detenu was in jail, his bail application had been rejected and his passport seized. A similar contention regarding compelling necessity was rejected by this Court. It is within the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority to come to the conclusion whether there is compelling necessity to make an order of detention in respect of a person who was in jail and whose passport had been seized. The sufficiency of material in arriving at the subjective satisfaction cannot be gone into in exercise of the writ jurisdiction. It is not a case of absence of material altogether. It cannot, therefore, be held that the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority about the compelling necessity stands vitiated. No other ground was urged.

9. In view of the aforesaid reasons, the writ petition is dismissed.