Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. MR K R SUKUMAR S/O LATE RAMANNA NAIK

Karnataka High Court
Jun 14, 2016

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 14THDAY OF JUNE, 2016

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE S.SUJATHA Writ Petition No.11105/2013 [L-TER]

BETWEEN:

THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER

KARNATAKA FOREST DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION LIMITED

SULLIA RUBBER DIVISION

SULLIA

DAKSHINA KANNADA-574327.

... PETITIONER

(By SRI. G. S. KANNUR, ADVOCATE)

AND

MR. K. R. SUKUMAR

S/O LATE RAMANNA NAIK

AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS

R/AT C.R. COLONY

NAGAPATNA ALETTI VILLAGE,

SULLIA TALUK -574327.

... RESPONDENT

(By SRI. SHIRISH KRISHNA, ADVOCATE FOR KRISHNA KESHAVA & ASSTS, ADVOCATES)

THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER

DT.30.3.2012, PASSED BY THE COURT OF PRESIDING OFFICER,

LABOUR COURT, DK, MANGALORE INID.NO.1/11 WHICH IS PRODUCED AS ANN-E TO THE WP.

1

THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING

'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, MADE THE FOLLOWING:

ORDER

This writ petition is filed by the Employer assailing the Award passed by the Labour Court, Dakshina Kannada, Mangalore in IDA No.1/2011.

2. Briefly stated the facts are:

that the respondent was appointed as a 'Watchman' on compassionate grounds in the petitioner-Corporation on 31.03.2010. It transpires that the respondent had produced a false medical certificate at the time of securing the appointment. The petitioner, after noticing the physical disability in the respondent, directed the respondent to appear for medical examination. Accordingly, the respondent appeared for the medical examination and permanent disability of 40% was found. The respondent was under probationary period. Since the respondent had produced false medical certificate at

2

the time of securing the job, the petitioner-Corporation discharged the respondent from services. Being aggrieved by the order of discharge, the respondent raised dispute under Section 10[4-A] of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 [the 'Act', for short]. The Labour Court allowed the petition filed by the respondent on the ground that the respondent ought to have been given any alternate work looking into the physical disability instead of discharging him from services. The Labour Court directed the petitioner to reinstate the respondent with continuity of service and with 50% of back wages. Being aggrieved by the Award passed by the Labour Court, the present writ petition is filed.

3. It transpires that the petitioner has reinstated the respondent without prejudice to the right of the Corporation pending disposal of the writ petition. A serious dispute was raised by the petitioner regarding the physical disability of the respondent before this

3

Court. In view of the same, to discern the truth, the respondent was directed to undergo medical examination before the District Surgeon and Superintendent of Wenlock District Hospital, Mangalore, on 10.12.2015 and the parties were directed to submit the medical report before this court.

4. Today, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted the medical report dated 14.12.2015 issued by Wenlock District Hospital, Mangalore, wherein it is stated that the respondent is physically disabled to the extent of 90% relating to his both upper and lower limbs.

5. The learned Counsel appearing for the respondent though accepted the medical report would contend that the petitioner-Corporation has failed to follow the procedures prescribed under the Act. Even if the petitioner has come to a conclusion that the

4

respondent is not physically fit to work with the Corporation, an order of dismissal passed by the Corporation without holding any enquiry is a stigmatic order which would affect his career in future. The respondent being of young age, the said dismissal order if not set aside, would be a hindrance to the respondent's progress. The Labour Court having considered this vital aspect is justified in setting aside the dismissal order passed by the petitioner-Corporation which does not call for any interference by this Court. Accordingly, he seeks for dismissal of the writ petition confirming the Award passed by the Labour Court.

6. The learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner fairly submits that though the medical report now produced shows 90% disability of the respondent to his both upper and lower limbs, the petitioner- Corporation is ready and willing to reinstate the respondent-workman in compliance with the Award

5

passed by the Labour Court as the respondent is being already reinstated without prejudice to their rights challenged in the present petition provided the respondent gives up 50% of the back wages awarded by the Labour Court.

7. This is a fair submission which deserves to be accepted in the circumstances of the case. Primarily, the respondent was appointed on compassionate grounds. It is evident from the medical certificate placed before this Court that there is some physical disability with the respondent which is not denied by the respondent. In the given circumstances, a sympathetic view taken by the petitioner-Corporation is worthy of acceptance.

8. Accordingly, I am of the considered opinion that it would be appropriate to modify the Award passed by the Labour Court. Hence, the following order:

6

[i] The order of the Labour Court setting aside the dismissal order passed against the respondent is confirmed.

[ii] The petitioner-Corporation shall reinstate the respondent to his original post with continuity of service and other consequential benefits.

[iii] The respondent shall not be entitled for any back wages.

9. In the result, writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above

Sd/-

JUDGE

AN/-

7