- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Noor Islam v. State Of Maharashtra
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant (original accused) was tried along with one Mohammad Yunus for offences under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code in Sessions Case No. 83/2012 before the Additional Sessions Judge-5, Aurangabad. Mohammad Yunus was acquitted for lack of evidence, while the appellant was convicted. The trial Court sentenced the appellant to rigorous imprisonment for ten years and a fine of Rs. 5,000 for the offence under Section 489(B), and to seven years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 5,000 for the offence under Section 489(C) (with default simple imprisonment provisions).
The underlying facts, as recorded by the prosecution, are that on 29.9.2011 the accused purchased a Vodafone recharge of Rs. 100 from P.W.2 (shopkeeper Dinesh Mahale) in Cannaught Market, Cidco, Aurangabad and tendered a Rs. 1,000 currency note which P.W.2 suspected to be fake. P.W.2 consulted an adjacent shopkeeper P.W.3 (Raju Vetal), a phone call was made to the police, and the accused was detained until police arrived. Police searched the accused and seized one Rs. 1,000 note (tendered to P.W.2) and, allegedly, 32 additional Rs. 1,000 notes from his trouser pocket. Various other items (mobile phone, two pay-in slips, diary, identity card, railway ticket, and steel plates) were also seized and recorded in panchanama Exh.36. A Currency Note Press, Nasik report (Exh.46) later found the seized notes to be counterfeit. A charge sheet was filed and the accused was tried.
The defence was a denial (including the accused's statement under section 313 Cr.P.C.). The trial Court convicted and sentenced as above. The appellant challenged that conviction on appeal; the present opinion is the appellate Court's decision on that challenge.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the prosecution proved the required mens rea ("knowing or having reason to believe" that currency notes were forged or counterfeit) necessary to sustain convictions under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) IPC.
- Whether the seizure of 32 additional Rs. 1,000 notes from the accused's person was lawfully and properly proved (in particular, whether police and panchas gave their personal search or offered such search before searching the accused), such that possession of those notes could be attributed to the accused.
- Whether proof of possession of counterfeit currency alone is sufficient, absent additional evidence showing that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes were counterfeit.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The mere fact of possession of counterfeit currency is not sufficient to attract conviction under Sections 489(B) and 489(C); those offences require mens rea — i.e., that the accused was "knowing or having reason to believe" the currency to be counterfeit.
- Reliance on precedents (Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh and M. Mammutti v. State of Karnataka) to show that possession alone does not establish mens rea and that the prosecution must prove circumstances from which knowledge can be inferred.
- Challenged the proof of seizure of the 32 notes on the ground that the record (panchanama Exh.36 and FIR Exh.53) did not show that the police/panchas offered their personal search before searching the accused; asserted that proper search procedure was not established.
Respondent's (State's) Arguments
- The learned A.P.P. for the State urged that the trial Court's reasoning and the prosecution evidence established the offence; the A.P.P. rebutted the appellant's grounds and relied on the trial Court's findings that the accused tendered a counterfeit note and that additional counterfeit notes were seized.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh [(2001) 9 SCC 642] | Establishes that mens rea under Sections 489-B and 489-C is "knowing or having reason to believe" the notes are counterfeit; possession or use alone is not sufficient. The case cautions against presuming mens rea without supporting material and notes requirement of specific questioning under Section 313 Cr.P.C. where appropriate. | The Court relied on Umashankar to emphasize that the prosecution must prove the accused had knowledge or reason to believe the notes were counterfeit; absent such proof, conviction under Sections 489-B/489-C cannot stand. The appellate Court used this principle to scrutinize the evidence of knowledge and found it lacking. |
| M. Mammutti v. State of Karnataka (1979) 4 SCC 723 | Holds that mere possession of counterfeit notes is not enough; to attribute knowledge, the notes must be of such a nature that a mere look would convince a person of average intelligence that they are counterfeit. Also highlights the need for the prosecution to question the accused specifically about knowledge. | The Court applied M. Mammutti to examine whether the seized notes were so plainly counterfeit that knowledge could be inferred. Finding the evidence did not show that the notes were obviously counterfeit on mere inspection, the appellate Court concluded mens rea was not proved. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The appellate Court proceeded by a careful review of the prosecution's oral and documentary evidence and the trial Court's findings.
- Credibility of eyewitnesses: The Court accepted P.W.2 (Dinesh Mahale) and P.W.3 (Raju Vetal) as credible on the point that the accused tendered a Rs. 1,000 note which gave rise to suspicion and that a phone call was made to the police; they and bystanders detained the accused until police arrived. The Court found no satisfactory basis in cross-examination to discard their evidence on these points.
- Proof of the single tendered note: The seized Rs. 1,000 note tendered to P.W.2 was identified in panchanama Exh.36 (note number 2BD 790666) and the Currency Note Press report (Exh.46), admissible under Section 292 Cr.P.C., declared it counterfeit. The Court agreed with the trial Court that this particular note was proved to be counterfeit and that the accused had tendered it.
- Seizure of the 32 notes — procedural defects: The Court scrutinized the evidence about the seizure of the additional 32 notes from the accused's right-hand trouser pocket. The panch (P.W.1) testified that the police searched the accused and found the notes but also admitted that the police did not take personal search from him and the other panch, and the panchanama (Exh.36) is silent about any offer or refusal of personal search. P.W.5 (the complainant officer) acknowledged that the record should note any offer of personal search. P.W.6 (investigating officer) orally asserted that he asked the accused about personal search and that the accused refused; however, the written panchanama does not reflect that refusal. Given these gaps and inconsistencies, the Court held the prosecution failed to prove that proper search procedure (i.e., that police/panchas gave or offered their personal search before searching the accused) was followed. The Court therefore declined to rely on the oral assertion by P.W.6 that an offer and refusal took place.
- Mens rea requirement: Relying on the cited Supreme Court authorities (Umashankar and M. Mammutti), the Court reiterated that conviction under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) requires proof that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes were counterfeit. The Court examined whether the prosecution had established circumstances from which such knowledge could reasonably be inferred.
- Whether the notes were obviously counterfeit on mere inspection: The Court considered witness testimony on the appearance of the notes. P.W.2 expressed suspicion and testified that the note's wire was coming out and its colour was removing, but the Currency Note Press report (Exh.46) referred to imitation of the security thread and ink shade mismatches rather than a smearable colour. P.W.3 admitted he could not identify a fake note from a distance. The police and the accused had themselves gone to the State Bank branch to verify the notes before registering the FIR, indicating the police sought confirmation of counterfeitness. The Court found that the prosecution had not proven that the notes were such that a person of ordinary intelligence would have known them to be counterfeit on mere inspection.
- Failure to prove source or additional incriminating circumstances: The Court noted that although two pay-in slips and evidence of deposits (Rs. 25,000 on two occasions) were seized, the prosecution did not bring material establishing the source of the amounts or linking the accused to trafficking or use of counterfeit notes beyond possession of the tendered note. There was no satisfactory inquiry recorded at trial to show the accused had the requisite knowledge or reasons to believe the notes were counterfeit.
- Conduct of the accused: The Court observed that the accused did not attempt to flee and agreed to remain until the police arrived; while this conduct was noted, it was not sufficient to establish knowledge of counterfeitness in the absence of the other required proof.
- Conclusion of analysis: Because the prosecution failed to prove the critical ingredient of mens rea — that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes in his possession were counterfeit — and because the seizure of the 32 notes was not satisfactorily proved on procedural grounds, the appellate Court found the conviction unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment of conviction and sentence is quashed and set aside, and the appellant-accused is acquitted of the offences punishable under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
Immediate consequences and directions given by the Court:
- The accused is to be set at liberty forthwith unless his custody is required in respect of any other offence.
- Any fine paid by the accused is to be refunded.
Broader implications: The opinion limits itself to the direct effect on the parties and does not purport to lay down new law. The Court applied existing Supreme Court authorities on mens rea under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) to the facts and found the prosecution's proof insufficient. No new precedent was announced.
Criminal Appeal No.510/2015
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.510 OF 2015
Noor Islam s/o Sadik Ali Age 25 years, Occu. Labour, R/o Rohitalab, Tq. and Dist. Shaebganj (Zarkhand State) ... APPELLANT
(Orig. Accused)
VERSUS
The State of Maharashtra (At the instance of CIDCO Police, Aurangabad) ... RESPONDENT
.....
Shri A.K. Bhosale, Advocate for appellant Shri R.V. Dasalkar, A.P.P. for respondent/ State
.....
CORAM: A.I.S. CHEEMA, J.
DATED: 15th July, 2016. Date of reserving judgment : 30th June, 2016 Date of reserving judgment : 15th July, 2016.
J U D G M E N T :
1. The appellant - original accused (hereafter referred to as "accused") was tried along with one Mohammad Yunus for offence punishable under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC in brief) in
1
2
Sessions Case No.83/2012 before Additional Sessions Judge-5, Aurangabad and, while the other accused came to be acquitted as there was no evidence against the said accused, the appellant was convicted for these Sections. He was sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten years and fine of Rs.5000/-, in default of fine, to suffer simple imprisonment for one month, under Section 489(B) of IPC. For offence under Section 489(C), he was convicted and sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for seven years and to pay fine of Rs.5000/- and in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for one month. Thus these appeals.
2. The case of prosecution in short is as under :
On 29.9.2011, at about 3.00 p.m., in Cannaught Market, Cidco, Aurangabad, the accused had gone to one shop, Shivam Mobile Shoppee. He purchased one Vodafone Reacharge of Rs.100/- from P.W.2 Dinesh Mahale and offered him a currency note of Rs.1000/-. Dinesh suspected the currency note and on the plea that he will get change, went to adjacent shop of P.W.3 Raju Vetal and explained his suspicion to him. A phone call was made to Cidco Police Station, received by P.I. Dabbewad (P.W.6). The fact was informed on phone to P.I. Dabbewad. The shopkeeper P.W.2 Dinesh and his neighbouring shopkeeper P.W.3 Raju Vetal, with the help of persons who had gathered,
3
detained the accused till the police came. Police reached the spot in about half an hour and panchas were called including P.W.1 Sanjay Govandar. Search of the bag which the accused was carrying, was taken and in the bag, further 32 notes of Rs.1000/- denomination were found. Accused had a Samsung Mobile phone with him which was also seized. In the bag, there were two Pay-in-slips having contents filled of two different Account Numbers and Rs.25,000/-. Election Identity Card of the accused as well as diary containing phone numbers, 6 steel plates/ dishes and Railway Ticket of Travel, dated 25.9.2011 from Bhagalpur to Manmad were also found. These articles were seized vide panchanama Exh.36. The police took the seized articles along with the accused to State Bank of India, Main Branch, Aurangabad and after verifying from the Branch Manager that the currency notes were fake, the police party reached back to the Police Station and P.W.5 P.S.I. Baburao Bodke, who was along with P.W.6 P.I. Dabbewad at the time of seizure, filed F.I.R. Exh.53. P.W.6 Maruti Dabbewad took up the investigation. Statements were recorded. The seized notes were sent to the General Manager, Currency Note Press, Nasik Road, Nasik on 13.10.2011. The investigation was taken over by the Crime Branch on 25.10.2011 and P.W.4 Harish Khatavkar received the expert opinion on forged notes from the Currency Note Press, Nasik (Exh.46) that the currency notes were counterfeit.
4
Through Deputy Commissioner of Police S.S. Garge, P.W.4 P.S.I. Harish got sent a letter to Department of Currency Management, informing the numbers of the currency notes which had been seized so that Rs.1000/- denomination currency notes in circulation in the market could be kept under observation. After the investigation, charge sheet came to be filed and the accused was put up to trial. Accused No.2 was stated to be his accomplice and two accused Nos.3 and 4 were shown as absconding, in whose accounts it was claimed accused No.1 had earlier deposited amounts.
3. Prosecution brought on record evidence of six witnesses and the documentary evidence was also proved. The defence of the accused, as can be seen from the cross- examination and his statement under section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C. in brief) is that of denial.
4. The trial Court, after considering the oral and documentary evidence, convicted the accused and sentence as mentioned above was passed.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the appellant - accused as well as the learned A.P.P. for State. Various grounds have been raised by the counsel for the appellant - accused and
5
in reply, the learned A.P.P. rebutted the same and relied on the reasonings recorded by the trial Court to submit that the offence has been established. I will refer to the arguments for deciding the matter while discussing the evidence.
6. On record, firstly there is evidence of P.W.2 Dinesh Mahale and P.W.3 Raju Vetal, the neighbouring shopkeeper. The evidence of these two witnesses shows that, the accused indeed had gone to the shop of P.W.2 Dinesh and on purchasing Vodafone Recharge of Rs.100/-, he tendered a currency note of Rs.1000/-. P.W.2 Dinesh deposed that he had suspicion about the currency note given by the accused to be fake and he had told the accused that he does not have change and went to the adjacent shop of P.W.3 Raju. The evidence of P.W.3 shows that P.W.2 Dinesh came to him and showed him the currency note and expressed his suspicion that the same was forged. P.W.3 did not depose that he also felt the note to be forged, but the evidence of both these witnesses is that a phone call was made to the police and police was called. Both these witnesses say that the other of them made the phone call. That, however, is not material. Important is that a phone call was made when the note of Rs.1000/- tendered by the accused was suspected by P.W.2 Dinesh to be fake and police did come to the shop of P.W.2 Dinesh. The evidence of these two witnesses show that, with the
6
help of people who had gathered, the accused was caught by them and when police came, he was handed over to the police. Regarding this evidence, although efforts have been made in the cross-examination to shatter these witnesses, I do not find that the witnesses are shattered on this count. There is no reason for these two witnesses to unnecessarily speak against the accused or that they had any axe to grind against the accused to involve him for no reason.
7. The evidence of P.Ws.2 and 3 read with the evidence of P.W.1 Panch Sanjay, P.W.5 P.S.I. Baburao Bodke and P.W.6 P.I. Dabbewad shows that, police reached the shop of P.W.2 Dinesh and the accused was taken charge of by the police and the currency note of Rs.1000/- tendered by the accused was taken in charge by the police. The seizure panchanama Exh.36 shows this note to be having No.2BD 790666 . The subsequent report from Currency Note Press Exh.46 admissible under Section 292 of the Cr.P.C. has found this note (along with others) to be counterfeit. I find the evidence that this one note of Rs.1000/- tendered by accused to P.W.2 Dinesh and which was seized by police has been proved to be counterfeit note. The note was tendered by the accused and thus, these facts are established in the present matter. I agree with the trial Court on this count.
7
8. Now the question is of the remaining 32 currency notes said to have been seized from the right side pocket of the trouser of accused. In this regard, there is evidence of the above prosecution witnesses that, when the police came, they searched the person of the accused and from his pocket, 32 currency notes were seized, the numbers of which notes were entered in the panchanama Exh.36. The learned counsel for the accused argued that, the seizure could not be said to be proved as there was no material to show that the police offered or gave their own search before searching the pockets of the accused.
9. If the evidence of P.W.1, who is the panch, is perused, it shows that, he was called and told that a currency note of Rs.1000/- is found with the accused, and his evidence is that, the police then searched the person of the accused and took out 32 fake currency notes from the right side pocket of the trouser of accused. He deposed (in para 4 of his cross- examination) that, accused No.1 did not take personal search of him and the other panch and police had also not given their personal search to the accused. In this context, the panchanama Exh.36 is silent and does not say anything that the search was offered and declined by the accused or that the accused had taken personal search of the police and panchas. The evidence of P.Ws.2 and 3 is silent regarding any search being offered,
8
declined, given or taken. The evidence of P.W.5 shows that, this P.S.I., who is the complainant, admitted (in para 3 of his evidence) that it is necessary for the police officer and panchas to give their personal search before taking search of any suspect and the said fact is required to be mentioned in the panchanama. As mentioned, the panchanama is silent on this count. In fact, the F.I.R. Exh.53 filed by this P.W.3 also does not mention that before searching the person of the accused any personal search was offered to him or that he declined or that the accused searched the persons of the police and panchas before his personal search was taken. In oral evidence, however, P.W.6 P.I. Dabbewad claimed that, after the panchas reached, he had asked the accused about their search in presence of panch witness, but he refused. According to this investigating officer, after the accused refused to take their search, they had searched the person of the accused and found 32 currency notes. In the cross-examination, this P.W.6 Dabbewad had to admit that the panchanama Exh.36 does not disclose that the accused had declined to take search.
10. Looking to the above discussion, I find that, the prosecution failed to prove that before putting their hands in the pocket of the accused the police had given their own personal search. Looking to the facts of the present matter, where seizure
9
of 32 currency notes of Rs.1000/- are shown from the pocket of the accused, which would not be a volume not possible to plant, I find that it was necessary to establish that proper procedure for search was followed and personal search was offered to the accused. This is not to say that the notes were planted in the pocket, but looking to the gravity of the matter, it was responsibility of the police to give fair opportunity to accused and to also make record of the same to claim that offence is proved beyond reasonable doubts.
11. I will ignore the oral evidence of P.W.6 that the police had offered their search but the accused refused.
12. I thus find that, the duly established fact is only of the seizure of one currency note of Rs.1000/-, which was tendered by the accused to the shopkeeper P.W.2 Dinesh. Now, before further discussing the oral evidence, I find it appropriate to make a reference to the judgment in the matter of Umashankar Vs. State of Chhattisgarh [(2001) 9 SCC 642] and the judgment of M. Mammutti Vs. State of Karnataka (1979) 4 SCC 723 relied on by the learned counsel for accused.
13. It has been argued by the learned counsel for the accused that, proving of mere fact of the accused being in
10
possession of counterfeit currency note or notes is not enough to hold that Section 489(B) or 489(C) is established. The learned counsel has rightly relied on the wordings of these Sections, where it is provided that, the using of the counterfeit currency or possession of the counterfeit currency is punishable if the accused was "knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit.
14. In the matter of "Umashankar" (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court, after referring to Sections 489(B) and 489(C) , observed in para 8 as follows :
"8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mens rea of offences under Sections 489- B and 489-C is "knowing or having reason to believe the currency notes or banknotes are forged or counterfeit". Without the aforementioned mens rea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes, is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489-B IPC. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489-C in the absence of the mens rea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite mens rea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect. The learned trial Judge on the basis of the evidence of P.W.2, P.W.4 and P.W.7 that they were able to make out that the currency note alleged to have been given to P.W.4 was fake, "presumed" such a mens rea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be an eighteen-year-old student. On the facts of this case
11
the presumption drawn by the trial Court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency notes being fake or counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code."
15. In the matter of "M. Mammutti" (supra), the appellant before the Hon'ble Supreme Court was found in possession of 2 rupee currency notes which were found to be counterfeit. The appellant-accused in that matter claimed that, two days earlier he had sold 3 quintals of tamarind fruits to a person, who had given him a sum of Rs.390/- and that the currency notes had been given to him by the said purchaser. The appellant therein claimed that, he did not know that these currency notes were counterfeit. The Hon'ble Apex Court observed in that matter that, there was no evidence of any witness to show that the counterfeit notes were of such a nature or description that a mere look at them would convince any person of average intelligence that it was a counterfeit note. The observations of the Hon'ble Apex Court are as under :
"There is no evidence of any witness to show that the counterfeit notes were of such a nature or description that a mere look at them would convince any person of average intelligence that it was a counterfeit note."
. . . . . . . . . . . . "Mr. Nettar submitted that once the appellant is found in possession of counterfeit notes, he must be presumed to know that the notes are counterfeit. If the notes were of such a nature that
12
mere look at them would convince anybody that it was a counterfeit such a presumption could reasonably be drawn. But the difficulty is that the prosecution has not put any specific question to the appellant in order to find out whether the accused knew that the notes were of such a nature."
16. Looking to the above judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it is clear that, mens rea in such matters is an important ingredient. The mens rea could be attributed if the notes are of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody of reasonable intelligence that it is counterfeit. In the present matter, in the statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the accused was asked, and informed that the report Exh.46 from currency note press showed that the currency notes were counterfeit. The accused did not give any explanation in his statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. However, looking to the above two judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court, it would be necessary to see if the evidence brought on record is sufficient to show that the accused had the necessary mens rea that the note or notes which were in his possession were counterfeit. With this object, I have examined the evidence. The evidence of P.Ws.2 and 3 is that when after talking between them it was felt by them that the currency is fake they caught the accused and kept him waiting for about half an hour till police came. These witnesses are silent regarding the talk they had with the accused at such time. In ordinary and natural course of conduct, they must have
13
told the accused that according to them the note tendered by him is fake and so he must keep waiting till police come. The accused would, in natural course, have said something. He was not accused at that point of time. No material has come as to what was their conversation when they forcibly kept the accused waiting till police came. Then, when the police came and panchas were called, and seizure took place, the evidence of P.W.1 Panch Sanjay and the police officials P.W.5 P.S.I. Baburao and P.W.6 Dabbewad is silent regarding any opportunity being given to the accused to explain as to from where he got the concerned note or notes. The F.I.R. Exh.53 has recorded in a vague manner that when the articles were seized from the accused and he was asked about the notes, the accused was giving "Udvaudvichi Uttare" i.e. evasive replies. In the search of the accused, apart from other things, 2 Pay-in-slips of State Bank of India were also found, in which certain Account numbers had been entered regarding deposit of Rs.25,000/- on two occasions in two different accounts on 28.9.2011 and 29.9.2011. Although a mobile phone was seized and a diary with telephone numbers was found, prosecution brought on record no material of source of the amounts. This, in spite of the fact that during the course of investigation P.W.4 P.S.I. Harish took over the investigation so that the Crime Branch would look into the matter. Cross- examination of P.W.6 Dabbewad shows that, on 30.9.2011, vide
14
Exh.59, State Bank was informed of the deposits made by accused in the two accounts. There appears endorsement on the document by Bank that the notes which had been accepted were genuine.
17. As observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of M. Mammutti, it is now necessary to see if the prosecution proved that the notes were of such a nature that a mere look at them would convince anybody that the same was counterfeit. If this would be so, knowledge could be attributed to the accused. In this context, I have gone through the evidence. P.W.2 deposed that, when accused offered him the currency note of Rs.1000/-, he had "suspicion" about the currency note to be fake. To verify, he went to P.W.3 Raju Vetal. Thus, P.W.2 Dinesh had only a suspicion. In his cross-examination, he deposed that, the fake currency note which was given to him, wire of the same was coming out and its colour was removing. In this regard, the Currency Note Press in report Exh.46 has mentioned that the security thread in the notes was imitated and with reference to "printing ink colour", it is reported that the ink shades were not matching. The report does not appear to be stating that on touch, the colour was going off. In this context, the evidence of P.W.3 Raju Vetal shows in cross-examination (para 3) that if the currency note was to be seen from distance,
15
he could not identify whether it was fake or original currency note. Further, there is evidence of P.W.5 as well as it is mentioned in the F.I.R. Exh.53 that after the seizure was done at the shop of P.W.2, the police along with the accused went and met the Branch Manager of State Bank of India, Main Branch to get the currency notes checked. Evidence of P.W.5 is that, the Branch Manager told the police that the 33 currency notes were counterfeit. His evidence is that, thereafter the police along with accused went to Police Station and he lodged the complaint. This evidence shows that, even the police wanted to be sure before they register the offence that the currency notes were counterfeit. Keeping such evidence in view, prosecution has not proved that the notes were of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody that it was counterfeit. When this is so, it cannot be presumed that, the accused had knowledge that the note or notes which were in his possession were counterfeit. Prosecution did not bring on record any further evidence which would show source from where the accused got the notes or any other material sufficient to assume that accused had the requisite knowledge, or that he had reason to believe the same to be counterfeit.
18. The learned counsel for the appellant - accused pointed out the evidence of P.W.1 where he deposed that when
16
the accused was caught, he did not try to run away. Then there is evidence of P.W.3 Raju Vetal, which shows (in para 4 of his evidence) that when they asked the accused to stop in the shop till arrival of the police, the accused told them to let the police come and he will remain there till arrival of police. There is no material that in the time of about half an hour when accused was kept waiting till police came, he tried to quietly throw off, drop aside or get rid of the 32 notes from his pocket. The evidence of P.W.5 P.S.I. Baburao shows that when the police reached the concerned shop, the accused was sitting there and two persons were near him. There is substance in the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellant-accused that this conduct of the accused also needs to be kept in view while appreciating the evidence regarding the knowledge or reason to believe. According to the counsel, if the accused knew or had reason to believe that he was carrying counterfeit currency notes, he would have reacted when P.W.2 went giving some excuse to P.W.3 with the currency note. The accused did not try to slip away or run away.
19. Looking to the above discussion, I find that the prosecution failed to prove important ingredient of the offence that the accused was knowing or had reason to believe that the note or notes he was in possession were counterfeit or forged.
17
This being so, the judgment of conviction and sentence as passed by the trial Court cannot be maintained.
20. I pass the following order :
The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment of the trial Court, convicting the accused and sentencing him to imprisonment and fine is quashed and set aside. The appellant- accused is acquitted of the offence punishable under Sections 489(B) and 489(C) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The accused be set at liberty forthwith unless his custody is required in any other offence. Fine, if paid, be refunded to the appellant - accused.
(A.I.S. CHEEMA, J.)
fmp/cri510.05
Alert