Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sri. Bijoy Krishna Mishra & Anr. v. Chittaranjan Das Bera & Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Aug 22, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This second appeal arises from a suit concerning the title to a property originally owned by Jatindra Nath Chakraborty and others, who dedicated the property to the deity Sri Sri Sitalamata Thakurani for Debseba. The plaintiffs claimed title by inheritance from their father, who purchased the suit property from Sarbani Debbya, the shebait (manager) of the deity's property. The lower courts examined whether the plaintiffs' father could validly acquire title by such purchase. The suit was initiated as Title Suit No. 374 of 2009 (renumbered as Title Suit No. 31 of 2011), and the judgments of the Civil Judge (Senior Division) and the Additional District Judge, First Court, Paschim Medinipore, were affirmed before this appeal was filed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiffs' father could acquire valid title to the suit property by purchasing the Debottar property from the shebait without obtaining permission from the District Judge.
  2. Whether there is any substantial question of law involved in the appeal that warrants admission under Order 41 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the nature of the suit property, which was dedicated to a deity and thus classified as Debottar property. It noted that the deity, being a perpetual minor, cannot alienate property without permission from the District Judge. The sale by the shebait was conducted without obtaining such mandatory permission, rendering the transfer void. Furthermore, the necessity for the sale was not established. The courts below had held that the plaintiffs did not acquire title due to these defects, and this court found no apparent illegality in those decisions. Consequently, the court determined there was no substantial question of law to admit the appeal under Order 41 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

This decision directly upholds the rulings of the lower courts, confirming that the plaintiffs did not acquire title to the suit property. The appeal was not admitted for hearing due to the absence of any substantial question of law. No broader legal precedent was established, and the related injunction application was deemed disposed of as a consequence of the dismissal.

Show all summary ...

Jyotirmay Bhattacharya, J.:— This is a defective appeal. Adequate court fees has not been paid. The learned advocate of the appellants however, undertakes to pay the deficit court fees in course of this day.

2. This second appeal is directed against the judgement and decree dated 18th February, 2016 passed by the Learned Additional District Judge, First Court, Paschim Medinipore in Title Appeal No. 02 of 2013 affirming the judgement and decree dated 11 October, 2012 passed by the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 2nd Court, Paschim Medinipore in Title Suit No. 374 of 2009 renumbered as Title Suit No. 31 of 2011, at the instance of the plaintiffs/appellants.

3. Let us now consider as to whether any substantial question of law is involved in this appeal for which the appeal is required to be admitted under the provision of Order 41 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, or not.

4. Admittedly, Jatindra Nath Chakraborty and others were the recorded owners of the suit property. They dedicated the suit property in favour of the deity Sri. Sri. Sitalamata Thakurani for Debseba out of the usufruct of the suit property. It is also an admitted position that Sarbani Debbya became the shebait who sold and transferred the suit property in favour of the plaintiffs' father. The plaintiffs prayed for declaration of title on the basis of the inheritance from their father who purchased the suit property from the said shebait.

5. In this context, a question came up for consideration before the courts below as to whether the plaintiffs' father could acquire any title in the suit property by virtue of such purchase of the Debottar property from the shebait.

6. The suit property was dedicated to the deity. Deity is the perpetual minor. Sale of any debottar property without obtaining permission from the District Judge concerned, is void. No permission was taken from the learned District Judge for selling and transferring of the debottar property. Even the legal necessity for which the property was sold, has also not been proved.

7. In these set of facts, both the courts below held that the plaintiffs did not acquire any title in the suit property. We, sitting in this jurisdiction, do not find any apparent illegality in the judgements and/or decrees of the courts below.

8. We do not find involvement of any substantial question of law in this appeal. We decline to admit this appeal for hearing under the provision of Order 41 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

9. The appeal is, thus, dismissed.

10. Since the appeal is disposed of in the manner as aforesaid, no further order need be passed on the injunction application.

11. The application for injunction being CAN 6710 of 2016 is thus, deemed to be disposed of.

12. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the Learned advocates for the parties immediately.