- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Deputy Director, Social Forestry Division And Another v. Lakshmi Chandra .
Supreme Court of India
Kurian Joseph, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeals arise out of long-standing disputes concerning daily-rated (Group D) workers in the Uttar Pradesh Forest Department.
- In State of U.P. v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337, this Court held that such daily wagers are entitled to the minimum of the pay scale received by their regular counterparts and that their cases for regularisation must be processed under the U.P. Regularisation of Daily Wagers (Appointment on Group D Posts) Rules, 2001.
- Alleging non-compliance, the workmen filed Contempt Petition No. 2465 of 2004 before the Allahabad High Court. On 1-7-2010, the High Court recorded prima facie wilful disobedience by departmental officers.
- The officers appealed to the Supreme Court (Civil Appeals Nos. 884-85 of 2016) against the contempt proceedings relating to non-payment of minimum wages.
- A separate set of appeals (Civil Appeals Nos. 879-83 of 2016) challenge High Court directions concerning failure to take effective steps for regularisation and preparation of eligibility/seniority lists.
- Several connected Special Leave Petitions (listed in para 18 of the opinion) were disposed of in terms of the present judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellants had wilfully disobeyed judicial directions to pay daily-rated workers at the minimum of the applicable pay scale, thereby justifying contempt proceedings.
- Whether the State authorities had failed to take meaningful steps towards regularisation of daily-rated workers in conformity with the 2001 Regularisation Rules and earlier Supreme Court and High Court orders.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- Contended that instructions had already been issued to all field officers to implement payment of minimum wages (affidavit of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests).
- Submitted that, during pendency of the proceedings, eligibility and seniority lists had been prepared in all 70 forest divisions and filed before the High Court.
Respondents’ (Workmen’s) Arguments
- Asserted that the eligibility/seniority lists were not prepared in accordance with the 2001 Rules and contained several fraudulent or “bogus” names.
- Maintained that the authorities had not taken genuine steps either to regularise services or to pay the minimum of the pay scale, despite repeated court directions.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of U.P. v. Putti Lal, (2006) 9 SCC 337; 2006 SCC (L&S) 1819 | Daily-rated workers performing duties similar to regular employees are entitled to the minimum of the pay scale, though not to increments or allowances; regularisation to be considered under the 2001 Rules. | Formed the foundation of the contempt and regularisation disputes; Supreme Court reiterated and directed strict implementation of this ruling. |
| Putti Lal (Allahabad HC), 1997 SCC OnLine All 864; (1999) 1 LLN 104 | Earlier High Court directions on payment of minimum wages to daily-rated workers. | Relied on by the High Court in its contempt order of 1-7-2010; noted by the Supreme Court when reviewing contempt proceedings. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Civil Appeals Nos. 884-85 of 2016 (Contempt Proceedings)
- The Court noted the affidavit of the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests stating instructions had been issued for compliance.
- To ensure implementation, it directed the Principal Secretary (Forest) and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests to file individual affidavits before the High Court confirming payment of minimum wages within one month.
- As an enforcement mechanism, the Court ordered that, if compliance was not achieved, these officers would be ineligible to draw salary from April 2016 without High Court permission.
Civil Appeals Nos. 879-83 of 2016 (Regularisation and Further Contempt)
- The Court acknowledged submission by the appellants that eligibility and seniority lists had been prepared across all forest divisions.
- Given allegations of irregularities in those lists, the Court refrained from fact-finding and instead remitted the matter to the High Court, directing it to “take into consideration all the subsequent developments and proceed accordingly” to reach a logical conclusion on both regularisation and minimum-pay issues.
- The High Court was requested to act expeditiously and, in any event, within three months; framing of contempt charges was to be deferred and reconsidered in light of subsequent compliance efforts.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF — All civil appeals and connected special leave petitions were disposed of subject to the directions issued.
Immediate Consequences:
- Forest Department officers must file compliance affidavits and ensure payment of minimum wages within one month.
- Failure to comply will result in the withholding of the Principal Secretary’s and Principal Chief Conservator’s salaries from April 2016, subject to High Court orders.
- The High Court must re-examine the regularisation process, verify the eligibility/seniority lists, and conclude the matter within three months.
No new legal principle was formulated; the decision enforces and operationalises the existing rule laid down in Putti Lal regarding minimum pay and regularisation of daily-rated employees.
Kurian Joseph, J.—
Civil Appeals Nos. 884-85 of 2016 [arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 27593-94 of 2010]
1. Leave granted. The appellants are before this Court, aggrieved by the proceedings for contempt initiated against them. The disputes herein are in a very narrow compass, regarding the payment of minimum of the pay scale to the daily wagers working in the Forest Department in Group D posts.
2. In the contempt application, being Civil Misc. Contempt Petition No. 2465 of 2004, by order dated 1-7-2010 2010 SCC OnLine All 2975, the High Court passed the following order: (Hari Shankar case 2010 SCC OnLine All 2975, SCC OnLine All paras 21-22)
“21. It is not the case of the opposite parties that the applicants are not working in the Forest Department at different places after the judgments of this Court and the Apex Court. It is admitted that the applicants are working as daily wagers. Thus, once this Court had issued directions to pay all the daily-rated workers the minimum of the pay scale but without allowances and other benefits, the applicants would be entitled to minimum of the pay scale so long they continue to work as daily-rated workers in the Forest Department. The opposite parties by not paying the minimum of the pay scale to all the daily-rated workers working in the Forest Department on the cut-off date and thereafter have thus violated/disobeyed the directions of this Court contained in the judgments of the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench in Putti Lal 1997 SCC OnLine All 864 , (1999) 1 LLN 104.
22. In view of discussions made above, the Court is prima facie satisfied that there has been wilful and deliberate disobedience/non-compliance on the part of the opposite parties with the directions of this Court as contained in the judgments of the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of this Court in Putti Lal 1997 SCC OnLine All 864 , (1999) 1 LLN 104, as modified (2006) 9 SCC 337 , 2006 SCC (L&S) 1819 by the Apex Court.”
3. The High Court had, in fact, directed the payment in terms of an order passed by this Court in Civil Appeal No. 3634 of 1998 dated 21-2-2002 titled as State of U.P v. Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 , 2006 SCC (L&S) 1819, in which this Court had held:
“5. In several cases, this Court applying the principle of equal pay for equal work has held that a daily wager, if he is discharging the similar duties as those in the regular employment of the Government, should at least be entitled to receive the minimum of the pay scale though he might not be entitled to any increment or any other allowance that is permissible to his counterpart in the Government. In our opinion that would be the correct position and we, therefore, direct that these daily wagers would be entitled to draw at the minimum of the pay scale being received by their counterparts in the Government and would not be entitled to any other allowances or increment so long as they continue as daily wagers. The question of their regular absorption will obviously be dealt with in accordance with the statutory rules already referred to.”
4. It is seen from the records of the contempt petition that the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests of the State had filed an affidavit before the High Court to the effect that necessary instructions had been issued to all the officers concerned to implement the directions referred to above with regard to payment of minimum of the pay scale to the daily wagers.
5. We direct the Principal Secretary to the Department of Forests, U.P and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, U.P to file separate affidavits before the High Court on the implementation of the orders referred to above. In case, the workmen have not been paid the amounts as per the orders, they shall see that wages are paid in terms of the orders within a period of one month from today and the affidavit in that regard shall be filed before the High Court within two weeks thereafter.
6. In case the orders are not implemented, the Principal Secretary to the Department of Forests and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests shall not be eligible to draw their salaries from the month of April 2016, without permission from the High Court.
7. Subject to the above directions, these civil appeals are disposed of with no orders as to costs. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, are disposed of.
Civil Appeals Nos. 879-83 of 2016 [arising out of Special Leave Petitions (C) Nos. 28317-21 of 2010]
8. Leave granted. The dispute essentially pertains to the regularisation of the daily wagers in the Forest Department of the State of U.P and payment of minimum of the pay scale being received by their counterparts in the Government without any other allowances or increment so long as the workmen continued as daily wagers.
9. In the decision rendered by this Court in Putti Lal (2006) 9 SCC 337 , 2006 SCC (L&S) 1819, this Court gave a quietus to both the disputes by permitting the State to take up the case of the daily wagers for regularisation in terms of the rules framed by the State viz. the U.P Regularisation of Daily Wagers (Appointment on Group D Posts) Rules, 2001. As far as the payment of minimum of pay scale also, this Court held that the daily wagers should be paid the minimum of the pay scale being received by their counterparts in the Government, without any other allowances or increment, so long as they continued as daily wagers.
10. The respondent approached the High Court complaining that no meaningful steps have been taken for regularisation in terms of the Rules referred to above despite the High Court issuing a direction in Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 43443 of 2004, decided on 23-10-2008 Writ-A No. 43443 of 2004, order dated 23-10-2008 (All).
11. The learned Single Judge, taking cognizance of the fact that despite the direction issued by this Court and the High Court, the State and their machinery had not been putting the house in order, directed the officers concerned to be present before the Court to explain the position. Accordingly, on 3-12-2009, the Principal Secretary, Department of Forests and the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, who were present before the learned Single Judge, submitted that steps would be taken to draw an accurate eligibility and seniority list in all the divisions in terms of the Rules referred to above for the purpose of regularisation. Despite such an undertaking given before the Court in person and recorded by the Court, apparently no meaningful steps were taken and therefore, the Court proceeded to the next stage of framing charges. The matter was taken in an intra-court appeal, which was also dismissed and thus, they are before this Court.
12. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants has submitted that during the pendency of these proceedings before the Court and the High Court, in all the 70 divisions of the Forest Department, the eligibility and seniority list has been prepared and submitted before the High Court. Mr Prashant Bhushan, learned counsel appearing for some of the workmen, has submitted that the lists which were submitted, were not prepared in accordance with the Rules and quite a few bogus names were also inserted in the list. We do not think it fit for us to go into all these aspects. Now that the lists have been prepared and presented before the Court, we request the High Court to take into consideration all the subsequent developments and proceed accordingly so as to reach a logical conclusion in terms of the orders passed by this Court and the High Court with regard to regularisation as well as the payment of minimum of pay scale to the daily wagers.
13. The needful may be done expeditiously and at any rate within three months from today. The parties will appear before the High Court on 17-2-2016. Needless to say, the steps proposed in the impugned order for framing charges will be deferred and reconsidered.
14. The Registry is directed to forward a copy of this judgment to the Registrar General of the High Court forthwith for posting of the case.
15. In view of the above, these civil appeals are disposed of with no order as to costs. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, are disposed of.
Special Leave Petitions (C) Nos. 26571-72, 26664-65, 27506-507, 27578-79 of 2010, 1340, 1342, 1343 of 2011
16. In view of the judgment passed in Civil Appeals Nos. 879-83 of 2016 [arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 28317-21 of 2010], no further orders are required to be passed in these special leave petitions and these are also disposed of in terms of the directions issued above.
17. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, are disposed of.
Alert