Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Damodar Anant Karandikar And Others v. Board Of Trustees Of The Port Of Bombay And Others

Bombay High Court
Aug 29, 1988
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Bombay Port Trust (Major Port Trusts Act, 1963)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are (1) Damodar Anant Karandikar, an employee of the Bombay Port Trust, and (2) the Bombay Port Trust Non-Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes Employees Association. They filed a writ petition challenging the Bombay Port Trust's promotion and reservation policy for Class III and Class IV employees.

Core facts admitted by both sides: the Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay (first respondent) is a statutory body under the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 and thus a "State" within Article 12 of the Constitution. Recruitment and promotion for Class III and IV posts are local: employees are recruited regionally (Bombay), posted to departments within the Port and their promotional opportunities are confined to the same department and local area.

The petitioners alleged that although initial recruitment quota followed State-of-Maharashtra percentages (6% SC and 6% ST initially; increased to 7% SC and 9% ST from June 1985), the Port Trust adopted a 40-point (All-India) roster for promotions—reserving 15% posts for SC and 7.5% for ST—without framing regulations under Section 28 of the Act. Petitioners claimed this increased reservation in promotions denied senior employees promotions based on seniority and sought: (a) a seniority list as on 1 June 1977 and promotions based on seniority; (b) quashing of promotions already granted; and (c) a direction to frame statutory regulations for Class III and Class IV employees.

Procedural history includes an earlier writ petition (No. 1075 of 1980) with an interim order dated 2 May 1980; the present petition was filed in 1982 and interim relief was granted on 22 April 1982 making promotions subject to final order. The Court declined to upset promotions granted on or before 2 May 1980 but held promotions after that date subject to the result of the petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bombay Port Trust is obliged under Section 28 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 to frame regulations governing appointment, promotion and other conditions of service for Class III and Class IV employees.
  2. Whether the Port Trust's adoption of an All-India (40-point) roster for promotional reservations (15% SC and 7.5% ST) is lawful and appropriate where initial recruitment and service of the cadre are confined locally to Bombay and initial reservation percentages followed State (Maharashtra) norms (6%/6% initially; 7%/9% from June 1985).
  3. Whether promotions already granted (particularly those after 2 May 1980) must be quashed or regularised in light of the proper reservation basis and seniority-cum-fitness principles.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The Bombay Port Trust failed to frame regulations under Section 28 governing conditions of service for Class III and IV employees, which it is obliged to do.
  • Promotions should be effected on a local basis and on seniority-cum-fitness; adoption of a 40-point (All-India) roster for promotions resulted in reserving a larger number of promotional posts for SC/ST and denied promotions to deserving candidates by seniority.
  • The Port Trust's practice therefore violated petitioners' fundamental rights and contravened Union of India rules and policies to the extent inconsistent.
  • The petitioners stated they were not opposed to reservation per se but sought that reservation in promotions be fair, in tune with applicable guidelines, and consistent with local recruitment percentages.

Respondents' Arguments (Bombay Port Trust and Union of India)

  • The Port Trust, being under control of the Government of India, was bound to follow the policy laid down by the Union of India. The Government's policy (brochure) prescribes uniform reservation percentages in promotions for Class III and IV posts: 15% for SC and 7½% for ST to achieve uniformity.
  • Although the Port Trust had not framed separate regulations for Class III and IV employees, it followed general policy and the regulations framed for Class I and II (specifically referencing regulation 13 and other regulations), applying those principles by analogy to lower classes.
  • Therefore, respondents contended there was no substance in petitioners' challenge to the reservation practice on promotions.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first establishing the statutory and factual backdrop and then applying statutory interpretation and constitutional principles found in the text:

  1. Status of the Port Trust: The Court confirmed the Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay is a statutory authority under the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 and therefore falls within the definition of "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution.
  2. Local character of the cadre: The Court emphasized that Class III and IV services of the Port Trust are recruited locally, posted and remain within Bombay and promotions are likewise restricted to vacancies within the same department and local area—i.e., the cadre is effectively local/non-transferable.
  3. Obligation under Section 28: The Court examined Section 28 (quoted in the opinion) which authorises the Board to make regulations not inconsistent with the Act to provide for appointment, promotion and conditions of service. The Court noted that while regulations exist for Class I and II (made under Section 126 by Central Government), the Port Trust had not framed regulations under Section 28 for Class III and IV. The absence of regulations led to ad hoc decision-making and, in the Court’s view, discriminatory treatment and uncertainty for Class III/IV employees. The Court therefore found merit in petitioners' contention that regulations ought to be framed.
  4. Reservations in promotion — general principle: The Court accepted that reservation in promotion is constitutionally permissible and that, where applied, promotions within the reserved quota must follow the policy of seniority-cum-fitness. The Court relied on the effect of existing regulations for Class I/II (regulation 11(5) and regulation 30 as cited in the opinion) to explain that seniority determined prior to commencement remains unaffected and that non-selection promotions ordinarily consider the senior-most in gradation.
  5. Specific objection to All-India roster for promotions: The Court found substance in petitioners' objection to the Port Trust's adoption of an All-India 40-point roster (15% SC, 7.5% ST) for promotions while initial recruitment used State-level percentages (6%/6% prior to 1985; 7%/9% from June 1985). The Court reasoned that where employment and promotions are confined to a local cadre (Bombay), adoption of All-India reservation percentages for promotions produces unequal treatment and is unjustified. The opinion noted a particular anomaly: the All-India percentage for ST (7.5%) is lower than the State percentage for Maharashtra from June 1985 (9%), producing an injustice to ST candidates in this local context.
  6. Concession and practical outcome: During argument, counsel for Union of India conceded that for the peculiar facts of the Bombay Port Trust (local cadre, non-transferability), it would be fair that promotions for Class III and IV follow the reservation percentages applicable to initial recruitment for the local cadre. The Court adopted this view and concluded that the Port Trust should have followed State/Local percentages in promotions.
  7. Remedies framed: The Court directed specific remedial steps: (a) the Port Trust and Union of India to frame necessary regulations under Section 28 within six months; (b) the Port Trust to prepare seniority lists based on continuous service in the Bombay Port Trust and to regularise promotions in conformity with the Court's observations; and (c) promotions granted after 2 May 1980 must be reconsidered and regularised accordingly, with deemed dates and consequential benefits where employees are found entitled. Promotions on or before 2 May 1980 were to remain undisturbed.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The rule is made absolute to the extent indicated in the opinion. Specifically:

  • The Bombay Port Trust and the Union of India are directed to frame necessary regulations under Section 28 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 within six months from the date of the order.
  • The Bombay Port Trust is directed to prepare a seniority list based on continuous service in the Trust and to reconsider and regularise promotions in conformity with the Court's findings (promotions after 2 May 1980 to be reconsidered and regularised; promotions on or before 2 May 1980 not to be upset).
  • If, upon regularisation, other employees are found entitled to promotions, they will be given deemed dates of promotion and consequential benefits; promotions inconsistent with this decision shall stand set aside.

Implications for the parties:

  • The immediate practical effect is that the Port Trust must undertake a statutory/regulatory process and administrative re-modelling of promotion lists and reservation application for Class III and IV within defined timelines (six months).
  • Promotions granted after 2 May 1980 are liable to re-examination and possible reversal/regularisation; promotions up to 2 May 1980 remain valid and will not be disturbed.
  • The decision does not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond the facts of this case; the Court’s directions are tied to the local character of the cadre, the admitted absence of Section 28 regulations, and the unfairness found in adopting All-India promotional percentages for a local, non-transferable cadre.
  • The Court ordered no costs in the circumstances of the case.

This summary is based exclusively on the provided opinion and contains only information explicitly stated therein.

Show all summary ...

Dharmadhikari, J.:— Petitioner 2 is the Bombay Port Trust Non-Scheduled Castes/Scheduld Tribes Employees Association and Petitioner 1, Damodar Anant Karandikar, is an employee of the Bombay Port Trust.

2. The petitioners have filed this writ petition challenging the promotion and reservation policy of the Bombay Port Trust on the ground that the Bombay Port Trust has failed to frame any regulation in that behalf and the policy so far followed runs counter to the policy decision taken by the Port Trust, viz., that seniority will be the criteria for promotions. It is not necessary to make a detailed reference to the various averments made in the petition or the affidavit filed in reply, since the factual position is admitted by both sides.

3. It is an admitted position that respondent 1, Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay, is a statutory body constituted under the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963, and is, therefore, a “State” within the meaning of Art. 12 of the Constitution of India. The first respondent is a local organisation situate in Bombay and its operation and or function is restricted to Bombay. Class IV and Class III employees are recruited on local or regional basis and the said staff is posted in various departments of the Port Trust such as railway department, estate department, docks department, labour department, etc. The persons recruited and posted in the said department continue to work in the same department and their promotional opportunites are also restricted to the vacancies in the same department. Thus, both on recruitment and promotion, employees belonging to Class III and Class IV employees are posted in local offices of the first respondent Port Trust in or around the city of Bombay.

4. So far as the first respondent, Bombay Port Trust is concerned, the percentage of reservation at the initial stage of recruitment is as applicable to the State of Maharashtra, viz., 6 per cent for scheduled caste and 6 per cent for scheduled tribes and for this purpose points are reserved on 100 point roster. This percentage became 7 and 9 from June 1985. Therefore, according to the petitioners the promotions should have been effected on the local basis, as the persons selected for promotions were being posted locally within the State of Maharashtra only. However, without framing any regulation in that behalf the Bombay Port Trust has followed 40 per cent roster and thereby reserved 15 per cent posts for the scheduled castes and 7½ per cent for scheduled tribes on All India ratio of respective population. It is the case of the petitioners that adoption of 40 per cent roster by the first respondent has resulted in vailing of larger number of promotional posts for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes and thereby denying promotions to the deserving candidates on the basis of their seniority. Therefore, the petitioners have contended that the respondent-Port Trust have violated the petitioners' fundamental rights and have also acted contrary to the rules laid down by the Union of India. On the basis of these averments the petitioners have prayed that the Port Trust be directed to prepare a seniority list of the employees working in Class III and Class IV categories as on 1 June 1977, when the order of reservation for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes came into force and to grant promotions to the petitioners and other employees on the basis of seniority with incidental and consequential benefits. It is also prayed that the promotions already granted be quashed. The petitioners have also prayed that the respondent-Port Trust be directed to frame statutory regulations governing the conditions of service of Class III and Class IV employees.

5. On the other hand it is contended by the Bombay Port Trust that being under the control of the Government of India it was bound to follow the policy laid down by the Union of India in that behalf. As per the policy laid down by the Government of India, which is incorporated in the brochure on reservation for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes in services direct recruitment is made on the open competition basis. Where recruitment is restricted to region, the percentage is fixed taking into account the proportion of the population of the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes in the region concerned. It was 6 per cent for scheduled castes, 6 per cent for scheduled tribes prior to 1985 and from 1985 onwards 7 per cent for scheduled caste and 9 per cent for scheduled tribes. However, so far as promotions are concerned, the Government of India has laid down an uniform policy and according to the said policy the reservation qua scheduled castes for the promotional posts for Class III and Class IV posts is 15 per cent and 71/2 per cent. This has been done to achieve uniformity it is also contended by the respondents that it is true that no regulations are framed by the Bombay Port Trust governing the conditions of services including recruitment, seniority and promotions of Class HI and Class IV posts. However, according to the respondent's general policy laid down in the regulations of 1977 for Class I and Class II employees is also followed in the case of Class III and Class IV employees and as per regulation 13 the reservation policy laid down by the Government of India is also followed by the Bombay Port Trust. Therefore, according to the respondents there is no substance in the contention raised by the petitioners.

6. This petition has a chequered history. It came to be filed in 1982. In this writ petition the petitioners have challenged the promotions as made in the year 1977 and thereafter. After filing of this writ petition it has come to be amended from time to time. The interim order came to be passed by this Court on 22 April 1982, issuing rule and granting the interim relief in terms of prayer C1. (i) of the petition, thereby directing that all promotions made in consequence of the circular, exhibit A, viz., seniority list of Class III office staff as on 1 July, 1975 to December 1982, will be subject to the final order that they may be passed in that behalf.

7. It also appears from the record that initially writ petition bearing No. 1075 of 1980 was filed. During the pendency of the said petition itself, petitioner 2 came to be registered as the association. Thereafter the present writ petition came to be filed and to avoid multiplicity the petitioner withdrew the earlier writ petition. We are informed that in the earlier writ petition also an interim order in the same terms as above was granted, viz. that promotions would be subject to the final order in the writ petition. The said order came to be passed on 2 May 1980, in Writ Petition No. 1075 of 1980. Therefore, in our view it will not be fair to upset the promotions granted till the date the interim order was passed in the first writ petition, viz., Writ Petition No. 1975 of 1980. Therefore, we do not propose to upset any promotion granted by the respondent Port Trust on or before 2 May 1980. However, the promotions granted thereafter were specifically made subject to the result of the writ petition.

8. So far as the first contention raised by the petitioners is concerned that the Bombay Port Trust is obliged to frame the regulations governing the conditions of service of Class III and Class IV employees, we find much substance in this contention. Section 28 confers power on the Board to make regulations not inconsistent with the Act and to provide for the matters enumerated in the section. The said section reads as under:

“28. A Board may make regulations not inconsistent with this Act to provide for any one or more of the following matters, namely:

(a) the appointment, promotion, suspension, reduction in rank, compulsory retirement, removal and dismissal of the employees;

(b) their leave, leave allowances, pensions, gratuities, compassionate allowances and travelling allowances and the establishment and maintenance of a provident fund or any other fund for their welfare;

(c) the terms and conditions of service of persons, who become employees of the Board under Cl. (f) of Sub-sec. (1) of S. 29;

(d) the time and manner in which appeals may be referred under Sub-sec. (2) of S. 25 and the procedure for deciding such appeals;

(e) any other matter which is incidental to, or necessary for the purpose of regulating the appointment and conditions of service of its employees.”

9. It appears that in exercise of the powers conferred upon the Central Government under S. 126 of the Act the Central Government has framed regulation for Class I and Class II employees. However, for the reasons best known to the Bombay Port Trust, it has not chosen to frame any regulation under S. 28 of the Act. Therefore, so far as Class III and Class IV employees are concerned, there are no regulations in the field. No reason has been disclosed either in the affidavit or in the course of arguments as to why no regulations are framed in that behalf. In the absence of the regulations ad hoc decisions are taken. In our view continuance of such a situation has resulted in discriminatory treatment to Class III and Class IV employees as they do not know as to what their conditions of service are. This may be intentional or unintentional, but the result is the same. Therefore, we direct respondent 1, Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay, to frame necessary regulations under S. 28 of the Act within a period of six months from today. Sri Ramaswamy, appearing for respondents 1 and 3 contended that some more time may be granted because the whole process is time-consuming. However, it cannot be forgotten that the earlier writ petition came to be filed in 1980. The present writ petition was filed in the year 1982 and by this writ petition enough notice was given to respondent 1 that they are obliged to frame necessary regulations under S. 28 of the Act. Fortunately the Union of India, who is before us as respondent 7, has an important role to play in framing the regula-tions. In these circumstances in our view a period of six months is more than enough. Therefore, we direct respondent 1, Bombay Port Trust, as well as respondent 7, Union of India, to take immediate steps and complete the process of framing of the regulations within a period of six months from today.

10. So far as the second contention regarding promotions and reservation is concerned, it is contended by the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners that in the absence of any regulation, the principle of seniority-cum-fitness alone should be followed in the matter of promotions. If respondent 1-Port Trust, was following the guidelines laid down in the regulations framed for Class I and Class II officers, then the regulation 11(5) in terms provides that the seniority already determined prior to the commencement of this regulation remains unaffected and the promotions to higher post will be made on the basis of seniority subject to rejection on the ground of fitness. To the similar effect is regulation 30, which provides that where the promotion is to be made to non-selection post, the employees, who are senior most in the gradation list of the cadre, from which the promotions are made, shall ordinarily be considered for such selection. According to the petitioners by the process of reservation, i.e, by reserving certain posts for the scheduled castes and scheduled tribes personnel the principle of seniority is given a go-by and, therefore, the action taken by the respondent-Port Trust is wholly illegal. In all fairness to the learned counsel for the petitioners, he has made a statement before us that the petitioners are not opposed to the reservation policy, but the said policy should be in tune with the guidelines laid in that behalf. It should be fair and just.

11. It is difficult for us to accept this contention of the petitioners as a whole. Once it is contended that the Bombay Port Trust, which is an authority within the meaning of Art. 12 of the Constitution of India, can reserve the posts for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes consistent with the reservation policy as laid down in the Constitution of India, then the promotions made on the basis of such reservation cannot be termed as illegal and void, if within the reserved quota or reserved class, the policy of seniority-cum-fitness is followed. There fore, the policy relevant for promotion, viz., seniority-cum-fitness is not given a go-by. Only certain posts are reserved for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes, as per the constitutional mandate. Thus, for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes inter se seniority of the persons belonging to the said class is followed. Similarly qua general class inter se seniority is maintained and in matters of promotions the principle of seniority-cum-fitness as a whole is also followed. Therefore, it cannot be said that the principle of seniority-cum-fitness is given a go-by by the Bombay Port Trust while making promotions.

12. However, we find some substance in the contentions of the petitioners that having followed the reservation policy qua initial appointment as framed by the State Government and the Union of India, viz., up to the year 1985, 6 per cent for scheduled castes and 6 per cent for scheduled tribes and from 1 June, 1985 itself 7 per cent for scheduled castes and 9 per cent for scheduled tribes, it was not open to the respondent-Trust to reserve the promotional posts on the basis of 40 point roster, i.e, 15 per cent for scheduled castes and 71/2 per cent for scheduled tribes. According to the respondents this reservation in the promotional posts is as per the policy laid down by the Government of India in order to achieve uniformity. We find some fallacy in the approach of the Bombay Port Trust in this behalf. Once it is admitted that the area of operation of the said Bombay Port Trust is confined to Bombay, services of Class III and Class IV employees are not transferable out of Bombay and, therefore, practically this is a local cadre, then in our view adoption of All India roster in the matter of promotions results in unequal treatment or inequality. If initial appointments are based on the percentage of reservation as applicable to the State of Maharashtra only, then we do not find any reason to adopt percentage based on All India basis in the matter of promotions and that too to the local cadres. If the cadre continues to be local and the services are not transferable at all, then it is difficult to understand as to how the Bombay Port Trust can reserve higher percentage for the reserved class in promotional posts when initial appointments are based on lower percentage. By following the All India percentage, the Bombay Port Trust is definitely doing injustice to the scheduled tribes. All India roster or percentage qua scheduled tribes is 71/2 per cent, whereas percentage of reservation meant for the State of Maharashtra for the scheduled tribe from June 1985 is 9 per cent. It was not possible for Sri Jaisinghani, learned counsel appearing for the Government of India, to give any reason as to why the Bombay Port Trust or the Government of India is following such a policy in the matter of employment, which is restricted to a particular region or place. In all fairness during the course of the arguments, Sri Jaisinghani conceded that, so far as the Bombay Port Trust is concerned, in view of the peculiar facts, viz., that employment is confined to Bombay only, services are not transferable and promotions are also restricted to Bombay itself, it will be fair and just that even in matters of promotions qua Class III and Class IV employees the reservation policy qua initial appointment and recruitment should be followed in the matter of promotions also. Therefore, for achieving the object of reservation policy, which is consistent with local requirements, in our view, the Bombay Port Trust should have followed the percentage of reservation meant for the local cadre, i.e, State of Maharashtra both in initial recruitment as well as in matters of promotions.

13. Hence the rule is made absolute to the extent indicated above. The Bombay Port Trust is directed to prepare a seniority list on the basis of continuous service in Bombay Port Trust and then order promotions in tune with the observations made hereinbefore. The promotions made after 2 May 1980, will have to be reconsidered and regularised in the light of our decision. If on such regularisation it is found that some other employees are entitled to be promoted, then it is needless to say that they will be given deemed date of promotions as well as consequential benefits. As a necessary consequence of this, the promotions made after 2 May 1980, which are not in tune with this decision shall stand set aside and the promotions will have to be regularised in accordance with this decision. The Bombay Port Trust to carry out this process within a period of six months. It is further directed to frame the necessary regulations under S. 28 of the Major Port Trusts Act, 1963, also within a period of six months from to day. However, in the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.