- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
N. Sunkanna v. State Of Andhra Pradesh .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, a Deputy Tahsildar (Civil Supplies), Kurnool, was accused of demanding and accepting a bribe of Rs 300 from a fair-price-shop dealer (PW 1) as alleged arrears of “monthly mamool”. Acting on PW 1’s written complaint dated 18-09-1993, the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB) laid a trap on 20-09-1993. Phenolphthalein-treated currency notes were recovered from the appellant’s person and chemical tests on his hands and shirt pocket were positive. After investigation and sanction, the appellant was tried by the Additional Special Judge for SPE & ACB Cases, Hyderabad, who convicted him under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, sentencing him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment on each count and a fine of Rs 1,000. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh affirmed the conviction on 02-07-2010. The present appeal before the Supreme Court challenges those concurrent findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a conviction under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act can be sustained solely on the recovery of tainted money when proof of demand for illegal gratification is absent.
- Whether the statutory presumption under Section 20 of the Act can arise in the absence of proved demand and acceptance of illegal gratification.
Arguments of the Parties
Prosecution/Respondent
- Relied on the trap proceedings, recovery of phenolphthalein-laced notes, and positive chemical tests to establish acceptance of illegal gratification.
- Invoked the presumption under Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act to contend that the money was received as a bribe.
- Cited the testimony of panch witness PW 2, who stated that PW 1 had confirmed the appellant’s prior demand for Rs 300.
Appellant/Accused
- Asserted that the money was voluntarily given by PW 1 towards the departmental target for purchasing National Savings Certificates, not as an illegal gratification.
- Emphasised that the complainant (PW 1) retracted his allegations in court, disowning the contents of the written complaint and stating that ACB officers dictated it.
- Argued that no independent witness supported any prior demand by the appellant, rendering the presumption under Section 20 inapplicable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| B. Jayaraj v. State of A.P., (2014) 13 SCC 55 | Demand of illegal gratification is a sine qua non; mere recovery of money is insufficient for conviction under Sections 7 & 13(1)(d). | The Court followed this ratio to hold that, since demand was unproved, conviction could not stand. |
| P. Satyanarayana Murthy v. State of A.P., (2015) 10 SCC 152 | Presumption under Section 20 can arise only after demand and voluntary acceptance are proved beyond reasonable doubt. | Reinforced the conclusion that, without proof of demand, the statutory presumption was inapplicable, requiring acquittal. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that the complainant (PW 1) turned hostile, retracting the allegation of demand and asserting that the money was meant for National Savings Certificates. Other fair-price-shop dealers (PWs 3, 4, 6) either denied any monthly payments or were declared hostile. No independent witness was produced to prove that the appellant demanded money.
Mere possession and recovery of tainted notes, though admitted by the appellant, were deemed insufficient because proof of illegal demand is essential for offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d). Without such proof, the presumption under Section 20 could not be invoked. Applying the principles laid down in B. Jayaraj and P. Satyanarayana Murthy, the Court held that the foundational facts necessary to draw the statutory presumption were absent. Consequently, both the trial court and the High Court had erred in sustaining the conviction.
Holding and Implications
HELD: The appeal is allowed; the conviction and sentences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted. Bail bonds, if any, stand discharged.
Implications: The decision reiterates that proof of demand for illegal gratification is indispensable in corruption prosecutions and that recovery alone cannot sustain a conviction. While the ruling does not create new precedent, it reinforces existing jurisprudence, signalling to investigating agencies the critical importance of securing reliable evidence of demand.
Chockalingam Nagappan, J.— Leave granted. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 2-7-20101 passed by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh affirming the conviction and sentence passed by the Additional Special Judge for SPE and ACB cases, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, whereby the appellant-accused has been found guilty of commission of offences under Sections 7, 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The appellant-accused has been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year for each of the offences and also to pay a fine of Rs 1000 in default to suffer simple imprisonment for three months.
2. The case of the prosecution is that the appellant-accused was, at the relevant point of time working as Deputy Tahsildar, Civil Supplies Mandal Revenue Officer, Kurnool in the State of Andhra Pradesh. The complainant PW 1, K. Sudhakar Reddy had a fair price shop at Narsimha Reddy Nagar Kurnool. It is alleged by the complainant that the appellant-accused used to collect Rs 50 per month from each fair price shop dealer in Kurnool as monthly mamool and when he visited the shop of the complainant on 17-9-1993 he demanded Rs 300 towards the monthly mamools from April 1993 by threatening to seize the stocks and foist a case against him. As the complainant was not willing to pay the said amount he had approached PW 7, Deputy Superintendent of Police, ACB, Kurnool and submitted Ext. P-1 complaint in writing on 18-9-1993 to him.
3. PW 7 the Deputy Superintendent of Police, registered a case and issued Ext. P-9 FIR. On 20-9-1993 he secured PW 2, N. Ravindranath Reddy, Senior Assistant in the Office of State Housing Corporation, Kurnool and LW 3 Abdul Jallel, to act as panch witnesses and explained the significance of chemical test to them. He got the currency notes treated with phenolphthalein powder and entrusted the same to the complainant. Ext. P-3 is the pre-trap proceedings. They reached the Mandal Revenue Office, Kurnool at 1.30 p.m Thereafter, according to the prosecution the complainant relayed pre-arranged signal to them at 1.45 p.m and they entered the office and the sodium carbonate solution test was conducted on the right hand fingers of the accused as well as the left shirt pocket. Both the tests proved to be positive and tainted currency notes were recovered from the possession of the accused. On completion of the investigation the sanction was obtained and a charge-sheet was filed against the appellant-accused. The charges were framed to which the accused pleaded not guilty. In the trial PWs 1 to 8 were examined and Exts. P-1 to P-9 and MOs 1 to 9 were marked on the side of the prosecution. The accused filed written statement and examined DWs 1 to 4 and marked Exts. D-1 to D-8 on his side. The plea of the accused was that target was fixed by the Department to collect contribution for the purchase of the National Savings Certificate and the amount that was given by the complainant was towards that only.
4. We have heard Mr Guntur Prabhakar, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr A. Venkateswara Rao, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent State. The complainant K. Sudhakar Reddy was examined as PW 1 and he did not support the prosecution case. He has testified that Ext. P-1 complaint is in his handwriting but the contents are not true and he wrote the same as dictated by the ACB officials and he gave the amount of Rs 300 to the accused with a request to purchase the National Savings Certificates. The prosecution declared him as hostile. PW 2 N. Ravindranath Reddy, the panch witness had testified that he was summoned by PW 7 DSP E. Damodar on 20-9-1993 and he went through the complaint and verified the contents from the complainant who acknowledged the fact that the accused had demanded a sum of Rs 300 as illegal gratification. Though the complainant did not support the prosecution case it is on the aforesaid basis that the trial court as well as the High Court held the offences as proved and in doing so they have also relied on the legal presumption under Section 20 of the Act.
5. The prosecution examined the other fair price shop dealers in Kurnool as PWs 3, 4 and 6 to prove that the accused was receiving monthly mamools from them. PWs 4 and 6 did not state so and they were declared hostile. PW 3 though in the examination-in-chief stated so, in the cross-examination turned round and stated that the accused never asked for any monthly mamool and he did not pay Rs 50 at any time. The prosecution has not examined any other witness present at the time when the money was demanded by the accused and also when the money was allegedly handed over to the accused by the complainant. The complainant himself had disowned his complaint and has turned hostile and there is no other evidence to prove that the accused had made any demand. In short there is no proof of the demand allegedly made by the accused. The only other material available is the recovery of the tainted currency notes from the possession of the accused. The possession is also admitted by the accused. It is settled law that mere possession and recovery of the currency notes from the accused without proof of demand will not bring home the offence under Section 7, since demand of illegal gratification is sine qua non to constitute the said offence. The above also will be conclusive insofar as the offence under Section 13(1)(d) is concerned as in the absence of any proof of demand for illegal gratification the use of corrupt or illegal means or abuse of position as a public servant to obtain any valuable thing or pecuniary advantage cannot be held to be established. It is only on proof of acceptance of illegal gratification that presumption can be drawn under Section 20 of the Act that such gratification was received for doing or forbearing to do any official act. Unless there is proof of demand of illegal gratification proof of acceptance will not follow. Reference may be made to the two decisions of the three-Judge Bench of this Court in B. Jayaraj v. State of A.P 2014 13 SCC 55 and P. Satyanarayana Murthy v. State of A.P 2015 10 SCC 152
6. In the present case the primary facts on the basis of which the legal presumption under Section 20 can be drawn are wholly absent. The judgments of the courts below are, therefore, liable to be set aside. For the aforesaid reasons the appeal is allowed and the conviction of the appellant under Section 7 and under Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Act and the sentences imposed are set aside and he is acquitted of the charges. The bail bond, if any, furnished by the appellant be released.
Alert