- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu v. Station House Officer Acb & Others.
Factual and Procedural Background
These four Criminal Petitions arise from the same incident and were heard together. A written complaint dated 3.12.2008 was filed by Shri Rajesh Rathi against Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu (then Registrar of Firms) alleging demand of bribe. The Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) verified the complaint on 8.12.2008 and conducted a trap on 10.12.2008: the petitioner was allegedly caught accepting Rs. 1,00,000/-, the amount was recovered from a drawer in her office, and she was arrested on 10.12.2008 at 9:10 p.m. A formal FIR (No. 300/2008) for offences under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act was registered on 12.12.2008. The petitioner was produced for remand on 11.12.2008 and sent to judicial custody the same day; her bail application under Section 437 Cr.P.C. was dismissed by the trial court.
Subsequently, on 16.9.2009 the ACB filed a charge-sheet after obtaining prosecution sanction under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. The petitioner (Smt. Upmanyu) filed several writ and criminal petitions challenging various aspects of arrest, detention, media exposure, procedures followed, and the FIR/charge-sheet. She also filed a complaint (Complaint Case No. 8/2009) against the trap officer and others which was later withdrawn with liberty. A second complaint/petition under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. (registered as Complaint Case No. 3/2010) seeking registration of FIR against the trap officer was forwarded by the trial court to the ACB on 9.4.2010; that forwarding order and a subsequent clarification of 4.5.2010 became the subject of separate Section 482 Cr.P.C. petitions (2480/2010 by the trap officer and 880/2010 by ACB).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the arrest of the petitioner on 10.12.2008 after sunset (at 9:10 p.m.) without prior permission of a Judicial Magistrate or Special Judge, in alleged contravention of sub-section (4) of Section 46 Cr.P.C., rendered the arrest and all consequent detention illegal and violative of Article 21 of the Constitution?
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to compensation under Article 226/Article 21 for alleged illegal detention, media exposure and defamation?
- Whether a formal FIR must be registered before ACB may conduct trap proceedings, arrest a public servant, investigate and produce the accused for remand?
- Whether the FIR (No. 300/2008) and charge-sheet are liable to be quashed at the preliminary stage under Section 482 Cr.P.C. (i.e., whether the FIR discloses no prima facie offence or is malafide/absurd)?
- Whether the order dated 9.4.2010 (and clarification 4.5.2010) forwarding a second complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. to the police was legally sustainable where a prior complaint with the same allegations had already been the subject of cognizance and where the earlier request to forward under Section 156(3) had been declined?
- Whether a Magistrate forwarding a complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. must record/reflect application of mind and (in complaints against public servants) ensure valid sanction where required?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner (Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu) — core contentions
- The arrest was effected after sunset (10.12.2008 at 9:10 p.m.) by a male officer without prior written permission of the Judicial Magistrate/Special Judge, contrary to Section 46(4) Cr.P.C., and therefore illegal.
- She was photographed and televised during the trap; this led to publication of pictures and live telecast causing defamation and violation of rights.
- Signatures on the arrest memo were obtained from the petitioner and her father under compulsion; copies of arrest memo were not furnished despite requests.
- Formal FIR had not been registered when she was remanded and when her bail was dismissed on 11.12.2008; ACB lacked jurisdiction to arrest/detain without FIR.
- Copy of FIR was provided under RTI on 16.12.2008 after payment of copying charges; such fees should not be charged from an accused in custody.
- ACB did not produce the case diary on the date fixed by High Court, which impeded consideration of her bail application; her subsequent proceedings were procedurally defective.
- She sought declaration that arrest/detention was void ab initio, deletion from jail records, and compensation totaling Rs. 1.3 crore for illegal custody and alleged defamation.
- In the petition to quash FIR and related reliefs, she alleged malafide registration, delay and suspicious timeline of FIR registration, biased and incomplete investigation, and invoked principles in Bhajan Lal to argue for quashing of FIR.
Respondents / Public Prosecutor / ACB — core contentions
- The ACB conducted a validated trap: the complaint was verified, petitioner was caught red-handed accepting Rs. 1,00,000/-, the amount was recovered and memos were prepared; arrest at 9:10 p.m. followed that sequence and was not a deliberate violation of Section 46(4) Cr.P.C.
- In anti-corruption cases formal FIRs are often registered after a public servant is found involved and recovery is made; ACB had jurisdiction to conduct trap, arrest and investigate even if formal FIR had not yet been entered.
- Other procedural complaints raised by petitioner did not amount to infringement of any statutory or fundamental right; issues such as non-provision of free copy of bail order, late supply of FIR copy, or procedural lapses are at most procedural and do not invalidate arrest/remand.
- Allegations regarding media presence and telecast are questions of fact as to who permitted/arranged the media coverage and require evidence in appropriate proceedings.
- On challenge to forwarding order under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., the respondents submitted that the Magistrate has the jurisdiction to forward a complaint to police without taking cognizance and that such forwarding means the Magistrate, after applying mind, found cognizable offence on the face of the complaint.
- On the issue of the second complaint, respondents argued the petition was not barred and the Magistrate's orders (9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010) were passed after application of mind; further, the petitioner-trap officer could not be deprived of his right to challenge those orders.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhim Singh v. State of Jammu & Kashmir, AIR 1986 SC 494 | Cited by petitioner in support of claim for compensation and reliefs relating to unlawful arrest/detention and publicity. | The Court noted the petitioner relied on this authority but, on the material, held the facts did not show a patent/gross violation meriting compensation; therefore the authority did not assist the petitioner to obtain relief in this case. |
| Division Bench, Bombay High Court — order dated 05.03.2012 (Criminal Writ Petition No. 1666/2010) | Cited by petitioner as supportive authority (order from another High Court cited in submissions). | Court acknowledged reliance on the order but did not treat it as establishing entitlement to relief; the petitioner's factual matrix did not satisfy the threshold applied by this Court. |
| Division Bench, Bombay High Court — order dated 30.11.2012 (Criminal Writ Petition No. 2515/2012) | Cited by petitioner by way of supportive orders from another High Court. | Court observed the orders were relied upon but concluded that on the present facts the criteria for compensation or quashing were not met. |
| Sube Singh v. State of Haryana, (2006) 3 SCC 178 | Stated tests for awarding compensation under Article 21: whether violation is patent and incontrovertible, and whether it is gross and of a magnitude to shock the conscience. | Court applied this two-question test and concluded the violations alleged in the present facts were not patent/gross to satisfy the test for awarding compensation. |
| M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, (1987) 1 SCC 395 | Held that not every breach of a fundamental right attracts compensation; infringement must be gross/patent and either large-scale or manifestly oppressive/vulnerable. | Court relied on this principle to hold that even if some procedural lapses occurred, they were not of the character to warrant compensation under Article 226/Article 21. |
| State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, AIR 1992 SC 604 | Provides the exceptional categories in which an FIR may be quashed at preliminary stage (i.e., quashable FIR principles). | Court considered Bhajan Lal and concluded the present FIR/charge-sheet did disclose prima facie offences (demand/acceptance of bribe and recovery) and did not fall within exceptions warranting quashing at this stage. |
| Anil Kumar v. M.K. Ayappa, 2014 Cr.L.J. 1 (SC) | Holds that when a Magistrate exercises jurisdiction under Section 156(3) or Section 200 Cr.P.C., he must apply his mind; the application of mind should be reflected; special rules apply when complaint is against public servant (sanction issues). | Court applied Anil Kumar to require that the Magistrate's order reflect application of mind and that in complaints against public servants, absence of valid sanction is a material consideration; used to assess validity of orders dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010. |
| State of Rajasthan v. Babu Lal (Criminal SLP No. 4669/10), order dated 07.10.2013 | Clarified that sending a complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. indicates the Magistrate, after applying mind, found a cognizable offence disclosed and directed police to register the case. | Cited by respondents to support the proposition that the Magistrate's forwarding under Section 156(3) is an endorsement that cognizable offence appears on the face of the complaint. |
| Bhawani Shankar Sharma v. Chief Judicial Magistrate (Rajasthan High Court), order dated 22.01.2015 | Cited by respondents in support of principles about forwarding complaints under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. | Court noted the citation among other authorities relied upon by respondents while assessing whether the trial court applied its mind before forwarding the complaint. |
| Gopal Das Sindhi v. State of Assam, 1996 Cr.L.J. 39 (Gauhati High Court) | Cited by respondents on procedural/legal points relating to complaints and forwarding under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. | Court considered this among other authorities in addressing whether the Magistrate applied mind and whether forwarding was legally sustainable. |
| Deputy Chief Controller of Import & Exports v. Roshan Lal Agrawal (Criminal Appeal No. 1656-1663/95), judgment dated 05.03.2013 | Cited in support of respondents' position on procedural aspects of forwarding complaints under Section 156(3). | Court took note of the authority as part of the respondents' submissions regarding the scope of Magistrate's power under Section 156(3). |
| Bhushan Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2012) 5 SCC 424 | Cited by respondents about the law concerning forwarding of complaints and investigational steps under Section 156(3). | Court acknowledged the citation in considering whether orders forwarding the complaint reflected application of mind and were sustainable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court considered submissions, materials on record and relevant legal provisions. The reasoning unfolded on multiple core points:
-
Arrest after sunset / Section 46(4) Cr.P.C.:
Legal principle applied:
Section 46(4) Cr.P.C. prohibits arrest of a woman after sunset and before sunrise except in exceptional circumstances and requires prior permission of the Judicial Magistrate or Special Court where the arrest is to be made. The Court held this requirement is procedural and while generally to be followed, it is not an absolute bar in every circumstance. The exigencies of each situation must be considered.
Applying the facts, the Court found the sequence (written complaint, verification, trap at about 5 p.m., petitioner accepting money, recovery, memos, involvement established and arrest at 9:10 p.m. in presence of lady constable, father and witnesses) showed that immediate arrest was necessitated by the circumstances. The Court therefore concluded that even if prior permission was not obtained, the arrest did not amount to a patent/gross violation of statutory or constitutional rights such as to vitiate the detention.
-
Entitlement to compensation under Article 21 / standards for awarding compensation:
Legal principle applied:
The Court applied the tests from Sube Singh and M.C. Mehta: compensation for infringement of Article 21 is not automatic; the violation must be patent, incontrovertible and gross—so as to shock the conscience, or must affect a large group or be manifestly unjust/oppressive to vulnerable persons.
On the facts, the Court concluded alleged procedural lapses (arrest timing, late FIR registration, non-free provision of a bail order copy, late provision of FIR copy, case diary non-production, presence of media) were at best procedural irregularities and not patent/gross violations of Article 21. Therefore compensation was not warranted.
-
Signatures on arrest memo, non-supply of memo copy and factual determinations:
Legal principle applied:
Whether signatures were obtained under duress is a question of fact. Preparation of arrest memo and obtaining signatures of the arrested person and family members is a legal requirement and, without evidence, cannot be treated as a breach of fundamental rights. The Court held these factual issues required trial or appropriate proceedings with evidence and could not be decided in writ proceedings under Article 226/227 or in summary Section 482 proceedings.
-
Requirement of formal FIR before arrest / ACB jurisdiction:
Legal principle applied:
For certain offences (e.g., under Prevention of Corruption Act, NDPS Act, Excise Act), investigation and arrest can follow on the basis of information/trap even before a formal FIR is lodged. The Court observed that in anti-corruption traps, formal FIRs are commonly registered after the trap and recovery. The petitioner’s arrest and production before the Magistrate within 24 hours did not render detention illegal merely because formal FIR registration occurred after remand.
-
Procedural lapses (copy of orders, delay in documents, conduct in bail hearings, media exposure):
Legal principle applied:
The Court treated these as procedural lapses which did not go to the root of the matter. Non-provision of free copy of an order dismissing bail is not mandated as with a convicted person under Section 361 Cr.P.C. Absence of a free copy did not amount to patent violation of Article 21. Media presence and publication were factual matters requiring evidence as to who arranged/authorized the media.
-
Quash application against FIR and charge-sheet (S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2017/2009):
Legal principle applied:
The Court applied the well-established principle that an FIR may be quashed at preliminary stage only when allegations and investigation materials do not even prima facie disclose essential ingredients of the offence. Considering the trap, recovery and memos the Court found prima facie ingredients of offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)/13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act were present. The petition to quash FIR/charge-sheet was therefore dismissed as the issues raised were predominantly factual and for trial.
-
Challenge to orders forwarding complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. (S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2480/2010 & 880/2010):
Legal principle applied:
The Court examined whether the trial court correctly forwarded a second complaint under Section 156(3) where an earlier complaint with the same allegations had been the subject of cognizance and where the earlier request to forward was refused and the earlier complaint was withdrawn. The Court emphasized that once cognizance is taken on a complaint and the Magistrate proceeds under Chapter XV (e.g., Section 200), the Magistrate ordinarily cannot revert to forward the same complaint under Section 156(3) — doing so would amount to review of his own order, which a criminal court lacks jurisdiction to undertake.
The Court further applied Anil Kumar to hold that a Magistrate forwarding a complaint under Section 156(3) must reflect application of mind in the order and, where the complaint is against a public servant, consideration of sanction requirements is necessary. The Court found that the second complaint/petition was barred in law because it repeated the same allegations and was filed after the prior complaint’s process, and that the forwarding orders (9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010) were passed disregarding the prior proceedings; accordingly those orders were quashed and set aside.
-
Disposition where multiple petitions interacted:
Legal principle applied:
The Court recognized petitioners’ rights to challenge impugned orders even where other petitions were filed by other parties; the trap officer was entitled to challenge the forwarding order although ACB had filed a separate petition. In respect of ACB’s petition (No. 880/2010), the Court disposed it in view of its decision on petition No. 2480/2010 and did not pass a further order on merit.
Holding and Implications
The Court rendered multiple determinations in the common order. The primary holdings and their immediate consequences are summarized below.
1. Criminal Writ Petition under Articles 14, 21, 226 and 227 (filed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu on 23.1.2013)
Holding: DISMISSED. The Court found no patent or gross violation of fundamental or statutory rights justifying declaration that arrest/detention was void ab initio, nor entitlement to compensation. Procedural irregularities identified did not amount to violations of Article 21 of such a magnitude as to attract compensation.
Implications: The dismissal leaves intact the prosecution process and the factual determinations required for trial. The Court explicitly held that the prosecution must be given an opportunity to prove the charge at trial; factual complaints (e.g., compulsion in signing arrest memo, media responsibility) are to be adjudicated in appropriate proceedings with evidence.
2. S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2017/2009 (petition to quash FIR No. 300/2008)
Holding: DISMISSED. The Court found that prima facie the FIR and charge-sheet disclosed offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)/13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act (demand/acceptance and recovery of bribe), and that the case did not fall within the limited exceptional categories warranting quashing at the preliminary stage.
Implications: The trial/prosecution was permitted to proceed; factual disputes and validity of prosecution sanction can be considered at trial rather than in preliminary quashing proceedings.
3. S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2480/2010 (filed by Shri Vineet Bansal challenging order dated 9.4.2010)
Holding: ALLOWED. The Court quashed and set aside the orders dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010 passed by the Special Judge, ACD Cases, Jaipur which had forwarded the second complaint/petition under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. to the ACB. The Court held the second complaint was barred because the same allegations had already been the subject of a prior complaint where cognizance had been taken and forwarding was earlier refused; the subsequent forwarding effectively reviewed the prior order which was impermissible.
Implications: The orders directing police to register/investigate the second complaint stand vacated. The decision restored the legal effect of the prior proceedings (including the fact that the earlier complaint had been dismissed as withdrawn and that the trial court had earlier declined the request to forward under Section 156(3)). The Court also stressed that proper application of mind and consideration of sanction issues are necessary when forwarding complaints against public servants.
4. S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 880/2010 (filed by ACB Rajasthan)
Holding: DISPOSED OF. The Court, in light of its decision in petition No. 2480/2010, did not pass any separate order on merit and disposed the petition.
Implications: No separate substantive relief was granted to ACB; the quashing of the forwarding orders (as decided in petition No. 2480/2010) determines the operative position regarding the second complaint.
Final practical consequence: The prosecution in FIR No. 300/2008 was not quashed and remains capable of being proceeded with in trial; orders forwarding the second complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. were set aside because of their being barred by prior proceedings and for lack of appropriate exercise/recording of judicial mind.
Prashant Kumar Agarwal, J.:— These four Criminal Petitions basically relate and have arisen from the same matter and, therefore, they were tagged together and with the consent of counsel for the parties they were heard together and are being decided by this common order. Copy of the order may be placed in each of the files.
2. Common relevant facts in brief for the disposal of these petitions may be stated as follow:-
(1) A written complaint was submitted on 3.12.2008 before Shri. Vineet Bansal, the then Additional Superintendent of Police, Anti Corruption Bureau Jaipur-II, Jaipur by one Shri. Rajesh Rathi son of Shri. Vishnu Kumar Rathi against Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu, the then Registrar of Firms about demand of bribe for making/deleting entries in the register maintained by her office.
(2) The allegations made in the complaint were verified on 8.12.2008 which were prima facie found to be correct and true.
(3) Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu was caught red handed on 10.12.2008 taking Rs. 1,00,000/- as bribe from Shri. Rajesh Rathi. Shri. Vineet Bansal in presence of two Motbir-witnesses and aforesaid amount was recovered from a drawer of her office table. She was arrested on 10.12.2008 itself at 9.10 p.m vide arrest memo.
(4) Formal FIR Numbered as 300/2008 for the aforesaid incident was registered on 12.12.2008 by the office of Superintendent of Police I, ACB, Jaipur for the offences under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act (hereinafter to be referred as ‘the Act”).
(5) Copy of FIR was received by ACD Court, Jaipur on 17.12.2008
(6) Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu was produced for remand on 11.12.2008 in the ACD Court, Jaipur and she was sent to judicial custody on the same day and her application for grant of bail under Section 437 Cr.P.C was dismissed by the said Court.
(7) After investigation charge-sheet was filed against Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu for the offences under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act on 16.9.2009 after obtaining necessary prosecution sanction from the competent authority as required under Section 19 of the Act.
(8) Complaint Case No. 8/2009 was filed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu against Shri. Vineet Bansal, Additional Superintendent of Polikce, ACB, Jaipur, Rajesh Rathi and his father Shri. Vishnu Kumar Rathi on 16.9.2009 in the ACD Court, Jaipur for the offences under Section 12 of the Act and for offences under Sections 120-B, 166, 167, 193, 204, 339, 340, 344, 499 and Section 500 IPC with the prayer that cognizance may be taken for the said offences against the persons named in the complaint as accused, issue process against them and punish them in accordance with law and she may be awarded adequate compensation for the loss suffered by her.
(9) In the aforesaid complaint, vide order dated 18.9.2009 it was decided by the Court to record the statement of Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu under Section 200 Cr.P.C
(10) An application came to be filed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu on 16.12.2009 in the aforesaid complaint with the prayer that the matter involves commission of several cognizable offences for which proper evidence could be collected by police investigation only and, therefore, the complaint filed by her may be sent for registration of FIR and investigation to ACB, but the application was dismissed by the Court vide order dated 8.1.2010
(11) On the basis of application filed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu in the aforesaid complaint, permission was given by the Court to withdraw the aforesaid Complaint Case No. 8/2009 and it was dismissed as withdrawn on 11.1.2010 with liberty to persue any other remedy legally available to her in regard to the offences for which the aforesaid complaint was filed.
(12) A complaint/petition under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C was filed on 16.3.2010 by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu (which was registered as Complaint Case No. 3/2010) before ACD Court, Jaipur with a prayer to direct the Director General, ACB Rajasthan, Jaipur to register FIR on the basis of complaint annexed with the complaint/petition.
(13) Vide order dated 9.4.2010, the said complaint/petition was sent by the Court below under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to SHO, ACB, Jaipur.
(14) This order dated 9.4.2010 has been challenged by Shri. Vineet Bansal, the then Additional Superintendent of Police, ACB, Jaipur by way of S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2480/2010 filed under Section 482 Cr.P.C
(15) Order dated 9.4.2010 is also subject matter of challenge in S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 880/2010 filed by ACB, Rajasthan, Jaipur under Section 482 Cr.P.C
(16) It is to be noted that as per direction of ACD Court, Jaipur vide order dated 9.4.2010, FIR was not registered and a report dated 19.4.2010 was filed by ACB containing reasons for non-registration of FIR which was opposed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu by filing a written application. Vide order dated 4.5.2010 it was made clear by the ACD Court that its order dated 9.4.2010 still stands and needs to be complied with.
(17) Order dated 9.5.2010 has not been challenged by ACB as well as by Shri. Vineet Bansal.
3. This Criminal Writ Petition under Articles 14, 21, 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India read with Sections 482, 483 has been filed by Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu on 23.1.2013 (accused in FIR No. 300/2008 registered by ACB, Jaipur) with the following prayers:-
1. Declare the arrest of the petitioner on 10/12/08 as void ab initio as also her subsequent detention in police custody from 10-11/12/08 and in Judicial Custody from 11/12/08 to 09/01.09.
2. Direct the respondent no. 4 and 5 to delete the name of petitioner from all jail records and official records and withdraw all references made to her as a prisoner in the official records.
3. Issue a writ/order/direction to the respondent (s) to compensate the petitioner by an amount of Rs. 30.00 lakh (Rs. 1,00,000.00 per day for illegal custody) for mental and physical torture suffered by the petitioner and her family during this period.
4. That the Hon'ble Court may be most graciously pleased to issue a writ/order/direction to the respondent (s) to compensate the petitioner by an amount of Rs. 1.00 Crore towards defamation by allowing the media to take pictures of a person in custody without proper authority from the Court, even before her formal arrest was made or any FIR was registered against the petitioner.
4. In support of the petition, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted as below:-
(1) Respondent-Shri Vineet Bansal called and made arrangement for the presence of a large number of newspaper, correspondents, photographers and T.V Channels at the time of laying of trap and allowed them to take photographs and TV shots from different angles. The vedio footage so collected were immediately telecasted Live on ETV-Rajasthan and P7 Channel-Rajasthan. Incident about taking and recovery of bribe amount from the petitioner was published with photographs in newspapers resulting in her defamation. Respondent was not entitled to allow media to take pictures of the petitioner in custody without proper authority from the Court, even before her formal arrest was made or any FIR was registered against her.
(2) In contravention of sub-section(4) of Section 46 Cr.P.C petitioner was arrested on 10.12.2008 at 9.10 p.m i.e after sun-set without there being in existence of any exceptional circumstances that too by a male police officer Shri. Vineet Bansal, Additional Superintendent of Police, ACB, Jaipur without obtaining prior written permission of the concerned Judicial Magistrate or Special Judge, ACD Cases.
(3) The petitioner and her father were compelled to put their signatures on the memo of arrest although they were not willing to do so because arrest was being made contrary to relevant legal provision.
(4) Although, memo of arrest was prepared at the place of incident itself and signatures of her father, who was present there, were also obtained on it but copy of same was not provided to him despite request/demand being made for it.
(5) Petitioner was produced before the Court of Special Judge, ACD Cases, Jaipur for remand on 11.12.2008 and she was sent to judicial custody on the same day and her application for grant of bail under Section 437 Cr.P.C was dismissed despite the fact that even formal FIR was not registered till then and it was admittedly registered on 12.12.2008 Learned Court below did not take into consideration that petitioner's detention, custody, arrest and even judicial remand was illegal ab-initio being contrary to provisions of Section 46(4) Cr.P.C
(6) Learned ACD Court as required by law did not provide free copy of the order dated 11.12.2008 whereby bail application of the petitioner was dismissed.
(7) Copy of the FIR registered on 12.12.2008 was sent to the Court as late as on 17.12.2008 and petitioner had no option but to file application for grant of bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C in High Court without enclosing copy of FIR and the application of the petitioner was put under the defect category by the High Court Registry.
(8) Without registration of formal FIR for an offence, ACB had no jurisdiction to investigate the crime, detain and arrest the petitioner and produce her for remand, police or judicial.
(9) Copy of FIR was provided to petitioner on 16.12.2008 by ACB under the provisions of Right to Information Act after obtaining Rs. 24/- as copying fee. Such fee cannot be charged from an accused under judicial custody for an offence.
(10) ACB failed to produce case diary on 22.12.2009 as directed by High Court in the bail application filed by the petitioner and in absence of the same, bail application could not be heard by High Court on merit compelling petitioner to withdraw it with liberty to file a fresh application before ACD Court, Jaipur.
(11) Second application for grant of bail filed by the petitioner was dismissed by ACD Court after giving opportunity of hearing to a party stranger to the case and placing reliance on documents placed on record by the counsel for that party.
(12) Although, benefit of bail was granted to petitioner by High Court by an order dated 7.1.2009 passed in S.B Criminal Second Bail Application filed by her but even then copy of order was provided to her counsel on 9.1.2009
5. On the strength of all these grounds learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that due to illegal acts and omissions of the respondents, petitioner was compelled to remain in illegal detention/custody from 10.12.2008 to 9.1.2009 which entitles her to make demand for and obtain all the reliefs made in the petition. It was further submitted that it is a case of not only of gross breach of directions issued by Hon'ble Supreme Court from time to time in regard to arrest and detention of a person suspect of an offence but also this is a case of gross and flagrant violation of the fundamental rights of life and liberty conferred upon the petitioner by Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It was also submitted that it is now well settled principle of law that compensation can be awarded to a person under Article 226 of the Constitution of India by High Court for contravention of fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
6. In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the case of Bhim Singh v. State of Jammu & Kashmir reported in AIR 1986 SC 494, order dated 5.3.2012 passed by learned Division Bench of Bombay High Court in Criminal Writ Petition No. 1666/2010 and order dated 30.11.2012 passed by another Division Bench of Bombay High Court in Criminal Writ Petition No. 2515/2012.
7. On the other hand, learned Public Prosecutor submitted that it is a case in which neither any statutory or any fundamental right of the petitioner has been infringed in any manner entitling her to seek relief for declaration or grant of compensation. It was submitted that on the basis of a written complaint submitted by complainant-Shri Rajesh Rathi trap proceedings were held and office of the petitioner was raided by the ACB team headed by Additional Superintendent of Police Shri. Vineet Bansal on 10.12.2008 after 5 PM and petitioner was caught red handed while accepting an amount of Rs. one lac as bribe and the said amount was recovered from one of the drawers of her office table and all formalities including preparation of various memos were undertaken and in continuous and sequence thereof petitioner was arrested at 9.10 PM when it was found that offence under the provisions of the PC Act are made out against her and, therefore, it cannot be said that the petitioner was deliberately arrested after sunset in violation of sub-section (4) of Section 46 Cr.P.C It was further submitted that in anti-corruption cases generally formal FIR is registered only after a public servant is found involved in the offence and recovery of bribe money is made and, therefore, it cannot be said that ACB had no jurisdiction to arrest and undertake trap proceedings or further investigation without formal FIR being registered. It was further submitted that other grounds raised on behalf of the petitioner also do not tantamount to infringement of any statutory or fundamental right of the petitioner leading to her arrest and detention being illegal. According to learned Public Prosecutor, it is not a case in which a person was arrested without preparation of memo of arrest or detained in custody for more than 24 hours without producing him before a Magistrate for remand.
8. On consideration of submissions made on behalf of the respective parties and the material made available on record as well as the relevant legal provisions and the case law, I do not find any substance in the petition and it is liable to be dismissed for the following reasons:-
Although, sub-section (4) of Section 46 Cr.P.C provides that no woman shall be arrested after sun set and before sun rise except in exceptional circumstances and where the police officer effecting arrest after sun set and before sun rise claims existence of some exceptional circumstances, he must obtain the prior permission of the Judicial Magistrate or Special Court within whose local jurisdiction the offence has been committed or the arrest is to be made but it cannot be said that under no circumstances can such requirement be waived. The exigencies of the situation have to be taken into account before it is held that arrest of the woman has been made in contravention of this provision. In a case it may happen that offence itself is committed after sun set and before sun rise and after undertaking some preliminary investigation involvement of a woman is found in the offence and her immediate arrest is required to be made and practically it is not possible to obtain the prior permission of the concerned Magistrate, in my opinion in such a situation the arrest of the woman accused cannot be said to be in contravention of the requirement of this provision and it does not amount violation of fundamental right conferred upon such woman under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It is well settled legal position that personal liberty of a person can be curbed by procedure established by law and Code of Criminal Procedure is one of such procedural law.
9. In the case of Sube Singh v. State of Haryana reported in (2006) 3 SCC 178, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that before awarding compensation for violation of the rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution in a proceeding under Article 32 or Article 226 of the Constitution the Court will have to pose itself the following questions; (a) whether the violation of Article 21 is patent and incontrovertible, (b) whether the violation is gross and of a magnitude to shock the conscience of the Court.
10. In the case of M.C Mehta v. Union of India reported in (1987) 1 SCC 395, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that it is not in every case where there is a breach of a fundamental right committed by the violator that compensation would be awarded by the Court in a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution. The infringement of the fundamental right must be gross and patent, that is, incontrovertible and ex facie glaring and either such infringement should be on a large scale affecting the fundamental rights of a large number of persons, or it should appear unjust or unduly harsh or oppressive on account of their poverty or disability or socially or economically disadvantaged position to require the person or persons affected by such infringement to initiate and pursue action in the Civil Courts.
11. Thus, it is not each and every contravention of a fundamental right entitles a person to claim compensation. In the present case from the material available on record prima facie it is revealed that the petitioner called the complainant of the case to her office on 10.12.2008 for the purpose of payment of amount of bribe to her on which necessary preparations were made by ACB to raid the office of the petitioner and caught her red handed while accepting the amount of bribe from the complainant. It is further clear that on 10.12.2008 at about 5 PM complainant entered into the office room of the petitioner and the petitioner obtained/accepted an amount of Rs. one lac from him and put it in one of the drawer of her office table and on signal being given by the complainant, respondent No. 2-Shri Vineet Bansal alongwith the raiding party including two motbir witnesses entered into the office room of the petitioner and on interrogation being made, it was found that petitioner has accepted the bribe amount upon which necessary steps were taken for recovery of the amount, preparation of various memos, father of the petitioner was called at the spot and when involvement of the petitioner was found for an offence under the provisions of the Act, she was arrested in the presence of a lady constable, father of the petitioner and two motbir witnesses and memo of arrest was also prepared. I am of the view that in the light of the sequence of events even if petitioner was arrested at 9.10 PM i.e after sun set without obtaining prior permission of the Court concerned, it cannot be said that it tantamount to violation of the statutory requirement or it was patent and gross and of such a magnitude so as to shock the conscious of the Court. After all, provisions of Section 46(4) Cr.P.C are procedural in nature which are generally to be followed honestly but there may be some cases in which it is almost impossible to fulfill the requirement or practicable unnecessary to do so.
12. So far as whether petitioner and her father were compelled to put their signatures on the memo of arrest under duress against their will or not is a question of fact which can be decided after parties led their evidence in an appropriate proceedings and this issue can not be decided in a proceeding filed under Article 226/227 of the Constitution or under Section 482/483 Cr.P.C Preparation of a memo of arrest and obtaining of signatures of a witness or family member of the person arrested and also of the person arrested is a legal requirement which is to be followed in each and every case of arrest of a person and, therefore, obtaining of signatures of petitioner and her father on the arrest memo is neither against any fundamental right of the petitioner nor against any statutory provision. As already said, the question of compulsion cannot be decided without recording evidence of the parties. Similarly, in absence of requirement of law to provide copy of memo of arrest or any other document as and when it is prepared during investigation of an offence to the accused, even if copy of memo of arrest was not provided to petitioner or her father in the present case at the time when it was prepared at the place of incident inspite of request/demand being made for it, it cannot be held that merely by that reason any fundamental or statutory right of the petitioner was infringed entitling her to claim that her arrest/detention in custody was illegal and she is entitled to be compensated.
13. Arrest and detention of the petitioner in judicial custody cannot also be held illegal merely because she was arrested and produced before the Court and sent to judicial custody and her application for bail was dismissed on 11.12.2008 before formal FIR was registered in the present case as in the opinion of this Court there are several offences like offences under the provisions of P.C Act, NDPS Act, Excise Act etc. in which investigation can be undertaken merely on the basis of an information for an offence likely to be committed, arrest can be made and accused can be remanded to police or judicial custody even before formal FIR for the offence is registered and there is no illegality in the same. In the present case also as already stated, information about demand of bribe by the petitioner from the complainant was given to ACB in the form of a written complaint which was verified and found to be true and it was further revealed that the petitioner will accept the amount of bribe in her office on 10.12.2008 upon which arrangements were made to raid her office and caught her red handed while accepting bribe. As per prosecution case, petitioner accepted Rs. one lac as bribe, the said amount was recovered and seized, other formalities regarding investigation were undertaken, she was arrested and necessary memos and other documents were prepared and the petitioner was produced before the Court within the prescribed period of twenty four hours for remand, police remand was not unnecessarily demanded. Although, it would have been better for ACB to have registered formal FIR on the same day or on the next day before petitioner was produced in the Court but merely in absence thereof, it cannot be said that any fundamental or statutory right of the petitioner was infringed and her arrest and detention became illegal. In my opinion the Court was competent to remand the petitioner to judicial custody and decide her application for grant of bail on the basis of remand papers and other material produced before it by ACB. When petitioner herself filed application for bail on 11.12.2008, the Court was bound to consider and decide it and the petitioner cannot be allowed now to claim that Court was not competent to decide her application in absence of registration of formal FIR more particularly in view of the fact that material was available before the Court showing involvement of the petitioner for an offence under the provisions of the Act.
14. Similarly, no infringement of any constitutional or statutory right of the petitioner can be said to have been taken place merely by the reason that copy of the order dated 11.12.2008 was not provided to her by the Court free of cost on the same day and she was compelled to obtain certified copy of it on the next day. Sub-section (1) of Section 361 Cr.P.C provides that when an accused is sentenced to imprisonment, a copy of the judgment shall, immediately after the pronouncement of the judgment, be given to him free of cost. No provision of law was brought to the knowledge of the Court providing that copy of an order dismissing application for bail is to be given to the petitioner free of cost. Otherwise also, even if copy was not given to the petitioner on the same day free of cost or otherwise, it cannot be accepted that it is patent and gross violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India amounting detention of the petitioner illegal.
15. Similarly, other grounds taken by the petitioner like late providing of copy of FIR, her application for bail being put under the category of defect by registry of the High Court, non-production of case diary on the date fixed by the High Court, permission given by the trial Court to counsel for a stranger to the case to oppose the bail and place on record some documents and late furnishing of copy of the bail order dated 7.1.2009 by High Court are at the most procedural lapses not going to the root of the matter and not adversely affecting any of the fundamental or statutory right of the petitioner. Apart from that, order dated 23.12.2008 passed by the trial Court shows that it was counsel for the complainant who was also present before the Court to submit his submissions to oppose the application filed by the petitioner and, therefore, counsel for the complainant cannot be said to be a stranger to the case.
16. So far as presence of newspaper and TV correspondents and photographers at the time of raid and publication of photographs and Live telecast of the incident is concerned, in my view this also is a question of fact at whose instance and in what circumstances it was done so, which can be decided only on the basis of evidence produced in an appropriate proceeding and not merely on the basis of allegations made in such a petition.
17. Though, illegal detention of an accused is recognized as violation of the fundamental rights of life and liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution and compensation can be awarded as a public law remedy for such violation but such compensation cannot be awarded in each and every case of violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. In the facts and circumstances of the present case any of the grounds taken of the petitioner individually and all the grounds cumulatively do not tantamount to infringement of any fundamental or statutory right of the petitioner entitling her to claim compensation or any other relief.
18. Consequently, the petition being meritless is, hereby, dismissed. Th stay application also stands dismissed.
S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2017/2009
19. Accused-petitioner-Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu in FIR No. 300/2008 registered by ACB Jaipur for offences under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act by way of this petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C has sought the following reliefs:
a) Quash the impugned FIR 300/08.
b) Direct the respondent no. 2 to recall the sanction order, if issued, or drop the proceeding in the matter of prosecution sanction, if still under consideration.
c) Issue directions to respondent no. 1 to terminate all investigations against the petitioner being conducted by Mr. Vineet Bansal Additional SP, and Mr. S.N Tripathi, Additional SP.
d) Any other order or direction, which may be considered just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case, may also kindly be issued in favour of the petitioner.”
20. During the pendency of this petition, an application dated 20.7.2011 (Inward No. 6863) filed by the petitioner was allowed vide order dated 30.5.2012 and liberty was given to the petitioner to assail the charge-sheet also which was filed in the trial Court on 16.9.2009 after filing of this petition and before interim order was passed on 18.9.2009
21. In support of the petition, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted as below:-
(1) Formal FIR was not registered on 3.12.2008 when information about commission of cognizable offence on 25.11.2008, 18.11.2008 and 3.12.2008 under the Act was given to ACB by complainant-Shri Rajesh Rathi by way of written complaint whereas legal mandate is that once a police officer receives an information about commission of a cognizable offence, he is bound to register FIR immediately for the offence. For the commission of two of the aforesaid offences, formal FIR's have not been registered till the filing of the petition whereas for the offence allegedly committed on 10.12.2008 present FIR was registered most probably on 16.12.2008 or atleast on 12.12.2008 and copy of the same was sent to the Court as late as on 17.12.2008 raising reasonable suspicion of the sanctity of the FIR.
(2) FIR has been registered malafidely by Shri. Vineet Bansal as petitioner was arrested against the provisions of Section 46(4) Cr.P.C by a male police officer and an amount of Rs. 1,19,600/- was seized and confiscated from the house of the petitioner without any legal authority and even without registering formal FIR for offence under Section 13(1)(e) of the Act even after nine months from the date of seizure.
(4) The allegations in the FIR are so absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person would proceed against the petitioner and the ACB proceeded against the petitioner even on the basis of such complaint only actuated by malice. It is absurd and inherently improbable that petitioner would demand Rs. five lacs as bribe on 18.11.2008 from the complainant when no work of his was pending before the petitioner, an amount of Rs. one lac would be paid by the complainant to petitioner on 25.11.2008 when no work was pending before petitioner, a demand of Rs. 11 lacs would be made as bribe although no work was pending and a demand of Rs. ten lacs and five lacs would be made by petitioner from rival parties for a non-existent work. It is well settled legal position that FIR is liable to be quashed if allegation in it are absurd and inherently improbable.
(5) Complaint was filed by the complainant to take revenge against the petitioner as he bore grudge against her for making the entry on 27.11.2008 in the register on the application of uncle of complainant.
(6) Shri. Vineet Bansal continued to further investigate the case despite general practice in the department that trap officer would not undertake further investigation in such cases. This is reflective of bias on the part of the ACB.
(7) ACB sought prosecution sanction on the basis of a motivated, half baked and incomplete investigation. At one hand prosecution sanction under Section 19 of the Act was sought from the Govt. claiming that investigation is complete whereas on the other hand as per reports filed on 28.8.2009 before the trial Court by the investigating officer it was stated that they are still investigating the matter. This also shows bias and motivated investigation by ACB.
(8) ACB sought prosecution sanction despite the fact that several representations were pending before government and petitioner was also granted an opportunity of oral representation on 9.9.2009 before Additional Chief Secretary attached to the office of Chief Minister.
(9) Present case is covered within the purview of principle of law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal reported in AIR 1992 SC 604 more particularly paras 108(5), (6) and (7) of the same.
22. On the basis of these grounds and the principle of law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bhajan Lal (supra), it was submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner that from the mere reading of the FIR, no offence of any kind is disclosed against the petitioner as there is neither demand nor acceptance of bribe by the petitioner nor there is any misuse of her office by the petitioner.
23. On the other hand, it was submitted by the learned Public Prosecutor that the allegations made in the complaint/FIR, material made available on record and the evidence collected during investigation which has resulted into submission of the charge-sheet before the trial Court prima facie disclose the essential ingredients of the offences for which the FIR was registered and the present case is not of that rate or exceptional category, which is enumerated by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bhajan Lal (supra). It was further submitted that from the material available on record it is manifest that petitioner demanded and accepted Rs. one lac from complainant on 10.12.2008 which amount was recovered from her possession from one of the drawers of her office table. It was submitted that as per clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 13 of the Act, if a public servant by corrupt or illegal means or by abusing his position as a public servant or while holding some office as a public servant obtains any pecuniary advantage without any public interest, the same amounts to criminal misconduct punishable under Section 13(2) of the Act. It was also submitted that the grounds raised by the petitioner are at the most questions of fact which can be considered and decided by the trial Court after appreciating the evidence led by the parties and they do not carry merit at this preliminary stage.
24. On consideration of submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, allegations made in the complaint/FIR and material made available on record, I prima facie found that there is sufficient evidence showing involvement of the petitioner in the incident and offences under Section 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act are prima facie disclosed against the petitioner at this stage of the proceedings. It is well settled legal position that FIR registered for an offence against a person can be quashed at the preliminary stage only when the allegation made in it and the evidence collected during investigation do not disclose even prima facie the essential ingredients of the offence for which it has been registered. In the present case, prima facie it is made out that the petitioner as a public servant demanded and accepted Rs. one lac as bribe from complainant and same was recovered from her possession. I am of the view that present case does not come within the purview of the exceptions enumerated by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal (supra). The grounds taken by the petitioner in support of the petition, in my considered opinion, involve questions of fact which can be considered and decided by the trial Court after both the parties lead their evidence and these grounds do not merit at this preliminary stage. Similarly, validity of the prosecution sanction also can be considered by the Court after trial and not at this stage. I am of the view that the prosecution must get opportunity to prove charge against the petitioner during trial.
25. Consequently, the criminal misc. petition being meritless is, hereby, dismissed. The stay application also stands dismissed.
S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2480/2010
26. By way of this Criminal Misc. Petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C petitioner, the then Additional Superintendent of Police, ACB, Jaipur and trap/investigating officer of FIR No. 300/2008 registered by ACB, Jaipur against respondet-Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu, has challenged the order dated 9.4.2010 passed by the Special Judge, Anti-Corruption Cases, Jaipur in Case No. 3/2010 whereby the learned Court below has forwarded the complaint/petition filed by respondent-Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu (accused in FIR No. 300/2008) to ACB Jaipur under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C
27. In support of the petition, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted as below:-
(1) The complaint/petition filed by the respondent was forwarded mechanically by the Court below without application of mind whereas legal requirement is that a petition/complaint cannot be sent even under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C by the Court for registration of FIR and investigation to police without going into the contents of the petition/complaint and prima facie finding that cognizable offence is disclosed.
(2) The order has been passed overlooking the fact that previous complaint filed by the respondent with the same allegations was dismissed by the same Court as withdrawn vide order dated 11.1.2010 after cognizance was taken by the Court in that complaint vide order dated 18.2.2009 and it was fixed for recording statement of respondent under Section 200 Cr.P.C and prayer made by the respondent to forward the prior complaint for investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C was refused vide order dated 8.1.2010 The Court below was not competent to entertain the second complaint with the same allegations and forward it even for registration of FIR and investigation thereon. It is well settled legal position that if cognizance for an offence has been taken by the Court on the basis of a complaint and Court has decided to proceed under Section 200 Cr.P.C, it can not revert back and forward the complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to police for registration of FIR and investigation. In the present case, respondent deliberately concealed the material facts about filing of first complaint, cognizance taken on it and its dismissal as withdrawn while filing present petition/complaint.
(3) The complaint has been filed by the respondent against the petitioner with an oblique motive and to pressurize him from discharging his duty and obligation as police officer in the case registered against her on the basis of FIR No. 300/2008.
(4) Bare reading of complaint/petition filed by the respondent shows that the ingredients of the offences for which the complaint has been filed are not disclosed even prima facie and, therefore, it is an abuse of process of law to forward the complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C
(5) Complaint is manifestly attended with malafide and/or it has been instituted with an ulterior motive for wrecking vengeance on the petitioner and with a view to spite him due to the reason that he happens to be trap/investigating officer in the case filed against the respondent on the basis of FIR No. 300/2008.
(6) At the relevant time, petitioner was discharging his public duty as a public servant and, therefore, the complaint could not have been entertained without sanction as required under Section 197 Cr.P.C
(7) Petitioner is entitled to challenge the order dated 9.4.2010 even if formal FIR has not been registered as the first complaint filed by the respondent with the same allegations has been dismissed as withdrawn vide order dated 11.1.2010
(8) The subsequent order dated 4.5.2010 need not be challenged as it is not a separate and independent order, but it was passed in continuance of and as a clarification of the order dated 9.4.2010 If the order dated 9.4.2010 is quashed and set aside by this Court, order dated 4.5.2010 will loss its value and existence automatically.
(9) The petitioner cannot be deprived of his right to challenge the impugned order merely by the reason that the order has separately been challenged by the ACB under Section 482 Cr.P.C more particularly in view of the fact that name of petitioner has been ordered to be deleted from the array of respondent in that petition. It is pertinent to note that in that petition the petitioner was joined only as a formal party.
(10) The petition cannot be dismissed on the ground of mere delay also more particularly in view of the fact that no period of limitation is prescribed for filing a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C and no in ordinate delay has been made for filing the petition.
28. In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the cases of Anil Kumar v. M.K Ayappa reported in 2014 Cr.L.J 1 (SC) and State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal reported in AIR 1992 (SC) 604.
29. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent submitted as below:-
(1) Petitioner is not entitled to challenge the order dated 9.4.2010 as the same has already been challenged by ACB on 2.5.2010 by way of a separate petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C and the present petitioner was arrayed as one of the respondents in that petition.
(2) Subsequent to the impugned order dated 9.4.2010, Court below has passed order dated 4.5.2010 reiterating its stand to forward the petition/complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C and in absence of challenge to subsequent order, present petition is not maintainable. Petitioner has concealed the order dated 4.5.2010 from the Court.
(3) Petition has been filed with a delay of more than seven months despite the fact that petitioner was represented by the counsel in the petition filed by the ACB.
(4) Forwarding of a petition/complaint under Section 156(3) is not a judicial order affecting rights of an accused empowering him to challenge it under Section 482 Cr.P.C Accused does not come into picture and is not empowered to challenge FIR unless and until it is registered and investigation is undertaken. Present petition is premature as FIR is yet to be registered as order dated 9.4.2010 has been stayed by this Court. It is well settled legal position that a person cannot challenge the complaint/FIR unless cognizance is taken and he is summoned as an accused or it is registered.
(5) Initially, respondent filed complaint on 12.1.2010 directly before ACB against petitioner and others for registration of FIR but ACB declined to register case vide letters dated 1.2.2010 and 10.3.2010 which compelled the respondent to file complaint/petition before ACD Court.
(6) As all efforts made by the respondent for registration of FIR against petitioner and others failed, she had no option but to file a complaint/petition before the Court below.
(7) Orders dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010 have been passed after application of mind by the Court below. No reasons are required to be recorded in support of such orders.
(8) The present petition/complaint is not barred as the first complaint was dismissed as withdrawn and not on merit.
(9) Order dated 4.5.2010 is an independent and separate order, which has been passed by the Court below after considering the report dated 19.4.2010 of ACB to the effect that FIR cannot be registered in compliance of the order dated 9.4.2010 In absence of challenge to order dated 4.5.2010, no purpose would be served even if order dated 9.4.2010 is quashed and set aside.
(10) Infact petition/complaint filed by the petitioner is cross-case of FIR No. 300/2008 registered against her as both relate to the same incident of 10.12.2008 and, therefore, proper course is that both the cases are investigated simultaneously by one and same independent and impartial investigating officer.
(11) A Magistrate is not bound to take cognizance on a complaint filed before him and one of the course open to him is to sent it under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to the police without taking cognizance as has been done in the present case vide order dated 9.4.2010
(12) Hon'ble Supreme Court vide order dated 7.10.2013 passed in the case of State of Rajasthan v. Babu Lal (Criminal SLP No. 4669/10) has clarified that if a complaint is sent under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to police it means that the Magistrate after applying his mind has found that a cognizable offence is disclosed from the complaint and he is directing the police to register the case.
30. In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the respondent relied upon the order dated 22.1.2015 passed by a learned Single Bench of Rajasthan High Court in S.B Criminal Writ Petition No. 205/2014) (Bhawani Shankar Sharma v. Chief Judicial Magistrate), Gopal Das Sindhi v. State of Assam reported in 1996 Cr.L.J 39 (Gauhati High Court), judgment dated 5.3.2013 passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Deputy Chief Controller of Import & Exports v. Roshan Lal Agrawal (Criminal Appeal No. 1656-1663/95) and the case of Bhushan Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi) reported in (2012) 5 SCC 424.
31. I have considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, material made available on record as well as the relevant legal provisions and the case law.
32. My findings with reasons are as below:-
(1) Petitioner is entitled to challenge the order dated 9.4.2010 and he cannot be deprived of to do so merely because a separate petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C was filed by ACB challenging the same order more particularly in view of the fact that the petitioner was arrayed in that petition only as proforma-respondent being named as an accused in the petition/complaint filed by the respondent and no relief of any kind against him or in his favour was sought by ACB in that petition and also by the reason that his name was deleted by the Court in that petition on the basis of an application filed by the respondent her.
(2) Petitioner has a right to challenge the order dated 9.4.2010 by this reason also that the prior complaint filed by the respondent was dismissed as withdrawn on the application of respondent her and thus, a right accrued in favour of the petitionr and the order dated 9.4.2010 may deprive him from the benefit of the order dated 11.1.2010
(3) Petition cannot be dismissed by the reason that it has been filed with a delay of seven months as no period of limitation is prescribed for filing a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C and it cannot be accepted that the petition has been filed with an inordinate delay. It is to be noted that name of petitioner was deleted from the array of proforma-respondent in that petition vide order dated 8.12.2010 and the present petition has been filed on 15.12.2010
(4) Petition cannot be dismissed by the reason that order dated 4.5.2010 has not been challenged as that order is not a separate and independent order and it has been passed in continuation and as a clarification of order dated 9.4.2010 If the order dated 9.4.2010 is quashed and set aside by this Court, order dated 4.5.2010 would not survive as it has no independent existence and value.
(5) The present petition/complaint filed by the respondent is barred as no second or further complaint/petition can be permitted to be filed with the same allegations and, therefore, the order dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010 are bad in law. It is an admitted position that with the same allegations complaint was filed on 16.9.2009 by the respondent which was registered as Complaint Case No. 8/2009 and vide order dated 18.9.2009 cognizance was taken and the Court below proceeded further to record the statement of the respondent under Section 200 Cr.P.C but her statement could not be recorded by one reason or the other. It is also an admitted fact that an application was filed by the respondent on 16.12.2009 with a prayer to send the complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to ACB for registration of FIR and investigation but the same was dismissed by the Court vide order dated 8.1.2010 and lateron on the basis of application dated 11.1.2010 filed by the respondent, the complaint was dismissed as withdrawn. Although, the first complaint has not been dismissed on merit but looking to the circumstances in which the complaint was withdrawn by the respondent, present petition/complaint is not legally maintainable and no order to forward it under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C could have been passed on it. Although, while dismissing first complaint as withdrawn, liberty was given by the Court below to respondent to persue any legal remedy available to her but that does not mean right accrued to her to file a fresh petition/complaint with a prayer to forward it under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C Once the prayer made by the respondent in the course of hearing of the first complaint to forward it under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C was specifically declined by the Court vide order dated 8.1.2010, order dated 9.4.2010 and subsequent order dated 4.5.2010 tantamount to review of the prior order. It is well settled legal position that Criminal Court has no jurisdiction to review its order. It is also well settled legal position that once cognizance is taken for an offence on a complaint and Magistrate decides to proceed under Chapter-XV Cr.P.C, he cannot revert back and send the complaint under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C In the present case, the present petition/complaint was filed by the respondent concealing the material facts and order dated 9.4.2010 has been passed in ignorance of the prior complaint and orders passed on it.
(6) Although, detailed reasons are not required to be recorded in support of an order passed under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C but the order must reflect that before forwarding complaint under this provision to police, Court applied its mind and prima facie found that cognizable offence is disclosed from it. Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Anil Kumar v. M.K Ayappa (supra) has held that where a jurisdiction is exercised on a complaint filed in terms of Section 156(3) or Section 200 Cr.P.C, the Magistrate is required to apply his mind, in such a case, the Special Judge/Magistrate cannot refer the matter under Section 156(3) against a public servant without valid sanction order. The application of mind by the Magistrate should be reflected in the order. The mere statement that he has gone through the complaint, documents and heard the complainant. After going through the complaint, got weighed with the Magistrate to order investigation under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C should be reflected in the order, though a detailed expression of his views is neither required nor warranted. In the present case, the requirement is absolutely absent.
(7) As per the law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Anil Kumar v. M.K Ayappa (supra), the petition/complaint was not even entertainable and could not have been forwarded under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C in absence of a valid sanction as required under Section 197 Cr.P.C
33. For the aforesaid reasons, both the orders dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010 are not legally sustainable and are liable to be quashed and set aside.
34. Consequently, the Criminal Misc. Petition is allowed and the orders dated 9.4.2010 and 4.5.2010 passed by the Special Judge, ACD Cases in Case No. 3/2010 are quashed and set aside. The stay application also stands disposed of. The stay application also stands disposed of.
S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 880/2010
35. This Criminal Misc. Petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C has been filed by ACB Rajasthan, Jaipur to challenge the order dated 9.4.2010 passed by the Special Judge, ACD Cases, Jaipur in Case No. 3/2010 whereby the learned Court below forwarded the petition/complaint filed by the respondent-Smt. Sadhna Upmanyu under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C to ACB, Jaipur for registration of FIR and investigation. It is to be noted that in the present case no one appeared on behalf of ACB on the dates when the matter was listed for hearing from time to time alongwith connected matters.
36. Learned counsel for the respondent interalia submitted that ACB has no right to challenge the impugned order as it cannot be said to be aggrieved by that order and it is its duty to register FIR and undertake investigation if complaint is forwarded by the Court to it under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C
37. Submissions were considered.
38. In view of the order passed today in S.B Criminal Misc. Petition No. 2480/2010, no order on merit is required to be passed in this petition.
39. Consequently, this Criminal Misc. Petition stands disposed of. The stay application also stands disposed of.
Alert