- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Vijaya Ukarda Athor (Athawale) v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Late Ukarda Athor, a clerk with the Municipal Corporation, Amravati, died on 18-6-1997 leaving two families from two wives. The appellant, Vijaya Ukarda Athor, is his daughter through the first wife (Shantabai); Respondent 3, Sagar Ukarda, is his son through the second wife (Kuntabai). After Athor’s death:
- 29-12-1997: The appellant’s mother applied for a future compassionate appointment for the then-minor appellant.
- 19-3-1998: Upon attaining majority, the appellant filed her own application for compassionate appointment as clerk.
- 25-5-2009: Respondent 3 applied for compassionate appointment; the appellant objected on 19-4-2012.
- 18-9-2012: The Municipal Corporation appointed Respondent 3 and rejected the appellant, citing her 2009 marriage and the prevailing Government Resolution (26-10-1994) that limited eligibility to an “unmarried daughter”.
- 18-3-2013: Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) dismissed the appellant’s writ petition (WP 1341/2013), holding her ineligible because she was married and the State policy extending eligibility to married daughters was adopted only on 26-2-2013.
- 22-11-2013: The High Court dismissed her review petition (MCA 511/2013).
- The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Effect of the Government Resolution dated 26-10-1994, particularly Clause 3(a) limiting eligibility to an “unmarried daughter”.
- Whether the appellant’s applications of 29-12-1997 and 19-3-1998 were improperly left pending by the authorities.
- Eligibility of Respondent 3 when the applications were considered in 2012.
- Impact of the later State policy dated 26-2-2013 extending compassionate appointment to married daughters under certain conditions.
- Any other questions relevant to compassionate appointment between rival claimants in the present factual matrix.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- She applied promptly—first through her mother in 1997 and personally in 1998—and delay by the authorities should not prejudice her.
- Her 2009 marriage should not disqualify her; she still supports her widowed mother and the Supreme Court recognises married daughters’ eligibility.
- Appointment of Respondent 3, an illegitimate son from the second wedlock, is unsustainable when a legitimate and earlier claimant exists.
Second Respondent (Municipal Corporation) Arguments
- Compassionate appointment is not a right but is governed strictly by applicable rules and resolutions.
- Under the 26-10-1994 Government Resolution, only an unmarried daughter was eligible; the appellant was therefore ineligible when the decision was made.
- The 26-2-2013 policy change allowing married daughters is prospective and subject to conditions not met by the appellant.
- Cited Supreme Court precedents emphasising strict adherence to norms for compassionate employment.
Third Respondent's Arguments
- Although an illegitimate child, he is still the deceased employee’s son and entitled to equal consideration.
- He satisfied the criteria at the relevant time, justifying the compassionate appointment granted to him.
- The High Court correctly upheld his appointment and dismissed the appellant’s petitions.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shreejith L. v. Director of Education, Kerala (2012) 7 SCC 248 | Norms governing compassionate appointments must be strictly followed; no entitlement beyond the rules. | Cited by the Corporation to argue that eligibility conditions in force at the time must control. |
| CCE & Customs v. Prabhat Singh (2012) 13 SCC 412 | Same principle—strict adherence to prescribed norms for compassionate employment. | Relied upon to justify rejection of claims not conforming to the governing resolution. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted the rival claims and the complex interplay between earlier applications, the 1994 Resolution, the 2012 decision granting Respondent 3 employment, and the 2013 policy expanding eligibility to married daughters. Rather than decide the merits directly, the Court identified five specific questions (listed above) that the High Court had not fully analysed. Concluding that these issues require detailed examination of facts and policies, the Supreme Court found remand appropriate. No final determination on eligibility or legality of the appointments was made at this stage.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s orders dated 18-3-2013 (in WP 1341/2013) and 22-11-2013 (Review MCA 511/2013), allowed the appeals, and remitted the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration.
Implications: The parties will receive a de novo hearing before the High Court, which must address the enumerated legal questions after giving them adequate opportunity. The Supreme Court established no new substantive precedent; the immediate effect is procedural—restoring the appellant’s challenge and directing expedited adjudication.
R. Banumathi, J.— Delay condoned. Leave granted. These appeals arise out of the impugned order dated 18-3-2013 passed by the High Court of Bombay, Bench at Nagpur, in Vijaya Ukarda Athor v. State of Maharashtra Vijaya Ukarda Athor v. State of Maharashtra, WP C No. 1341 of 2013, order dated 18-3-2013 Bom and order dated 22-11-2013 passed in Vijaya Ukarda Athor v. State of Maharashtra Vijaya Ukarda Athor v. State of Maharashtra, MCA No. 511 of 2013 in WP C No. 1341 of 2013, order dated 22-11-2013 Bom, whereby the High Court dismissed the writ petition and also the review application thereby declining to issue direction to consider the case of the appellant for compassionate appointment.
2. The issue relates to the compassionate appointment between the rival claimants. Late Ukarda Athor (Athwale), who was working as a clerk in Municipal Corporation, Amravati, had two wives, namely, Shantabai Ukarda Athor and Kuntabai Ukarda Athor. He died on 18-6-1997. The appellant Vijaya Ukarda Athor (Athawale), is the daughter of late Ukarda Pundlikrao Athor (Athwale) through the first wife, the third respondent is the son of late Ukarda Athor through the second wife. Smt Shantabai Ukarda Athor, mother of the appellant, filed Regular Civil Suit No. 40 of 2001 in the Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division), Anjanagaon Surji, District Amravati, seeking for a declaration being the legal heirs of deceased Ukarda Athor, they have the right in the property, pension and funds of deceased Ukarda Athor and the said suit was decreed by the judgment dated 15-1-2005.
3. In Succession Case No. 6 of 1998 dated 24-9-2007 filed under Section 372 of the Succession Act, 1925, the Civil Judge (JD), District Amravati, inter alia, ordered that the mother of the appellant would be entitled for the benefit of the pension of the deceased. In the succession case, it was further ordered that the appellant and her mother would be entitled to 1/4th share each of total amount of GPF and other funds of Ukarda Athor.
4. On 25-5-2009, Respondent 3 moved an application seeking compassionate appointment. On 19-4-2012, the appellant filed an objection application, raising objection for consideration of job application filed by Respondent 3 and requesting the authorities not to give him the compassionate appointment. The Municipal Corporation vide order dated 18-9-2012 appointed Respondent 3, Sagar Ukarda thereby declaring the appellant ineligible for the compassionate appointment as she has already got married.
5. Aggrieved by the order of non-grant of appointment, the appellant herein filed Writ Petition No. 1341 of 2013 before the High Court of Bombay. Vide order dated 18-3-2013, the High Court dismissed the aforesaid writ petition holding that on the date of appointment, the appellant was a married daughter and the policy decision was taken by the State Government on 26-2-2013 for grant of compassionate appointment to married daughter and before the said date the appellant was not eligible for any appointment. The appellant filed a review application before the High Court which was also dismissed vide order dated 22-11-2013. In these appeals, the appellant assails the above orders.
6. The learned counsel for the appellant contended that at the time of death of her father Mr Ukarda Athor (dated 18-6-1997) the appellant who was then a minor, submitted an application seeking appointment on 29-12-1997 and again after attaining majority, the appellant sought compassionate appointment for the post of clerk vide her application dated 19-3-1998, filed in a prescribed pro forma. However, for a long time, no appointments took place in the respondent Corporation. It was also submitted that the appellant got married in 2009, but still she would take care of the needs of her widowed mother and there is no bar for giving compassionate appointment to a married daughter and rejecting the claim of a married daughter who is otherwise suitable for seeking compassionate employment defies any logic. It was submitted that the High Court did not keep in view that the appointment has been sought on compassionate grounds for the post of clerk ever since the death of the appellant's father as per the well-settled proposition laid down by the Supreme Court. It was contended that the compassionate appointment given to Respondent 3, who is an illegitimate son of the deceased employee is not sustainable.
7. The learned counsel for the second respondent Corporation submitted that the appointment on compassionate ground cannot be claimed as a matter of right but can be claimed only in terms of the rules or regulations framed in this regard. Placing reliance upon the judgments of this Court in Shreejith L. v. Director of Education, Kerala 2012 7 SCC 248 and CCE and Customs v. Prabhat Singh 2012 13 SCC 412, it was submitted that where the norms have been laid down for making compassionate appointments, the same have to be strictly followed.
8. The learned counsel further submitted that when the application for compassionate appointment was considered as per the Government Resolution dated 26-10-1994, only unmarried daughter was eligible to be considered for compassionate appointment. The learned counsel urged that the State Government has taken a policy decision only on 26-2-2013, as per which the married daughters would also be eligible for consideration for the grant of compassionate appointment subject to the fulfilment of certain conditions. The learned counsel further contended that before 26-2-2013 since the appellant was not eligible to be considered for compassionate appointment, the High Court rightly dismissed the writ petition and the impugned orders do not suffer from any infirmity warranting interference.
9. The learned counsel for Respondent 3 submitted that even though Respondent 3 is the son of a deceased employee from the second wedlock and illegitimate child, yet there is no denying the fact that he remains the son of deceased Ukarda Athor and therefore, Respondent 3 was entitled to the same treatment as is available to the child from the first marriage. It was submitted that as the illegitimate son of the deceased the third respondent is entitled to get appointment on compassionate ground subject to the fulfilment of certain criteria as laid down by the authorities and in consideration of the status of Respondent 3 and the policy decision of the State Government, rightly Respondent 3 was given the appointment and the High Court rightly dismissed the writ petition and also the review application and the impugned orders, warrant no interference.
10. We have carefully considered the rival contentions and perused the impugned order and other materials on record.
11. The fact that the appellant is the daughter through the first wife Shantabai Athor and Respondent 3 is the son through the second wife Kuntabai Athor of late Ukarda Athor is not in dispute. Ukarda Athor died on 18-6-1997. According to the appellant, her mother submitted an application dated 29-12-1997 stating that her daughter Vijaya Athor, the appellant who is aged seventeen years and then a minor studying in 10th standard, should be given compassionate appointment when she attains majority. According to the appellant after she attained majority she has submitted another application on 19-3-1998, seeking compassionate appointment; but for quite sometime, the same was not considered by the authorities. The appellant was married in the year 2009.
12. The contention of the appellant is that her application for compassionate appointment was kept pending by the authorities without any justifiable reason. But according to Respondent 2 Corporation, giving employment in government service on compassionate ground was then governed by Government Resolution, General Administration Department, No. Comp. 1093/2335.M.No. 90/93.Eight, dated 26-10-1994. As per the said Resolution only the unmarried daughter of the deceased would be eligible for the appointment as per the Rules. Reliance is placed on Clause (3)(a) of the Government Resolution which reads as under:
“(3)(a) Husband/Wife, son or unmarried daughter of the deceased/prematurely retired government employee or son/unmarried daughter lawfully adopted, before death/premature retirement, shall be deemed to be the relatives eligible to be appointed as per the Rules. Except them, no other relative shall get the benefit under this scheme.”
The State Government has taken a policy decision on 26-2-2013 and held that the married daughters are also entitled for compassionate appointment subject to certain conditions.
13. In our considered view, the questions viz.:
(i) the effect of Government Resolution, General Administration Department, No. Comp. 1093/2335.M.No. 90/93.Eight dated 26-10-1994 and effect of Clause (3)(a);
(ii) the plea that the appellant submitted applications on 29-12-1997 and 19-3-1998, that the same were not considered by the authorities for quite some time;
(iii) at the time when the applications for compassionate appointment was considered in 2012 whether the third respondent was eligible to be considered;
(iv) the effect of subsequent policy decision dated 26-2-2013 taken by the State Government as per which the married daughter is also eligible to get compassionate appointment; and
(v) such other relevant questions which are to be examined.
In our considered view, instead of this Court examining the above questions, the matter is to be remitted back to the High Court for considering the above questions in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case.
14. In the result, the impugned orders of the High Court in Writ Petition No. 1341 of 2013 dated 18-3-2013 and Review Application No. 511 of 2013 dated 22-11-2013 are set aside and the appeals are allowed and the matter is remitted back to the High Court for consideration of the matter afresh. The High Court shall give sufficient opportunity to the appellant and the respondents and consider the matter afresh expeditiously and in accordance with law.
Alert