Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S. Sam Sundar Singh v. Inspector Of Police

Madras High Court
Aug 22, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of Opinion — Criminal Revision Petition (Order dated 27.07.2010)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns a Criminal Revision Petition under Section 397 read with Section 401 Cr.P.C. challenging an order dated 27.07.2010 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C., which permitted further investigation in Crime No. 129 of 2007 (Rathapuram Police Station).

Material events as stated in the opinion:

  • On 26.08.2007 at about 5 p.m., an unidentified charred body was found by Kakkum Perumal Nadar in his land in Singara Thope, Rathapuram. He reported the matter to the Inspector of Police around 7 p.m. on the same day. A case of suspicious death was registered as Crime No. 129 of 2007 under Section 174 Cr.P.C.
  • The Inspector commenced investigation and collected materials. On 01.10.2009 the Inspector altered the section of law to Section 302 IPC and submitted an alteration report to the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor.
  • Subsequently, on 21.03.2009 the Investigation Officer submitted a negative final report treating the case as "UN - undetectable", which the learned Magistrate accepted.
  • After acceptance of that negative final report, the prosecution obtained some new clue(s) and sought permission from the Magistrate to re-investigate. On 27.07.2010 the learned Judicial Magistrate passed the order: "Records perused. Case reopened and the Inspector of Police is permitted to investigate the matter further as contemplated U/s. 173(8) Cr.P.C".
  • Following that order, the Investigation Officer reopened the investigation and obtained materials implicating the petitioner, who therefore filed the present revision challenging the Magistrate's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a learned Magistrate who has accepted a negative final report treating a case as "undetectable" (a judicial order) can, on his own, set aside that acceptance and direct a fresh/re-de novo investigation under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C.
  2. Whether Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. empowers the Magistrate to order a fresh/re-de novo investigation, or whether the Magistrate's power is limited to directing "further investigation" without ordering a fresh/de novo probe.
  3. Whether the impugned order dated 27.07.2010 permitting the police to re-open investigation (in the manner recorded) is legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner (Accused) — Arguments

  • The counsel for the petitioner contended that the Magistrate's earlier order accepting the negative final report (treating the case as undetectable) was a judicial order and, once passed, could not be reopened by the same Magistrate; it could be set aside only by a superior forum.
  • It was argued that, under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C., the Magistrate has power to order further investigation but not to order a fresh/re-de novo investigation; that power belongs only to a superior court.
  • The petitioner relied on a Division Bench decision of this Court in K.K.S.S. Ramachandran v. State (2015 (2) MLJ (Crl) 257) and the Supreme Court decision in Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali @ Deepak [(2013) 5 SCC 762] in support of these contentions.
  • Accordingly, the petitioner submitted the impugned order of 27.07.2010 directing the police to conduct fresh investigation was contrary to law and that subsequent actions taken pursuant to that order were vitiated.

Prosecution — Arguments

  • The learned Government Advocate (Criminal side) opposed the petition. He submitted that on reinvestigation the accused's involvement came to light and that the accused is a notorious criminal implicated in several cases. In those circumstances, the impugned order was not flawed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
ABHINANDAN JHA v. DINESH MISHRA [1968 AIR 117] When a magistrate peruses a police final report (positive or negative), he may concur or come to a different conclusion: he can take cognizance under Section 190(1)(b) Cr.P.C., or direct further investigation (Sections 156(3) and 173(8)). The magistrate cannot, however, direct the manner/method of investigation nor direct the police to file a charge-sheet. The Court relied on this principle to describe the magistrate's powers on receipt of a final report and to delineate limits on directing investigation methods.
BHAGAWANT SINGH v. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE [(1985) 2 SCC 537 : AIR 1985 SC 1285] Reiterated the principles in Abhinandan Jha regarding a magistrate's function on perusal of a police final report. The Court noted that this three-Judge Bench reiterated the position in Abhinandan Jha, reinforcing the legal framework applied to the facts.
K.K.S.S. RAMACHANDRAN v. STATE (Division Bench) [2015 (2) MLJ (Crl) 257] Held that an order by a Magistrate accepting a negative final report treating a case as "undetectable" is a judicial order, which the same Magistrate cannot recall; such an order must be set aside by a superior forum. The Court relied on this Division Bench view to support the proposition that the learned Magistrate could not have himself set aside his earlier acceptance and order a fresh investigation.
VINAY TYAGI v. IRSHAD ALI @ DEEPAK [(2013) 5 SCC 762] Held that a Magistrate has power to direct further investigation when a defacto complainant presents valid grounds; however, the police have power of "further investigation" under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. but no power to conduct "fresh/re/de novo investigation" — that can be done only after scrapping the earlier investigation. The Court used Vinay Tyagi to distinguish between permissible "further investigation" and impermissible "fresh/re-de novo" investigation by the police or magistrate, and to conclude that the impugned order exceeded competent power.
REETA NAG v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL [2009 (13) SCR 276] Earlier view (noted by the Court) that the magistrate lacked power at the instance of the defacto complainant to order further investigation; this view was later departed from by the Supreme Court in Vinay Tyagi. The Court observed that Vinay Tyagi departed from Reeta Nag on the specific point of magistrate's power to order further investigation at the instance of the defacto complainant.
CHANDRA BABU v. STATE THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE [2015 Crl. L.J 4538] Followed the principle in Vinay Tyagi regarding limits on fresh/re-de novo investigations and magistrate/police powers. The Court cited it as subsequent authority following Vinay Tyagi, confirming the present position of law.
P. RAVINDRANATH v. K. CHANDRA GANDHI AND INSPECTOR OF POLICE [2014 (3) MWN (Cri) 236] Followed the Vinay Tyagi principle (as cited in the opinion). Noted as an authority that follows the Vinay Tyagi position on limits of "further" vs. "fresh" investigation.
RAMSARAN VARSHNEY v. STATE OF U.P [(2016) 2 SCC (Cri) 190 = (2016) 3 SCC 724] Followed and affirmed the legal position regarding the distinction between further investigation and fresh/de novo investigation. Used by the Court to demonstrate that the present position of law treats Magistrate-ordered fresh/re-de novo investigations as impermissible by the Magistrate and permissible only by higher courts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by setting out the statutory and doctrinal framework governing police investigation, police final reports, and magistrate powers as contained in the opinion:

  1. The opinion explains the investigative process: registration of an FIR under Section 154 Cr.P.C., police power to investigate under Section 156 Cr.P.C., the definition of "investigation" under Section 2(h) Cr.P.C., and the contents/sources of materials gathered during investigation (statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C., seizures, scientific evidence, etc.).
  2. On conclusion of investigation, the Investigation Officer must form an opinion and submit a report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C., which may be a positive final report (charge-sheet) or a negative final report (e.g., undetectable). Both are "police reports" or "final reports".
  3. Citing ABHINANDAN JHA and BHAGAWANT SINGH, the Court reiterated that after perusal of a final report (positive or negative) the Magistrate may concur, take cognizance under Section 190(1)(b), or direct further investigation under Sections 156(3) and 173(8), but the Magistrate cannot dictate how the police should conduct the investigation nor direct the precise method of investigation or that a charge-sheet be filed.
  4. The Court then examined the Division Bench decision in K.K.S.S. Ramachandran which held that the Magistrate's acceptance of a negative final report treating a case as "undetectable" is a judicial order that the same Magistrate cannot recall and which can be set aside only by a superior forum.
  5. Relying on Vinay Tyagi, the Court highlighted the distinction the Supreme Court drew between "further investigation" (which the police may carry out under Section 173(8) subject to limitations) and a "fresh/re-de novo investigation" (which the police/magistrate cannot undertake unless the earlier investigation is scrapped by a superior court). The opinion notes that Vinay Tyagi departed from earlier dicta in Reeta Nag to the extent that a Magistrate may direct further investigation on valid grounds presented by the defacto complainant, but reiterated that fresh/re-de novo investigations cannot be ordered by the Magistrate or police.
  6. The Court synthesized these authorities and the statutory scheme to conclude that because the Magistrate's earlier acceptance of the negative final report was a judicial order, the Magistrate could not, on his own, set aside that acceptance and order a fresh/re-de novo investigation. The impugned order of 27.07.2010 was held to suffer from illegality on this basis.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed and the impugned order dated 27.07.2010 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor in Crime No. 129 of 2007 is set aside.

Implications and direct consequences (as stated in the opinion):

  • The impugned Magistrate's order permitting the police to investigate further (in the manner ordered) has been declared illegal and is set aside.
  • The Investigation Officer remains at liberty to pursue the clues obtained after the initial investigation only by first approaching the appropriate superior Court to set aside the Magistrate's earlier order accepting the police report treating the case as undetectable; thereafter the Investigation Officer may proceed in accordance with law.
  • The connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.

The Court applied existing precedents and stated the present position of law; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond the principles it applied from cited authorities.

Show all summary ...

PRAYER: Criminal Revision Petition is filed, under Section 397 r/w 401 Cr.P.C, to set aside the order passed under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C in Crime No. 129 of 2007, dated 27.07.2010 on the file of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyur.

P. Devadass, J.:— The accused in Crime No. 129 of 2007 on the file of the Inspector of Police, Rathapuram, Tirunelveli District directed this revision as against the order of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor, dated 27.07.2010, passed under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C, directing fresh investigation.

2. On 26.08.2007, at about 5 p.m, Kakkum Perumal Nadar, in his land situate in Singara Thope in Rathapuram found an unidentified charred body. On the same day, at about 7 p.m at the Rathapuram Police Station, he reported this to the Inspector of Police. The Inspector of Police registered a case of suspicious death in Crime No. 129 of 2007 under Section 174 Cr.P.C

3. The Inspector commenced his investigation. Collected materials. On 01.10.2009, he altered the Section of law to Section 302 I.P.C and submitted his alteration report to the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor. Thereafter, on 21.03.2009, he submitted a negative final report to the said Magistrate, temporarily treating the case as ‘UN - undetectable’. The learned Magistrate, accepted the said report.

4. Subsequently, the prosecution seems to have obtained some clue and sought the permission of the learned Magistrate to re-investigate the case.

5. On 27.07.2010, the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor passed the following order:

“Records perused. Case reopened and the Inspector of Police is permitted to investigate the matter further as contemplated U/s. 173(8) Cr.P.C”

6. Thereafter, the Investigation Officer reopened the investigation and he is stated to have obtained some materials implicating the petitioner with this case.

7. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner contended that the order already passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor accepting the negative final report submitted by the Investigation Officer treating the case as UN-undetectable is a ‘judicial order’. It cannot be reopened by the learned Magistrate. It can be reopened only after the said order being set aside by a superior forum.

8. In this connection, the learned counsel for the petitioner cited a Division Bench decision of this Court in K.K.S.S RAMACHANDRAN v. STATE REP. BY THE INSPECTOR OF POLICE, IRUKKANKUDI POLICE STATION, SATTUR TALUK, VIRUDHUNAGAR DISTRICT [2015 (2) MLJ (Crl) 257].

9. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner also contended that under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C, the learned Magistrate has got power to order further investigation, but he has no power to order fresh/re/denovo investigation. Such a power could be exercised only by a superior Court.

10. In this connection, the learned counsel for the revision petitioner cited VINAY TYAGI v. IRSHAD ALI @ DEEPAK [(2013) 5 SCC 762].

11. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner would submit that in the circumstances, the impugned order passed by the learned Magistrate on 27.07.2010 directing the police to conduct fresh investigation is against law and whatever follow-up action taken pursuant to such an order is vitiated.

12. The prosecution filed the counter opposing the plea of the petitioner.

13. The learned Government Advocate (Criminal side) submitted that on reinvestigation the accused having been concerned with this case came to light. He is a notorious criminal. He is involved in many cases. In the facts and circumstances the impugned order passed by the learned Magistrate is not flawed.

14. I have anxiously considered the rival submissions, perused the averments made in the revision petition and the counter filed by the prosecution, the impugned order and the decisions cited by the learned counsel for the revision petitioner.

15. We have already given the necessary factual matrix for the disposal of this revision. Let us not duplicate it.

16. On receipt of an information relating to the commission of a cognizable offence, a Station House Officer (S.H.O), registers a First Information Report (F.I.R) under Section 154 Cr.P.C Thereafter, under Section 156 Cr.P.C, he gets the power to investigate the crime reported. As per Section 2(h) Cr.P.C, collection of materials with reference to the Crime reported is ‘investigation’. The procedure the investigation officer has to follow has been delineated in Section 157 Cr.P.C His collection of materials, mainly consists of oral statement of witnesses recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C, seizure of documents, materials seized through search and seizure, statement obtained through custodial interrogation, Section 27 Evidence Act recoveries and scientific evidence and the reports thereon etc.

17. Concluding his investigation/collection of materials, the Investigation Officer has to form an opinion thereon and submit his report under Section 173(2) Cr.P.C to the Court. In his said report he must state whether his investigation discloses commission of any offence. His such report is called ‘positive final report’; ‘Challan’, loosely called ‘Charge Sheet’. When his report says that no offence appears to have been committed and it is a ‘Mistake of Fact’, ‘Mistake of Law’, ‘Accidental Fire’, ‘a Civil Case’, ‘Untraceable’ and ‘Undetected’, then it is called ‘negative final report’, ‘referred charge sheet’, referred challan’. In either case, whether positive or negative, the report is called ‘Police Report’ or ‘final report’.

18. Upon such report being filed by the Investigation Officer, as held in ABHINANDAN JHA v. DINESH MISHRA [1968 AIR 117], whether it is a positive or negative, on his perusal of the materials presented along with the final report, the learned Magistrate can concur with the conclusion of the Investigation Officer or come to a different conclusion and take cognizance thereon under Section 190(1)(b) Cr.P.C or direct further investigation vide Section 156(3) and 173(8) Cr.P.C and call for further report from the Investigation Officer. However, while doing so, he cannot direct the manner or method of investigation to be done by the Investigation Officer nor he direct the Magistrate to file a charge sheet.

19. The principles laid down in ABHINANDAN JHA (supra) has been subsequently reiterated by a three Judge Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in BHAGAWANT SINGH v. COMMISSIONER OF POLICE [(1985) 2 SCC 537 : AIR 1985 SC 1285].

20. In case a negative final report is filed, the learned Magistrate after giving notice to the defacto complainant, some times to the victim, in some cases, to the relatives or legal heirs of the deceased, shall receive ‘protest petition’, if any filed by them, treat it as ‘a complaint’, enquire accordingly and pass orders thereon. (See 200, 202, 203, 204, 190(1)(b) Cr.P.C)

21. A Division Bench of this Court in K.K.S.S RAMACHANDRAN (supra) examined the nature of the order passed by a Magistrate accepting the negative final report filed by the Investigation Officer treating the case as Undetectable. The Division Bench held that it is a ‘Judicial Order’ passed by the learned Magistrate. And he cannot recall it. He is incompetent to do so. And it had also opined that such an order has to be set aside by a superior forum.

22. After the acceptance of a negative final report by the Magistrate when some clue or material may be unearthed by the Investigation Officer. In such a case need may arose for ‘further investigation’. In such a case, the prosecution has to get the judicial order of the learned Magistrate accepting the negative final report of the Investigation Officer by setting it aside by a superior forum and thereafter the Investigation Officer can seek leave of the Magistrate to do further investigation under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C,

23. In VINAY TYAGI (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court after noticing the three Judge Bench Decision in BHAGAWANT SINGH (supra) deviated from its earlier view in REETA NAG v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL [2009 (13) SCR 276] that at the instance of the defacto complainant the Magistrate has no power to order further investigation and held that the Magistrate has power to direct further investigation after filing of the initial final report, when the defacto complainant presents a valid ground.

24. However in VINAY TYAGI (supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court has clearly held that though the police has power of ‘further investigation’ under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C they have no power of ‘fresh/re/de novo investigation’. It can be done only after scrapping the earlier investigation done by the police.

25. Both in REETA NAG (supra) and in VINAY TYAGI (supra) conclusively the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that a Magistrate has no power to order for re/fresh/de novo investigation. He is incompetent to do so. However, such a power can be exercised by the High Courts under Section 482 Cr.P.C and under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

26. VINAY TYAGI (supra) has been subsequently followed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in CHANDRA BABU v. STATE THROUGH INSPECTOR OF POLICE [2015 Crl. L.J 4538], also see P. RAVINDRANATH v. K. CHANDRA GANDHI AND INSPECTOR OF POLICE, USILAMPATTI, MADURAI DISTRICT [2014 (3) MWN (Cri) 236] and RAMSARAN VARSHNEY v. STATE OF U.P [(2016) 2 SCC (Cri) 190 = (2016) 3 SCC 724. This is the present position of law with regard to a negative, referred charge sheet, ‘further investigation’ and ‘re-investigation’.

27. In the light of the above position of law since the order of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor accepting the final report of the Investigation Officer that the case is undetectable is a judicial order, he cannot set aside it on his own and order fresh investigation. Thus, the impugned order dated 27.07.2010 suffers from legality. It calls for our interference.

28. In view of the foregoings, this revision is allowed. The impugned order dated 27.07.2010 passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor in Crime No. 129 of 2007 on the file of the Inspector of Police, Rathapuram is set aside.

29. It is made clear that it is open to the Investigation Officer to pursue the clues, if any, obtained by him subsequent to the closure of his initial investigation by approaching the appropriate superior Court to set aside the order of the learned Judicial Magistrate, Valliyoor accepting his report treating the case as undetectable and proceed further in accordance with law. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.