Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tanaji Krishna Shinde v. Mahadeo Maruti Pisal

Bombay High Court
Aug 6, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

In Regular Civil Suit No. 34 of 1978 the trial Court, by judgment and order dated 27 October 1986, refused specific performance of an agreement of sale dated 3 December 1973 (Exhibit 71). The trial Court directed Defendant No. 1-A to return Rs. 1,000 to the plaintiffs with interest at 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit until payment. That judgment was challenged in Regular Civil Appeal No. 13 of 1987. The lower appellate Court allowed the appeal on 17 August 1992 and passed a decree for specific performance of Exhibit 71. The operative portion of the lower appellate Court's order required Defendant No. 1-A to apply for permission under the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act to sell the suit land in favour of the plaintiffs, and, upon receiving such permission, to receive the remaining consideration and execute a sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs; registration charges were to be borne by Defendant No. 1-A and Defendant No. 2 was to join as executant. The plaintiffs were directed to recover joint possession after execution, and were entitled to execute the decree through process of law if the defendants failed to obtain permission and execute the sale deed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the agreement of sale dated 3 December 1973 in favour of the Plaintiff was unenforceable since the sale of the suit land would admittedly create a fragment and was thus illegal under Sections 6, 7 and 31 of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act?
  2. Whether the finding recorded by the lower Appellate Court in paragraph 17 of his judgment that the suit land is not an irrigated land since it receives well water is legal and proper?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded on the accepted premise (recorded in the opinion) that if the proposed sale, by agreement, would create a fragment then the transaction would be governed by Sections 6, 7 and 31 of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act. In view of that legal position, the lower appellate Court's directions requiring Defendant No. 1-A to apply for permission to sell the suit land to the plaintiffs under that Act were noted and upheld.

The Court observed that the questions whether a fragment is created and whether the land is irrigated are matters for the Competent Authority under the Act. Accordingly:

  • If the Competent Authority holds that permission under the Act is not required, the decree passed by the lower appellate Court would become unenforceable (as framed in the opinion).
  • If the Competent Authority grants permission under the Act, the lower appellate Court's decree would become enforceable on the terms specified in that decree.
  • The Competent Authority is to decide all questions arising between the parties in respect of fragmentation (and related issues) without being influenced by observations made by any of the courts below.

Having recorded these clarifications about the role of the Competent Authority and the conditional enforceability of the decree, the Court concluded that no alteration of the lower appellate Court's judgment and order was required.

Holding and Implications

Core ruling: The second appeal is disposed of and no alteration is made to the judgment and order passed by the lower appellate Court.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The decree of the lower appellate Court for specific performance (as reproduced in the opinion) stands, subject to the condition that Defendant No. 1-A shall first apply for and obtain any permission required under the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act. Upon receiving permission, Defendant No. 1-A is to receive the remaining consideration and execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs; registration charges are to be borne by Defendant No. 1-A; Defendant No. 2 is to join as executant; and the plaintiffs may recover possession after execution.
  • If the Competent Authority decides that permission is not required, the decree will become unenforceable; if permission is granted, the decree will be enforceable on the terms specified by the lower appellate Court.
  • The Competent Authority must decide issues of fragmentation and irrigation independently and without regard to the courts' observations.
  • The civil application, if any, before this Court does not survive following disposal of the appeal.
Show all summary ...

R.K Deshpande, J.:— 1] In Regular Civil Suit No. 34 of 1978, the trial Court by its judgment and order dated 27th October, 1986 refused to grant specific performance of the agreement of sale dated 3rd December, 1973 at Exh. 71. The Defendant No. 1-A is, however, directed to return to the plaintiffs Rs. 1000/- together with interest thereon at the rte of 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit till the actual payment is made. This was the subject matter of challenge in Regular Civil Appeal No. 13 of 1987, which has been decided by the lower appellate Court on 17 August, 1992. The lower appellate Court has passed a decree for specific performance of agreement at Exh. 71. The operative portion of the order passed by the lower appellate Court being relevant, is reproduced below.

“The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and decree is set aside. The plaintiff's suit is decreed for specific performance of the agreement of sale deed dated 3 December, 1973 (Exhibit 71) as follows:

The Defendant No. 1-A shall immediately apply for permission to sell the suit land in favour of the Plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8 to the Competent Authority under the provisions of Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act, within period of one month after receiving such permission, she shall receiving remaining consideration of Rs. 7,100 from the Plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8 and shall execute sale deed in respect of the suit lands in their favour. The registration charges shall be incurred by the Defendant No. 1-A. The Defendant No. 2 shall join the Defendant No. 1-A as executant No. 2 of the sale deed.

The Plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8 shall recover joint possession of the suit lands from the Defendant No. 2 after execution of the sale deed.

On failure of the Defendant to obtain sale permission and execute sale deed as stated above, the Plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8 would be entitled to get the decree executed through process of law.

The Defendant Nos. 1-A and the Defendant No. 2 shall bear their own costs and shall costs of the suit and that of the appeal, to the plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8/-

2. The substantial questions of law framed by this Court and pressed by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant are contained in paragraph 1(a) and 1(b) of the memo of appeal, which are reproduced below.

(a) Whether the agreement of the sale dated 3 December, 1973, in favour of the Plaintiff was unenforceable since the sale of the suit land would admittedly create a fragment and was thus illegal under Sections 6, 7 and 31 of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act?

(b) Whether the finding recorded by the lower Appellate Court in paragraph 17 of his judgment that the suit land is not an irrigated land since it receives well water is legal and proper?

3. It is not disputed that if by way of agreement to sell, the land proposed to be sold creates a fragment then it would be hit by Section 6, 7 and 31 of the Bombay Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of Holdings Act. Keeping in view this aspect of the matter, the lower appellate Court has issued directions to the defendant no. 1-A to immediately apply for permission to sell the suit land in favour of the plaintiff Nos. 1-1 to 1-8 to the competent Authority under the said Act and upon receiving such permission, the defendant no. 1-A shall receive the remaining consideration of Rs. 7,000/- from the plaintiff nos. 1-1 to 1-8 and shall execute the sale deed in their favour.

4. It is not in dispute that all the questions in respect of creation of fragment and also of the fact whether the land in question is an irrigated land are required to be decided by the Competent Authority under the said Act. If the questions are answered holding that such permission is not required to be granted then the decree passed by the lower appellate Court shall become uneforceable, but if the competent Authority grants the permission then the decree would become enforceable on the terms specified in the order passed by the lower appellate Court. It is also made clear that the Competent Authority under the said Act shall decide all the questions arising between the parties in respect of fragment without being influenced by any of the observations either made by this Court or the lower appellate Court or the trial Court.

5. With this clarification, no alteration is called for in the judgment and order passed by the lower appellate Court. The second appeal stands disposed of.

6. Consequently, the civil application, if any, does not survive.