- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Nisha Priya Bhatia v. Ajit Seth And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Ms. Nisha Priya Bhatia, an officer in a sensitive intelligence organisation, filed WP (C) No. 7971 of 2008 before the Delhi High Court alleging sexual harassment by two senior officers—Mr. Sunil Uke (Joint Secretary) and Mr. Ashok Chaturvedi. Although the writ petition contained several prayers, only one was ultimately pressed: that Mr. Chaturvedi be directed to proceed on leave during the pendency of an independent enquiry so he could not influence it. On 12-11-2008, the High Court ordered that the enquiry be concluded expeditiously.
Two internal committees were constituted. The first looked into allegations against Mr. Uke and submitted its report on 19-05-2008. The second investigated the complaint against Mr. Chaturvedi and submitted its report on 23-01-2009. The disciplinary authority later accepted both reports and concluded that insufficient evidence existed to proceed against either officer.
Believing the enquiry reports were being withheld in violation of the High Court’s order, the appellant filed a contempt petition. The Delhi High Court, by judgment dated 12-11-2009 (Nisha Priya Bhatia v. Ajit Seth, 2009 SCC OnLine Del 4277), held that no contempt had been committed. The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Union of India could legitimately claim privilege under Sections 123 and 124 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 to withhold the sexual-harassment enquiry report dated 23-01-2009 and related documents from the appellant on the ground of national security.
- Consequently, whether the respondents were in contempt of the High Court’s order dated 12-11-2008 for not supplying those documents.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- She was entitled to receive the complete enquiry reports and supporting material concerning her own allegations of sexual harassment.
- Failure to supply the documents constituted non-compliance with the High Court’s earlier directions and amounted to contempt.
Respondents' Arguments (Union of India)
- Filed an affidavit dated 22-07-2010 asserting privilege under Sections 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act, contending that disclosure “would be against national interest and would compromise national security” because the appellant served in a “highly sensitive organisation.”
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court (per Madan B. Lokur, J.) inspected both enquiry reports and the accompanying documents submitted in sealed cover. It found “absolutely nothing” suggesting any threat to national security or the integrity of the country. When queried, the Additional Solicitor General could not identify any portion of the material that would be detrimental to national interests.
The Court considered it “very odd” that privilege under Sections 123 and 124—provisions intended to protect State affairs—was invoked in a sexual-harassment enquiry. The subject-matter did not pertain to State secrets, and no statutory or factual basis for withholding the reports had been demonstrated. Accordingly, the privilege claim was rejected.
Because the enquiry reports were now to be supplied, the question of contempt did not survive. The Court nevertheless noted that none of the respondents had, on the facts, wilfully disobeyed the High Court’s order.
While examining the report of 19-05-2008, the Court detected missing pages and absent CDs containing witness depositions. It directed the Union of India to furnish those items to the appellant within one week.
Holding and Implications
Appeal DISPOSED OF.
Orders:
- The appellant is entitled to receive the complete enquiry reports dated 19-05-2008 (Sunil Uke) and 23-01-2009 (Ashok Chaturvedi) along with all accompanying documents.
- The Court Master must hand over to the appellant the sealed-cover materials presently before the Supreme Court.
- The Union of India must supply the missing deposition pages (Annexures Q-2 and Q-5) and the CDs containing the depositions recorded on 22-04-2008, including that of Mr. Uke, within one week.
- No contempt is found against any respondent; Mr. Chaturvedi had passed away during the proceedings.
Implications: The decision underscores that claims of State privilege under Sections 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act must be narrowly construed and cannot be invoked to shield routine departmental enquiry reports, particularly those concerning sexual-harassment allegations. While the ruling provides relief only to the appellant, it signals that transparency is required unless a concrete and demonstrable threat to national security is shown.
Madan B. Lokur, J.— Leave granted. The appellant is aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 12-11-2009 passed by the Delhi High Court in Nisha Priya Bhatia v. Ajit Seth 2009 SCC OnLine Del 4277. By the impugned judgment and order, the High Court held that the respondents had not committed any violation of the order dated 12-11-2008 passed in Nisha Priya Bhatia v. Union of India WP (C) No. 7971 of 2008.
2. In WP (C) No. 7971 of 2008 the appellant had made several prayers but during the course of hearing in the High Court, five of the prayers were not pressed with liberty to take appropriate proceedings in accordance with law. The sixth prayer which was pressed related to Respondent 2 (Ashok Chaturvedi). It was prayed that he should be asked to proceed on leave pending the independent enquiry into the appellant's complaint of sexual harassment so that this respondent could not use his power and authority to influence any independent enquiry. As will be evident from the prayer, the enquiry relating to the allegation of sexual harassment made by the appellant was already pending. In the order dated 12-11-2008 WP (C) No. 7971 of 2008 a direction was given by the High Court to expeditiously conclude the enquiry.
3. A few brief facts are necessary for a proper appreciation of the controversy before us.
4. The appellant had complained of sexual harassment by her senior Sunil Uke, Joint Secretary in the Department and Ashok Chaturvedi. The allegation of sexual harassment by Sunil Uke was looked into by a committee constituted for this purpose. The committee gave its report on 19-5-2008.
5. A separate enquiry was held by a separate committee into the allegation of sexual harassment by Ashok Chaturvedi. This committee gave its report on 23-1-2009.
6. In the contempt petition filed by the appellant in the Delhi High Court, it was brought out that the committee inquiring into the allegation against Ashok Chaturvedi had since given its report. It appears that pursuant to the report an order dated 22-9-2009 was passed against the appellant but she disputed that this order was based on the report. In any event, we are not concerned with the order dated 22-9-2009 except to say that it noted that the appellant's disciplinary authority had considered both the reports and had approved the conclusion that there was not enough evidence to take action against Sunil Uke or Ashok Chaturvedi.
7. Be that as it may, the controversy that arose during the pendency of the proceedings in the High Court and in this Court related to the entitlement of the appellant to a copy of the report dated 23-1-2009. The High Court did not pass any substantive order relating to furnishing that report to the appellant.
8. At this stage, it may be noted that on 7-7-2014 2014 SCC OnLine SC 1641, 2015.” this Court recorded that Ashok Chaturvedi had since passed away.
9. With respect to furnishing the report dated 23-1-2009 an affidavit has been filed on behalf of the Union of India claiming privilege under Sections 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act, 1872. We have been taken through the affidavit dated 22-7-2010 and all that the affidavit says is that disclosure of the contents of the report would be against national interest and would compromise national security. Apparently, this is only because the appellant happens to belong to the highly sensitive organisation which is entrusted with the delicate job of collecting and analysing intelligence inputs necessary to maintain the unity, integrity and sovereignty of the country.
10. Both the reports and the accompanying documents have been filed by the Union of India in a sealed cover in this Court.
11. We have gone through both the reports and the accompanying documents and find absolutely nothing therein which could suggest that there is any threat to the integrity of the country or anything contained therein would be detrimental to the interests of the country. We had also specifically asked the learned Additional Solicitor General to tell us exactly what portion of the reports and the documents would be detrimental to the interests of the country but nothing could be pointed out during the hearing.
12. We find it very odd that in a matter of an enquiry in respect of an allegation of sexual harassment, the Union of India should claim privilege under Sections 123 and 124 of the Evidence Act. The contents of reports alleging sexual harassment can hardly relate to affairs of State or anything concerning national security. In any event, absolutely nothing has been shown to us to warrant withholding the reports and the documents from the appellant in relation to the enquiry of allegations of sexual harassment made by the appellant against Sunil Uke and Ashok Chaturvedi.
13. The report relating to allegations of sexual harassment made by the appellant against Sunil Uke is not the subject-matter of any dispute or controversy before us. However, since that report has also been filed in this Court in a sealed cover, we did go through it and find nothing in the report that would require it to be withheld from the appellant on any ground whatsoever. We, accordingly, dispose of this appeal by holding that the appellant is entitled to the reports in respect of the allegations made by her of sexual harassment by Sunil Uke and Ashok Chaturvedi and that none of the respondents have committed any contempt of court. In any case Ashok Chaturvedi has since passed away.
14. While going through the report dated 19-5-2008 we found that by mistake one or two pages of the deposition marked as Annexure Q-2 and Annexure Q-5 of the witnesses were not photocopied. Similarly, the CD containing the deposition of 6 officers/staff on 22-4-2008 has not been filed nor has the CD containing the deposition of Sunil Uke been filed in the sealed cover, perhaps to prevent damage to the CD.
15. We direct the Court Master to hand over to the appellant the report and documents pertaining to the enquiry in relation to the allegations made by the appellant against Sunil Uke and against Ashok Chaturvedi and which have been filed in this Court in a sealed cover.
16. We direct the Union of India to supply to the appellant the missing pages of the deposition marked as Annexure Q-2 and Annexure Q-5 of the witnesses as well as the CD containing the deposition of six officers/staff recorded on 22-4-2008 and the CD containing the deposition of Sunil Uke. The needful be done within one week from today.
17. With the above directions the appeal is disposed of.
Alert