Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Mysore And Another v. G.B Purohit And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 25, 1967
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents, serving as Senior (and Junior) Health Inspectors, were originally employees of the former State of Bombay. Upon the reorganisation of States on 1 November 1956, they were allotted to the State of Mysore. A provisional, district-wise seniority list for Sanitary Sub-Inspectors and Inspectors was published in 1958, inviting objections, but it was never finalised.

In October 1961 the Mysore Government decided to remove most Class III posts from the Public Service Commission’s purview and, by order dated 29 January 1962, re-classified Class III posts into State-wise, division-wise and district-wise cadres. Senior and Junior Health Inspectors were placed in the State-wise cadre, and in February 1962 the Director of Public Health was instructed to prepare a State-wide seniority list. Consequently, the 1958 district-wise list was scrapped and a new provisional State-wise list was issued on 2 April 1963, again inviting objections.

The respondents filed a writ petition in the Mysore High Court seeking to quash the 1963 notification. The High Court, finding no adequate explanation for replacing the district-wise system, allowed the writ. The present appeal to the Supreme Court of India was brought by special leave against that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government had the authority to scrap the 1958 district-wise provisional seniority list and issue a new State-wise list for Senior and Junior Health Inspectors.
  2. Whether converting the cadre from district-wise to State-wise, thereby altering the respondents’ promotional prospects, violated the proviso to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.
  3. Whether the Government’s action was vitiated by mala fides aimed at favouring employees of the erstwhile Mysore State over those allotted from Bombay.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The Government lacked power to discard the 1958 district-wise list and substitute a State-wise list.
  • The change drastically reduced their seniority, adversely affecting their chances of promotion, contrary to the protection in the proviso to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act.
  • The measure was taken with mala fide intent to benefit officials originally belonging to the old Mysore State and to disadvantage those allotted from Bombay.

Appellant’s (State Government) Arguments

  • Government orders issued from 29 January 1962 onwards created a State-wise cadre for Junior and Senior Health Inspectors; scrapping the district-wise list was a logical and necessary consequence.
  • The change stemmed from a policy decision—taken for reasons of administrative efficiency—to remove Class III posts from the Public Service Commission’s workload and to reorganise recruitment through State-level committees.
  • Charges of mala fides were unsupported; the change was dictated by service considerations, not by any intention to harm the respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Orissa v. Durga Charan Das (1966) 2 SCR 907 Chances of promotion do not constitute “conditions of service.” Used to reject the respondents’ contention that diminished promotion prospects amounted to a change in conditions of service prohibited by Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice Wanchoo, writing for the Court, undertook a sequential examination of Government orders starting with the decision of October 1961 to exclude most Class III posts from the Public Service Commission. The 29 January 1962 order expressly created three cadres—State-wise, division-wise and district-wise—and placed Junior and Senior Health Inspectors in the State-wise cadre. A subsequent Government letter of February 1962 instructed the Director of Public Health to prepare a seniority list on that basis. Reading these instruments together, the Court held:

  • The Government decisively intended to create a single State-wide cadre for all existing and future Health Inspectors; the High Court erred in viewing the orders as limited to future recruitment machinery.
  • Because the cadre structure itself changed, refixing seniority on a State-wide basis was inevitable; the fact that the 1958 list was still provisional did not restrain the Government from introducing a more efficient structure.
  • Alleged prejudice to promotional prospects did not equate to an alteration of “conditions of service” under Section 115(7); the cited precedent confirmed that chances of promotion are not protected conditions.
  • Mala fides were unsubstantiated: the writ petition contained only a bare allegation of detriment without specific facts or identification of any officer acting with improper motive. Absence of such particulars barred a finding of bad faith.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Writ Petition Dismissed.

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s order and reinstated the Government’s provisional State-wise seniority list issued on 2 April 1963. No costs were awarded. The decision affirms the State’s authority to restructure cadres and refix seniority when such restructuring is supported by valid administrative reasons; it also reiterates that diminished promotional prospects, by themselves, do not constitute a protected “condition of service.” Beyond these clarifications, the judgment creates no new broader precedent.

Show all summary ...

Wanchoo, J.—This is an appeal by special leave against the judgment of the Mysore High Court and arises in the following circumstances. The respondents who are working as Senior Health Inspectors in the State of Mysore filed a writ petition in the High Court praying that a notification dated April 2, 1963 by which a seniority list of Sanitary Sub-Inspectors and Sanitary Inspectors serving in the Department of Public Health was issued calling for objections should be quashed. The respondents were originally serving in the State of Bombay but on reorganisation of States from November 1, 1956 they were allotted to the State of Mysore. It appears that after November 1956 a provisional seniority list of Sanitary Sub-Inspectors and Inspectors was published in 1958 by the Director of Public Health. By that notification objections were called for to the seniority list on grounds connected with the establishment of equivalence of posts or other matters relating to States reorganisation. This seniority list, though it related to the entire State, was however prepared districtwise as till then the cadre of these officials was districtwise and not Statewise. It is said that in pursuance of this notification of February 1958 objections were filed but nothing further happened thereafter. It appears that when the seniority list was published in February 1958 some officials objected that it should be on a Statewise basis and not on a districtwise basis. But this objection was turned down in March 1958. It is said that this seniority list of 1958 continued in operation till February 1962 even though it was not finalised as required under the States Reorganisation Act, 37 of 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) and promotions used to be made districtwise in accordance therewith.

2. In October 1961 however, it is said that Government decided to change the districtwise system for these officials prevalent till then, and substitute therefor a Statewise system. This change was made after the Government decided to take out class III posts from the purview of the Public Service Commission. Thereafter a Government Order was issued in January 1962 by which class III posts were divided into three cadres, namely, (i) Statewise, (ii) division-wise, and (in) districtwise and different methods of recruitment through what were called State-level recruitment committees and divisional-level recruitment committees were to prevail for recruitment of Statewise and division-wise posts. The order also said that all class IV posts would normally be treated as district-wise. The annexure to the order shows that Senior and Junior Health Inspectors of the Public Health Department were put in the cadre of Statewise system and their recruitment was to be made by State-level recruitment committees.

3. After this decision the Director of Public Health, was informed by Government that his proposal to prepare seniority lists of Senior and Junior Health Inspectors and others on Statewise basis instead of region-wise basis was approved. Thereafter the Director took steps to prepare a Statewise seniority list of all Senior and Junior Health Inspectors in spite of the protest of the respondents. Eventually the old provisional seniority list of 1958 relating to these officials which had been prepared on districtwise basis was apparently scrapped and in its place a new seniority list was published on April 2, 1963. This was on Statewise basis and necessary objections were invited to this list in the context of the Act before its finalisation as required thereunder. Then followed the writ petition out of which the present appeal has arisen praying for quashing the new provisional seniority list prepared on Statewise system.

4. The principal ground taken in support of the plea that the list should be quashed was that by making the list Statewise persons like the respondents who had been allotted to the State of Mysore after the reorganisation of States went down heavily in seniority with the result that their chances of promotion were affected. It was urged that the State Government had no power to scrap the old seniority list and substitute the present provisional seniority list in its place. Besides, it was also urged that this had been done with mala fide intention in order to favour the official of the old Mysore State and cause damage to officials of the former Bombay State who were allotted to the new State of Mysore.

5. The petition was opposed on behalf of the State Government. It is strange that the State Government did, not file any affidavit in reply. We must say that in a case of this kind we should have expected the State Government to file a proper affidavit in reply that would show how, when and why the districtwise system was given up in favour of the Statewise system with reference to these officials. It seems to us that the main reason why the writ petition succeeded in the present case was that there was no proper explanation on behalf of the State to show how exactly the system was changed from districtwise to Statewise.

6. The High Court allowed the petition mainly on the ground that there was nothing to show why the State Government had changed the districtwise system for a Statewise system. The High Court seems to have been of the view that all that the orders of Government from January 29, 1962 on wards show is that future recruitment was to be on a Statewise system. The High Court therefore thought that that was no reason for scrapping the provisional seniority list which had been made as far back as 1958, for, in the words of the High Court, “what the Government did by this notification was merely to constitute a separate machinery for selection to class III posts. The change in the mode of selection or of the machinery of selection has nothing to do with the integration of services and determination of inter-State seniority of officers belonging to a particular category”. In this view of the matter, the High Court quashed the list published along with the notification dated April 2, 1963.

7. The main contention on behalf of the appellant before us is that the High Court misunderstood the effect of orders passed by Government from time to time from January 29, 1962 onwards. It is said that these orders of Government show that the Government created Statewise cadres of Junior and Senior Health Inspectors and in consequence of the creation of Statewise cadres it was necessary to scrap the earlier provisional seniority list which had been prepared on a districtwise basis and to substitute in its place a new provisional seniority list prepared on Statewise basis. It is said that the Government decided to change the system in the interest of efficiency after it had decided in October 1961 to take out practically all Class III posts from the purview of the Public Service Commission in order to relieve the Commission of a heavy workload which it was unnecessary for the Commission to discharge. Having decided to take out Class III posts from the purview of the Commission, Government had to decide what system should be evolved for various Class III posts, and what cadres should be constituted on that behalf. The Government decided to have three types of cadres namely, (i) Statewise, (ii) division-wise, and(iii) district-wise, and divided all the Class III services amongst these three types of cadres and placed the Junior and Senior Health Inspectors on Statewise cadre. In consequence, the Government directed the Director of Public Health to prepare a fresh Statewise seniority list for such officials.

8. This in brief is the argument on behalf of the appellant before us. It seems to us that if the argument supported by all this necessary facts had been put before the High Court by an affidavit on behalf of the appellant, the High Court would probably not have come to the conclusion that the old list of 1958 was scrapped for no relevant reason. It is however urged on behalf of the respondents that the High Court was right in holding on a perusal of various Government Orders that all that the Government intended was to constitute a separate Statewise machinery for selection of Class III posts for future recruitment and that there was no decision of Government to create a Statewise cadre for Junior and Senior Health Inspectors including all those who were in service before November 1, 1956. It is urged that no order of Government has been produced which expressly says so in terms. It may be accepted that there is no order of Government which expressly says in terms that Junior and Senior Health Inspectors recruited upto date whether before or after November 1, 1956 would be put in one Statewise cadre. But when one reads various orders passed by Government from January 29, 1962 onwards one must come to the conclusion that that was what the Government intended after it had decided to take away Class III posts from the purview of the Public Service Commission. We have already indicated that the order taking away Class III posts from the purview of the Public Service Commission was passed in October 1961. Thereafter the Government had to provide for recruitment of Class III posts and it began to do so by the order of January 29, 1962. It is remarkable that in that order, Government created three types of cadres, namely, (i) Statewise, (ii) division-wise, and (iii) district-wise. The actual words of the order are that “Government are accordingly pleased to approve the classification of these posts into Statewise, division-wise and districtwise cadres as in the annexure.” Obviously therefore three types of cadres for Class III posts in the State service were created by the order of January 29, 1962. The annexure shows that so far as Junior and Senior Health Inspectors were concerned they were put in Statewise cadre. This was followed by a letter from Government in February 1962 to the Director of Public Health asking him to prepare the seniority list of Junior and Senior Health Inspectors on Statewise basis. These two orders read together clearly show that the intention of Government was to create a Statewise cadre of Junior and Senior Health Inspectors and further this cadre was to consist of all such officials upto date, whether recruited before or after November 1, 1956. We cannot agree with the High Court that these orders merely show that only a recruitment agency was being created in place of the Public Service Commission. Besides, it is difficult to understand how two different types of cadres could continue in the same service one on districtwise basis upto January 29, 1962 when the order in question was passed and the other on Statewise basis from January 29, 1962. In any case the Government's letter of February 1962 to the Director of Public Health makes it quite clear that Junior and Senior Health Inspectors were to be put on the Statewise cadre and that this was to apply to all such Inspectors who were in service on that date, whether recruited before or after November 1, 1956. We cannot therefore agree with the High Court that these orders show that merely a recruitment agency for the future was being created and no more. There is no doubt that the Government had created a Statewise cadre of Junior and Senior Health Inspectors and ordered the Director of Public Health to prepare a seniority list in accordance with the Statewise cadre with respect to all such employees whether recruited before or after November 1,1956. It was because of this that the provisional seniority list prepared in 1958 on districtwise basis had to be scrapped and a new provisional list of such officials in service upto November 1, 1956 had to be prepared on a Statewise basis. We would have agreed with the High Court if we had come to the conclusion that Government Orders showed that only future recruitment was to be done in a particular manner; but we are satisfied that Government Orders from January 29, 1962 onwards show that a Statewise cadre of Junior and Senior Health Inspectors was being created and it was in that context that the old lift of 1958 had to be scrapped as it was based on a districtwise system.

9. It is however urged on behalf of the respondents that it was not open to Government to take into account factors subsequent to November 1, 1956 in the matter of fixing seniority as on that date. On the face of it the argument looks attractive. But if one goes deeper into the matter it is clear that what the Government did after the Statewise cadre had been created in 1962 was necessary even for purposes of fixing seniority of those who had been recruited before 1956 in view of the new cadre thus created. This will be clear from a simple example. Suppose that the districtwise seniority list of 1958 had been finalised before 1962. It is not disputed that that would not have prevented Government from changing the system of districtwise basis and substituting in its place Statewise system. If that had been done the Government was bound to refix seniority on a State wise basis. If the Government could refix seniority on Statewise cadre even after the provisional seniority list of 1958 had been finalised, we do not understand why the Government could not refix seniority on a Statewise basis simply because the provisional list of 1958 had not been finalised. It is not as if the question whether the cadre should be fixed on Statewise or districtwise basis arose for the first time in 1962; on the respondents' own showing the matter was raised even when, the list of 1958 was being prepared but at that time the Government stuck to the districtwise system. Later however it seems that the Statewise system was thought to be more efficient and so the districtwise system was given up. In the circumstances there was nothing improper in the Government scrapping the provisional list of 1958 and preparing a new list of all the employees based on Statewise system introduced in 1962. We are therefore of opinion that the High Court is not right in the view it has taken that the Government had no reason to change the seniority list of 1958.

10. It is then urged on behalf of the respondents that by changing the system from districtwise to Statewise, the respondents have been very hard hit and have become very junior. It appears from the figures supplied by the respondents that there were 665 Junior Health Inspectors in the old State of Mysore on November 1, 1956 while only 48 Junior Health Inspectors were allotted to the new State of Mysore after the Act. So long as the districtwise system continued these 48 persons would naturally have better chances of promotion in their districts but when the cadre was made Statewise, these 48 were likely to go down in seniority as the list of 1963 actually shows. It is urged that this has affected their chances of promotion which were protected under the proviso to Section 115(7) of the Act, which lays down that the conditions of service applicable immediately before the appointed day to the case of any person allotted to the new State shall not be varied to his disadvantage except with the previous approval of the Central Government. It is said on behalf of the respondents that as their chances of promotion have been affected their conditions of service have been changed to their disadvantage. We see no force in this argument because chances of promotion are not conditions of service. It is enough in this connection to refer to State of Orissa v. Durga Charan Das (1966) 2 SCR 907.

11. Lastly, it is urged on behalf of the respondents that the action of the Government was mala fide. Now there is no doubt that if the Government changed the districtwise system into Statewise with the sole object of favouring the old Mysore employees and doing damage to the employees who had come from Bombay or other States on reorganisation of States the action of Government would be mala fide and would be liable to be set aside. But the mere fact that a change in the system from districtwise to Statewise has affected chances of promotion of the respondents or others like them is no ground for holding that the Government's action was mala fide. All that the respondents said in their petition with respect to mala fide was just this: “that their position had been affected”. But there was no definite allegation that this was done by any person in authority in order solely to cause harm to the respondents. In the absence of any such definite allegation we cannot hold that the action of Government in changing the districtwise system and replacing it by the Statewise system on the ground that the latter was presumably more conducive to efficiency was mala fide. It may be noted that there is no discussion of mala fides at all in the judgment of the High Court and that shows that the point was not seriously pressed there.

12. In the result the appeal is allowed and the writ petition is dismissed. In the circumstances however we pass no order as to costs.