- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Harish Chandra Singh Rawat And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 11567 of 2016 challenges the judgment dated 21-4-2016 of the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India, 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, which had quashed the Presidential Proclamation dated 27-3-2016 issued under Article 356 of the Constitution.
On 22-4-2016, the Supreme Court issued notice, kept the High Court judgment in abeyance, and directed that the Presidential Proclamation would not be revoked until further orders. Subsequent hearings on 4-5-2016 and the present date focused on the Court’s oral suggestion that the controversy be resolved through a floor test in the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly. After consultations among the Attorney General, senior counsel for the respondent Chief Minister, counsel for the Speaker, and other representatives, consensus was reached on holding a Court-supervised floor test.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, pending final adjudication of the SLP, the Supreme Court could devise an interim arrangement requiring a floor test to determine whether the incumbent Chief Minister enjoys the confidence of the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly.
- What safeguards and modalities should govern such a Court-supervised floor test, including supervision, security, voting procedure, and treatment of disqualified members.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners (Union of India)
- The Attorney General stated that the Union had “no objection” to a floor test being conducted to resolve the impasse.
- Agreed that the test could be held under the supervision of the Supreme Court and accepted the procedural framework suggested by the Court.
Respondent 1 (Shri Harish Chandra Singh Rawat)
- Through senior counsel, concurred with the proposal for a Court-monitored floor test and raised no objection to the suggested date or procedure.
Submission on behalf of Disqualified MLAs
- Mr C.A. Sundaram, Senior Counsel, urged that the disqualified Members of the Legislative Assembly be permitted to participate in the vote, even if their votes were ultimately not counted while the disqualification subsists.
- The Court noted the submission but declined to issue directions permitting their participation, clarifying that its observation would not prejudice the ongoing litigation concerning their disqualification.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted the unanimity among counsel that a floor test was the most appropriate method to ascertain the actual majority in the House. Stressing the need for an expeditious and transparent process, it prescribed a detailed framework:
- A special session of the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly is to be convened on 10-5-2016 at 11:00 a.m. with the sole agenda of a confidence motion moved by Respondent 1.
- No other business shall be transacted; proceedings must remain peaceful.
- The Chief Secretary and Director General of Police are charged with ensuring that all qualified MLAs can attend and vote freely and securely.
- The Principal Secretary of the Assembly will supervise voting, which will be by division and recorded individually by a show of hands. Proceedings shall be videographed.
- The video recording and the result of the vote are to be placed before the Court in a sealed cover at 10:30 a.m. on 11-5-2016.
- The Court expressly refrained from directing participation of disqualified MLAs, leaving that issue to the pending proceedings in the High Court.
- To facilitate the test, the Presidential Proclamation will stand “in abeyance” from 10:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. on 10-5-2016, during which time the Governor will exercise the functions of the State.
- After 1:00 p.m., the earlier interim order of 22-4-2016 reviving President’s Rule will again operate until further orders.
Holding and Implications
ORDERED: A floor test of the Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly shall be conducted on 10-5-2016 under the supervision and modalities set out by the Supreme Court; the Presidential Proclamation is suspended only for the limited period required to hold the vote, and the result is to be produced before the Court on 11-5-2016.
Implications: The immediate consequence is that the numerical strength of the Chief Minister will be objectively tested, potentially resolving the constitutional standoff without prolonged litigation. The order is interim in nature; it sets no new precedent but demonstrates the Court’s willingness to craft practical, temporally-limited solutions when constitutional crises arise.
1.-5. See at (2016) 16 SCC 748(1) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
6.-8. See at (2016) 16 SCC 748(2) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1850. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
9.-11. See at (2016) 16 SCC 749(1) : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1851. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
SLP (C) No. 11567 of 2016
12. The present special leave petition is directed against the judgment and order dated 21-4-2016, passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, whereby the Division Bench has quashed the order of Proclamation dated 27-3-2016, issued by the President of India under Article 356 of the Constitution of India. We need not advert to any of the facts that have been adumbrated in the said judgment, for the nature of the order we are passing today. That is for another day.
13. When the special leave petition was taken up on 22-4-2016 the Court issued notice and passed the following order:
“1. Issue notice.
2. As Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel along with Mr Amit Bhandari, learned counsel has entered appearance on behalf of Respondent 1, no further notice need be issued. As far as Respondent 2 is concerned, let service be effected through Dasti.
3. Let the matter be listed on 27-4-2016. The High Court is requested to provide the judgment dated 21-4-2016, passed in Harish Chandra Singh Rawat v. Union of India 2016 SCC OnLine Utt 502, to the parties by 26-4-2016. The judgment shall be filed before this Court on that day.
4. Having heard Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India in connected special leave petitions, Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1 and Mr Kapil Sibal, learned Senior Counsel for the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, Uttarakhand, it is directed that the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance till 27-4-2016. That apart, as undertaken by Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, the Union of India shall not revoke the Presidential Proclamation till the next date of hearing.”
14. Be it stated, after the said order was passed, the judgment passed by the High Court was brought on record and the petitioner had sought time to amend the special leave petition to incorporate the grounds assailing the defensibility of the same and the same was permitted. The matter was adjourned thereafter and when it was listed on 4-5-2016, regard being had to the oral suggestion given on the prior date, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General, submitted that the Union of India was seriously considering the suggestion given by this Court to have a floor test of the Assembly to put an end to the controversy that has emerged in this case. Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Mr Kapil Sibal and Dr Rajeev Dhavan, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent 1 submitted that they had no objection. The matter was accordingly adjourned and the interim order was allowed to remain in force.
15. Today, Mr Mukul Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, has submitted that the petitioners have no objection to have a floor test of the Assembly. The learned counsel appearing for both the sides have debated over the suggestions that have been given by the Court, as well as by each other, sometimes with appreciable amity and sometimes with some cavil, but, eventually, there has been an agreement.
16. Be it noted, the learned counsel appearing for Respondent 1, very fairly stated, which was conceded to by Mr Rohatgi, learned Attorney General for the Union of India, that they have no objection and we state it with uninhibited appreciation at our command that the floor test should be conducted under the supervision of this Court. The agreed position which has emerged after quite a long debate, is recorded below:
16.1. A Special Session of Uttarakhand Legislative Assembly be summoned/convened on 10-5-2016, commencing 11.00 a.m.
16.2. The only agenda in the Assembly would be the vote of confidence sought by Respondent 1, namely, Shri Harish Singh Rawat.
16.3. Apart from the said agenda, nothing else shall be discussed in the Assembly.
16.4. The proceedings in the Assembly are expected to be absolutely peaceful and without any disturbance. This Court expects that all the Members and all concerned with the affairs of the Assembly shall abide by the same in letter and spirit.
16.5. The Chief Secretary and the Director General of Police, State of Uttarakhand, shall see that all the qualified Members of the Legislative Assembly, freely, safely and securely attend the Assembly and no interference or hindrance is caused by anyone therein.
16.6. Mr Maninder Singh, learned Senior Counsel, being assisted by Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the State of Uttarakhand, shall convey it to the Chief Secretary and the Director General of the Police of the State of Uttarakhand so that the order is carried out as directed hereinabove, because it is the duty of the State and its high officials to take care to do so.
16.7. The Assembly Session shall commence at 11.00 a.m. for the singular agenda, that is, the floor test of the Assembly and shall be over by 1.00 p.m.
16.8. On the confidence motion having been put, a division of the House shall take place and the Members who are inclined to vote in favour of the motion, shall sit on the one wing/side and the others who are against the motion, shall sit on the other wing/side.
16.9. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall see to it that the voting is appositely done and recorded.
16.10. The Members voting in favour of the motion shall singularly vote by raising their hands one by one and that will be counted by the Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly. Similar procedure shall be adopted while the Members voting against the motion.
16.11. The entire proceedings shall be videographed and the video recording shall be placed before this Court so that it can be perused by this Court, if required.
16.12. The result of the voting shall be placed before this Court at 10.30 a.m. on 11-5-2016, in a sealed cover.
17. Having stated about the mode of voting, computation, the person in-charge and also the control to be made outside the House, the smooth functioning and entry of the Members, we are obliged to record the submission of Mr C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel, which has been done with immense vehemence. His submission is that the disqualified Members should be allowed to vote, though their votes may not be counted as long as the disqualification remains. This Court cannot direct them to participate in the Assembly. We say no more on this score. However, our observation in praesenti will not cause any kind of prejudice to the merits of the case of disqualified Members of Legislative Assembly, which is sub judice before the High Court.
18. As the parties have conceded for the floor test and we have recorded the method, to give effect to the same, there has to be a variation of the order passed by us on the earlier occasion and, accordingly, we direct that Presidential Proclamation shall remain in abeyance from 10.30 a.m. to 1.00 p.m. on 10-5-2016, and during that period the Governor shall remain in charge of the State. Needless to say, after 1.00 p.m. the judgment of the High Court shall remain in abeyance and our order passed on 22-4-2016, shall revive.
19. Let the matter be listed on 11-5-2016.
20. The Principal Secretary, Legislative Assembly of the State of Uttarakhand, shall come on that day with the documents in the sealed cover and the video recording of the proceedings.
21. The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to communicate this order to the Chief Secretary of the State of Uttarakhand. A copy of the order be also handed over to Mr Maninder Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the State of Uttarakhand, to do the needful in the matter.
SLPs (C) Nos. … (CCs Nos. 7915-16) and SLP (C) No. … (CC No. 7916 of 2016)
22. Let these matters be listed on 11-5-2016.
23.-31. See at (2016) 16 SCC 752 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 618. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
32.-37. See at (2016) 16 SCC 755 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 488. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
38.-49. See at (2016) 16 SCC 757 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1852. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
50. See at (2016) 16 SCC 758 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 1853. See Combined Report at (2016) 16 SCC 744 : 2016 SCC OnLine SC 354.
Alert