- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Limited v. Prathyusha Resources And Infra Private Limited And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. (Visakhapatnam Steel Plant), a Government of India undertaking engaged in the manufacture and sale of steel products, floated a tender on 31-3-1992 for transportation of pig iron from its plant to Visakhapatnam Port. Respondent 1, a transporter and forwarding agent, emerged as the successful bidder and entered into an agreement on 24-2-1993. Although the agreement was initially set to expire on 31-3-1993, the work was extended several times and finally completed on 23-10-1997.
After completion, Respondent 1 submitted a final bill comprising three annexures. The appellant admitted the first two but rejected the third, which concerned the “base year” (1992 or 1994) for calculating price-escalation. The dispute was referred to arbitration. A sole arbitrator, a retired High Court Judge, framed five issues and decided all in favour of the respondent, holding 1992 as the base year and rejecting the limitation objection.
The appellant challenged the award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 before the District Judge, Visakhapatnam, who set it aside on limitation grounds. On appeal under Section 37, the High Court reversed the District Judge and reinstated the award. The present civil appeal challenges that High Court judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent’s claim before the arbitrator was barred by limitation under the Limitation Act, 1963.
- Which article of the Limitation Act—Article 18 (applicable to work-contracts) or Article 137 (residuary)—governs the dispute.
- The point of time at which the cause of action arose for the purposes of limitation: on completion of the contract (23-10-1997) or on/after subsequent correspondence relating to escalation (15-7-1996 or 4-9-1998).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments
- The High Court erred in applying Article 137; the work being a “work contract,” Article 18 should apply.
- Under Article 18, the right to sue accrued on 23-10-1997 when the contract ended, rendering the notice invoking arbitration time-barred.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The dispute regarding the base year for escalation arose as early as 15-7-1996, allegedly placing the notice invoking arbitration outside the limitation period; however, the respondent had reserved the right to claim the amount while the contract was subsisting.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court reiterated the settled principle that a cause of action arises when a “real dispute” surfaces—i.e., when one party asserts a right and the other denies it. It observed that although the contract concluded on 23-10-1997, the disagreement over the base year for escalation first surfaced in correspondence dated 15-7-1996 and continued thereafter.
The Court noted that the respondent expressly reserved its right to claim escalation while the contract was still in force. Bills raised on 4-9-1998, followed by exchanges on 7-2-2000 and 9-5-2000, demonstrated that the accounts remained unsettled. Consequently, the cause of action crystallised “on or after 4-9-1998.”
Accepting this timeline, the Court agreed with the arbitrator and the High Court that the notice invoking arbitration was filed within the permissible limitation period. Accordingly, the limitation bar invoked by the appellant was rejected.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Dismissed. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decision, thereby restoring the arbitral award in favour of the respondent. No order as to costs was made.
Implications: The dismissal confirms the arbitral determination of 1992 as the base year for escalation and underscores that, for limitation purposes in arbitration, the cause of action may arise with the real dispute rather than merely on completion of the underlying contract. The ruling directly affects the parties but does not announce a new legal precedent.
Order
1. The present appeal is filed by the appellant challenging the judgment and order dated 16-12-2005 2005 SCC OnLine AP 1024, (2006) 1 AP LJ 244 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad, whereby the order dated 6-7-2004, passed by the learned District Judge, Visakhapatnam, was set aside and the arbitration award was confirmed.
2. The appellant Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd., which is popularly known as Visakhapatnam Steel Plant, is a Government of India undertaking, inter alia, engaged in manufacture and sale of steel products and pig iron in the domestic and export markets. Respondent 1 is a transporter, stevedoring, clearing and forwarding agent at Visakhapatnam. The appellant floated a tender vide Notification dated 31-3-1992 for transportation of pig iron, etc. from its Visakhapatnam Steel Plant to the Visakhapatnam Port area. Respondent 1 being the successful bidder, was awarded the work order on 28-7-1992. An agreement was entered into between the appellant and Respondent 1 on 24-2-1993 which was to expire on 31-3-1993. But owing to circumstances, the work was extended several times and the contract was finally completed on 23-10-1997. Issues arose as to the rate of escalation based on the base year 1992 or 1994. Respondent 1 submitted final bill having three annexures out of which first two were admitted, however, the appellant rejected the third one which was as to deciding the base year for calculating escalation.
3. The Arbitration Tribunal (consisting of a retired Judge of the High Court) decided the five issues framed in favour of the respondent claimant whereby the base year was adjudged as 1992, the bar of limitation was negated and the calculations made by the claimant were upheld. The appellant challenged the said award under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act, 1996 before the learned District Court which set aside the award as the relief was barred by limitation. Upon appeal under Section 37 of the Act by the respondent claimant, the High Court set aside the order of the District Judge and upheld the award of the arbitrator. The appellant employer herein have challenged the said order of the High Court.
4. The bone of contention in this appeal is the question of relief being barred by the law of limitation. The appellant submits that the High Court has arrived at a wrong conclusion by invoking Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, and since the contract was in the nature of work contract, Article 18 would apply. This article would thereby provide that the right to sue accrued when the contract was completed i.e. 23-10-1997 and hence notice for arbitration was beyond the period of limitation. The respondent claimant also argued that the dispute as to determination of base year for calculating escalation arose vide letter dated 15-7-1996 and hence the notice for arbitration was issued beyond the period of limitation. Either ways, the cause of action in favour of the respondent claimant accrued, if any, is an imperfect right.
5. We shall now consider the settled law on the subject. This Court in a catena of judgments has laid down that the cause of action arises when the real dispute arises i.e. when one party asserts and the other party denies any right. The cause of action in the present case is the claim of the respondent claimant to the determination of base year for the purposes of escalation and the calculation made thereon, and the refusal of the appellant to pay as per the calculations.
6. We find that the view taken by the High Court is correct as to when the real dispute arose between the parties to be adjudicated by the arbitrator. It is nobody's case that the contract came to an end on 23-10-1997, but the difference on determination of base year first arose in the letter dated 15-7-1996. The said letter is already controverted as the service of the same was seriously contested before in arbitration. However, the said letter was there even before completion of the work and prior to that the respondent claimant had reserved his right to claim money later since the contract was still subsisting then. In the light of the above reservation by the respondent claimant, bills were raised in 1998 vide letter dated 4-9-1998, which actually resulted into exchange of letters which formed the base of dispute between the parties. It is an admitted fact that the bills were not finalised as could be seen from the letters dated 7-2-2000 and 9-5-2000. Therefore, we find that the findings of the learned arbitrator and concurrently affirmed by the High Court are correct on the point that the cause of action arose on or after 4-9-1998. Hence, the said letter by the respondent claimant to the appellant to initiate arbitration was not barred by the law of limitation.
7. Accordingly, the civil appeal is dismissed with no order as to costs.
Alert